Presidency of Eleazar López Contreras

Eleazar López Contreras

The presidency of Eleazar López Contreras was a post‑Gómez transitional government in a Venezuela without political parties, with Congress ratifying López Contreras as interim president in 1935 to complete Gómez's term after his death, and electing him constitutional president in 1936 until 1941 with 121 out of 122 votes, so that legally they were two governments. Considered a hybrid regime, it was the third government of the period known as the Andean Hegemony, led by presidents born in Táchira state.

López Contreras was conservative ideologically.[1] In legislative terms, the 1936 Constitution was approved. López Contreras's economic policy was protectionist, also creating the Central Bank of Venezuela and signing a free trade treaty with the United States.

He was the founder of the National Guard. López Contreras's government presided over the first part of World War II, declaring a neutral position in 1939.

The February 14, 1936, demonstration was decisive for his democratic opening at the electoral level, carrying out in 1937 the first elections of the 20th century in which the opposition to the government participated,[2] maintaining an anti-communist stance. President López Contreras encouraged the return of political opponents of the Gómez regime and later exiled several of their main leaders, outlawing political parties.

After his term, he supported the succession of his Minister of War and Navy, Isaías Medina Angarita, with the hope of succeeding him in a second government, but the latter distanced himself from his mentor. After the coup d'état against his successor in 1945, the Jury of Civil and Administrative Responsibility was established to investigate corruption related to the Gómez and post-Gómez governments, including that of López Contreras. Due to his presidential term, after the establishment of the 1961 constitution, he was appointed senator for life, a position he held until his death.

Background

Juan Vicente Gómez and López Contreras in Maracay, 1934

Dictator Juan Vicente Gómez was 77 years old at the beginning of 1935, was ill, and there was an internal conspiracy in the government vying for his succession, particularly involving Eustoquio Gómez.[3] Several authors indicate that Gómez had thought of Diógenes Escalante as his successor.[4]

When Gómez died in December 1935, the cabinet met and selected General Eleazar López Contreras, Minister of War and Navy, to finish Gómez's term, which legally ended in 1936. Congress ratified López Contreras as interim president in 1935 and as constitutional president after the 1936 elections.[3]

Cabinet

López Contreras and his cabinet in 1936
Cabinet[5]
OFFICENAMETERM
PresidentEleazar López Contreras1935–1941
Interior AffairsPedro Tinoco Smith1935–1936
Diógenes Escalante1936
Alejandro Lara Núñez1936
Régulo Olivares1936–1937
Alfonso Mejía1937–1938
Luis Gerónimo Pietri1938–1941
Foreign AffairsPedro Itriago Chacín1935–1936
Esteban Gil Borges1936–1941
FinanceEfraim González1935–1936
Gustavo Herrera1936
Alejandro Lara Núñez1936
Alberto Adriani1936
Cristóbal L. Mendoza1937–1938
Francisco J. Parra1938–1941
War and NavyAntonio Chalbaud Cardona1935–1936
Isaías Medina Angarita1936–1941
DevelopmentPedro París1936
Néstor Luis Pérez1936–1938
Manuel Egaña1938–1941
Public WorksAntonio Díaz1935–1936
Tomás Pacaninis1936–1938
Enrique Jorge Aguerrevere1938–1941
Public InstructionR. González Rincones1935–1936
José Ramón Ayala1936
Caracciolo Parra Pérez1936
Rómulo Gallegos1936
Alberto Smith1936–1937
Rafael Ernesto López1937–1938
Enrique Tejera Guevara1938–1939
Arturo Uslar Pietri1939–1941
Sanitation and AgricultureR. González Rincones1935–1936
Health and Social WelfareEnrique Tejera Guevara1936
Santos Dominici1936–1937
Honorio Sigala1937–1938
Julio García Álvarez1938–1941
AgricultureAlberto Adriani1936
Alfonso Mejía1936–1937
Hugo Parra Pérez1937–1938
Amenodoro Rangel Lamus1938–1939
Alfonso Mejía1939–1941
CommunicationsFrancisco H. Rivero1936
Honorio Sigala1936
Alejandro Lara1936–1937
Luis Gerónimo Pietri1937–1938
Héctor Cuenca1938–1939
José Rafael Pocaterra1939–1941
Secretary of the PresidencyAmenodoro Rangel1935-1936
Francisco Parra1936
Diógenes Escalante1936–1938
Alfonso Mejía1938–1939
Tulio Chiossone1939−1941
SecretaryAmenodoro Rangel Lamus1935-1937

Domestic policy

Legislative policy

Constitution of 1936

Congress after the 1936 elections, in green the ruling party

The Venezuelan Constitution was approved on July 16, 1936, during the presidency of Eleazar López Contreras. Its importance lies in being the first political constitution of the State after the dictatorship of Juan Vicente Gómez. Although it put an end to the personalistic character of its predecessors, initially it had more restrictive characteristics than the seven Gómez-era constitutions, until April 23, 1945, when President Isaías Medina Angarita promoted a reform.

