Executive Council of the Province of Canada

The Executive Council of the Province of Canada was the cabinet of the colonial government of the United Province of Canada, the polity in existence between 1841 and 1867. The council was not initially accountable to the Legislative Assembly of the Province of Canada, the legislature of the colony, but answered only to the Governor-General of the Province of Canada. Responsible government was not firmly established until 1848 under Lord Elgin. The council was the successor body of the Executive Council of Upper Canada and the Executive Council of Lower Canada and was dissolved in 1867 and was replaced by the Canadian Cabinet, the Executive Council of Ontario and the Executive Council of Quebec upon Canadian Confederation.

Members of the Executive Council functioned as portfolio ministers and advisers to the colonial governor, and later to the Joint Premier of the Province of Canada. They were generally members of the elected Legislative Assembly, but there were also some members from the appointed Legislative Council of the Province of Canada. Due to the frequent move of the colony's capital during this period, the council sat in five different cities during its short lifespan: Kingston (1841–43), Montreal (1843–49), Toronto (1849–52 and 1856–58), Quebec City (1852–1856 and 1859–66) and Ottawa (1866–67).

Partisanship

While political partisanship was certainly present during this era, it was neither formal nor clearly defined.[1] There was no contemporary political maps or listing of members (of the assembly or the executive council) by "political party" per se.[2] Partisan affiliations was not the sole, and sometimes not even the primary, determining factor of politicians' political allegiances, and how much their affiliation influenced their allegiances varied over time. Accordingly, the political affiliation classifications below serve only as general references to the broad political groupings the joint-premiers most likely belonged to, and the broad groupings the supporters of their governments most likely considered themselves as parts of. Varying classification systems/approaches and partisanship labels have been used by differing authors depending on the focus of their analysis. There were sub-groupings with membership that straddled multiple groupings with fluctuating degrees of cohesion and formality from session to session.[2] There were moderate and radical or "ultra" members within each grouping.[2] The ministry often could not count on the support of all members of the joint-premiers' political groupings and some counted on support from different rival fractions on different issues/voting divisions. The political deadlock and instability was the primary driver that led to the Great Coalition ministry, which eventually produced the Canadian Confederation.

Ministries and Premiers of the Province of Canada

  •   Conservative
  •   Reform
  •   Liberal-Conservative
  •   Liberal/Grits
  •   Coalition
  •   Governor driven / loyalist
Ministry
(Political party)
Tenure Joint-premiers № Governor General
Canada West Canada East
Governor Sydenham
(Multi-partisan)
February 13, 1841 – January 12, 1842
Samuel Harrison

co-leading Executive Councillor

[a] 1st Baron Sydenham

(1841)

   
William Henry Draper
co-leading Executive Councillor
 Governor Bagot
(Multi-partisan)
January 12, 1842 – Sep 15, 1842
Charles Richard Ogden
co-leading Executive Councillor
Sir Charles Bagot
(1842–43)
Lafontaine-Baldwin I
(Reform)
Sep 16, 1842 – Nov 27, 1843
Robert Baldwin
Co-premier
Louis-Hippolyte
Lafontaine

Premier
Draper
(Pro-Governor; Tory/Conservative)
Nov 27, 1843 – December 12, 1843 vacant
Dominick Daly[b]
de facto
government leader
[c]
Sir Charles Metcalfe
(1843–45)
December 12, 1843 – June 17, 1846
William Henry Draper
Premier
Denis-Benjamin Viger
Co-premier
2nd
June 18, 1846 – May 28, 1847
Denis-Benjamin
Papineau

