Bond v. United States (2014)
| Bond v. United States | |
|---|---|
![]() | |
| Argued November 5, 2013 Decided June 2, 2014 | |
| Full case name | Carol Anne Bond, Petitioner v. United States |
| Docket no. | 12-158 |
| Citations | 572 U.S. 844 (more) 134 S. Ct. 2077; 189 L. Ed. 2d 1 |
| Argument | Oral argument |
| Case history | |
| Prior | Bond v. United States, 564 U.S. 211 (2011); on remand, 681 F.3d 149 (3d Cir. 2012); cert. granted, 568 U.S. 1140 (2013). |
| Holding | |
| The Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Act does not criminalize "an amateur attempt by a jilted wife to injure her husband's lover" using chemicals. | |
| Court membership | |
| |
| Case opinions | |
| Majority | Roberts, joined by Kennedy, Ginsburg, Breyer, Sotomayor, Kagan |
| Concurrence | Scalia (in judgment), joined by Thomas; Alito (Part I) |
| Concurrence | Thomas (in judgment), joined by Scalia; Alito (Parts I, II, and III) |
| Concurrence | Alito (in judgment) |
| Laws applied | |
| 18 U.S.C. § 229 Concurrences: U.S. Const. arts. I, II, amend. X | |
Bond v. United States, 572 U.S. 844 (2014), was a United States Supreme Court case concerning whether and how international arms control agreements may regulate local crime. More specifically, it found that an attack committed by the petitioner, Carol Anne Bond, involving dangerous toxicants, was not usage of a chemical weapon under section 229(a)(1) of the Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Act (CWCIA), a law passed to bring the United States into compliance with the namesake treaty. The case followed up on a 2011 opinion of the same name involving the same parties.
Bond had been convicted of using a chemical weapon after she was caught spreading a mixture of toxic substances around her best friend's home, having learned of an affair between her and Bond's husband. Bond subsequently challenged her conviction on the basis that CWCIA section 229(a)(1) was an unconstitutional infringement on states' rights and that her actions did not violate it. After several years of litigation, including an initial trip to the Supreme Court, the Court heard the case in 2013 and decided it seven months later. Due to the apparent conflict between Bond's "local" crime and the CWCIA's passage pursuant to an international agreement, scholars of American federalism and foreign relations law, especially conservatives, were highly interested in the case's outcome, with some believing that the Court would overturn long-standing precedent on the topic.
The majority opinion, written by Chief Justice John Roberts, vacated Bond's conviction. It found that the CWCIA was not intended and could not properly be read to criminalize conduct like Bond's, given the Chemical Weapons Convention's goal of preventing chemical warfare and other potential mass-casualty scenarios. Samuel Alito, Antonin Scalia, and Clarence Thomas wrote concurrences agreeing with the case's outcome but arguing that the Court should have struck down section 229(a)(1) as unconstitutional.
Because the Court intentionally avoided constitutional questions in its majority opinion and did not overturn any precedents, the legal community largely characterized Bond as unexpectedly narrow and anticlimactic, though some observers have remarked that the case may have more significant implications for foreign relations and federalism than initially thought.
Background
Treaties and federalism
The United States Constitution contains two important clauses concerning treaties. Article II, which describes the powers of the president, grants the president the power, "by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, to make Treaties, provided two-thirds of the Senators present concur."[1]: 1523 Article VI describes treaties as forming part of the "supreme Law of the Land," alongside federal statutes and the Constitution itself.[2]: 1612 Furthermore, Article I, describing the powers of Congress, permits it to "make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper" to carry out other powers of the federal government.[3]: 29
Conversely, the Tenth Amendment restrains the federal government's powers to those described in the Constitution; other powers are "reserved to the States respectively."[4]: 486 These provisions, taken together, raised questions over whether Congress could avoid potential states' rights objections to federal legislation by entering into treaties and then passing laws to implement these treaties, especially given that, according to Article VI, federal law preempts, or supersedes, the laws of individual states.[5]
In 1920, the U.S. Supreme Court issued an opinion in Missouri v. Holland, which would prove to be "[t]he seminal decision concerning the scope of the treaty power," as described by Curtis A. Bradley.[4]: 486 Holland implied that legislation passed by Congress pursuant to a treaty was almost always valid, even if it would otherwise exceed the powers allotted to the federal government.[6]: 307 In 1957, this proposition was scaled back somewhat when the Supreme Court ruled in Reid v. Covert that treaties could not grant the government powers "free from the restraints of the Constitution."[7]: 82–83 Holland nonetheless remained good law, and lower courts were hesitant to discard its thesis that treaties granted Congress authority that it normally would not have.[8]: 184
For much of the 20th century, the question of the treaty power's scope was thought moot because Congress already had extensive powers under other parts of the Constitution.[7]: 83–84 In the 1990s, however, the Supreme Court began to institute and emphasize restraints on the federal government, reviving the debate over the treaty power's scope.[9]: 625–26 Two prominent views in favor of overruling Holland were that of Nicholas Quinn Rosenkranz, who believed that treaty-implementing legislation could not exceed Congress's pre-existing powers,[10]: 207–08 and Bradley, who argued that treaties themselves should be subject to the same limits as any other federal law.[11]: 1416 These arguments in favor of a limited treaty power were premised on the idea that treaties and their implementing legislation, if not properly checked, could infringe on the sovereignty afforded to states under the Tenth Amendment,[12] and supporters and critics of Holland debated whether it comported with the intended design of the Constitution.[13]: 74–78