The presidential term was reduced from seven to five years.[6] The constitution limited voting to men over 21 years of age who could read, at a time when more than half of Venezuelans could not read.

Judicial policy

Release of political prisoners and return of exiles

On December 20, 1935, General López Contreras ordered the release of all political prisoners and detainees from the Gómez dictatorship, many of whom were engaged in forced labor for road construction, as well as the provision for the return of exiles and banished persons.[3]

Defense

The government of López Contreras signified a military continuism of the Gómez regime; transforming itself into a new power elite based on military prestige and command relationships inherited from Gómez.[7]

Economics

1 silver bolívar coin of 1935

López Contreras's economic policy was protectionist.[3] In 1936, Congress ordered the confiscation of the assets of Juan Vicente Gómez and all his ministers.[8] On October 13, 1936, the Customs Tariff Law was approved, a project of Minister Alberto Adriani.[3] In November 1939, a free trade treaty with the United States was established.[3] The Central Bank of Venezuela was also founded in 1940.[9]

Energy

Royal Dutch Shell, Standard Oil, and Gulf Oil were the major oil companies in Venezuela when López became president.[10] An export tax on oil shipped from Venezuela was prohibited by the pre-1936 constitution, but this was omitted in the 1936 constitution.[11] Oil concessions to private people was ended by López in 1938.[12]

Petroleum workers started striking in the Maracaibo region on 11 December 1936, and this continued until it was ended by a presidential degree from López on 22 January 1937. There was a 39% decrease in oil production during the strike and 6.5 million bolívares lost. Oil companies instituted some reforms such as increasing the wages to 8 bolívares a day and improving living conditions.[13]

Electoral policy

In 1937, municipal elections were held, the first elections of the 20th century in which the opposition to the government participated.[2] The parties ORVE, FEV-OP, PRP, Frente Obrero, and Frente Nacional were outlawed.[14]

Health policy

On February 25, 1936, the Ministry of Health, Agriculture and Livestock was divided into two, giving rise to the Ministry of Health and Social Assistance. It also established the National Institute of Childcare.[3]

Labor

López Contreras maintained a confrontation with the labor movement and its political leaders, who demonstrated in successive strikes such as that of 1936.[3] By orders of military officer Elbano Mibelli on March 26, 1939, the Workers' Trade Union Federation (FST) and the General Union of Labor (UGT) were banned, accused of being communist.[15]

Infrastructure

The Monumental Plan of Caracas was designed.[3]

Education

In October 1936, the Pedagogical Institute was founded, and in January 1937, teacher education programs were established.[3] That same year, the Central University of Venezuela (UCV) was raided.

Agricultural policy

The Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock was created, dividing the Ministry of Health, Agriculture and Livestock.[3] In 1936, the National Coffee Institute was founded.[16]

Human Rights

February 1936 demonstration

At the beginning of 1936, various violent protests occurred in Maracaibo and Cabimas, generating looting and causing seven deaths. Meanwhile, in Valencia and Caracas, demonstrations degenerated into looting. In response to these events, the regime suspended constitutional guarantees on January 6, 1936.[17]

The February 14, 1936, demonstration was repressed, resulting in six dead and nearly 150 wounded.[17] Following the repression of the demonstration, a series of altercations and looting occurred, leading to the removal and arrest of Governor Galavís and the subsequent restoration of guarantees.[17]

That same year, Alejandro Lara was appointed Minister of Interior, who promoted the approval of the Public Order Law, better known as the Lara Law. The law prohibited strikes and work stoppages, authorized the use of firearms to end protests, allowed the search of homes without a court order, and legalized the expulsion of citizens from the nation.[17]

Over the years, social conflict persisted, degenerating into government repression. In 1936, the militarization of the city of Valencia occurred by order of Colonel F. Celestino Hernández due to a strike by telegraph office workers.[17] In 1937, the headquarters of the FEV (Venezuelan Student Federation) located in the Central University of Venezuela was raided, causing the death of student Eutimio Rivas.[17]

