| Institution |
Nickname |
City |
State |
Program Established |
Conference for football |
Primary conference |
| Andrew College |
Fighting Tigers |
Cuthbert |
Georgia |
2024 |
Independent (Appalachian Athletic Conference in 2027.) |
Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Arizona Christian University |
Firestorm |
Phoenix |
Arizona |
2014 |
Frontier Conference |
Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Arkansas Baptist College |
Buffaloes |
Little Rock |
Arkansas |
2007 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
Continental Athletic Conference |
| Ave Maria University |
Gyrenes |
Naples |
Florida |
2011 |
The Sun Conference |
| Avila University |
Eagles |
Kansas City |
Missouri |
1999 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Baker University |
Wildcats |
Baldwin City |
Kansas |
1890 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Benedictine College |
Ravens |
Atchison |
Kansas |
1902 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Bethany College |
Terrible Swedes |
Lindsborg |
Kansas |
1893 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Bethel University |
Wildcats |
McKenzie |
Tennessee |
1900 |
Mid-South Conference |
| Bethel College |
Threshers |
Newton |
Kansas |
1914 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Bluefield University |
Rams |
Bluefield |
Virginia |
1941; 2012 |
Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Briar Cliff University |
Chargers |
Sioux City |
Iowa |
2003 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Campbellsville University |
Tigers |
Campbellsville |
Kentucky |
1988 |
Mid-South Conference |
| Carroll College |
Fighting Saints |
Helena |
Montana |
1920 |
Frontier Conference |
| Central Methodist University |
Eagles |
Fayette |
Missouri |
1896 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Clarke University |
Pride |
Dubuque |
Iowa |
2019 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Concordia University-Nebraska |
Bulldogs |
Seward |
Nebraska |
2000 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Culver–Stockton College |
Wildcats |
Canton |
Missouri |
N/A |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Cumberland University |
Phoenix |
Lebanon |
Tennessee |
1894 |
Mid-South Conference |
| University of the Cumberlands |
Patriots |
Williamsburg |
Kentucky |
1985 |
Mid-South Conference |
| Dakota State University |
Trojans |
Madison |
South Dakota |
2006 |
Frontier Conference |
| Dakota Wesleyan University |
Tigers |
Mitchell |
South Dakota |
1897 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Defiance College |
Yellow Jackets |
Defiance |
Ohio |
1903 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Dickinson State University |
Blue Hawks |
Dickinson |
North Dakota |
1925 |
Frontier Conference |
| Doane University |
Tigers |
Crete |
Nebraska |
1891 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Dordt University |
Defenders |
Sioux Center |
Iowa |
2008 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Eastern Oregon University |
Mountaineers |
La Grande |
Oregon |
1929 |
Frontier Conference |
Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Evangel University |
Valor |
Springfield |
Missouri |
1977 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Faulkner University |
Eagles |
Montgomery |
Alabama |
2007 |
Independent (Appalachian Athletic Conference in 2027.) |
Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Florida Memorial University |
Lions |
Miami Gardens |
Florida |
1945; 2020 |
The Sun Conference |
| Friends University |
Falcons |
Wichita |
Kansas |
N/A |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Georgetown College |
Tigers |
Georgetown |
Kentucky |
1893 |
Mid-South Conference |
| Graceland University |
Yellowjackets |
Lamoni |
Iowa |
1910 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Grand View University |
Vikings |
Des Moines |
Iowa |
2008 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Hastings College |
Broncos |
Hastings |
Nebraska |
1895 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| College of Idaho |
Coyotes |
Caldwell |
Idaho |
1905; 2014 |
Frontier Conference |
Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Indiana Wesleyan University |
Wildcats |
Marion |
Indiana |
2018 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Crossroads League |
| Judson University |
Eagles |
Elgin |
Illinois |
2021 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Kansas Wesleyan University |
Coyotes |
Salina |
Kansas |
1893 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Keiser University |
Seahawks |
West Palm Beach |
Florida |
2018 |
The Sun Conference |
| Kentucky Christian University |
Knights |
Grayson |
Kentucky |
2008 |
Appalachian Athletic Conference |
River States Conference |
| Langston University |
Lions |
Langston |
Oklahoma |
1922 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Lawrence Technological University |
Blue Devils |
Southfield |
Michigan |
1933; 2018 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Lindsey Wilson University |
Blue Raiders |
Columbia |
Kentucky |
2010 |
Mid-South Conference |
| Louisiana Christian University |
Wildcats |
Pineville |
Louisiana |
1908; 2000 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
Red River Athletic Conference |
| Madonna University |
Crusaders |
Livonia |
Michigan |
2020 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Wolverine-Hoosier Athletic Conference |
| Marian University |
Knights |
Indianapolis |
Indiana |
2007 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Crossroads League |
| Mayville State University |