Co-premier
Earl Cathcart
(1846–47)
  Earl of Elgin
(1847–54)
Sherwood
(Pro-Governor; Tory/Conservative)
May 29, 1847 – December 7, 1847
Henry Sherwood
Premier
December 8, 1847 – March 10, 1848 vacant 3rd
Responsible government instituted
Lafontaine-Baldwin II
(Reform)
March 10, 1848 – October 27, 1851
Robert Baldwin
Co-premier
Louis-Hippolyte
Lafontaine, Premier
Hincks-Morin
(Reform)
October 28, 1851 – Sep 10, 1854
Francis Hincks
Premier
Augustin-Norbert Morin
Co-premier
4th
MacNab-Morin/Taché
(Coalition: Conservative, Bleu & moderate Reformers)
Sep 11, 1854 – January 26, 1855
Sir Allan N. MacNab
Premier
5th Sir Edmund Walker Head
(1854–61)
January 27, 1855 – May 23, 1856
Étienne-Paschal Taché[b]
Co-premier
(until May 24, 1856)
Premier
Taché-Macdonald
(Liberal-Conservative)
May 24, 1856 – Nov 25, 1857
John A. Macdonald
Co-premier
(until Nov. 26, 1857)
Premier
[b]
Macdonald–Cartier I
(Liberal-Conservative)
Nov 26, 1857 – July 29, 1858
George-Étienne Cartier
Co-premier[b]
6th
Interregnum July 30, 1858 – August 1, 1858 vacant vacant
Brown–Dorion (Reform)
(Clear Grits/Rouges
)
August 2, 1858 – August 4, 1858
George Brown
Premier
Antoine-Aimé Dorion
Co-premier
Interregnum August 5, 1858 vacant vacant
  Macdonald–Cartier II
(Liberal-Conservative)
August 6, 1858[d] – May 23, 1862
John A. Macdonald
Co-premier
George-Étienne Cartier
Premier
  7th The Viscount Monck
(1854–61)
  Sandfield Macdonald–Sicotte
(Moderate Reform)
May 24, 1862 – May 15, 1863
John Sandfield Macdonald
Premier
Louis-Victor Sicotte
Co-premier
  Sandfield Macdonald–Dorion
(Reform/Liberal)
May 16, 1863 – March 29, 1864
Antoine-Aimé Dorion
Co-premier
  8th
Great Coalition
(coalition: Conservatives; Blues; most Liberals)[e]
March 30, 1864 – July 30, 1865
John A. Macdonald
Co-premier
Sir[3] Étienne-Paschal Taché†[f]
Premier
July 31, 1865 – August 6, 1865 vacant
August 7, 1865 – June 30, 1867
Sir Narcisse-Fortunat Belleau
Premier[g]

Offices held by executive councillors

The following offices were held by members of the executive council, thought not always:

  • President of the Executive Council
  • Attorney General, Lower Canada
  • Attorney General, Upper Canada
  • Provincial Secretary and Registrar (existed prior to 1842 as two separate offices, one each for Upper and Lower Canadas)
  • Inspector General (after 1859 renamed Ministers of Finance) (sub-cabinet 1841–42)
  • Receiver General
  • Ministers of Agriculture (from 1852)[h]
  • Commissioner of Public Works (in commission by members of the Board of Works 1841–46)[6]
  • Commissioner of Crown Lands (sub-cabinet 1841–42)
  • Solicitor General, Lower Canada (sub-cabinet 1845–47, 1848–58)
  • Solicitor General, Upper Canada (sub-cabinet 1848–60)
  • Postmaster General (sub-cabinet 1841–51)
  • Superintendent General of Indian Affairs[i]

Presidents of the Executive Council

The title president of the council were usually not held by the actual leader of the government during this period. Allen MacNab was the only person who held the title while premier. George Brown held the title in Great Coalition years after his two day-tenure as Premier. Most, but not all, joint premiers held the office of Attorney General for the portion of the colony they hailed from.

