Teams
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
2010 team
- See footnotes[5][6][7]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Kiehl Frazier | Quarterback | Shiloh Christian School | Springdale, Arkansas | Auburn |
| Savon Huggins | Running back | St. Peter's Preparatory School | Jersey City, New Jersey | Rutgers |
| Malcolm Brown | Running back | Steele High School | Cibolo, Texas | Texas |
| Jeremy Hill | Running back | Redemptorist High School | Baton Rouge, Louisiana | LSU |
| Demetrius Hart | Running back | Dr. Phillips High School | Orlando, Florida | Alabama |
| Cyrus Kouandjio | Offensive line | DeMatha Catholic High School | Hyattsville, Maryland | Alabama |
| Christian Westerman | Offensive line | Hamilton High School | Chandler, Arizona | Auburn |
| Brandon Shell | Offensive line | Goose Creek High School | Charleston, South Carolina | South Carolina |
| La'el Collins | Offensive line | Redemptorist High School | Baton Rouge, Louisiana | LSU |
| Zach Banner‡ | Offensive line | Lakes High School | Lakewood, Washington | USC |
| Dorial Green-Beckham‡ | Wide receiver | Hillcrest High School | Springfield, Missouri | Missouri |
| Kasen Williams | Wide receiver | Skyline High School | Sammamish, Washington | Washington |
| Jace Amaro | Tight end | MacArthur High School | San Antonio, Texas | Texas Tech |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Jadeveon Clowney | Defensive line | South Pointe High School | Rock Hill, South Carolina | South Carolina |
| Tim Jernigan | Defensive line | Columbia High School | Lake City, Florida | Florida State |
| Anthony Johnson | Defensive line | O. Perry Walker High School | New Orleans, Louisiana | LSU |
| Viliami Moala | Defensive line | Grant High School | Sacramento, California | California |
| Ray Drew | Defensive line | Thomas County Central High School | Thomasville, Georgia | Georgia |
| Curtis Grant | Linebacker | Hermitage High School | Richmond, Virginia | Ohio State |
| James Wilder, Jr. | Linebacker | Plant High School | Tampa, Florida | Florida State |
| Stephone Anthony | Linebacker | Anson High School | Wadesboro, North Carolina | Clemson |
| Tony Steward | Linebacker | Pedro Menendez High School | St. Augustine, Florida | Clemson |
| De'Anthony Thomas | Defensive back | Crenshaw High School | Los Angeles, California | Oregon |
| Ha'Sean Clinton-Dix | Defensive back | Dr. Phillips High School | Orlando, Florida | Alabama |
| Jordan Phillips | Athlete | Circle High School | Towanda, Kansas | Oklahoma |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Cody Kessler | Quarterback | Centennial High School | Bakersfield, California | USC |
| Mike Bellamy | Running back | Charlotte High School | Punta Gorda, Florida | Clemson |
| Aaron Green | Running back | Madison High School | San Antonio, Texas | Nebraska |
| Nick O'Leary | Tight end | Dwyer High School | West Palm Beach, Florida | Florida State |
| Trey Metoyer | Wide receiver | Whitehouse High School | Whitehouse, Texas | Oklahoma |
| Charone Peake | Wide receiver | Dorman High School | Roebuck, South Carolina | Clemson |
| Matt Freeman | Offensive line | Cooper High School | Abilene, Texas | Texas State |
| Ryne Reeves | Offensive line | Crete High School | Crete, Nebraska | Nebraska |
| Kiaro Holts | Offensive line | Warren Central High School | Indianapolis, Indiana | North Carolina |
| Brey Cook | Offensive line | Har-Ber High School | Springdale, Arkansas | Arkansas |
| Michael Bennett | Offensive line | Centerville High School | Centerville, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Mac McGuire | Placekicker | Carroll High School | Southlake, Texas | Boston University |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Connor McGovern | Defensive line | Shanley High School | Fargo, North Dakota | Missouri |
| Kevin McReynolds | Defensive line | St. John's High School | Washington, D.C. | UCLA |
| Jesse Hayes | Defensive line | Moeller High School | Cincinnati, Ohio | Wisconsin |
| Kris Harley | Defensive line | Warren Central High School | Indianapolis, Indiana | Virginia Tech |
| Trey DePriest | Linebacker | Springfield High School | Springfield, Ohio | Alabama |
| Lawrence Thomas | Linebacker | Renaissance High School | Detroit, Michigan | Michigan State |
| Tre Madden | Linebacker | Mission Viejo High School | Mission Viejo, California | USC |
| Derek Watt | Linebacker | Pewaukee High School | Pewaukee, Wisconsin | Wisconsin |
| Brandon Mullins | Linebacker | Coppell High School | Coppell, Texas | Syracuse |
| Karlos Williams | Defensive back | Ridge Community High School | Davenport, Florida | Florida State |
| Doran Grant | Defensive back | St. Vincent – St. Mary High School | Akron, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Jabriel Washington | Defensive back | Trinity Christian Academy | Jackson, Tennessee | Alabama |
2011 team
- See footnotes[11]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Dorial Green-Beckham | Wide receiver | Hillcrest High School | Springfield, Missouri | Missouri |
| Jameis Winston | Quarterback | Hueytown High School | Hueytown, Alabama | Florida State |
| Johnathan Gray | Running back | Aledo High School | Aledo, Texas | Texas |
| Rushel Shell | Running back | Hopewell High School | Aliquippa, Pennsylvania | Pittsburgh |
| Kelvin Taylor‡ | Running back | Glades Day School | Belle Glade, Florida | Florida |
| D. J. Humphries | Offensive line | Mallard Creek High School | Charlotte, North Carolina | Florida |
| John Theus | Offensive line | Bolles School | Jacksonville, Florida | Georgia |
| Andrus Peat | Offensive line | Corona del Sol High School | Tempe, Arizona | Stanford |
| Zach Banner | Offensive line | Lakes High School | Lakewood, Washington | USC |
| J. J. Denman | Offensive line | Pennsbury High School | Fairless Hills, Pennsylvania | Rutgers |
| Jordan Westerkamp | Wide receiver | Montini Catholic High School | Lombard, Illinois | Nebraska |
| Stefon Diggs | Wide receiver | Good Counsel High School | Olney, Maryland | Maryland |
| Ross Martin | Kicker | Walsh Jesuit High School | Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio | Duke |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Mario Edwards Jr. | Defensive line | Ryan High School | Denton, Texas | Florida State |
| Ellis McCarthy | Defensive line | Monrovia High School | Monrovia, California | UCLA |
| Noah Spence | Defensive line | Bishop McDevitt High School | Harrisburg, Pennsylvania | Ohio State |
| Tommy Schutt | Defensive line | Glenbard West High School | Glen Ellyn, Illinois | Ohio State |
| Darius Hamilton | Defensive line | Don Bosco Preparatory High School | Ramsey, New Jersey | Rutgers |
| Vince Biegel | Linebacker | Lincoln High School | Wisconsin Rapids, Wisconsin | Wisconsin |
| Scott Starr | Linebacker | Norco High School | Norco, California | USC |
| Noor Davis | Linebacker | Leesburg High School | Leesburg, Florida | Stanford |
| Shaq Thompson | Defensive back | Grant Union High School | Sacramento, California | Washington |
| Landon Collins | Defensive back | Dutchtown High School | Geismar, Louisiana | Alabama |
| Leon McQuay III‡ | Defensive back | Armwood High School | Seffner, Florida | USC |
| Tracy Howard | Defensive back | Miramar High School | Miramar, Florida | Miami (FL) |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Gunner Kiel | Quarterback | Columbus East High School | Columbus, Indiana | Notre Dame |