Comets |
Mayville |
North Dakota |
N/A |
Frontier Conference |
| McPherson College |
Bulldogs |
McPherson |
Kansas |
1917 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| MidAmerica Nazarene University |
Pioneers |
Olathe |
Kansas |
1979 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Midland University |
Warriors |
Fremont |
Nebraska |
1895 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Missouri Baptist University |
Spartans |
St. Louis |
Missouri |
2014 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Missouri Valley College |
Vikings |
Marshall |
Missouri |
1892 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Montana State University-Northern |
Lights |
Havre |
Montana |
1957 |
Frontier Conference |
| Montana Technological University |
Orediggers |
Butte |
Montana |
1902 |
Frontier Conference |
| University of Montana Western |
Bulldogs |
Dillon |
Montana |
N/A |
Frontier Conference |
| Morningside University |
Mustangs |
Sioux City |
Iowa |
1898 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Mount Marty University |
Lancers |
Yankton |
South Dakota |
2021 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Mount Mercy University |
Mustangs |
Cedar Rapids |
Iowa |
2026 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| Nelson University |
Lions |
Waxahachie |
Texas |
1996 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Northwestern College |
Red Raiders |
Orange City |
Iowa |
1950 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Oklahoma Panhandle State University |
Aggies |
Goodwell |
Oklahoma |
N/A |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Olivet Nazarene University |
Tigers |
Bourbonnais |
Illinois |
1976 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Ottawa University |
Braves |
Ottawa |
Kansas |
1891 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Ottawa University Arizona |
Spirit |
Surprise |
Arizona |
2018 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
Great Southwest Athletic Conference |
| Peru State College |
Bobcats |
Peru |
Nebraska |
1900 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| University of Pikeville |
Bears |
Pikeville |
Kentucky |
2001 |
Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Point University |
Skyhawks |
West Point |
Georgia |
2012 |
Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Reinhardt University |
Eagles |
Waleska |
Georgia |
2013 |
Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| University of Rio Grande |
RedStorm |
Rio Grande |
Ohio |
2025 |
Appalachian Athletic Conference |
River States Conference |
| Rocky Mountain College |
Battlin' Bears |
Billings |
Montana |
1931 |
Frontier Conference |
| St. Ambrose University |
Fighting Bees |
Davenport |
Iowa |
1893; 1974 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| University of St. Francis (IL) |
Fighting Saints |
Joliet |
Illinois |
1986 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| University of Saint Francis (IN) |
Cougars |
Fort Wayne |
Indiana |
1998 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Crossroads League |
| University of Saint Mary |
Spires |
Leavenworth |
Kansas |
2000 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Saint Mary-of-the-Woods College |
Pomeroys |
Saint Mary-of-the-Woods |
Indiana |
2022 |
Mid-States Football Association |
River States Conference |
| Saint Thomas University |
Bobcats |
Miami Gardens |
Florida |
2019 |
The Sun Conference |
| Saint Xavier University |
Cougars |
Chicago |
Illinois |
1993 |
Mid-States Football Association |
Chicagoland Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Simpson University |
Red Hawks |
Redding |
California |
2023 |
Frontier Conference |
California Pacific Conference |
| Southeastern University |
Fire |
Lakeland |
Florida |
2014 |
The Sun Conference |
| Southern Oregon University |
Raiders |
Ashland |
Oregon |
1927 |
Frontier Conference |
Cascade Collegiate Conference |
| Southwestern College |
Moundbuilders |
Winfield |
Kansas |
1903 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Sterling College |
Warriors |
Sterling |
Kansas |
1893 |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Tabor College |
Bluejays |
Hillsboro |
Kansas |
N/A |
Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference |
| Taylor University |
Trojans |
Upland |
Indiana |
N/A |
Mid-States Football Association |
Crossroads League |
| Texas College |
Steers |
Tyler |
Texas |
1922; 2004 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
Red River Athletic Conference |
| Texas Wesleyan University |
Rams |
Fort Worth |
Texas |
1933; 2017 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Thomas University |
Night Hawks |
Thomasville |
Georgia |
2022 |
The Sun Conference |
Southern States Athletic Conference |
| Union Commonwealth University |
Bulldogs |
Barbourville |
Kentucky |
1905; 1922; 1984 |
Appalachian Athletic Conference |
| Valley City State University |
Vikings |
Valley City |
North Dakota |
N/A |
Frontier Conference |
| Waldorf University |
Warriors |
Forest City |
Iowa |
1965 |
Great Plains Athletic Conference |
| Warner University |
Royals |
Lake Wales |
Florida |
2013 |
The Sun Conference |
| Wayland Baptist University |
Pioneers |
Plainview |
Texas |
2012 |
Sooner Athletic Conference |
| Webber International University |
Warriors |
Babson Park |
Florida |
2003 |
The Sun Conference |
| William Penn University |
Statesmen |
Oskaloosa |
Iowa |
1892 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |
| William Woods University |
Owls |
Fulton |
Missouri |
2024 |
Heart of America Athletic Conference |