In re Debs

In re Debs
Supreme Court of the United States
Argued March 25–26, 1895 Decided May 27, 1895
Full case name	In re Eugene V. Debs, Petitioner
Citations	158 U.S. 564 (more) 15 S. Ct. 900; 39 L. Ed. 1092; 1895 U.S. LEXIS 2279
Holding
The court ruled that the government had a right to regulate interstate commerce and ensure the operations of the Post Office Department, along with a responsibility to "ensure the general welfare of the public."
Court membership
Chief Justice Melville Fuller Associate Justices Stephen J. Field · John M. Harlan Horace Gray · David J. Brewer Henry B. Brown · George Shiras Jr. Howell E. Jackson · Edward D. White
Case opinion
Majority	Brewer, joined by unanimous
Laws applied
Commerce Clause; Postal Clause
Superseded by
Lauf v. E. G. Shinner & Co. (1938)
Abrogated by
Norris–La Guardia Act of 1932

In re Debs, 158 U.S. 564 (1895), was a labor law case of the United States Supreme Court, which upheld a contempt of court conviction against Eugene V. Debs. Debs had the American Railway Union continue its 1894 Pullman Strike in violation of a federal injunction ordering labor unions back to work. The Supreme Court held that the federal government's Postal and Commerce Clause authority includes the ability to regulate the labor conditions of railways.

Background

Eugene V. Debs, president of the American Railway Union, had been involved in the Pullman Strike earlier in 1894 and challenged the federal injunction ordering the strikers back to work where they would face being fired. The injunction had been issued because of the violent nature of the strike. However, Debs refused to end the strike and was subsequently cited for contempt of court; he appealed the decision to the courts.

The main question being debated was whether the federal government had a right to issue the injunction, which dealt with both interstate and intrastate commerce and shipping on rail cars.

Judgment

The Fuller Court

Justice David Josiah Brewer held, for a unanimous court, in favor of the U.S. government. Joined by Chief Justice Melville Fuller and Justices Stephen Johnson Field, John Marshall Harlan, Horace Gray, Henry Billings Brown, George Shiras Jr., Howell Edmunds Jackson, and Edward Douglass White, the court ruled that the government had a right to regulate interstate commerce and ensure the operations of the Post Office Department, along with a responsibility to "ensure the general welfare of the public." The decision slowed the momentum of labor unions. Debs would go on to lose another Supreme Court case in Debs v. United States.

Significance

In Loewe v. Lawlor, the Supreme Court stated that unions were potentially liable for antitrust violations. In response, Congress passed the Clayton Antitrust Act of 1914 to take unions out of antitrust law. In addition, the ability to issue labor injunctions was greatly reduced with the passage of the Norris–La Guardia Act of 1932, which stripped the jurisdiction of federal courts over labor disputes, and was later upheld by the Supreme Court in Lauf v. E. G. Shinner & Co., 303 U.S. 323 (1938).

See also

• List of United States Supreme Court cases, volume 158

Further reading

• Papke, David Ray (April 1999). The Pullman Case: The Clash of Labor and Capital in Industrial America. Landmark Law Cases and American Society. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas. ISBN 0-7006-0954-7. LCCN 98-50880. OCLC 40339932.

External links

• Works related to In re Debs at Wikisource
• Text of In re Debs, 158 U.S. 564 (1895) is available from: Justia Library of Congress WorldLII