| Nelson Agholor | Running back | Berkeley Preparatory School | Tampa, Florida | USC |
| D. J. Foster | Running back | Saguaro High School | Scottsdale, Arizona | Arizona State |
| Ty Isaac, Jr.‡ | Running back | Joliet Catholic High School | Joliet, Illinois | USC |
| T. J. Yeldon | Running back | Daphne High School | Daphne, Alabama | Alabama |
| Arik Armstead | Offensive line | Pleasant Grove High School | Elk Grove, California | Oregon |
| Hiva Lutui | Offensive line | Trinity High School | Euless, Texas | Utah |
| Jordan Simmons | Offensive line | Crespi High School | Encino, California | USC |
| Jordan Diamond | Offensive line | Simeon Career Academy | Chicago, Illinois | Auburn |
| Cayleb Jones | Wide receiver | Austin High School | Austin, Texas | Texas |
| Shaq Roland | Wide receiver | Lexington High School | Lexington, South Carolina | South Carolina |
| Bradley Pinion | Placekicker | Northwest Cabarrus High School | Concord, North Carolina | Clemson |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Eddie Goldman | Defensive line | Friendship Collegiate Charter School | Washington, D.C. | Florida State |
| Caleb Gulledge | Defensive line | Prattville High School | Prattville, Alabama | Alabama |
| Robert Nkemdiche‡ | Defensive line | Grayson High School | Loganville, Georgia | Ole Miss |
| Benetton Fonua | Linebacker | Kahuku High School | Kahuku, Hawaii | Hawaii |
| DeMarkus Lathan‡ | Linebacker | Longview High School | Longview, Texas | Tarleton State |
| Justin Lyles | Linebacker | Phoebus High School | Hampton, Virginia | Concord |
| Antonio Morrison | Linebacker | Bolingbrook High School | Bolingbrook, Illinois | Florida |
| Jabari Ruffin | Linebacker | Downey High School | Downey, California | USC |
| Ronald Darby | Defensive back | Potomac High School | Oxon Hill, Maryland | Florida State |
| Yuri Wright | Defensive back | Don Bosco Preparatory High School | Ramsey, New Jersey | Colorado |
| Sal Martinez | Defensive back | Edinburg High School | Edinburg, Texas | UTSA |
2012 team
- See footnotes[13]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ and ‡‡ denotes high school juniors and sophomores, respectively
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Max Browne | Quarterback | Skyline High School | Sammamish, Washington | USC |
| Thomas Tyner | Running back | Aloha High School | Aloha, Oregon | Oregon |
| Derrick Henry | Running back | Yulee High School | Yulee, Florida | Alabama |
| Robert Foster | Wide receiver | Central Valley High School | Monaca, Pennsylvania | Alabama |
| Laquon Treadwell | Wide receiver | Crete-Monee High School | Crete, Illinois | Ole Miss |
| Hunter Henry | Tight end | Pulaski Academy | Little Rock, Arkansas | Arkansas |
| Evan Lisle | Offensive line | Centerville High School | Centerville, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Ethan Pocic | Offensive line | Lemont High School | Lemont, Illinois | LSU |
| Grant Hill | Offensive line | Huntsville High School | Huntsville, Alabama | Alabama |
| Kent Perkins | Offensive line | Lake Highlands High School | Dallas, Texas | Texas |
| Laremy Tunsil | Offensive line | Columbia High School | Lake City, Florida | Ole Miss |
| Matt Wogan | Kicker | Porter Ridge High School | Indian Trail, North Carolina | Oregon |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Su'a Cravens | Defensive back | Vista Murrieta High School | Murrieta, California | USC |
| Jabrill Peppers‡ | Defensive back | Paramus Catholic High School | Paramus, New Jersey | Michigan |
| Marlon Humphrey‡ | Defensive back | Hoover High School | Hoover, Alabama | Alabama |
| Vernon Hargreaves III | Defensive back | Wharton High School | Tampa, Florida | Florida |
| Reuben Foster | Linebacker | Auburn High School | Auburn, Alabama | Alabama |
| Peter Kalambayi | Linebacker | Butler High School | Matthews, North Carolina | Stanford |
| Jaylon Smith | Linebacker | Bishop Luers High School | Fort Wayne, Indiana | Notre Dame |
| Andrew Brown‡ | Defensive line | Oscar Smith High School | Chesapeake, Virginia | Virginia |
| Montravius Adams | Defensive line | Dooly County High School | Vienna, Georgia | Auburn |
| Robert Nkemdiche | Defensive line | Grayson High School | Loganville, Georgia | Ole Miss |
| Dee Liner | Defensive line | Muscle Shoals High School | Muscle Shoals, Alabama | Alabama |
| Henry Poggi | Defensive line | Gilman School | Baltimore, Maryland | Michigan |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Austin Kafentzis‡‡ | Quarterback | Jordan High School | Sandy, Utah | Wisconsin |
| Greg Bryant | Running back | American Heritage School | Delray Beach, Florida | Notre Dame |
| Derrick Green | Running back | Hermitage High School | Richmond, Virginia | Michigan |
| Kelvin Taylor | Running back | Glades Day School | Belle Glade, Florida | Florida |
| LaQuvionte Gonzalez | Running back | Cedar Hill High School | Cedar Hill, Texas | Texas A&M |
| Leonard Fournette‡ | Running back | St. Augustine High School | New Orleans, Louisiana | LSU |
| Tramel Terry | Wide receiver | Goose Creek High School | Goose Creek, South Carolina | Georgia |
| Jalen Brown‡ | Wide receiver | Mountain Pointe High School | Phoenix, Arizona | Oregon |
| Kyle Bosch | Offensive line | St. Francis High School | Wheaton, Illinois | Michigan |
| Cameron Hunt | Offensive line | Centennial High School | Corona, California | California |
| Thomas Duarte | Tight end | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | UCLA |
| Austin Rehkow | Placekicker | Central Valley High School | Spokane Valley, Washington | Idaho |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Jonathan Allen | Defensive line | Stone Bridge High School | Ashburn, Virginia | Alabama |
| Da'Shawn Hand‡ | Defensive line | Woodbridge High School | Woodbridge, Virginia | Alabama |
| Tim Williams‡ | Defensive line | Louisiana State University Lab School | Baton Rouge, Louisiana | Alabama |
| Joey Bosa | Defensive line | St. Thomas Aquinas High School | Fort Lauderdale, Florida | Ohio State |
| A'Shawn Robinson | Defensive line | Arlington Heights High School | Fort Worth, Texas | Alabama |
| Eddie Vanderdoes | Defensive line | Placer High School | Placer, California | Notre Dame |
| Michael Hutchings | Linebacker | De La Salle High School | Concord, California | USC |
| Mark Fossati‡ | Linebacker | St. Joseph High School | Montvale, New Jersey | Princeton |
| Raekwon McMillan‡ | Linebacker | Liberty County High School | Hinesville, Georgia | Ohio State |
| Max Redfield | Defensive back | Mission Viejo High School | Mission Viejo, California | Notre Dame |
| Leon McQuay III | Defensive back | Armwood High School | Seffner, Florida | USC |
| Tony Brown‡ | Defensive back | Ozen High School | Beaumont, Texas | Alabama |
2013 team
- See footnotes[15]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Leonard Fournette | Running back | St. Augustine High School | New Orleans, Louisiana | LSU |
| Kyler Murray‡ | Quarterback | Allen High School | Allen, Texas | Texas A&M |
| Dalvin Cook | Running back | Miami Central High School | Miami, Florida | Florida State |
| Sony Michel | Running back | American Heritage School | Plantation, Florida | Georgia |
| Malachi Dupre | Wide receiver | John Curtis Christian High School | River Ridge, Louisiana | LSU |