Additionally, a series of detentions of activists and politicians took place, including Gustavo Machado, Salvador de la Plaza, Carlos D'Ascoli, Jesús González, Luis Hernández Solís, Luis Francisco Troconis, Hernani Portocarrero, and others.[17]

Due to the repressive attitude, some organizations began to emerge to denounce abuses. In 1937, relatives of political detainees founded the National Pro-Prisoners League, an organization responsible for offering help and assistance to detainees; however, authorities prevented its legalization on several occasions.[17] Meanwhile, in 1938, Father Manuel Aguirre Elorriaga founded Revista SIC (Seminario Interdiocesano de Caracas), influenced by the Christian Workers' Youth. This publication would become one of the first windows for the dissemination of information about human rights in Venezuela and the social doctrine of the Church.[18]

In 1939, the Vagrancy and Misconduct Law entered into force. Although it did not explicitly criminalize homosexuality, it left the door open for the detention of persons suspected of any "threat to society."[19] The concept of "vagrants" was not clearly defined and included unemployed persons or those who "walk the streets (...) fostering idleness and other vices."[19]

Security

In August 1937, the National Security Service was established.[3]

Media policy

Censorship

On January 28, 1936, the Governor of the Federal District, Félix Galavís, created a Censorship Office within the governor's office.[20] Galavís decreed the prohibition of communist propaganda, the posting of posters, and press articles without prior administrative authorization.[21] Following the February 14, 1936, demonstration, President Contreras removed Galavís from office and reversed the censorship decree.[22]

Red Book

Documents shown in the Red Book

In 1936, the newspapers Orve and El Popular announced the appearance of a book called "La verdad de las actividades comunistas en Venezuela" (The Truth about Communist Activities in Venezuela), popularly known thereafter as the Red Book, whose author was unknown. It was a compendium of names of persons accused of being communists (including real communists and ex-communists at that time). Mentioned were the Secretary of Government of the Federal District, the Prefect of the Capital Department, and the private secretary of the governor, Elbano Mibelli,[23] as well as the Barranquilla Plan, linking the signatories to communism, including Rómulo Betancourt and other participants grouped as the Movimiento de Organización Venezolana.[24]

This resulted in a political scandal and unleashed a witch hunt; Betancourt was persecuted and remained underground.[23] Eventually, it was demonstrated that the Red Book was linked to the government of Eleazar López Contreras.[24]

Immigration

Immigration policy since Juan Vicente Gómez was influenced by positivism, an ideology that continued to determine the migration policies of the López Contreras government.[7]

Foreign policy

Eleazar López Contreras and Colombian president Eduardo Santos, 1941

During the government of López Contreras, World War II broke out. López Contreras himself stated on the matter:[25]

"Before that conflict, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs had completed its studies on neutrality and its evolution in recent times, also defining the situation of the Republic, taking into account its international commitments and its vital interests. Immediately after receiving notification of the existence of a state of war between some European powers, the Government of Venezuela, by Decree of September 4, 1939, declared its strict neutrality."

The government declared itself neutral on September 4, 1939.

Legacy

1941 presidential election

Several authors indicate that Juan Vicente Gómez had thought of Diógenes Escalante as his successor; according to writer Francisco Suniaga, he would also have been López Contreras's first choice, but the military leadership forced him to choose a military officer.[4] In 1941, Isaías Medina Angarita, former Minister of War under López Contreras, was elected by Congress.[26] General López Contreras expected to receive the presidency again, after Medina Angarita's government.[27]

Jury of Civil and Administrative Responsibility

Headline of the newspaper Últimas Noticias stating that in Venezuela it will be possible to defend the government of Eleazar López Contreras, but not that of his successor Isaías Medina Angarita

The Jury of Civil and Administrative Responsibility was a set of ad hoc trials established by the Revolutionary Government Junta of Venezuela on November 27, 1945, during the period known as the Adeco Triennium, charged with establishing responsibilities for alleged embezzlement by Gómez-era, López-era, Medina-era officials, and associates from previous administrations. The Jury examined a total of 108 files and issued judgments restoring assets to the national patrimony totaling Bs. 124,000,000.

