1931 United Kingdom general election in Scotland

1931 United Kingdom general election in Scotland

27 October 1931

All 74 Scottish seats to the House of Commons
Turnout77.4% (Increase4.2 pp)
  First party Second party Third party
 
Leader Stanley Baldwin Herbert Samuel John Simon
Party Unionist Liberal National Liberal
Alliance Conservative & National Government Liberal & National Government National Government
Leader since 23 May 1923 October 1931 5 October 1931
Leader's seat Bewdley Darwen Spen Valley
Last election 22 seats,[a] 35.3% 14 seats,[a] 18.2% Did not contest
Seats won 50[a] 8[a] 8[a]
Seat change Increase28[a] Decrease6[a] Increase8
Popular vote 1,056,768[b] 205,384[b] 101,430[b]
Percentage 48.6%[b] 9.5%[b] 4.7%[b]
Swing Increase13.3 pp[b] Decrease8.7 pp[b] New party

  Fourth party Fifth party
 
Leader Arthur Henderson Ramsay MacDonald
Party Labour National Labour
Alliance National Government
Leader since 1 September 1931 24 August 1931
Leader's seat Burnley
(Lost seat)
Seaham
Last election 36 seats,[a] 41.8% Did not contest
Seats won 7[a][c] 1[a]
Seat change Decrease29[a][c] Increase1[a]
Popular vote 696,248[b][c] 21,803[b]
Percentage 32.0%[b][c] 1.0%[b]
Swing Decrease9.8 pp[b][c] New party

On Tuesday 27 October 1931,[1] the 1931 United Kingdom general election was held in Scotland, to elect all 615 members of the House of Commons, with 74 constituencies being in Scotland. 71 seats (32 burgh constituencies and 38 county constituencies)[d] represented territorial constituencies. There was also one university constituency, which elected an additional 3 members using the Single Transferable Vote (STV) method.[2]

The election saw massive gains for the Unionists across the country, with the party winning nearly 70 per cent of all Scottish seats. The parties forming the National Government together won 63.7 per cent of the vote, and 90.5 per cent of the seats in Scotland. In contrast the Labour Party, which had been the largest party in Scotland following the 1929 general election (where it had won 41.8 per cent of the Scottish vote), was relegated into fourth place within just two years. Across the United Kingdom, the National Government coalition won 67 per cent of the popular vote and over 90 per cent of the seats in the House of Commons.

Candidates

Below is a table summarising the candidates of the 1931 general election in Scotland, excluding those in the Combined Scottish Universities constituency.[3][4][5]

Affiliation Candidates
Unionist Party 56
Labour Party 45[e]
Scottish Liberal Party 14
Independent Labour Party 9
Liberal National Party 8
Communist Party of Great Britain 8
National Party of Scotland 5[f]
New Party 5[g]
Constituency Labour Party 3[h]
Scottish Prohibition Party 1[i]
National Labour Organisation 1[j]
Total 155

Analysis

National Government

The Parties that made up the National Government won a total of 67 seats at this election in Scotland, including a total of 31 gained seats primarily from the Labour Party. However, the newly formed Liberal National Party also internally won seats by defects from the Scottish Liberal Party, which was within a national affiliation with the Liberal Party in the National Government.

The Liberal National Party won Dunfermline Burghs from the Labour Party; however, within the National Government coalition, it won Inverness, Ross and Cromarty, Western Isles, Montrose Burghs, Fife East, Greenock and Leith from the Liberal Party. Furthermore, the Unionist Party, within a national affiliation with the Conservative Party within the National Coalition, won Aberdeenshire West and Kincardine and Galloway from the Scottish Liberals. Contrary to the losses, The Liberal Party won Paisley, Edinburgh East as well as one of the two seats in Dundee from Labour. The Liberal Party also retained its seat in the Combined Scottish Universities constituency. The Liberal National Party therefore won a total of eight seats at the election (which were all candidates that stood for the party in Scotland), with the Scottish Liberals also holding eight.

The Unionist Party made further gains from Labour. These were Aberdeen North, Stirling and Falkirk, Clackmannan and Eastern Stirlingshire, Stirlingshire West, Fife West, Kirkcaldy Burghs, Dunbartonshire, Lanark, Partick, North Lanarkshire, Renfrewshire West, Maryhill, Motherwell, Camlachie, Bothwell, Coatbridge, Springburn, Rutherglen, Tradeston, South Ayrshire, Edinburgh West, Edinburgh Central, Midlothian South and Peebles, Linlithgow and Berwick and Haddington. It also took the other other of two seats in Dundee from the Scottish Prohibition Party. The Unionists also retained their two seats in the Combined Scottish Universities Constituency.