| Allen Lazard | Wide receiver | Urbandale High School | Urbandale, Iowa | Iowa State |
| Trey Quinn | Wide receiver | Barbe High School | Lake Charles, Louisiana | LSU |
| Damien Mama | Offensive line | St. John Bosco High School | Bellflower, California | USC |
| Damian Prince | Offensive line | Bishop McNamara High School | Forestville, Maryland | Maryland |
| Cameron Robinson | Offensive line | West Monroe High School | West Monroe, Louisiana | Alabama |
| Braden Smith | Offensive line | Olathe South High School | Olathe, Kansas | Auburn |
| Cole Hedlund | Kicker | Argyle High School | Argyle, Texas | Arkansas |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Jabrill Peppers | Defensive back | Paramus Catholic High School | Paramus, New Jersey | Michigan |
| Marlon Humphrey | Defensive back | Hoover High School | Hoover, Alabama | Alabama |
| Adoree' Jackson | Defensive back | Serra High School | Gardena, California | USC |
| Steven Parker | Defensive back | Jenks High School | Jenks, Oklahoma | Oklahoma |
| Dante Booker, Jr. | Linebacker | St. Vincent-St. Mary High School | Akron, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Raekwon McMillan | Linebacker | Liberty County High School | Hinesville, Georgia | Ohio State |
| Nyles Morgan | Linebacker | Crete-Monee High School | Crete, Illinois | Notre Dame |
| Tre Williams | Linebacker | St. Paul's Episcopal School | Mobile, Alabama | Auburn |
| Andrew Brown | Defensive line | Oscar Smith High School | Chesapeake, Virginia | Virginia |
| Lorenzo Carter | Defensive line | Norcross High School | Norcross, Georgia | Georgia |
| Da'Shawn Hand | Defensive line | Woodbridge High School | Woodbridge, Virginia | Alabama |
| Gerald Willis | Defensive line | Karr High School | New Orleans, Louisiana | Florida |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Deshaun Watson | Quarterback | Gainesville High School | Gainesville, Georgia | Clemson |
| Elijah Hood | Running back | Charlotte Catholic High School | Charlotte, North Carolina | North Carolina |
| Joe Mixon | Running back | Freedom High School | Oakley, California | Oklahoma |
| Racean Thomas | Running back | Oxford High School | Oxford, Alabama | Auburn |
| K. D. Cannon | Wide receiver | Mount Pleasant High School | Mount Pleasant, Texas | Baylor |
| Alex Bars | Offensive line | Montgomery Bell Academy | Nashville, Tennessee | Notre Dame |
| Orlando Brown Jr. | Offensive line | Peachtree Ridge High School | Suwanee, Georgia | Oklahoma |
| Garrett Brumfield | Offensive line | Louisiana State University Lab School | Baton Rouge, Louisiana | LSU |
| Demetrius Knox | Offensive line | All Saint's Episcopal Day School\ | Fort Worth, Texas | Ohio State |
| K. C. McDermott | Offensive line | Palm Beach Central High School | Wellington, Florida | Miami (FL) |
| Quenton Nelson | Offensive line | Red Bank Catholic High School | Red Bank, New Jersey | Notre Dame |
| Gary Wunderlich | Placekicker | Memphis University School | Memphis, Tennessee | Ole Miss |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Demarcus Christmas | Defensive line | Manatee High School | Bradenton, Florida | Florida State |
| Matt Dickerson | Defensive line | Serra High School | San Mateo, California | Notre Dame |
| Matt Elam | Defensive line | John Hardin High School | Elizabethtown, Kentucky | Kentucky |
| Connor Humphreys | Defensive line | Central Catholic High School | Portland, Oregon | Arizona State |
| Chad Thomas | Defensive line | Booker T. Washington High School | Miami, Florida | Miami (FL) |
| Solomon Thomas | Defensive line | Coppell High School | Coppell, Texas | Stanford |
| Dillon Bates | Linebacker | Ponte Vedra High School | Ponte Vedra, Florida | Tennessee |
| Jamardre Cobb | Linebacker | Salesian High School | Los Angeles, California | Arizona |
| Christian Miller | Linebacker | Spring Valley High School | Columbia, South Carolina | Alabama |
| Kenny Young | Linebacker | John Curtis Christian High School | River Ridge, Louisiana | UCLA |
| Quin Blanding | Defensive back | Bayside High School | Virginia Beach, Virginia | Virginia |
| Tony Brown | Defensive back | Ozen High School | Beaumont, Texas | Alabama |
2014 team
- See footnotes[17][18]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Kyler Murray | Quarterback | Allen High School | Allen, Texas | Texas A&M |
| Josh Rosen | Quarterback | St. John Bosco High School | Bellflower, California | UCLA |
| Jake Browning | Quarterback | Folsom High School | Folsom, California | Washington |
| Soso Jamabo | Running back | Plano West High School | Plano, Texas | UCLA |
| Damien Harris | Running back | Madison Southern High School | Berea, Kentucky | Alabama |
| Alizé Jones | Tight end | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | Notre Dame |
| DaMarkus Lodge | Wide receiver | Cedar Hill High School | Cedar Hill, Texas | Ole Miss |
| Tyron Johnson | Wide receiver | Warren Easton High School | New Orleans, Louisiana | LSU |
| Tristen Hoge | Offensive line | Highland High School | Pocatello, Idaho | Notre Dame |
| Martez Ivey | Offensive line | Apopka High School | Apopka, Florida | Florida |
| Mitch Hyatt | Offensive line | North Gwinnett High School | Suwanee, Georgia | Clemson |
| Maea Teuhema | Offensive line | Keller High School | Keller, Texas | LSU |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Trenton Thompson | Defensive line | Westover High School | Albany, Georgia | Georgia |
| Byron Cowart | Defensive line | Armwood High School | Seffner, Florida | Auburn |
| Terry Beckner, Jr. | Defensive line | East St. Louis High School | East St. Louis, Illinois | Missouri |
| Rasheem Green | Defensive line | Junípero Serra High School | Gardena, California | USC |
| Malik Jefferson | Linebacker | Poteet High School | Mesquite, Texas | Texas |
| Justin Hilliard | Linebacker | St. Xavier High School | Cincinnati, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Leo Lewis | Linebacker | Brookhaven High School | Brookhaven, Mississippi | Mississippi State |
| Iman Marshall | Defensive back | Polytechnic High School | Long Beach, California | USC |
| Kevin Toliver II | Defensive back | Trinity Christian Academy | Jacksonville, Florida | LSU |
| Kendall Sheffield | Defensive back | Marshall High School | Missouri City, Texas | Alabama |
| Terry Godwin | Defensive back | Callaway High School | Hogansville, Georgia | Georgia |
| Kevin Robledo | Kicker/Punter | Westlake High School | Westlake Village, California | Florida State |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Tate Martell‡‡ | Quarterback | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | Ohio State |
| Ben DiNucci | Quarterback | Pine-Richland High School | Gibsonia, Pennsylvania | Pittsburgh |
| Ke'Shawn Vaughn | Running back | Pearl-Cohn High School | Nashville, Tennessee | Illinois |
| Jacques Patrick | Running back | Timber Creek High School | Orlando, Florida | Florida State |
| Sihiem King | Running back | Colquitt County High School | Moultrie, Georgia | Kentucky |
| Christian Kirk | Wide receiver | Saguaro High School | Scottsdale, Arizona | Texas A&M |
| Deon Cain | Wide receiver | Tampa Bay Tech High School | Tampa, Florida | Clemson |
| George Campbell | Wide receiver | East Lake High School | Tarpon Springs, Florida | Florida State |
| Tommy Kraemer‡ | Offensive line | Elder High School | Cincinnati, Ohio | Notre Dame |