Eleazar López Contreras was convicted by the Jury of Civil and Administrative Responsibility.[6]

Rufino Blanco Fombona of the National Academy of History wrote on the matter: "As far as we know, not a single bolívar was lost in his pockets. He also had the elegance to disdain embezzlement."[6] Juan Serafín Penzini Hernández, Individual Number of the Academy of Political and Social Sciences and former Minister of Interior of Isaías Medina Angarita, wrote: "They went to the unheard-of extreme of judging and convicting Generals López Contreras and Medina Angarita for the crime of embezzlement before a Jury of Civil and Administrative Responsibility, an ad-hoc tribunal where the right to defense was annulled, the weight of evidence was altered, and the trial and sentencing process was modified to the manifest detriment of those judged by this ex-post-facto law, issued by Democratic Action."[6]

Ideology

Positivism

The government of Eleazar López Contreras, like the Gómez dictatorship, was influenced by positivism.[7]

Cult of personality of Simón Bolívar

The government of López Contreras promoted the cult of personality of Simón Bolívar as a means of unifying the country and an alternative to Marxism, considered a "foreignizing ideology."[3] It also promoted the creation of the Bolivarian Civic Grouping.[28]

Opposition

Outlawing of political parties

PRP supporters protesting in 1936. The party was outlawed the following year

In 1936, a new constitution was approved that maintained the prohibition of communism and anarchism, as well as the impossibility of women's participation in political life.[17]

Under the protection of the Lara Law, the dissolution of parties and organizations such as the Organization of Venezuelans (ORVE), the Progressive Republican Party (PRP), the Venezuelan Student Federation (FEV), the Workers' Front (FO), and the National Labor Front (FNT) was ordered.[14][17]

Exiles

Jóvito Villalba (center-left) and Rómulo Betancourt (center), formerly part of the Generation of 1928, were exiled in 1937

On March 13, 1937, the government decreed the expulsion of 48 political leaders, who were the main opposition leaders, accused of being communists.[3][2] Among those expelled were Miguel Acosta Saignes, Juan Bautista Fuenmayor, Rodolfo Quintero, Gonzalo Barrios, Carlos D'Ascoli, Carlos Augusto León, José Mayobre, Jóvito Villalba, Luis Troconis, Raúl Leoni, Gustavo Machado, Augusto Malavé Villalba, Hernani Portocarrero, among others. They were expelled on the ship Flandre to Panama and Mexico.[17]

