David Carr (New York politician)

David Carr
Carr in 2026
Minority Leader of the New York City Council
Assumed office
January 7, 2026
Preceded byJoann Ariola
In office
January 28, 2025 – February 7, 2025
Preceded byJoe Borelli
Succeeded byJoann Ariola
Member of the New York City Council
from the 50th district
Assumed office
November 30, 2021
Preceded bySteven Matteo
Personal details
Born (1987-08-28) August 28, 1987
PartyRepublican
EducationGeorgetown University (BA)
WebsiteOfficial website

David Carr (born August 28, 1987) is an American politician serving as Council Member for the 50th Council District of the New York City Council. He is a Republican, and the minority leader of the council.[1]

His district was formerly located only on Staten Island but now also encompasses part of Brooklyn.[2]

Life and career

David Carr was born on Staten Island and is a lifelong resident of the Grasmere section of the borough.[3] He attended local schools including the former St. John Villa Academy and Monsignor Farrell High School. Carr went on to earn a B.A. from Georgetown University. His first senior role in local government was as chief of staff to then-assemblyman Joe Borelli and later in the same position for council member and later New York City Council minority leader Steven Matteo.[4]

Elections to New York City Council

Carr became a candidate for the 50th Council District of the New York City Council in 2020, and sought to be the latest in a continuous line of representatives for that seat going back to its creation in 1991 when John Fusco was first elected. Since then, each new council member had been the chief of staff of his immediate predecessor.[5] Carr was endorsed by the Staten Island Republican Party.[6]

As one of five candidates in the primary, Carr made his campaign about public safety by calling for 6,000 new police officers to be hired over the ensuing five fiscal years, and the restoration of qualified immunity to New York City Police Department officers.[7] The contest became contentious as Carr accused an opponent, Marko Kepi, of illegal ballot harvesting including the registering of a dead person to vote and of forging signatures to get absentee ballots.[8] This in turn led to recriminations of racism and vote manipulation.[6] After losing a manual recount, Kepi took the matter to court where the presiding judge noted disturbing patterns in the signatures on the absentee envelopes.[9] Ultimately, Carr prevailed in all court challenges, sustaining his win of the GOP nomination.[10]

In the general election, Carr defeated Sal Albanese (Democrat) and George Wonica (Conservative).[11] He was sworn in early to take over for the unexpired term of Matteo after the latter left to lead a Staten Island not-for-profit.[12] Carr became the only openly gay Republican elected representative for Staten Island and the first openly gay Republican on the City Council.[13]

Carr was unopposed for re-election in 2023 as the nominee of the Republican and Conservative parties.[14] He was re-elected to a final four-year term in 2025 also as the Republican and Conservative nominee with over 75% of the vote.[15]

Council tenure

Carr passed two pieces of legislation in his first term. The first required the New York City Department of Buildings to give fee waivers for those seeking permits to build back after a fire after caused by a defect and to give permit fee waivers for those seeking to correct that same defect before a fire would happen in their homes.[16] The second allowed the city to set a different interest rate on unpaid property taxes for individuals and families that entered into a repayment plan with the New York City Department of Finance in order to give them a lower interest payment.[17]

As chair of the Italian Caucus, Carr has strongly supported the retention of Columbus Day as a holiday.[18] He is a member of the LGBTQIA+ Caucus.[19]

In 2024, amid a housing shortage in New York City, Carr voted against a proposal (City of Yes) to permit construction of 80,000 new housing units across the city over a 15-year period.[20] He argued that the environmental effects of new housing had not been studied.[20]

Carr was elected Minority Leader of the council's Republican caucus on January 28, 2025 because he had more seniority than Councilwoman Ariola and there was a tie vote. The vote was disputed as a quorum was not present (attendance via Zoom was not factored into the numerical quorum). Speaker Adams had to intervene. The council's attorney recommended against certifying the vote.[21] Carr became the first gay person elected leader of the Republican caucus or Republican conference of the New York City Council. Councilwoman Ariola served as the minority leader until January 7, 2026.[22]