| Greg Little‡ | Offensive line | Allen High School | Allen, Texas | Ole Miss |
| Chuma Edoga | Offensive line | McEachern High School | Powder Springs, Georgia | USC |
| Michael Tarbutt | Placekicker | Canisius High School | Buffalo, New York | Connecticut |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Natrez Patrick | Defensive line | Mays High School | Atlanta, Georgia | Georgia |
| Joseph Wicker | Defensive line | Polytechnic High School | Long Beach, California | Arizona State |
| Shy Tuttle | Defensive line | North Davidson High School | Lexington, North Carolina | Tennessee |
| Joe Gaziano | Defensive line | Xaverian Brothers High School | Westwood, Massachusetts | Northwestern |
| Thomas Hutchings | Linebacker | Cedar Park High School | Cedar Park, Texas | Stephen F. Austin |
| Sam Kuschnick | Linebacker | Silverton High School | Silverton, Oregon | Oregon State |
| John Houston | Linebacker | Junípero Serra High School | Gardena, California | USC |
| Porter Gustin | Linebacker | Salem Hills High School | Salem, Utah | USC |
| Kerryon Johnson | Defensive back | Madison Academy | Madison, Alabama | Auburn |
| Niko Small | Defensive back | Bowie High School | Arlington, Texas | TCU |
| Derwin James | Defensive back | Haines City High School | Haines City, Florida | Florida State |
| Minkah Fitzpatrick | Defensive back | St. Peter's Preparatory School | Jersey City, New Jersey | Alabama |
2015 team
- See footnotes[20][21]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Jacob Eason | Quarterback | Lake Stevens High School | Lake Stevens, Washington | Georgia |
| Drake Davis | All-purpose back | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | LSU |
| Sean McGrew | Running back | St. John Bosco High School | Bellflower, California | Washington |
| Tavien Feaster | Running back | Spartanburg High School | Spartanburg, South Carolina | Clemson |
| Najee Harris‡ | Running back | Antioch High School | Antioch, California | Alabama |
| Nate Craig-Myers | Wide receiver | Tampa Catholic High School | Tampa, Florida | Auburn |
| Donnie Corley | Wide receiver | Martin Luther King High School | Detroit, Michigan | Michigan State |
| Isaac Nauta | Tight end | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Georgia |
| Greg Little | Offensive line | Allen High School | Allen, Texas | Ole Miss |
| Ben Bredeson | Offensive line | Arrowhead High School | Hartland, Wisconsin | Michigan |
| Tommy Kraemer | Offensive line | Elder High School | Cincinnati, Ohio | Notre Dame |
| Quinn Nordin | Placekicker | Rockford High School | Rockford, Michigan | Michigan |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Rashan Gary | Defensive line | Paramus Catholic High School | Paramus, New Jersey | Michigan |
| Dexter Lawrence | Defensive line | Wake Forest High School | Wake Forest, North Carolina | Clemson |
| Derrick Brown | Defensive line | Lanier High School | Sugar Hill, Georgia | Auburn |
| Marlon Davidson | Defensive line | Greenville High School | Greenville, Alabama | Auburn |
| Mique Juarez | Linebacker | North High School | Torrance, California | UCLA |
| Lyndell Wilson | Linebacker | Carver High School | Montgomery, Alabama | Alabama |
| Ben Davis | Linebacker | Gordo High School | Gordo, Alabama | Alabama |
| Caleb Kelly | Linebacker | Clovis West High School | Fresno, California | Oklahoma |
| Levonta Taylor | Defensive back | Ocean Lakes High School | Virginia Beach, Virginia | Florida State |
| Shaun Wade‡ | Defensive back | Trinity Christian Academy | Jacksonville, Florida | Ohio State |
| Saivion Smith | Defensive back | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | LSU |
| Drue Chrisman | Kicker/Punter | La Salle High School | Cincinnati, Ohio | Ohio State |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Shea Patterson | Quarterback | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Ole Miss |
| Cecil Langston | Running back | Rivercrest High School | Wilson, Arkansas | Henderson State |
| DeShawn Smith | Running back | Nature Coast High School | Brooksville, Florida | Savannah State |
| Ty Chandler‡ | Running back | Montgomery Bell Academy | Nashville, Tennessee | Tennessee |
| Dillon Mitchell | Wide receiver | White Station High School | Memphis, Tennessee | Oregon |
| Simi Fehoko | Wide receiver | Brighton High School | Cottonwood Heights, Utah | Stanford |
| Naseir Upshur | Tight end | Imhotep Charter High School | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | Florida State |
| Erik Swenson | Offensive line | Downers Grove South High School | Downers Grove, Illinois | Oklahoma |
| Michael Jordan | Offensive line | Plymouth High School | Canton Township, Michigan | Ohio State |
| Jonah Williams | Offensive line | Folsom High School | Folsom, California | Alabama |
| Terrance Davis | Offensive line | DeMatha High School | Hyattsville, Maryland | Maryland |
| Connor Culp | Placekicker | Desert Vista High School | Phoenix, Arizona | LSU |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| McTelvin Agim | Defensive line | Hope High School | Hope, Arkansas | Arkansas |
| Marvin Wilson‡ | Defensive line | Episcopal High School | Bellaire, Texas | Florida State |
| Julian Rochester | Defensive line | McEachern High School | Powder Springs, Georgia | Georgia |
| Ed Oliver | Defensive line | Westfield High School | Houston, Texas | Houston |
| Shane Simmons | Linebacker | DeMatha Catholic High School | Hyattsville, Maryland | Penn State |
| Rahshaun Smith | Linebacker | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Clemson |
| Keandre Jones | Linebacker | Good Counsel High School | Olney, Maryland | Ohio State |
| Brandon Jones | Defensive back | Nacogdoches High School | Nacogdoches, Texas | Texas |
| Mecole Hardman | Defensive back | Elbert County High School | Elberton, Georgia | Georgia |
| Nigel Warrior | Defensive back | Peachtree Ridge High School | Suwanee, Georgia | Tennessee |
| Trayvon Mullen | Defensive back | Coconut Creek High School | Coconut Creek, Florida | Clemson |
| Logan Tyler | Punter | Nixa High School | Nixa, Missouri | Florida State |
2016 team
- See footnotes[22]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Tate Martell | Quarterback | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | Ohio State |
| Cam Akers | Quarterback | Clinton High School | Clinton, Mississippi | Florida State |
| D'Andre Swift | Running back | Saint Joseph's Preparatory School | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | Georgia |
| Najee Harris | Running back | Antioch High School | Antioch, California | Alabama |
| Donovan Peoples-Jones | Wide receiver | Cass Tech High School | Detroit, Michigan | Michigan |
| Jeff Thomas | Wide receiver | East St. Louis High School | St. Louis, Missouri | Miami |
| Foster Sarell | Offensive line | Graham-Kapowsin High School | Graham, Washington | Stanford |
| Trey Smith | Offensive line | University School of Jackson | Jackson, Tennessee | Tennessee |
| Calvin Ashley | Offensive line | St. John's College High School | Washington, D.C. | Auburn |
| Wyatt Davis | Offensive line | St. John Bosco High School | Bellflower, California | Ohio State |
| Josh Myers | Offensive line | Miamisburg High School | Miamisburg, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Blake Haubeil | Placekicker | Canisius High School | Buffalo, New York | Ohio State |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Shaun Wade | Defensive back | Trinity Christian Academy | Jacksonville, Florida | Ohio State |