The newly formed National Labour under Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald also took one seat in Scotland. This was Kilmarnock wherein the sitting MP, Craigie Aitchison, defected from the Labour Party and won the seat for National Labour in this election.

Labour Opposition

Following the election, the Labour Party appeared to teeter on the edge of the electoral abyss in Scotland. The Labour Party itself in Scotland managed to win three seats under its officially endorsed candidates. Two candidates, David Kirkwood in Dumbarton Burghs and George Buchanan in Glasgow Gorbals, re-contested and won their seats; however, both were members of the Independent Labour Party and endorsed by the Constituency Labour Party at this election, rather than being the official candidates of the Labour Party. A further two candidates, James Maxton in Glasgow Bridgeton and John McGovern in Glasgow Shettleston re-contested and won their seats, but as members and representing the Independent Labour Party. John McGovern also won his electoral race against an official Labour candidate.

Each of these four represented losses for the official Labour Party, but stood as party of the Labour Opposition after election. However, the Independent Labour Party increasingly moved apart from Labour, and ultimately dissociating from the party in March 1932. The ILP had dominated the Labour movement in Scotland since 1918, dominating community based activism, and essentially forming the Labour Party in Scotland. This had ultimately served to undermine the organisational growth of the Labour Party in Scotland.[6]

The Labour Party, however, gain Glasgow Govan. Neil Maclean who had won the seat under the label of Independent Labour re-contested and won the seat again, this time winning as the official Labour candidate. This was one of only two gains for the Labour Party across the United Kingdom in 1931. The combined losses from the parties within the National Government and the losses from internal independent Labour candidates, Labour was reduced to holding just three seats in its own right, but carried within the Labour Opposition a slightly larger seven.

Seat summary

Below is a table summarising the total number of seats, gains and losses for each party in both the territorial county and burgh constituencies and the Combined Scottish Universities constituency.

Party Seats
Total Gains Losses Net Of all (%)
  National Government (Total) 67NewIncrease3190.5
Unionist 50280Increase2867.6
  Liberal National 8NewIncrease810.8
Liberal 839Decrease610.8
National Labour 1NewIncrease11.4
  Labour Opposition (Total) 7130Decrease299.5
Labour 3134Decrease334.1
Ind. Labour Party 2Did not stand in 1929Increase22.7
  Constituency Labour 2NewIncrease22.7
  Scottish Prohibition 001Decrease1—
  Other 001Decrease1—
Total 74

County and burgh constituency results

Below is a table summarising the constituency results of the 1931 general election in Scotland, excluding the result in the Combined Scottish Universities constituency.

Party[7][8] Seats Aggregate votes
Total Gains Losses Net Of all (%) Total Of all (%) Difference
  National Government (Total) 64NewIncrease3190.11,385,38563.7New
Unionist 48280Increase2867.61,056,76848.6Increase13.3
  Liberal National 8NewIncrease811.3101,4304.7New
Liberal 739Decrease69.9205,3849.5Decrease8.7
National Labour 1NewIncrease11.421,8031.0New
  Labour Opposition (Total) 7130Decrease299.9696,24832.0Decrease9.8
Labour 31[k]34Decrease334.2525,76524.2Decrease17.6
Ind. Labour Party 2Did not stand in 1929Increase22.8127,3315.9N/a
  Constituency Labour 2NewIncrease22.843,1522.0New
  Communist 000Steady—35,6181.6Increase0.4
  Scottish Prohibition 001[l]Decrease1—32,2291.5Decrease0.7
  NPS 000Steady—20,9541.0Increase0.8
  New Party 0New—3,8950.2New
  Other 001[k]Decrease1—00.0N/a
Total 71 2,174,329 77.4[9][10] Increase4.2
Popular vote[b]
Unionist
 
48.6%
Labour Opp.
 
32.0%
Liberal
 
9.5%
National Liberal
 
4.7%
Communist
 
1.6%
National Labour
 
1.0%
NPS
 
1.0%
Other
 
1.7%
Popular vote (coalitions)[b]
National Gov.
 