Ministries

Sydenham-Bagot Ministry (February 1841 – September 1842)

In the months immediately following the reunion of the two Canadas, the ministry was led by the Governor General, the recently raised Baron Sydenham, himself. In his despatch to his direct superior, Colonial Secretary the Lord Russell on February 16, he reported having made only three appointments formally, appointing Dominick Daly, Samuel Harrison, and John Henry Dunn, to continue in their roles as provincial secretary for Lower Canada, for Upper Canada, and as Receiver General, and submitted additional names seeking approval from the Crown: Robert Baldwin Sullivan, William Henry Draper, and Robert Baldwin from Canada West and Charles Richard Ogden, Charles Dewey Day from Canada East, all to executive portfolios they held prior to the union.[7] [8] The line up was not well received in Lower Canada. The press noted that there was only one Catholic (Mr. Daly) in the administration, and not a single French Canadian.[9]

There was no premier identified in either Sydenham's despatch or in contemporary press reports. The mentions of Draper-Ogden cabinet or Harrison-Draper administration appeared half a century later in Senate debates[j] but mentions of the cabinet or individual executive councillors in news report of the day invariably portrayed them as advisors subservient to the Governor. In the debate to move the writ of election for the newly appointed Attorney General LaFontaine that took place in late 1842 Sir Allen MacNab, then in opposition, drew attention to the uncertain of status, and was met with uniform responses from executive councillors that it was not the right time to discuss the subject.[10]

Sydenham took an active role in lining up candidates that would be supportive of his administration in the lead up to the 1841 legislative election. The primary political dividing line during this brief period was the issue of the union. Political alignment could be generalized into the following four main groupings:[11]

  • Upper Canada Tories, the all power elite who had wielded power former known as the Family Compact, saw the union as a threat of their power
  • Upper Canada Reformers, who had been systematically prevented from power despite their large numbers, favoured the union as a means to divert power away from the Tories
  • Lower Canada English Tories, a tiny minority of the population with an increasingly tenuous grip on power, supported the union to gain greater number of English speaking votes
  • French Canadians, made up of nearly half the united province's population at the time but was excluded from political participation for two years due to the suspension of the constitution in Lower Canada, most strongly opposed to the union due to their exclusion in the process

Accordingly, the governor found himself relying on the support of reformers on one side and the Tories on the other. Elections were to take place in April and Sydenham had grand plans in mind. His low regard and misgiving for the Tory local leaders, those in Lower Canada in particular, motivated his aggressive drive to preserve the township form of municipal government in Upper Canada and to extend it to Lower Canada, believing that the provincial assemblies neither had the capacity nor the credibility to manage matters centrally.[12] Having made the command of a majority in the assembly a requirement of the future governments of the province, he set out on a tour of more than 40 towns for the purpose of handpicking candidates for the forthcoming elections to the united parliament in the months leading up to the reunion.[13]

Sydenham's engagement and interest in ministry building was not all that surprising. He was not yet forty when he was appointed to the post, and was considered a rising star with jilted ambition in Westminster just a year earlier, having previously entered cabinet at age 34 as the President of the Board of Trade (essentially trade minister) in the short-lived Whig Melbourne ministry. A ruthless veteran of consequential electoral politics back home, Sydenham did not refrain from high-handed tactics like gerrymandering and bribery with patronage. He also largely turned a blind eye to riots, election related violence instigated by the Orange Order and blatant electoral fraud.[14] His simultaneous aggressive intervention and non intervention resulted in electoral divisions such as Chambly, Rouville, Vaudreuil, Terrebonne, Beauharnois, all with overwhelming majority of French Canadians oppose to the union, returning the governors preferred candidates. For this Sydenham was severely criticized not just by local press but by newspapers back in London.[15] He was unapologetic however, having been quoted with this retort "If he means that I personally interfere he is quite misinformed, but the Govt. officials must try to get seats in Parliament… and they surely have a right to look after their elections."

Sydenham's supporters won thirteen of the forty-two seats in Canada East and an overwhelming twenty-six of the forty-two in Canada West, a total of thirty-nine firm supporters of the union against thirty-three opposed, and the ten remaining with uncertain allegiances. The group of supporters Sydenham assembled was shaky at best, however. While he controlled a good portion with government offices, his ministry was dependent on many independent minded reformers. Many new politician hand picked by him, including Hamilton Hartley Killaly who he quickly installed into the ministry, lacked political experience and wielded little influence in the legislature. After his ministry failed to get a bill passed to establish a single bank, according to his civil secretary Thomas Murdoch, Sydenham took control of not only policy making but also legislative strategy.