| Jaelan Phillips | Defensive line | Redlands East Valley High School | Redlands, California | UCLA |
| Marvin Wilson | Defensive line | Episcopal High School | Bellaire, Texas | Florida State |
| Joshua Kaindoh | Defensive line | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Florida State |
| Anthony Hines III | Linebacker | Plano East Senior High School | Plano, Texas | Texas A&M |
| Nate McBride | Linebacker | Vidalia Comprehensive High School | Vidalia, Georgia | Georgia |
| Dylan Moses | Linebacker | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Alabama |
| Jeff Okudah | Defensive back | South Grand Prairie High School | Grand Prairie, Texas | Ohio State |
| Bubba Bolden | Defensive back | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | USC |
| Richard LeCounte | Defensive back | Liberty County High School | Hinesville, Georgia | Georgia |
| JaCoby Stevens | Defensive back | Oakland High School | Murfreesboro, Tennessee | LSU |
| Pressley Harvin III | Kicker/Punter | Sumter High School | Sumter, South Carolina | Georgia Tech |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Jake Fromm | Quarterback | Warner Robins High School | Warner Robins, Georgia | Georgia |
| Eno Benjamin | Running back | Wylie East High School | Wylie, Texas | Arizona State |
| Ty Chandler | Running back | Montgomery Bell Academy | Nashville, Tennessee | Tennessee |
| Khalan Laborn | Running back | Bishop Sullivan Catholic High School | Virginia Beach, Virginia | Florida State |
| Tee Higgins | Wide receiver | Oak Ridge High School | Oak Ridge, Tennessee | Clemson |
| Jerry Jeudy | Wide receiver | Deerfield Beach High School | Deerfield Beach, Florida | Alabama |
| Colby Parkinson | Tight end | Oaks Christian High School | Westlake Village, California | Stanford |
| Austin Jackson | Offensive line | North Canyon High School | Phoenix, Arizona | USC |
| Walker Little | Offensive line | Episcopal High School | Bellaire, Texas | Stanford |
| Alex Leatherwood | Offensive line | Booker T. Washington High School | Pensacola, Florida | Alabama |
| Isaiah Wilson | Offensive line | Poly Prep Country Day School | Brooklyn, New York | Georgia |
| Brandon Ruiz | Placekicker | Williams Field High School | Gilbert, Arizona | Alabama |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| A. J. Epenesa | Defensive line | Edwardsville High School | Edwardsville, Illinois | Iowa |
| Tavis Lee‡ | Defensive line | Martinsburg High School | Martinsburg, West Virginia | West Virginia |
| Aubrey Solomon | Defensive line | Lee County High School | Leesburg, Georgia | Michigan |
| Xavier Thomas‡ | Defensive line | Wilson High School | Florence, South Carolina | Clemson |
| Louis Acceus | Linebacker | St. Joseph Regional High School | Montvale, New Jersey | NC State |
| Baron Browning | Linebacker | Kennedale High School | Kennedale, Texas | Ohio State |
| Willie Gay | Linebacker | Starkville High School | Starkville, Mississippi | Mississippi State |
| Matt Lorbeck | Linebacker | Bay Port High School | Green Bay, Wisconsin | Northern Illinois |
| Chase Young | Linebacker | DeMatha High School | Hyattsville, Maryland | Ohio State |
| Darnay Holmes | Defensive back | Calabasas High School | Calabasas, California | UCLA |
| Patrick Surtain II‡ | Defensive back | American Heritage School | Plantation, Florida | Alabama |
| Trevor Denbow | Punter | Corsicana High School | Corsicana, Texas | SMU |
2017 team
- See footnotes[23][24]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Trevor Lawrence | Quarterback | Cartersville High School | Cartersville, Georgia | Clemson |
| J. T. Daniels | Quarterback | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | USC |
| Lorenzo Lingard | Running back | University High School | Orange City, Florida | Miami (FL) |
| Zamir White | Running back | Scotland County High School | Laurinburg, North Carolina | Georgia |
| Amon-Ra St. Brown | Wide receiver | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | USC |
| Jackson Carman | Offensive line | Fairfield High School | Fairfield, Ohio | Clemson |
| Devontae Dobbs‡ | Offensive line | Belleville High School | Belleville, Michigan | Michigan State |
| Cade Mays | Offensive line | Knoxville Catholic High School | Knoxville, Tennessee | Georgia |
| Jamaree Salyer | Offensive line | Pace Academy | Atlanta, Georgia | Georgia |
| Brey Walker | Offensive line | Westmoore High School | Moore, Oklahoma | Oklahoma |
| Jeremy Ruckert | Tight end | Lindenhurst High School | Lindenhurst, New York | Ohio State |
| Ryan Fitzgerald‡ | Placekicker | Colquitt County High School | Moultrie, Georgia | Florida State |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Solomon Tuliaupupu | Linebacker | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | USC |
| Nik Bonitto | Defensive line | St. Thomas Aquinas High School | Fort Lauderdale, Florida | Oklahoma |
| Nesta Silvera | Defensive line | American Heritage School | Plantation, Florida | Miami (FL) |
| Xavier Thomas | Defensive line | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Clemson |
| Taron Vincent | Defensive line | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Ohio State |
| Matthew Bauer | Linebacker | Cathedral Preparatory School | Erie, Pennsylvania | Notre Dame |
| Teradja Mitchell | Linebacker | Bishop Sullivan Catholic High School | Virginia Beach, Virginia | Ohio State |
| Channing Tindall | Linebacker | Spring Valley High School | Columbia, South Carolina | Georgia |
| Akeem Dent‡ | Defensive back | Palm Beach Central High School | Wellington, Florida | Florida State |
| A. J. Lytton | Defensive back | Wise High School | Upper Marlboro, Maryland | Florida State |
| Isaac Taylor-Stuart | Defensive back | Helix High School | La Mesa, California | USC |
| Brian Williams‡ | Defensive back | Bishop Dunne Catholic School | Dallas, Texas | Texas A&M |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Phil Jurkovec | Quarterback | Pine-Richland High School | Gibsonia, Pennsylvania | Notre Dame |
| Tony Brown | Running back | East Central High School | Moss Point, Mississippi | South Alabama |
| Eric Gray‡ | Running back | Lausanne Collegiate School | Memphis, Tennessee | Tennessee |
| Ricky Slade Jr. | Running back | Hylton High School | Woodbridge, Virginia | Penn State |
| Rondale Moore | Wide receiver | Trinity High School | Louisville, Kentucky | Purdue |
| Justin Shorter | Wide receiver | South Brunswick High School | Monmouth Junction, New Jersey | Penn State |
| Emil Ekiyor Jr. | Offensive line | Cathedral High School | Indianapolis, Indiana | Alabama |
| Trey Hill | Offensive line | Houston County High School | Warner Robins, Georgia | Georgia |
| Nicholas Petit-Frere | Offensive line | Berkeley Preparatory School | Tampa, Florida | Ohio State |
| Rasheed Walker | Offensive line | North Point High School | Waldorf, Maryland | Penn State |
| Brevin Jordan | Tight end | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | Miami (FL) |
| Seth Small | Placekicker | Katy High School | Katy, Texas | Texas A&M |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Eyabi Anoma | Defensive line | St. Frances Academy | Baltimore, Maryland | Alabama |