The possibility of revisiting Holland came up in 2012, when the Supreme Court considered Golan v. Holder, which concerned whether legislation passed to implement the Berne Convention, a treaty concerning intellectual property, exceeded Congress's power to establish copyrights.[10]: 212 The government had argued that, even if the Court were to find that the legislation exceeded Congress's copyright powers, it would still be constitutional as treaty-implementing legislation under Holland.[14] During oral arguments in Golan, Justice Antonin Scalia commented, "I do not think a treaty can expand the powers of the federal government," implying an openness to overturning Holland.[15] However, Golan was ultimately decided without reliance on the Berne Convention or the treaty power.[16]: 1475
Chemical Weapons Convention
The Chemical Weapons Convention (CWC) is a multilateral treaty which prohibits countries from creating, using, or stockpiling chemical weapons.[17] The CWC additionally obligates countries to ensure that non-state actors, such as individuals or organizations, do not obtain or use chemical weapons, including passing criminal legislation to punish such.[18]: 2269–70 The United States ratified the CWC in 1997 and Congress passed the Chemical Weapons Implementation Act (CWCIA) in 1998 to bring it in compliance with the treaty.[19]: 117 Among other mechanisms to implement the CWC's goals, section 229(a)(1) of the CWCIA criminalizes individual possession and usage of chemical weapons,[20]: 208 more specifically making it illegal to "develop, produce, otherwise acquire, transfer directly or indirectly, receive, stockpile, retain, own, possess, or use, or threaten to use, any chemical weapon."[8]: 192
Events and procedural history

In 2005, microbiologist Carol Anne Bond learned that her husband had had an affair with her best friend, Myrlinda Haynes, resulting in pregnancy.[21] Seeking vengeance upon Haynes, Bond stole 10-chloro-10H-phenoxarsine, an arsenic-based compound, from her workplace and ordered potassium dichromate from the Internet.[22] She combined these chemicals into a toxic, bright-orange powder and dusted various surfaces around Haynes's home in Pennsylvania, including doorknobs and the inside of her car, with the substance.[23] In doing so, Bond intended to harm Haynes, but not kill her.[24]: 68
However, the mixture's color alerted Haynes as to Bond's actions, and ultimately, the only injury Haynes suffered at Bond's hands was a small burn on her thumb. Haynes's mail carrier alerted the U.S. Postal Service, which videotaped Bond spreading the mixture on 24 separate occasions.[25] Bond was subsequently arrested in 2007 and, after the trial court denied her motions to dismiss the charges,[26]: 16 pleaded guilty to mail fraud and possessing and using a chemical weapon in violation of section 229(a)(1),[27] reserving the right to appeal.[28]: 328 After being sentenced to six years in prison, she appealed to the Philadelphia-based Third Circuit Court of Appeals.[29]
The basis of Bond's appeal was that section 229(a)(1) was unconstitutional because it criminalized actions committed entirely within one state; regulating these "local" crimes is traditionally an exclusive power of the states rather than the federal government.[30]: 1007 Initially, however, the court of appeals found that Bond lacked standing to challenge the law.[31] The Supreme Court reversed this finding on appeal in 2011, requiring the court to decide the actual merits of Bond's claim.[32]
On remand, the court of appeals unanimously upheld her conviction, finding that section 229(a)(1) criminalized her assault on Haynes and, per Holland, was constitutional. Despite this, two of the three judges who heard the appeal, Kent Jordan and Thomas Ambro, suggested that the Supreme Court clarify the nature of Holland,[33]: 1960–61 with Ambro warning of a potential "blank check" for Congress to pass any law that was "rationally related to a valid treaty," while judge Marjorie Rendell wrote that federalism was irrelevant to the case.[34]: 433–34 Bond appealed to the Supreme Court, which on January 18, 2013, granted certiorari again, this time to consider Bond's statutory and constitutional arguments.[35]
Lead-up to the decision
Bond's brief to the Supreme Court argued that section 229(a)(1) did not cover her assault on Haynes, and if it did, it exceeded Congress's Article I powers,[36] while the government claimed that any usage of a chemical to harm violated the statute and that a ruling in favor of Bond would, by hampering the ability to implement treaties, cause international concern that the U.S. would not uphold its international obligations.[37] Due to the constitutional question raised by Bond, a significant portion of the legal community believed that the outcome of her case would be a watershed in American federalism and foreign relations,[38]: 134 with NPR characterizing it as "the most important decision on the treaty power since 1920 [when Holland was decided]."[39] Given the subject matter of the case, John Bellinger referred to it as "a cause célèbre among some conservatives,"[40] and political commentator George Will called it the "most momentous issue" of the term.[41]
On the other hand, Peter Spiro questioned the importance of a decision in Bond's case, noting that few if any instances of Congress actively exercising the treaty power existed, and that most laws passed pursuant to treaties could be passed as more typical legislation.[42] Rick Pildes wrote that, because the subject of the case was Congress's Article I powers to implement treaties, rather than the president and Senate's Article II powers to enter into them, even a favorable ruling for Bond could be circumvented by making a treaty "self-executing," or effective without the need for implementing legislation.[43] Julian Ku agreed and wrote that, if Holland were overruled, it could encourage the government to enter into more self-executing treaties.[44]