The ministry's most serious adversaries ultimately came from within. Robert Baldwin and Francis Hincks, two leading Reformers supportive of the ministry members of the ministry, parted ways with Sydenham over the clergy reserves bill, and sought to construct a united Reform Party in alliance with French speaking Reformers. They moved for an expression of non-confidence in four executive councillors, and demanded that the council be reconstituted on a party basis. While Sydenham's ministry survived the initial attack, the ministers conceded to the assembly that they would resign if they lost the confidence of the house. Sydenham, too, also acknowledged he could not perpetually set aside the democratic principles he practiced back home. He did not live to see the ministry he built collapse. An infection from a riding accident claimed his life on September 19, 1841, at age 42, a day after the first session of the legislative assembly prorogued.

Sydenham was succeeded by Sir Charles Bagot, who arrived in Kingston in January the following year and inherited Sydenham's ministry. Bagot spoke fluent French and swiftly took a number of actions that demonstrated his willingness to work with the French speaking community in Canada East, such as appointing French-speakers to government positions and suspending selected decrees of the notorious Special Council.[16] Bagot also took meaningful steps toward responsible government, despite maintaining an official position against any demand toward it.

Executive councillors of the Sydenham-Bagot Ministries

  •   Conservative
  •   Reform
  •   Governor loyalist

  Officeholder was not a member of the Executive Council at the time.

OfficeStartEndHolder ConstituencyNote
President of the Council1841-02-101943-11-27 Robert Baldwin Sullivan West Leg. Co. (appointed)later Reform
Attorneys General, LC1841-02-101842-09-15 Charles Richard Ogden East Three Rivers
Attorneys General, UC1841-02-101842-09-15 William Henry Draper West Russell
Provincial Secretary, LC[k]1841-02-101848-03-10 Dominick Daly East Megantick
Provincial Secretary, UC 1841-02-101843-09-30 Samuel Bealey Harrison West Kingston
Solicitor General, LC1841-02-101842-06-20 Charles Dewey Day East Ottawa County
Solicitor General, UC1841-02-101841-06-13 Robert Baldwin West Hastingsresigned
1842-07-231842-09-15 Henry Sherwood West Toronto
Inspector General1841-02-101841-12-31 James Cary (for LC) n/asub-cabinet
1841-02-101842-06-08 J. Macaulay (for UC) n/asub-cabinet
1842-06-091843-12-11 Francis Hincks West Oxford
Receiver General1841-02-101843-12-31 John Henry Dunn West Toronto
Commissioner of Crown Lands1841-02-101841-06-30 Robert Baldwin Sullivan WestLeg. Co. (appointed)
1841-07-231842-10-12 John Davidson n/asub-cabinet
Chair, Board of Works1841-12-211846-06-08 Hamilton Hartley Killaly West London
Postmasters General1841-02-101851-02-21 Thomas Allen Stayner n/asub-cabinet

First Lafontaine-Baldwin ministry (September 1842 – November 1843)

Strictly speaking, the first Reform ministry led by Robert Baldwin and Louis-Hippolyte Lafontaine was just part of Governor Bagot's ministry. On accepting the appointment as Governor General, Bagot was instructed to uphold existing policy of accommodation of the will of the local legislature without submitting to demands for responsible government. Bagot nonetheless took the advice of William Henry Draper and Samuel Harrison, his two leading moderate executive councillors, and negotiated with LaFontaine toward ending the exclusion of French speakers in government. In recognition of the sizable block of Reformers in the legislature, Bagot invited Louis-Hippolyte Lafontaine to nominate certain number of executive councillors in exchange for their support. Recognizing the likely danger of the continual exclusion of half of the colony's population, Draper offered his resignation along with those of other councillors to give the governor any required room for negotiation.