| KJ Henry | Defensive line | West Forsyth High School | Clemmons, North Carolina | Clemson |
| Micah Parsons | Defensive line | Harrisburg High School | Harrisburg, Pennsylvania | Penn State |
| Nolan Smith‡ | Defensive line | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Georgia |
| Kayvon Thibodeaux‡ | Defensive line | Oaks Christian High School | Westlake Village, California | Oregon |
| Bo Calvert | Linebacker | Oaks Christian High School | Westlake Village, California | UCLA |
| Palaie Gaoteote | Linebacker | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | USC |
| Owen Pappoe‡ | Linebacker | Grayson High School | Loganville, Georgia | Auburn |
| Drake Thomas‡ | Linebacker | Heritage High School | Wake Forest, North Carolina | NC State |
| Anthony Cook | Defensive back | Lamar High School | Houston, Texas | Texas |
| Patrick Surtain II | Defensive back | American Heritage School | Plantation, Florida | Alabama |
| Logan Taylor | Defensive back | Narbonne High School | Harbor City, California | Hawaii |
2018 team
- See footnotes[25][26]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| DJ Uiagalelei‡ | Quarterback | St. John Bosco High School | Bellflower, California | Clemson |
| Bo Nix | Quarterback | Pinson Valley High School | Pinson, Alabama | Auburn |
| Zach Evans‡ | Running back | North Shore High School | Houston, Texas | TCU |
| Eric Gray | Running back | Lausanne Collegiate School | Memphis, Tennessee | Tennessee |
| Jamious Griffin | Running back | Rome High School | Rome, Georgia | Georgia Tech |
| David Bell | Wide receiver | Warren Central High School | Indianapolis, Indiana | Purdue |
| Puka Nacua | Wide receiver | Orem High School | Orem, Utah | Washington |
| Bru McCoy | Wide receiver | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | USC |
| Garrett Wilson | Wide receiver | Lake Travis High School | Austin, Texas | Ohio State |
| Hudson Henry | Tight end | Pulaski Academy | Little Rock, Arkansas | Arkansas |
| Logan Brown | Offensive line | East Kentwood High School | Kentwood, Michigan | Wisconsin |
| Kardell Thomas | Offensive line | Southern University Lab High School | New Orleans, Louisiana | LSU |
| Clay Webb | Offensive line | Oxford High School | Oxford, Alabama | Georgia |
| Darnell Wright | Offensive line | Huntington High School | Huntington, West Virginia | Tennessee |
| Ryan Fitzgerald | Placekicker | Colquitt County High School | Moultrie, Georgia | Florida State |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Kayvon Thibodeaux | Defensive line | Oaks Christian High School | Westlake Village, California | Oregon |
| Bryan Bresee‡ | Defensive line | Damascus High School | Damascus, Maryland | Clemson |
| George Karlaftis | Defensive line | West Lafayette High School | West Lafayette, Indiana | Purdue |
| Siaki Ika | Defensive line | East High School | Salt Lake City, Utah | LSU |
| Nolan Smith | Defensive line | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Georgia |
| Ishmael Sopsher | Defensive line | Amite High Magnet School | Amite City, Louisiana | Alabama |
| Nakobe Dean | Linebacker | Horn Lake High School | Horn Lake, Mississippi | Georgia |
| Justin Flowe‡ | Linebacker | Upland High School | Upland, California | Oregon |
| Brandon Smith | Linebacker | Louisa County High School | Mineral, Virginia | Penn State |
| Cade Stover | Linebacker | Lexington High School | Lexington, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Daxton Hill | Defensive back | Booker T. Washington High School | Tulsa, Oklahoma | Michigan |
| Derek Stingley Jr. | Defensive back | The Dunham School | Baton Rouge, Louisiana | LSU |
| Chris Steele | Defensive back | St. John Bosco High School | Bellflower, California | USC |
| Eli Ricks‡ | Defensive back | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | LSU |
| Jay Bramblett | Placekicker | Katy High School | Tuscaloosa, Alabama | Notre Dame |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Kaiden Bennett | Quarterback | Folsom High School | Folsom, California | Boise State |
| Grant Gunnell | Quarterback | St. Pius X High School | Houston, Texas | Arizona |
| John Emery Jr. | Running back | Destrehan High School | Destrehan, Louisiana | LSU |
| Trey Sanders | Running back | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Alabama |
| Charlie Spegal‡ | Running back | New Palestine High School | New Palestine, Indiana | Indiana |
| Julian Fleming‡ | Wide receiver | Southern Columbia High School | Catawissa, Pennsylvania | Ohio State |
| Jadon Haselwood | Wide receiver | Cedar Grove High School | Ellenwood, Georgia | Oklahoma |
| Theo Wease Jr. | Wide receiver | Allen High School | Allen, Texas | Oklahoma |
| Jake Smith | Wide receiver | Notre Dame Preparatory High School | Scottsdale, Arizona | Texas |
| Brayden Liebrock | Tight end | Chandler High School | Chandler, Arizona | Texas |
| Wanya Morris | Offensive Line | Grayson High School | Loganville, Georgia | Tennessee |
| Nolan Rumler | Offensive Line | Archbishop Hoban High School | Akron, Ohio | Michigan |
| Will Reichard | Placekicker | Hoover High School | Birmingham, Alabama | Alabama |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Antonio Alfano | Defensive line | Colonia High School | Colonia, New Jersey | Alabama |
| Chris Braswell‡ | Defensive line | St. Frances Academy | Baltimore, Maryland | Alabama |
| McKinnley Jackson‡ | Defensive line | George County High School | Lucedale, Mississippi | Texas A&M |
| Zacch Pickens | Defensive line | T. L. Hanna High School | Anderson, South Carolina | South Carolina |
| Ty Robinson | Defensive line | Gilbert High School | Gilbert, Arizona | Nebraska |
| Faatui Tuitele | Defensive line | Saint Louis School | Honolulu, Hawaii | Washington |
| De'Gabriel Floyd | Linebacker | Westlake High School | Westlake Village, California | Texas |
| Owen Pappoe | Linebacker | Grayson High School | Loganville, Georgia | Auburn |
| Shane Lee | Linebacker | St. Frances Academy | Baltimore, Maryland | Alabama |
| Henry To'oTo'o | Linebacker | De La Salle High School | Concord, California | Tennessee |
| Akeem Dent | Defensive back | Palm Beach Central High School | Wellington, Florida | Florida State |
| Kyle Hamilton | Defensive back | Marist School | Atlanta, Georgia | Notre Dame |
| DeMarcco Hellams | Defensive back | DeMatha Catholic High School | Hyattsville, Maryland | Alabama |
| Mike Sainristil | Defensive back | Everett High School | Everett, Massachusetts | Michigan |
| Austin McNamara | Placekicker | Highland High School | Gilbert, Arizona | Texas Tech |
2019 team
- See footnotes[27][28]
[29]
[30]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ denotes high school juniors
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Bryce Young | Quarterback | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | Alabama |
| DJ Uiagalelei | Quarterback | St. John Bosco High School | Bellflower, California | Clemson |
| Demarkus Bowman | Running back | Lakeland High School | Lakeland, Florida | Clemson |
| Bijan Robinson | Running back | Salpointe Catholic High School | Tucson, Arizona | Texas |
| Jalen White | Running back | Daleville High School | Daleville, Alabama | Georgia Southern |
| Kody Epps | Wide receiver | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | BYU |
| Julian Fleming | Wide receiver | Southern Columbia High School | Catawissa, Pennsylvania | Ohio State |