Several amicus briefs were submitted to the Court. The Cato Institute, the Claremont Institute's Center for Constitutional Jurisprudence, the Atlantic Legal Foundation, and Edwin Meese jointly submitted a brief arguing that Holland should be overruled.[45] Other briefs supporting Bond came from the Home School Legal Defense Association, Center for Individual Rights, and American Center for Law & Justice.[46] Eric Posner castigated the Cato Institute brief in particular as engaging in a "literal-minded" reading of the Constitution, comparing it to how "a kindergartener [sic] might read a board book" and calling it a sign of "the degraded state of our legal culture."[47] Bond also found an ally in Senator Ted Cruz, who wrote an article for the Harvard Law Review supporting her constitutional arguments.[48]
Columbia Law School professor and future International Court of Justice judge Sarah Cleveland, along with UC Hastings College of the Law professor William S. Dodge submitted a brief arguing that the CWCIA was permissible under a different constitutional provision permitting Congress to "define and punish ... offences against the law of nations,"[49] which the two later developed into a Yale Law Journal article.[18]: 2202 Other groups who filed briefs supporting the government included the American Chemistry Council,[50]: 341 Constitutional Accountability Center,[51] and six former legal advisors to the Department of State.[52]
Oral arguments
The Supreme Court heard oral arguments on November 5, 2013. Former Solicitor General and Supreme Court argument specialist Paul Clement represented Bond at oral arguments;[53] he had also represented Bond during her prior visit to the Supreme Court.[54]: 405 Incumbent Solicitor General Donald B. Verrilli Jr. represented the federal government. The attorneys and justices vigorously debated the scope of both the CWC and the treaty power. Stephen Breyer remarked that the treaty could potentially reach chemicals which, while unlawful, were not "weapons," such as performance-enhancing drugs, while Samuel Alito jokingly pondered whether chocolate, being poisonous to dogs, qualified as a chemical weapon.[55] Breyer and Anthony Kennedy discussed the possibility of narrowly construing the CWC to avoid implicating the Constitution or other domestic concerns. The justices also expressed worries about the potential effects of the case on American foreign relations. Chief Justice John Roberts noted that a prior Supreme Court decision, Medellín v. Texas, had also involved the intersection of international obligations and federalism and resulted in "serious conflict." Alito considered a narrow interpretation of "treaty" under the Constitution which would only encompass "matters that are of legitimate concern of a foreign State."[56]
Sonia Sotomayor noted that, at the time of oral arguments, the United States had recently condemned Syria for the Ghouta chemical attack, claiming that "it would be deeply ironic" if American chemical weapons control obligations were to become unconstitutional; Clement suggested that the Court resolve this by construing section 229(a)(1) to only encompass "war-like" usages of chemicals, though Verrilli claimed that the Court should instead respect the executive branch's "exclusive control over the treaty function." Ruth Bader Ginsburg noted an incongruity in the fact that neither party disputed that the CWC itself was constitutional, but the CWCIA did not add anything to the treaty's provisions; Clement responded that the CWC did not regulate individuals, though Elena Kagan pointed out that the treaty did command states to pass laws doing so.[57] Breyer criticized Verrilli's arguments in favor of a "comprehensive ban," emphasizing a need to "draw lines," though Kagan worried about the judiciary potentially usurping treaty-making.[58]
Roberts asked Verrilli whether Congress could claim "national police powers" using a treaty, to which Verrilli responded that it was "unimaginable" that the Senate would ratify such a treaty; Kennedy responded by calling the government's prosecution of Bond similarly "unimaginable." Scalia criticized the government for attempting to "drag Congress into areas where it has never been before," and suggested that, taking the government's arguments to the extreme, Congress could force all states to recognize same-sex marriage by ratifying an appropriate treaty.[59]
Despite the debate over the constitutionality of section 229(a)(1), neither party discussed Holland in detail.[60] Kagan and Clement briefly discussed it, though Clement distinguished Holland as not encompassing individual conduct.[61] After oral arguments, observers believed that the Court would overturn Bond's conviction,[62] though they were unsure how; Rosenkranz, who helped write the Cato Institute brief, remarked that "the Court may not reach the big question."[63]: 231 Holly Doremus of UC Berkeley School of Law conversely speculated that Verrilli's "aggressive" approach could lay groundwork for a sweeping ruling, in contrast to Clement's strategy of permitting a narrower outcome.[64]
Opinion
.jpg)
The Court issued its opinion on June 2, 2014. The justices unanimously overturned Bond's conviction, but were split 6–3 as to reasoning.[65] Chief Justice Roberts wrote the majority opinion, which found that the CWCIA did not criminalize Bond's actions. Contrary to expectations, Roberts did not write about the constitutionality of section 229(a)(1) and confined the opinion to the law's scope.[66]
Roberts began his opinion with a description of John Singer Sargent's painting Gassed, which depicts mustard gas victims during the First World War.[67] Characterizing Bond's crimes as nothing more than "an amateur attempt by a jilted wife to injure her husband's lover, which ended up causing only a minor thumb burn readily treated by rinsing with water," Roberts explained that the CWC, and thus the CWCIA, was intended to prohibit significantly more egregious behavior.[68]