The result was the entry of Lafontaine and Robert Baldwin along with three of their nominees, Augustin-Norbert Morin and Thomas Cushing Aylwin from Canada East and James Edward Small from Canada West, into council. The incumbent councillors who were Reformers or primarily loyalist to the administration remained while Draper and two other Conservatives took their leave. Bagot also appointed Baldwin and Lafontaine as Attorney General of Upper and Lower Canada respectively, firmly establishing them as co-premiers of the his government. The continual presence of Sydenham's appointees who were not Reformers allowed Bagot to maintain the appearance of having starved off responsible government. But as Bagot admitted in his despatch to Colonial Secretary Edward Stanley, "whether the doctrine of responsible government is openly acknowledged, or is only tacitly acquiesced in, virtually it exists."[17]

Executive councillors in the first Lafontaine-Baldwin ministry

  •   Reform
  •   Governor loyalist

  Officeholder was not a member of the Executive Council at the time.

OfficeStartEndHolder ConstituencyNote
President of the Council1841-02-101943-11-27 Robert Baldwin Sullivan West Leg. Co. (appointed)later a Reformer
Attorneys General, LC1842-09-171843-12-11 Robert Baldwin West Rimouski*
Attorneys General, UC1842-09-161843-12-11 Louis-Hippolyte Lafontaine East 4th York*
Provincial Secretary, LC[k]1841-02-101848-03-10 Dominick Daly East Megantick
Provincial Secretary, UC1841-02-101843-09-30 Samuel Bealey Harrison West Kingston
Inspector General1842-06-091843-12-11 Francis Hincks West Oxford
Receiver General1841-02-101843-12-31 John Henry Dunn West Toronto
Solicitor General, LC1842-09-241843-12-11 Thomas Cushing Aylwin East Portneuf
Solicitor General, UC1842-09-261843-12-11 James Edward Small West 3rd York
Commissioner of Crown Lands1842-10-131843-12-11 Augustin-Norbert Morin East Saguenay
Chair, Board of Works1841-12-211846-06-08 Hamilton Hartley Killaly WestLondon
Postmasters General.1841-02-101851-02-21 Thomas Allen Stayner n/asub-cabinet

As Bagot became ill in 1843, he handed off more of his authorities to his co-premiers. He died in May 1843, and the brief experiment of responsible came quickly to a halt under his successor.

Draper-Sherwood ministry (December 1843 – March 1848)

Executive councillors of the Draper-Sherwood Ministry

  •   Conservative
  •   Governor loyalist

  Officeholder was not a member of the Executive Council at the time.

OfficeStartEndHolder ConstituencyNote
Attorneys General, UC1843-12-121847-05-28 William Henry Draper WestLeg. Co. (appointed)
1847-05-291848-03-10Henry Sherwood WestToronto
Attorneys General, LC 1844-09-021847-04-22James Smith EastMissiskoui
1847-04-231848-03-10William Badgley EastMissiskoui
President of the Council1843-12-121846-06-17Denis-Benjamin Viger EastRichelieu
1847-05-221848-03-10 William Morris WestLeg. Co. (appointed)
Provincial Secretary1841-02-131848-03-10Dominick Daly EastMegantick
Inspector General1844-12-201845-04-30 William Benjamin Robinson WestSimcoe
1845-08-061848-03-10 William Cayley WestHuron
Receiver General1844-09-021847-05-20 William Morris WestLeg. Co. (appointed)
1847-05-111847-12-07John A. Macdonald WestKingston
1847-12-081848-03-10François-Pierre Bruneau EastLeg. Co. (appointed)
Commissioner of Crown Lands1844-09-021847-12-07Denis-Benjamin Papineau EastOttawa County
1847-12-081848-03-10John A. Macdonald WestKingston
Solicitor General, UC1846-07-011848-03-10 John Hillyard Cameron WestCornwallsub-cabinet prior
to 1847-05-22
Speaker of the Legislative Council1847-05-311848-03-10 Peter McGill EastLeg. Co. (appointed)
Chair, Board of Works1841-12-211846-06-08 Hamilton Hartley Killaly WestLondonsub-cabinet
Commissioner of Public Works1846-06-221848-03-10 William Benjamin Robinson WestSimcoesub-cabinet
Solicitor General, UC1844-10-071846-06-30 Henry Sherwood WestTorontosub-cabinet
Solicitor General, LC1845-08-211847-05-21J. A. Taschereaun/asub-cabinet
1847-12-081848-03-10J.E. Tarcotten/asub-cabinet
Postmasters General1841-02-101851-02-21Thomas Allen Staynern/asub-cabinet