63.7%
Labour Opp.
 
32.0%
Communist
 
1.6%
NPS
 
1.0%
Other
 
1.7%

Parliament seats

Parliamentary seats[a]
Unionist
 
67.6%
National Liberal
 
10.8%
Liberal
 
10.8%
Labour Opp.
 
9.5%
National Labour
 
1.4%
Parliament seats (coalitions)[b]
National Gov.
 
90.5%
Labour Opp.
 
9.5%

Combined Scottish Universities result

General election, November 1931: Combined Scottish Universities
Party Candidate Votes % ±%
Unionist John Buchan Unopposed
Liberal Dugald McCoig Cowan Unopposed
Unionist Archibald Noel Skelton Unopposed

Notes

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 Combined results for burgh, county and university seats
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Total and percentage votes given here are for territorial constituencies only
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 Figure is for all Scottish candidates in the Labour Opposition in 1931
  4. ↑ One burgh seat, Dundee, was represented by two members of parliament.
  5. ↑ Includes three Co-operative Party candidates, as part of the Labour-Co-op alliance.
  6. ↑ The candidates that stood were Oliver Brown in East Renfrewshire, Thomas Thomson Alexander in Edinburgh East, Elma Campbell in Glasgow St Rollox, John MacCormick in Inverness and Roland Muirhead in West Renfrewshire.
  7. ↑ The candidates that stood were William Weir Gilmour in Coatbridge, Cecil Dudgeon in Galloway, J. Mellick in Glasgow Cathcart, W. E. Stevenson in Glasgow Shettleston and Robert Forgan in West Renfrewshire.
  8. ↑ This category of candidates were those who were chosen in seats to represent Labour, however, were sponsored by the Constituency Labour Party in seats in which the Labour Party chose not to stand, and were not official candidates at this election. The candidates that stood were David Kirkwood in Dumbarton Burghs, George Buchanan in Glasgow Gorbals and Charles Aloysius O'Donnell in Glasgow Hillhead.
  9. ↑ Leader Edwin Scrymgeour stood in Dundee.
  10. ↑ Incumbent sitting Labour Member of Parliament Craigie Aitchison, who defected to National Labour, stood in Kilmarnock.
  11. 1 2 Neil Maclean in Glasgow Govan re-contested and won the seat, but was the official Labour candidate in this election.
  12. ↑ Edwin Scrymgeour in Dundee.

See also

References

  1. ↑ Colin Rallings; Micheal Thrasher (2006). British Electoral Facts. Total Politics. p. 29. ISBN 978-1-907278-03-7.
  2. ↑ "Research Briefing: Voting systems in the UK". Library of the House of Commons. 10 January 2023. Retrieved 26 November 2024.
  3. ↑ Cracknell, Richard; Uberoi, Elise; Burton, Matthew (9 August 2023). "UK Election Statistics: 1918-2023, A Century of Elections" (PDF). House of Commons Library. p. 25. Retrieved 8 August 2026.
  4. ↑ "UK General Elections Results 1832-2019". Retrieved 12 August 2026.
  5. ↑ Craig, F. W. S. (1977). British Parliamentary Election Results 1918–49 (1st ed.). London and Basingstoke: The Macmillan Press Ltd. ISBN 978-1-349-81467-1.
  6. ↑ William Kenefick (2007). Red Scotland!: The Rise and Fall of the Radical Left, C. 1872–1932. Edinburgh University Press. pp. 202–203. ISBN 978-0-7486-2517-8.
  7. ↑ Colin Rallings; Micheal Thrasher (2006). British Electoral Facts. Total Politics. p. 27. ISBN 978-1-907278-03-7.
  8. ↑ Craig, F. W. S. (1977). British Parliamentary Election Results 1918–49 (1st ed.). London and Basingstoke: The Macmillan Press Ltd. ISBN 978-1-349-81467-1.
  9. ↑ Colin Rallings; Micheal Thrasher (2006). British Electoral Facts. Total Politics. p. 89. ISBN 978-1-907278-03-7.
  10. ↑ Cracknell, Richard; Uberoi, Elise; Burton, Matthew (9 August 2023). "UK Election Statistics: 1918-2023, A Century of Elections" (PDF). House of Commons Library. p. 29. Retrieved 8 August 2026.