Roberts noted that a guiding principle of statutory interpretation was the "federalism canon,"[69]: 1518 which states that, unless Congress has explicitly said otherwise, courts should not construe federal laws to reach into areas traditionally regulated by states, with one such area being local crime.[70]: 1566 With this in mind, Roberts wrote that the ordinary meaning of "chemical weapon," in addition to the basic goals and history of the CWC, implied that section 229(a)(1) only criminalized activity related to warfare and terrorism, giving the devastating chemical warfare in the First World War and Iran-Iraq War as an example.[71]: 1571–72 Bond's localized assault did not fit this definition, and a reading of section 229(a)(1) that did cover such activity would, according to Roberts, "sweep in everything from the detergent under the kitchen sink to the stain remover in the laundry room;"[72] such a wide interpretation was unexpressed by Congress and unjustifiable in light of the federalism canon.[73]: 158 Roberts closed by referring back to Gassed, noting, "There are no life-sized paintings of Bond's rival washing her thumb."[74]
Concurrences
Justices Alito, Scalia, and Clarence Thomas wrote individual concurrences. They all agreed with the majority in vacating Bond's conviction, but believed that section 229(a)(1) was an unconstitutional encroachment on states' rights under the Tenth Amendment. All three called for Holland to be limited or overruled.[2]: 1610–11
Scalia's concurrence began by criticizing the majority's interpretation of section 229(a)(1). He argued that Roberts had unnecessarily employed the federalism canon to distort the otherwise-clear meaning of "chemical weapon," which in his view did, in fact, encompass the chemicals Bond used to attack Haynes.[75]: 416 Because of this, Scalia believed that the Court should have considered Bond's constitutional arguments, decrying the majority's interpretation of the statute as "gruesome surgery" intended to shy away from the "obligation" the Court had to strike down unconstitutional legislation.[76]
Turning to the constitutional argument, Scalia considered what kind of treaty-related laws Congress could pass. Adopting Rosenkranz's argument against Holland, Scalia wrote that Article I only empowered Congress to pass laws which helped bring treaties into being, but not laws which implemented or enforced those treaties, which had to be supported by other provisions of the Constitution. Scalia believed that the reading of Article I in Holland granted essentially limitless power to the federal government;[77]: 1541–46 in theory, Congress could pass any legislation, unencumbered by the Constitution, simply by repeatedly making treaties with a foreign country.[78]
Thomas joined Scalia's concurrence, but wrote a separate opinion (which Scalia joined) discussing the nature of treaties under Article II. Taking an originalist perspective,[10]: 212–13 he stated that the founding generation would have only viewed agreements on international affairs to be "treaties," and thus the treaty power did not extend to purely domestic matters. However, he noted difficulties in discerning appropriate treaty subjects (in part because neither party discussed the matter in their briefs), expressing hope that "the increasing frequency with which treaties have begun to test the limits of the Treaty Power" would bring a new opportunity to consider the topic in detail.[1]: 1525–26
Alito joined Thomas's concurrence and Scalia's interpretation of section 229(a)(1). In a one-page concurrence, he endorsed Thomas's limitation of the treaty power to "matters of legitimate international concern," noting that, although the "heart" of the CWC was clearly an international matter, "insofar as the Convention may be read to obligate the United States to enact domestic legislation," it was outside the treaty power's proper scope.[79]: 302
Reactions
A decision that might have roared like a lion instead squeaked like a mouse.
Legal observers characterized the decision, particularly its avoidance of constitutional issues, as anticlimactic. Amy Howe, the founder of SCOTUSblog, compared the decision to the ending of Seinfeld,[72] while Josh Blackman remarked that, though disappointing "[a]t first blush," it was neither "fantastic" nor "terrible."[81] Simon Lazarus of The New Republic, on the other hand, saw the case as a "wake-up call," noting that it was a setback, but not a total defeat, for conservatives hoping to restrict the treaty power.[82]
Spiro speculated that the Court's hesitancy to resolve the constitutional problem may have been due to the case's underlying facts being "too freaky" to make a significant ruling on,[83] while Richard Re of Harvard Law School believed that the expected "grand verdict on Missouri v. Holland" was in the justices' eyes afield of the more practical matter of the prosecution's absurdity.[84] Several months after the decision, during oral arguments in Yates v. United States, which also involved an unusual prosecution under federal law, Scalia sardonically asked the government's attorney whether the prosecutor was "the same guy who brought Bond."[85]
Legal scholars were generally skeptical of the Court's reading of section 229(a)(1). Laurence Tribe harshly criticized the Court's attempt to narrowly read what he perceived as an unambiguous statute,[86] and Heather K. Gerkin considered Bond "the worst of both worlds" for having failed to significantly change federalism whilst also being '"filled with enough analytic holes that it could be dismembered by a 1L [first-year law student]."[87]: 92 On the other hand, Richard Lempert, writing for the Brookings Institution, described the Court's interpretation of section 229(a)(1) as "defensible," noting that, although it did not directly consult the statute's legislative history, its intuition that Congress could not have intended the law to cover crimes "as trivial as Bond’s" was "most likely correct."[88] Jonathan H. Adler wrote that "reading the statute narrowly so as to avoid the constitutional question" was "a common tactic of the Chief," noting similarities between Bond, Northwest Austin Municipal Utility District No. 1 v. Holder, and National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius.[89] Similarly S. Ernie Walton of Regent University School of Law, writing two years after the initial decision, noted that Bond reflected Roberts' "marked intention to favor precedent, defer to the political branches, and avoid broad, constitutional rulings—despite what the Constitution might require."[75]: 416