| Marvin Mims | Wide receiver | Lone Star High School | Frisco, Texas | Oklahoma |
| Jaxon Smith-Njigba | Wide receiver | Rockwall High School | Rockwall, Texas | Ohio State |
| Arik Gilbert | Tight end | Marietta High School | Marietta, Georgia | LSU |
| Savion Byrd‡ | Offensive line | Duncanville High School | Dallas, Texas | Oklahoma |
| Paris Johnson Jr. | Offensive line | Princeton High School | Sharonville, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Myles Murao | Offensive line | Mater Dei High School | Santa Ana, California | Washington |
| Andrew Raym | Offensive line | Broken Arrow High School | Broken Arrow, Oklahoma | Oklahoma |
| Landon Tengwall‡ | Offensive line | Our Lady of Good Counsel High School | Olney, Maryland | Penn State |
| Joshua Karty | Placekicker | Western Alamance High School | Elon, North Carolina | Stanford |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Justin Flowe | Linebacker | Upland High School | Upland, California | Oregon |
| Noah Sewell | Linebacker | Orem High School | Orem, Utah | Oregon |
| Cody Simon | Linebacker | St. Peter's Preparatory School | Jersey City, New Jersey | Ohio State |
| Josh White | Linebacker | Cypress Creek High School | Houston, Texas | LSU |
| Chris Braswell | Defensive line | St. Frances Academy | Baltimore, Maryland | Alabama |
| Bryan Bresee | Defensive line | Damascus High School | Damascus, Maryland | Clemson |
| Jordan Burch | Defensive line | Hammond School | Columbia, South Carolina | South Carolina |
| Fadil Diggs | Defensive line | Woodrow Wilson High school | Camden, New Jersey | Texas A&M |
| Donell Harris | Defensive line | Gulliver Preparatory School | Miami, Florida | Texas A&M |
| JT Tuimoloau‡ | Defensive line | Eastside Catholic School | Sammamish, Washington | Ohio State |
| Emeka Egbuka‡ | Defensive back | Steilacoom High School | Steilacoom, Washington | Ohio State |
| Luke Hill | Defensive back | St. Frances Academy | Baltimore, Maryland | Oregon |
| Malachi Moore | Defensive back | Hewitt-Trussville High School | Trussville, Alabama | Alabama |
| Clark Phillips III | Defensive back | La Habra High School | La Habra, California | Utah |
| Kelee Ringo | Defensive back | Saguaro High School | Scottsdale, Arizona | Georgia |
| Hunter Renner | Punter | Marian High School | Mishawaka, Indiana | Northwestern |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Ja'Quinden Jackson | Quarterback | Duncanville High School | Dallas, Texas | Texas |
| Caleb Williams‡ | Quarterback | Gonzaga College High School | Washington, DC | Oklahoma |
| Blake Corum | Running back | St. Frances Academy | Baltimore, Maryland | Michigan |
| TreVeyon Henderson‡ | Athlete | Hopewell High School | Hopewell, Virginia | Ohio State |
| Charlie Spegal | Running back | New Palestine High School | New Palestine, Indiana | Indiana |
| Elijhah Badger | Wide receiver | Folsom High School | Folsom, California | Arizona State |
| A.J. Henning | Athlete | Lincoln-Way East High School | Frankfort, Illinois | Michigan |
| John Humphreys | Wide receiver | Corona Del Mar High School | Newport Beach, California | Stanford |
| Gee Scott Jr. | Wide receiver | Eastside Catholic School | Sammamish, Washington | Ohio State |
| Michael Mayer | Tight end | Covington Catholic High School | Alexandria, Kentucky | Notre Dame |
| Marcus Dumervil | Offensive Line | St. Thomas Aquinas High School | Fort Lauderdale, Florida | LSU |
| Andrew Gentry | Offensive Line | Columbine High School | Columbine, Colorado | Virginia |
| Nolan Rucci‡ | Offensive Line | Warwick High School | Lititz, Pennsylvania | Wisconsin |
| Myles Hinton | Offensive Line | Greater Atlanta Christian School | Norcross, Georgia | Stanford |
| Luke Wypler | Offensive Line | Saint Joseph Regional High School | Montvale, New Jersey | Ohio State |
| Parker Lewis | Placekicker | Saguaro High School | Scottsdale, Arizona | USC |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Gervon Dexter | Defensive Line | Lake Wales High School | Lake Wales, Florida | Florida |
| Van Fillinger | Defensive line | Corner Canyon High School | Draper, Utah | Utah |
| Jason Harris | Defensive line | Higley High School | Gilbert, Arizona | Arizona |
| Landon Jackson‡ | Defensive line | Pleasant Grove High School | Texarkana, Texas | LSU |
| McKinnley Jackson | Defensive line | George County High School | Lucedale, Mississippi | Texas A&M |
| Jack Sawyer‡ | Defensive line | Pickerington High School North | Pickerington, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Reid Carrico‡ | Linebacker | Ironton High School | Ironton, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Jalen Garner‡ | Linebacker | Norcross High School | Norcross, Georgia | Houston |
| Derek Wingo | Linebacker | St. Thomas Aquinas High School | Fort Lauderdale, Florida | Florida |
| Zihenryon Perry | Linebacker | Brandon High School | Brandon, Mississippi | Jones College |
| O. J. Burroughs‡ | Defensive back | IMG Academy | Bradenton, Florida | Kansas |
| Tony Grimes‡ | Defensive back | Princess Anne High School | Virginia Beach, Virginia | North Carolina |
| Antonio Johnson | Defensive back | East St. Louis High School | East St. Louis, Illinois | Texas A&M |
| Jaylon Jones | Defensive back | Steele High School | Cibolo, Texas | Texas A&M |
| Jahari Rogers | Defensive back | Arlington High School | Arlington, Texas | Florida |
| Mitchell Tomasek‡ | Punter | Worthington Kilbourne High School | Columbus, Ohio | Eastern Michigan |
2025 team
- See footnotes[31]
- Note: Bold denotes Offensive and Defensive Players of the Year, respectively, and ‡ and ‡‡ denotes high school juniors and sophomores, respectively
- First Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Keisean Henderson | Quarterback | Legacy the School of Sport Sciences | Houston, Texas | Houston |
| Ezavier Crowell | Running back | Jackson High School | Jackson, Alabama | Alabama |
| David Gabriel-Georges‡ | Running back | Baylor School | Quebec, Canada | |
| Jermaine Bishop Jr. | Wide receiver | Willis High School | Willis, Texas | Texas |
| Roye Oliver III‡‡ | Wide receiver | Hamilton High School | Chandler, Arizona | USC |
| Ian Premer | Tight end | Great Bend High School | Great Bend, Kansas | Notre Dame |
| Landen Williams-Callis‡ | Flex | Randle High School | Richmond, Texas | |
| Jackson Cantwell | Offensive line | Nixa Public High School | Columbia, Missouri | Miami (FL) |
| Lamar Brown | Offensive line | Louisiana State University Laboratory School | Baton Rouge, Louisiana | LSU |
| Darius Gray | Offensive line | St. Christopher's School | Richmond, Virginia | South Carolina |
| Keenyi Pepe | Offensive line | IMG Academy | Long Beach, Calififornia | USC |
| Mikey Barth‡ | Placekicker | Basha High School | Elon, North Carolina | Arizona State |
- First Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Richard Anderson | Defensive line | Edna Karr High School | Baton Rouge, Louisiana | LSU |
| Bryce Perry-Wright | Defensive line | Buford High School | Atlanta, Georgia | Texas A&M |
| Deuce Geralds | Defensive line | Collins Hill High School | Suwanee, Georgia | LSU |
| Luke Wafle | Defensive line | Hun School of Princeton | Middletown Township, New Jersey | USC |
| Cincere Johnson | Linebacker | Glenville High School | Cleveland, Ohio | Ohio State |
| Tyler Atkinson | Linebacker | Grayson High School | Lawrenceville, Georgia | Texas |