See also

References

  1. ↑ Ewell, Judith (1991), "Venezuela since 1930", in Bethell, Leslie (ed.), The Cambridge History of Latin America, vol. 8: Latin America since 1930: Spanish South America, Cambridge University Press, pp. 727–790, doi:10.1017/chol9780521266529.014, ISBN 978-0-521-26652-9
  2. 1 2 3 Straka, Tomás (2024-01-24). "Entre el miedo y la libertad: Votar antes de la democracia". Prodavinci (in Spanish).
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Machado de Acedo, Clemy. "López Contreras, Eleazar, gobierno de". Fundación Empresas Polar (in Spanish). Diccionario de Historia de Venezuela.
  4. 1 2 Olmo, Guillermo D. (14 September 2019). "Diógenes Escalante, el dirigente llamado a cambiar la historia de Venezuela que perdió la cabeza cuando estaba a punto de ser presidente". BBC News Mundo (in Spanish).
  5. ↑ Centro Editor/José Rivas Rivas (1972). "Historia Gráfica de Venezuela. 1- El Gobierno de López Contreras"
  6. 1 2 3 4 TABLANTE GARRIDO, P. N. (1983). "ELEAZAR LOPEZ CONTRERAS: PRESIDENTE • GENERAL EN JEFE • SENADOR VITALICIO" (PDF). Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México (in Spanish). Boletín de la Academia Nacional de la Historia.
  7. 1 2 3 Arámbulo, Angélica. "LA POLÍTICA INMIGRATORIA GOMECISTA: POSITIVISMO Y EXCLUSIÓN (1909 – 1945)" (PDF). Consejo Latinoamericano de Ciencias Sociales (in Spanish).
  8. ↑ "EDICIÓN Nº 127". REVISTA EXCESO (in Spanish). February 2000. pp. 38–39.
  9. ↑ Camacho Rodríguez, Francisco (2018). "La "siembra del petróleo" durante el trienio de acción democrática y el papel de las transnacionales en Venezuela (1945-1948)". Tzintzun. Revista de Estudios Históricos (in Spanish) (67): 195–222.
  10. ↑ Singh 1989, p. 89.
  11. ↑ Singh 1989, p. 92.
  12. ↑ Yarrington 2025, p. 173.
  13. ↑ Singh 1989, p. 95.
  14. 1 2 Masegosa Xucla, Eric. "El movimiento obrero venezolano durante el primer tercio del siglo XX". Universitat de Lleida (in Spanish).
  15. ↑ Montes de Oca, Rodolfo (2022). "La democracia como punto de partida". Sospechosos habituales. Diez aproximaciones a los antecedentes históricos del movimiento por los derechos humanos en Venezuela (1936-1999) (PDF) (in Spanish). Caracas: Edición del Programa Venezolano de Educación-Acción en Derechos Humanos (PROVEA). pp. 29–92. ISBN 978-980-6544-74-1.
  16. ↑ Martínez Quintero, Lucía Wilmajay. "EL CAFÉ VENEZOLANO, UN CULTIVO EN RIESGO DE DESAPARECER" (PDF). Universidad de Los Andes (in Spanish).
  17. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Montes de Oca, Rodolfo (2022). "La democracia como punto de partida". Sospechosos habituales. Diez aproximaciones a los antecedentes históricos del movimiento por los derechos humanos en Venezuela (1936-1999) (PDF) (in Spanish). Caracas: Edición del Programa Venezolano de Educación-Acción en Derechos Humanos (PROVEA). pp. 29–92. ISBN 978-980-6544-74-1.
  18. ↑ Montes de Oca, Rodolfo (2022). "Estar del lado de los desposeídos". Sospechosos habituales. Diez aproximaciones a los antecedentes históricos del movimiento por los derechos humanos en Venezuela (1936-1999) (PDF) (in Spanish). Caracas: Edición del Programa Venezolano de Educación-Acción en Derechos Humanos (PROVEA). pp. 225–294. ISBN 978-980-6544-74-1.
  19. 1 2 Montes de Oca, Rodolfo (2022). "Capítulo VIII. Diversxs y libres". Sospechosos habituales. Diez aproximaciones a los antecedentes históricos del movimiento por los derechos humanos en Venezuela (1936-1999) (PDF) (in Spanish). Caracas: Edición del Programa Venezolano de Educación-Acción en Derechos Humanos (PROVEA). pp. 441–486. ISBN 978-980-6544-74-1.
  20. ↑ Padrón García, Rebeca Gerardina (December 2017). "Del gendarme al prestigio moral necesario: La transición en el gobierno de Eleazar López Contreras". Tiempo y Espacio (in Spanish). 27 (68): 129–149. ISSN 1315-9496. Retrieved 2022-07-12.
  21. ↑ Montes de Oca, Rodolfo (2022). Sospechosos habituales. Diez aproximaciones a los antecedentes históricos del movimiento por los derechos humanos en Venezuela (1936-1999) (PDF) (in Spanish). Caracas: Edición del Programa Venezolano de Educación-Acción en Derechos Humanos (PROVEA). p. 37. ISBN 978-980-6544-74-1.
  22. ↑ Ayala, Carlos Capriles (1988). Pérez Jiménez y su tiempo: 1930-1948 (in Spanish). Consorcio de Ediciones Capriles. ISBN 978-980-6201-03-3. Retrieved 2024-04-05.
  23. 1 2 HERNÁNDEZ DROULERS, JIMENO JOSÉ (2020-01-15). "Los exilios". El Universal (in Spanish).
  24. 1 2 "Plan de Barranquilla". Fundación Empresas Polar (in Spanish).
  25. ↑ Lima Dávila, María Carolina; Massimini Arguello, Antonio Edmundo (February 2008). "LA POSTURA NEUTRAL VENEZOLANA FRENTE A LAS GUERRAS MUNDIALES" (PDF). Universidad Metropolitana de Caracas (in Spanish).
  26. ↑ Bustamante Luciani, Nora. "Medina Angarita, Isaías". Fundación Empresas Polar (in Spanish). Diccionario de Historia de Venezuela.
  27. ↑ Lucca, Rafael Arráiz (2022-09-15). "Isaías Medina Angarita: otra vuelta de tuerca (I Parte)". La Gran Aldea (in Spanish).
  28. ↑ Bruni Celli, Marco Tulio (2014). El 18 de octubre de 1945 (in Spanish). La Hoja del norte. ISBN 978-980-7212-41-0. Retrieved 2024-04-04.

Books

Journals