Observers also compared the majority opinion with the concurrences, especially Scalia's. David Golove and Marty Lederman called the Court's avoidance of Bond's constitutional arguments "a most welcome reprieve" for the treaty power, given that even the typically-conservative Kennedy and Roberts refused to endorse Scalia and Thomas's arguments against Holland.[90] David Sloss of Santa Clara University School of Law called Roberts's interpretation of the CWCIA "the lesser of two evils," writing that, despite being in his view incorrect, it was nonetheless preferable to Scalia's construction of the Constitution.[91]: 1584 Monica Hakimi of Columbia Law School remarked that the Court showed its "ambivalence" about the scope of the treaty power, but found the concurrences, particularly Scalia's, unconvincing.[92]: 89–90 Jean Galbraith of Rutgers Law School called Scalia's concurrence "strained," though she agreed with its statutory analysis.[93] Conversely, Rosenkranz, who called the majority's analysis of section 229(a)(1) "dodgy," commended all three concurrences as "some of the most scholarly and thoughtful treaty opinions ever to emanate from the Supreme Court,"[79]: 287–88 with particular praise for Scalia's, which he called "extremely important, and exactly right."[94] Ilya Somin found both the majority and concurrences unconvincing, stating that, although he believed that section 229(a)(1) was unlawful, he did not agree with either Scalia or Thomas's reasoning.[95]
Despite the Court's attempt to "sidestep" Holland and the lack of constitutional analysis, some scholars have read the opinion to have more significant implications than traditionally thought, particularly in terms of interpreting treaty-implementing statutes. Michael J. Glennon and Robert D. Sloane have argued that Bond de facto made Holland unworkable, as any statute that implemented a treaty would have to be interpreted in accordance with the federalism canon, defeating the point of permitting treaty-implementing legislation to exceed typical Congressional powers.[7]: 80–81 Ryan Scoville of Marquette University Law School likewise expressed puzzlement at the usage of the federalism canon in the context of Holland and noted that future treaty-implementing legislation would need to clearly express Congress's intent to override state law.[96] Dodge similarly remarked that requiring implementing legislation to follow the federalism canon "potentially creates a wedge between the interpretation of a treaty and its implementing legislation."[97]: 87
Scholars have also discussed Bond's impact in terms of general restraints on federal power. Llewellyn J. Gibbons of University of Toledo College of Law argued that, although Bond could be interpreted narrowly as merely restating the federalism canon, the case's "references to federalism open the door to a broader understanding of State power."[98]: 155–56 Alison L. LaCroix relatedly claimed that Bond implied a "hierarchy" of legislative powers, where treaty implementation was close to the bottom and subject to harsher scrutiny.[99]: 33 Conversely, Dylann M. Taxman of Baylor Law School, reflecting ten years after Bond, wrote that the Supreme Court failed to set a precedent restraining the federal government. To the contrary, courts had taken Bond to permit federal prosecutions for any crimes which could lead to mass suffering, local or otherwise.[100]: 132–33
See also
- Bricker Amendment, proposed limitation of Congress's treaty powers
- Destruction of chemical weapons in the United States
References
- 1 2 Swaine, Edward T. (May 2015). "Bond's Breaches". Notre Dame Law Review. 90 (4): 1517–1538.
- 1 2 Ku, Julian; Yoo, John (May 2015). "Bond, the Treaty Power, and the Overlooked Value of Non-Self-Executing Treaties". Notre Dame Law Review. 90 (4): 1607–1630.
- ↑ Nash, Jonathan Remy (2016). "Doubly Uncooperative Federalism and the Challenge of U.S. Treaty Compliance". Columbia Journal of Transnational Law. 55 (1): 3–64 – via HeinOnline.
- 1 2 Bradley, Curtis A. (July 2014). "Federalism, Treaty Implementation, and Political Process: Bond v. United States". Chicago Unbound. 108 (3): 486–496.
- ↑ Weiner, Sarah (March 2, 2017). "When Do Treaties Preempt State Law?". Yale Journal of International Law. Archived from the original on December 5, 2025. Retrieved March 30, 2026.
- ↑ Lawson, Gary (January 2017). "Original Foreign Affairs Federalism". Boston University Law Review. 97 (1): 301–314.
- 1 2 3 Glennon, Michael J.; Sloane, Robert D. (Winter 2016). "The Sad, Quiet Death of Missouri v. Holland: How Bond Hobbled the Treaty Power". Yale Journal of International Law. 41 (1): 51–102.
- 1 2 Peral, Stephanie (2013). "Bond v. United States: Deciphering Missouri v. Holland and the Scope of Congress's Powers when Implementing a Non-Self-Executing Treaty". Duke Journal of Constitutional Law & Public Policy Sidebar. 9: 179–199.
- ↑ Corn, Geoffrey S.; Brenner-Beck, Dru (Spring 2015). "Exploring U.S. Treaty Practice Through a Military Lens" (PDF). Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy. 38 (2): 547–628.
- 1 2 3 Van Houten, Gregory (Winter 2016). "Testing Congress's Foreign Commerce and Treaty Powers: A New, (Un)Constitutional Tool for Combating American Child Sex Tourists". American Criminal Law Review. 53 (1): 177–214 – via HeinOnline.
- ↑ Hollis, Duncan B. (May 2015). "An Intersubjective Treaty Power". Notre Dame Law Review. 90 (4): 1415–1464.
- ↑ Bradley, Curtis A. (January 27, 2013). "Bond v. United States and the Treaty Power Debate". Lawfare. Archived from the original on March 13, 2026. Retrieved May 8, 2026.
- ↑ Galbraith, Jean (October 2014). "Congress's Treaty-Implementing Power in Historical Practice". William & Mary Law Review. 56 (1): 59–113.
- ↑ Shapiro, Ilya (January 27, 2012). "Copyright Case May Have Profound Effect on Treaty Power". Jurist. Archived from the original on September 20, 2024. Retrieved May 8, 2026.