| TJ White | Linebacker | Jackson Academy | Jackson, Mississippi | Tennessee |
| Quinton Cypher‡ | Linebacker | Millbrook High School | Raleigh, North Carolina | Ohio State |
| Jermaine Bishop Jr. | Cornerback | Willis High School | Willis, Texas | Texas |
| Jireh Edwards | Safety | St. Frances Academy | Upper Marlboro, Maryland | Alabama |
| Jaden Walk-Green‡ | Flex | Centennial High School | Corona, California | |
| Jimmy Gregg | Punter | University High School | Morgantown, West Virginia | Syracuse |
- Second Team Offense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Jett Thomalla | Quarterback | Millard South High School | Lexington, Nebraska | Alabama |
| Ty Keys‡ | Running back | Poplarville High School | Poplarville, Mississippi | Miami |
| SaRod Baker‡ | Running back | DeSoto High School | DeSoto, Texas | Texas Tech |
| C.J. Sadler | Wide receiver | Cass Technical High School | Detroit, Michigan | North Carolina |
| Boobie Feaster | Wide receiver | DeSoto High School | Shreveport, Louisiana | USC |
| Kaiden Prothro | Tight end | Bowdon High School | Bowdon, Georgia | Georgia |
| Cederian Morgan | Flex | Benjamin Russell High School | Alexander City, Alabama | Alabama |
| Kaeden Penny‡ | Offensive Line | Bixby High School | Bixby, Oklahoma | Oklahoma |
| Felix Ojo | Offensive Line | Lake Ridge High School | Mansfield, Texas | Texas Tech |
| Kodi Greene | Offensive Line | Mater Dei High School | Renton, Washington | Washington |
| Immanuel Iheanacho | Offensive Line | Georgetown Prep | Baltimore, Maryland | Oregon |
| Harran Zureikat | Placekicker | Fox Chapel Area High School | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | Georgia |
- Second Team Defense
| Player | Position | School | Hometown | College |
| Carter Buck | Defensive Line | Lake Travis High School | Austin, Texas | TCU |
| Breeze Carter | Defensive line | Douglas County High School | Douglasville, Georgia | Tennessee |
| Aaden Aytch | Defensive line | Jefferson High School | Lafayette, Indiana | Minnesota |
| Prince Williams | Defensive line | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | Arizona |
| Xavier Griffin | Linebacker | Gainesville High School | Cullman, Alabama | Alabama |
| Anthony Jones Jr. | Linebacker | St. Paul's Episcopal School | Mobile, Alabama | Oregon |
| Roman Igwebuike‡ | Linebacker | Mount Carmel High School | Chicago, Illinois | |
| Jalaythan Mayfield‡ | Linebacker | Lincolnton High School | Lincolnton, North Carolina | |
| Jorden Edmonds | Cornerback | Sprayberry High School | Marietta, Georgia | Alabama |
| Jett Washington | Safety | Bishop Gorman High School | Las Vegas, Nevada | Oregon |
| Ayden Pouncey | Flex | Winter Park High School | Orlando, Florida | Notre Dame |
| Wade Register | Punter | Trinity Christian School | Dublin, Georgia | Georgia |
Accumulated stats
- Most selections by school (as of 2017)
| Rank | State | |
| 1 | De La Salle High School, Concord, California | 8.5 |
| 2 | Cretin-Derham Hall High School, St. Paul, Minnesota | 8 |
| 3 | IMG Academy, Bradenton, Florida | 6.5 |
| 4 | St. Thomas Aquinas High School, Fort Lauderdale, Florida | 6 |
| Bishop Gorman High School, Las Vegas, Nevada | 6 |
| 6 | Carter High School, Dallas, Texas | 5 |
| 7 | Oaks Christian School, Westlake Village, California | 4.5 |
| 8 | Moeller High School, Cincinnati, Ohio | 3.5 |
| Northwestern High School, Miami, Florida | 3.5 |
| American Heritage School, Plantation, Florida | 3.5 |
- Most selections by state (as of 2017)
References
- ↑ "USATODAY.com". usatoday30.usatoday.com.
- ↑ "USA TODAY High School Sports". USA TODAY High School Sports.
- ↑ "Football: Players and Coaches of the Year (1982–2005)". USA Today. June 26, 2006. Retrieved October 24, 2011.
- ↑ On the following webpage, go to "Football archives" (for links to "All-USA Team", "Super 25" teams, and "Regional rankings"): "Super 25 and All-USA archive". USA Today. Retrieved October 24, 2011.
- 1 2 "All-USA football: Frazier, Clowney named players of year". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. December 22, 2010. Retrieved January 19, 2011.
- ↑ "All-USA first team and second team". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. December 22, 2010. Retrieved January 19, 2011.
- ↑ "Photos: 2010 All-USA football team". USAToday.com. December 20, 2010. Retrieved January 19, 2011.
- ↑ Halley, Jim (December 20, 2010). "South Panola (Batesville, Miss.) finishes year as Super 25's top tea". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. Retrieved January 20, 2011.
- ↑ Halley, Jim (December 20, 2010). "USA TODAY Super 25 - Boys Varsity Football". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. Archived from the original on January 15, 2011. Retrieved January 20, 2011.
- ↑ "USA TODAY Super 25 regional rankings". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. August 18, 2010. Archived from the original on September 5, 2010. Retrieved January 20, 2011.
- ↑ "All-USA first team and second team". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. December 21, 2011. Retrieved December 29, 2011.
- ↑ "Super 25 Expert Rankings". Archived from the original on June 15, 2012. Retrieved December 29, 2011.
- ↑ "Browne, Cravens Headline the 2012 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. December 20, 2012.
- ↑ "2012 Preseason Super 25 Football". www.usatodayhss.com. Archived from the original on August 3, 2012.
- ↑ "Fournette, Peppers lead the 2013 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. December 28, 2012.
- ↑ "2013 Boys Varsity Football". www.usatodayhss.com. Archived from the original on January 7, 2014.
- ↑ "2014 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football First Team Football Team". HighSchoolSports.net. USA Today. December 24, 2014.
- ↑ "2014 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Second Team". December 24, 2014.
- 1 2 "Rankings: Clarkstown South looks to avenge only defeat". October 22, 2015.
- ↑ "2015 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team: Offense". December 23, 2015.
- ↑ "ALL-USA Football Offense: Second Team". USA Today High School Sports. December 23, 2015.
- ↑ "2016 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team: Offense". December 22, 2016.
- ↑ "2017 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team: Offense". December 19, 2017.
- ↑ "2017 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team: Defense". December 20, 2017.
- ↑ "2018-19 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team: Offense". December 18, 2018.
- ↑ "2018-19 American Family Insurance ALL-USA Football Team: Defense". December 19, 2018.
- ↑ "2019-20 ALL-USA High School Football Offensive First Team". December 19, 2019.
- ↑ "2019-20 ALL-USA High School Football Offensive Second Team". December 19, 2019.
- ↑ "2019-20 ALL-USA High School Football Defensive First Team". December 19, 2019.
- ↑ "2019-20 ALL-USA High School Football Defensive Second Team". December 19, 2019.
- ↑ "USA TODAY Sports announces 2025 ALL-USA National Football Team". USA TODAY High School Sports. Retrieved June 2, 2026.
|
|---|
| Team award | |
|---|
| Overall trophies | |
|---|
| Overall media awards | |
|---|
| Positional awards | |
|---|
| All-Americans | |
|---|
| Head Coaching awards | |
|---|
| Academic, inspirational, and versatility awards | |
|---|
| Regional awards | |
|---|