References

Notes

  1. ↑ Practice of government being headed jointly by a minister from Canada West and a minister from Canada East had not yet be formally established.
  2. 1 2 3 4 The honours associated with entitlement of being addressed as "sir" were conferred upon Daly/Taché/Macdonald /Cartier after this period in office. Daley was knighted in 1856; Taché in 1858;[3] Macdonald on Dominion Day in 1867; Cartier was created a Baronet in 1868[4]
  3. ↑ Daly was he only member remaining in the Executive Council following resignation of all Reform members
  4. ↑ See Double Shuffle
  5. ↑ 7 Liberals (Sandfield Macdonald faction) from Canada West and 21 Rouges were in opposition 31 Liberals from Canada West and 4 Liberals from Canada East support the coalition until 1866; in 1866 Brown and 8 others rejoined the Liberals in opposition.
  6. ↑ Died in office
  7. ↑ Belleau's partisan affiliation at this time is subject to debate. His selection was not opposed by Brown and Dorion who were in council at the time, likely a compromise choice.
  8. ↑ Office established by statue in 1852, but not held as a standalone office until 1862[5]
  9. ↑ Not a cabinet post prior to 1860 but a role commissioned to one of the secretaries of the Governor. From 1860 to 1867 ex officio of the Commissioner of Crown Lands
  10. ↑ for examples, seeJoseph-Hyacinthe Bellerose, Senator (April 7, 1897). "Debate on the Address". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). Canada: Senate. p. 150-171.
  11. 1 2 from 1844 onward in later ministries, Provincial Secretary for the entire province

Cited work

Additional citations and references

  1. ↑ Moore 2011.
  2. 1 2 3 Cornell 1962.
  3. 1 2 "No. 22201". The London Gazette. November 16, 1858. p. 4854.
  4. ↑ "No. 23411". The London Gazette. August 11, 1868. p. 4453.
  5. ↑ Côté 1866, p. 4.
  6. ↑ Côté 1866, p. 9.
  7. ↑ Parliament 1841, p. 28, No.12.
  8. ↑ Civil 1841, p. 207.
  9. ↑ Collection de documents inédits sur le Canada et l'Amérique. Vol. 2. L.-J. Demers. 1889. p. 29.
  10. ↑ "Provincial Parliament, Friday 16th Sept 1842". Western Herald. Vol. 5, no. 25. Sandwich, Canada. October 6, 1842. p. 1.
  11. ↑ Cornell 1962, pp. 4–12, 93–94.
  12. ↑ Parliament 1841, No.4, Despatch from the Rt Hon. C. POULETT THOMSON to Lord JOHN RUSSELL, dated Toronto, 16th September, 1840..
  13. ↑ Phillip Buckner (2021) [1988]. "THOMSON, CHARLES EDWARD POULETT, 1st Baron SYDENHAM". In Halpenny, Francess G. (ed.). Dictionary of Canadian Biography. Vol. VII (1836–1850) (online ed.). University of Toronto Press.
  14. ↑ Parliament 1841, p. 30.
  15. ↑ Parliament 1841, p. 34.
  16. ↑ Halpenny, Francess G., ed. (1988). "BAGOT, Sir CHARLES". Dictionary of Canadian Biography. Vol. VII (1836–1850) (online ed.). University of Toronto Press.
  17. ↑ Jacques Monet (1988). "Bagot, Sir Charles". In Halpenny, Francess G. (ed.). Dictionary of Canadian Biography. Vol. VII (1836–1850) (online ed.). University of Toronto Press.