- ↑ Shapiro, Ilya (October 7, 2011). "Justice Scalia Reads Cato's Amicus Briefs". Cato at Liberty. Archived from the original on December 26, 2020. Retrieved May 8, 2026.
- ↑ Cohen, Harlan Grant (December 2015). "The Death of Deference and the Domestication of Treaty Law". BYU Law Review. 2015 (6): 1467–1498.
- ↑ Green, Shannon; Moulton, John; Parthemore, Christine (August 18, 2023). "Fulfilling the Humane Promise of the Chemical Weapons Convention". Lawfare. Archived from the original on September 12, 2025. Retrieved March 19, 2026.
- 1 2 Cleveland, Sarah H.; Dodge, William S. (May 2015). "Defining and Punishing Offenses Under Treaties" (PDF). Yale Law Journal. 124 (7): 2202–2284.
- ↑ Kellman, Barry (January 1999). "The Advent of International Chemical Regulation: The Chemical Weapons Convention Implementation Act". Journal of Legislation. 25 (2): 117–139.
- ↑ Muldoon, Anna; Kornblet, Sarah; Katz, Rebecca (September 2011). "Carol Anne Bond v the United States of America: How a Woman Scorned Threatened the Chemical Weapons Convention" (PDF). Biosecurity and Bioterrorism: Biodefense Strategy, Practice, and Science. 9 (3): 207–211.
- ↑ "Wife Tries to Poison Husband's Pregnant Lover". ABC News. February 22, 2011. Archived from the original on February 10, 2026. Retrieved February 10, 2026.
- ↑ Mears, Bill (June 3, 2014). "Justices: Feds erred with chemical weapons charges in love-triangle case". CNN. Archived from the original on August 21, 2025. Retrieved February 10, 2026.
- ↑ Mears, Bill (February 22, 2011). "High court debates implications of poisoned paramour case". CNN. Archived from the original on October 9, 2020. Retrieved February 10, 2026.
- ↑ Nickles, Dean M. (February 2015). "Bond v. United States". Notre Dame Law Review Online. 90 (2): 68–76.
- ↑ Totenberg, Nina (November 5, 2013). "A Toxic Love Triangle Heads To The Supreme Court". NPR. Archived from the original on August 4, 2025. Retrieved February 10, 2026.
- ↑ Brenner-Beck, Dru (2014). "Federalism and the Treaty Power: Breaking the 'Bond(s)' Between Nations: The Treaty Power and Status of Forces Agreements". American University National Security Law Brief. 5 (1): 1–34.
- ↑ Mears, Bill (November 5, 2013). "Justices divided over 'toxic love' case involving states' rights". CNN. Archived from the original on August 16, 2014. Retrieved February 10, 2026.
- ↑ Godlove, Nicholas C. (2011). "U.S. Supreme Court Cases on Gender and Criminal Justice from the 2010 Term". Women & Criminal Justice. 21 (4): 328–331. doi:10.1080/08974454.2011.624479.
- ↑ Liptak, Adam (October 18, 2010). "A 10th Amendment Drama Fit for Daytime TV Heads to the Supreme Court". The New York Times. Archived from the original on September 10, 2025. Retrieved February 10, 2026.
- ↑ Thompson, Scott G.; Klimmek, Christopher (Spring 2012). "Tenth Amendment Challenges After Bond v. United States". University of San Francisco Law Review. 46 (4): 995–1028.
- ↑ Youderian, Anna (September 18, 2009). "Court Upholds Use of Chemical Weapons Law". Courthouse News Service. Archived from the original on May 4, 2026. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
- ↑ Denniston, Lyle (July 16, 2011). "Opinion analysis: States' rights ruling, a big deal or not?". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on December 10, 2025. Retrieved March 13, 2026.
- ↑ Sullivan, Scott (2015). "The Future of the Foreign Commerce Clause". Fordham Law Review. 83 (4): 1955–1995.
- ↑ Crook, John R. (April 2013). "Contemporary Practice of the United States Relating to International Law". American Journal of International Law. 107 (2): 431–434. doi:10.5305/amerjintelaw.107.2.0431.
- ↑ Denniston, Lyle (November 2, 2013). "Argument preview: New look at old precedent". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on September 16, 2025. Retrieved April 10, 2026.
- ↑ Epps, Garrett (October 31, 2013). "A Soap-Opera Court Case That Could Seriously Threaten U.S. Foreign Policy". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on July 3, 2025. Retrieved April 14, 2026.
- ↑ Howe, Amy (November 5, 2013). "Treaty power before the Court: In Plain English". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on January 18, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Cope, Kevin L. (April 2014). "Lost in Translation: The Accidental Origins of Bond v. United States". Michigan Law Review First Impressions. 112 (1): 133–141.
- ↑ Chappell, Bill (June 2, 2014). "Chemical Weapons Law Doesn't Apply To Jilted Lover, Supreme Court Rules". NPR. Archived from the original on December 24, 2025. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Bellinger, John (November 8, 2013). "Bond v United States: The Supreme Court Should Not Let Bad Facts Make Bad Law". Lawfare. Archived from the original on September 8, 2025. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
- ↑ Will, George (November 3, 2013). "George Will: High Court's biggest issue? A thumb". The Daily Telegram. Archived from the original on May 6, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Spiro, Peter (November 4, 2013). "Bond v. United States and the Non-Use of the Treaty Power". Opinio Juris. Archived from the original on September 12, 2025. Retrieved March 14, 2026.
- ↑ Pildes, Rick (January 16, 2013). "Does Congress Have the Power to Enforce Treaties? Part II". The Volokh Conspiracy. Archived from the original on October 14, 2025. Retrieved May 8, 2026.
- ↑ Ku, Julian (January 19, 2013). "Will Bond v. United States Matter?". Opinio Juris. Archived from the original on September 11, 2025. Retrieved May 8, 2026.
- ↑ Rosenkranz, Nicholas Quinn; Shapiro, Ilya; Burrus, Trevor (May 15, 2013). "Bond v. United States". Cato Institute. Archived from the original on May 14, 2021. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
- ↑ Walsh, Mark (November 5, 2013). "Unusual Supreme Court Mix: Chemical Weapons, Treaties, and Education". Education Week. Archived from the original on December 10, 2025. Retrieved April 15, 2026.
- ↑ Posner, Eric (October 31, 2013). "Is the Constitution Written Like the Da Vinci Code?". Slate. Archived from the original on July 9, 2025. Retrieved April 16, 2026.
- ↑ Kleiner, Sam (January 20, 2014). "Why Did Ted Cruz Write a Harvard Law Review Article Embracing a Convicted Poisoner's Cause?". The New Republic. Archived from the original on September 7, 2025. Retrieved April 15, 2026.
- ↑ "Bond v. U.S. and the Treaty Ties that Bind". Columbia Law School. November 11, 2013. Archived from the original on May 29, 2024. Retrieved March 19, 2026.
- ↑ Joyce, Catherine (2014). "Dulce et Decorum: The Unique Perception of Chemical Warfare and the Enforcement of the Geneva Protocol in the 21st Century". Pacific McGeorge Global Business & Development Law Journal. 28 (2): 331–357.
- ↑ Meyer, Joey (June 9, 2014). "Trick or Treaty Power: What Justice Scalia's Concurrence in Bond v. United States Ignores". Constitutional Accountability Center. Archived from the original on February 11, 2026. Retrieved April 15, 2026.
- ↑ Williamson, Edwin (November 11, 2013). "Bond v. United States: Response from Edwin Williamson". Lawfare. Archived from the original on September 15, 2025. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
- ↑ Howe, Amy (November 6, 2013). "Wednesday round-up". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on January 12, 2026. Retrieved April 15, 2026.
- ↑ Bashman, Howard J. (2013). "Looking Ahead: October Term 2013" (PDF). Cato Supreme Court Review. 2013: 393–408.
- ↑ Howe, Amy (November 6, 2013). "Little drama, more skepticism in treaty power case: In Plain English". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on January 16, 2026. Retrieved April 12, 2026.
- ↑ Lederman, Marty (November 6, 2013). "Seven Observations About the Oral Argument in Bond". Opinio Juris. Archived from the original on March 6, 2026. Retrieved April 12, 2026.
- ↑ Barnes, Robert (November 5, 2013). "Supreme Court finds dilemma in spurned wife's conviction". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on August 18, 2024. Retrieved April 14, 2026.
- ↑ Wolf, Richard (November 5, 2013). "Justices decry chemical arms case against jilted wife". USA Today. Archived from the original on August 15, 2025. Retrieved April 15, 2026.
- ↑ Denniston, Lyle (November 5, 2013). "Argument recap: A tense hour at the Court". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on January 23, 2026. Retrieved April 12, 2026.
- ↑ Ku, Julian (November 5, 2013). "A Quick Reaction to Oral Argument in Bond v. U.S.: Missouri v. Holland is in Real Trouble". Opinio Juris. Archived from the original on September 12, 2025. Retrieved April 12, 2026.
- ↑ Richey, Warren (November 5, 2013). "Supreme Court skeptical about use of chemical weapons treaty in charging wife". Christian Science Monitor. Archived from the original on November 6, 2024. Retrieved April 15, 2026.
- ↑ Golove, David (November 6, 2013). "Bond v. United States and a Plain Statement Rule". Just Security. Archived from the original on February 8, 2026. Retrieved April 14, 2026.
- ↑ Rosenkranz, Nicholas Quinn (2013). "Bond v. United States: Can the President Increase Congress's Legislative Power by Entering into a Treaty?". New York University Journal of Law & Liberty. 8: 228–259.
- ↑ Doremus, Holly (November 7, 2013). "Is Missouri v. Holland in the Court's crosshairs?". Legal Planet. Archived from the original on October 14, 2025. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Richey, Warren (June 2, 2014). "US Supreme Court: don't use chemical weapons ban to charge vengeful wife". Christian Science Monitor. Archived from the original on August 24, 2025. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
- ↑ Denniston, Lyle (June 2, 2014). "Opinion analysis: World law and "romantic jealousy"". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on March 6, 2026. Retrieved April 10, 2026.
- ↑ "Jealous wife who sought revenge wins court fight". Tampa Bay Times. June 2, 2014. Archived from the original on April 10, 2026. Retrieved April 10, 2026.
- ↑ "Supreme Court Rules Wife's Revenge Not a Chemical Weapons Attack". NBC News. June 2, 2014. Archived from the original on October 1, 2024. Retrieved March 19, 2026.
- ↑ Galbraith, Jean (December 2015). "What Should the Restatement (Fourth) Say About Treaty Interpretation?". BYU Law Review. 2015 (6): 1499–1524.
- ↑ Moore, David H. (May 2015). "Treaties and the Presumption against Preemption". BYU Law Review. 2015 (6): 1555–1580.
- ↑ Alford, Roger P. (May 2015). "Bond and the Vienna Rules". Notre Dame Law Review. 90 (4): 1561–1582.
- 1 2 Howe, Amy (June 2, 2014). "A narrow reading of chemical weapons ban for Bond: In Plain English". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on January 18, 2026. Retrieved April 10, 2026.
- ↑ Sourgens, Frédéric Gilles (June 2019). "States of Resistance". Duke Journal of Constitutional Law & Public Policy. 14 (1): 91–168.
- ↑ de Vogue, Ariane (June 2, 2014). "Bizarre Love Triangle Poison Case Overturned By Supreme Court". ABC News. Archived from the original on April 10, 2026. Retrieved April 10, 2026.
- 1 2 Walton, S. Ernie (2016). "The Judicial Philosophy of Chief Justice John Roberts: An Analysis Through the Eyes of International Law". Emory International Law Review. 30 (3): 391–432.
- ↑ Barnes, Robert (June 2, 2014). "Supreme Court throws out 'two-bit' conviction based on chemical weapons ban". The Washington Post. Archived from the original on March 8, 2018. Retrieved May 3, 2026.
- ↑ Ramsey, Michael D. (May 2015). "Congress's Limited Power to Enforce Treaties". Notre Dame Law Review. 90 (4): 1539–1560.
- ↑ Epps, Garrett (June 2, 2014). "Woman Not Guilty of Chemical Warfare; Constitution Saved". The Atlantic. Archived from the original on January 31, 2023. Retrieved April 10, 2026.
- 1 2 Rosenkranz, Nicholas Quinn (2014). "Bond v. United States: Concurring in the Judgment". Cato Supreme Court Review. 2014: 285–306.
- ↑ Stephan, Paul B. (May 2015). "Bond v. United States and Information-Forcing Defaults: The Work that Presumptions Do". Notre Dame Law Review. 90 (4): 1465–1498.
- ↑ Blackman, Josh (June 2, 2014). "Bond Dissolves With Federalism". Josh Blackman. Archived from the original on April 16, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Lazarus, Simon (June 9, 2014). "The Supreme Court Deals Radical Conservatives a Foreign-Policy Setback". The New Republic. Archived from the original on February 15, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Spiro, Peter (June 3, 2014). "Bond Cheat Sheet". Opinio Juris. Archived from the original on August 13, 2025. Retrieved April 14, 2026.
- ↑ Re, Richard (June 2, 2014). "Prosecutorial Discretion in Bond". Re's Judicata. Archived from the original on February 1, 2023. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Denniston, Lyle (November 5, 2014). "Argument analysis: Building to a Scalia crescendo". SCOTUSblog. Archived from the original on March 8, 2026. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Tribe, Laurence (November 2016). "Soundings and Silences". Michigan Law Review Online. Archived from the original on February 12, 2026. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Gerken, Heather K. (November 2014). "Slipping the 'Bonds' of Federalism". Harvard Law Review. 128 (1): 85–123.
- ↑ Lempert, Richard (September 2, 2014). "A Poisoned Door Knob and the Fate of the Affordable Care Act: Reading Tea Leaves at the Supreme Court". Brookings. Archived from the original on March 10, 2026. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Adler, Jonathan H. (June 2, 2014). "A day without dissents on the Supreme Court". The Volokh Conspiracy. Archived from the original on June 13, 2017. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Golove, David; Lederman, Marty (June 3, 2014). "Stepping back from the precipice in Bond". Just Security. Archived from the original on December 5, 2025. Retrieved April 14, 2026.
- ↑ Sloss, David (May 2015). "Bond v. United States: Choosing the Lesser of Two Evils". Notre Dame Law Review. 90 (4): 1583–1606.
- ↑ Hakimi, Monica (2014). "The Bond Court's Institutional Truce". AJIL Unbound. 108: 89–90.
- ↑ Galbraith, Jean (June 2, 2014). "Guest Post: Silences in the Bond Case". Opinio Juris. Archived from the original on December 14, 2025. Retrieved April 14, 2026.
- ↑ Rosenkranz, Nicholas Quinn (June 3, 2014). "Justice Scalia's masterful concurrence in Bond v. United States". The Volokh Conspiracy. Archived from the original on July 22, 2019. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Somin, Ilya (June 2, 2014). "Thoughts on Bond v. United States". The Volokh Conspiracy. Archived from the original on June 13, 2017. Retrieved May 6, 2026.
- ↑ Scoville, Ryan (July 25, 2014). "US Supreme Court Review: Bond v. United States". Marquette University Law School Faculty Blog. Archived from the original on January 15, 2026. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
- ↑ Dodge, William S. (2014). "Bond v. United States and Congress's Role in Implementing Treaties". AJIL Unbound. 108: 86–88. doi:10.1017/S2398772300001914.
- ↑ Gibbons, Llewellyn J. (2015). "E Unum Pluribus: After Bond v. United States, State Law as a Gap Filler to Meet The International Obligations of the United States". Washington University Journal of Law and Policy. 46: 149–184.
- ↑ LaCroix, Alison L. (November 2014). "Redeeming Bond?". Harvard Law Review. 128 (1): 31–38.
- ↑ Taxman, Dylann M. (June 2025). "'I'm Guilty, But I'm Not a War Criminal!': Fixing Treaty Crimes". Duke Journal of Constitutional Law & Public Policy. 20 (1): 113–165.
External links
- Text of Bond v. United States, 572 U.S. 844 (2014) is available from: Google Scholar Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Oyez (oral argument audio) Supreme Court (slip opinion) (archived)



.jpg)

.jpg)