On January 7, 2026, Carr was elected to his second term as minority leader of the New York City Council. With former councilwoman Kristy Marmorato losing re-election to Shirley Aldebol in 2025, councilwoman Joann Ariola lost a vote during the private election. Vickie Paladino, Frank Morano and Inna Vernikov supported Carr.[22] He became the only openly gay person elected leader of the New York City Republican caucus twice within less than one year.[22]

Borough President campaign

In April 2026, Carr announced that he intends to run for Staten Island Borough President in 2029.[23]

Electoral history

2026

2026 New York City Council minority leader election[24]
* denotes incumbent
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican David Carr (District 50) 4[a] 80.0
Republican Joann Ariola* (District 32) 1[b] 20.0
Total votes 5 100.0
Votes necessary 3 >50.0

2025

January 2025 New York City Council minority leader election[25][26]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican David Carr (District 50) 3[c] 50.0
   — Absent 3[d] 50.0
Total votes 3 100.0
Votes necessary 4 >50.0
February 2025 New York City Council minority leader election[27]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican Joann Ariola (District 32) 3[e] 60.0
   — Absent 2[f] 40.0
Total votes 3[g] 100.0
Votes necessary 3 >50.0
2025 New York City Council election, District 50[28]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican David Carr 32,972 67.8
Conservative David Carr 2,635 5.4
Total David Carr (incumbent) 35,607 73.2
Democratic Radhakrishna Mohan 12,953 26.6
Write-in 74 0.2
Total votes 48,634 100.0
Republican hold

2023

2023 New York City Council election, District 50[29]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican David Carr 7,526 79.5
Conservative David Carr 1,525 16.1
Total David Carr (incumbent) 9,051 95.6
Write-in 413 4.3
Total votes 9,464 100.0
Republican hold

2021

2021 New York City Council Republican primary, District 50[30]
Party Candidate Maximum
round
Maximum
votes
Share in
maximum
round
Maximum votes
  First round votes   Transfer votes
Republican David Carr 5 3,625 50.3%
​​
Republican Marko Kepi 5 3,583 49.7%
​​
Republican Sam Pirozzolo 4 2,172 26.5%
​​
Republican Kathleen Sforza 3 618 7.3%
​​
Republican Jordan Hafizi 2 414 4.8%
​​
Write-In 1 43 0.5%
​​
2021 New York City Council election, District 50[31]
Party Candidate Votes %
Republican David Carr 21,286 59.8
Democratic Sal Albanese 10,661 29.9
Staten Island 1st Sal Albanese 1,115 3.1
Total Sal Albanese 11,776 33.1
Conservative George S. Wonica 2,503 7.0
Write-in 50 0.1
Total votes 35,615 100.0
Republican hold

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ The four votes for Carr were cast by Carr himself, Frank Morano, Vickie Paladino, and Inna Vernikov.
  2. ↑ The one vote for Ariola was cast by Ariola herself.
  3. ↑ The three votes for Carr were cast by Joe Borelli, Carr himself, and Inna Vernikov.
  4. ↑ The three absences were from Joann Ariola, Kristy Marmorato, and Vickie Paladino.
  5. ↑ The three votes for Ariola were cast by Ariola herself, Kristy Marmorato, and Vickie Paladino.
  6. ↑ The two absences were from David Carr and Inna Vernikov.
  7. ↑ One seat (District 51) was vacant at the time of the election due to Joe Borelli's resignation.

References

  1. ↑ "Joann Ariola prevails as NYC Council minority leader". City & State NY. 2025-02-07. Retrieved 2025-06-13.
  2. ↑ "NYC Council David Carr Homepage". Retrieved 2021-12-14.
  3. ↑ DeSantis, Kelli. "Know your candidates: David Carr is running for Mid-Island City Council seat". Staten Island Advance. Retrieved 2024-03-24.
  4. ↑ Kashiwagi, Sydney (28 July 2020). "Matteo throws his support behind his Chief of Staff David Carr, who is running for his City Council seat". Staten Island Advance.
  5. ↑ Murphy, Jarrett (18 May 2021). "It's Insider Vs. Outsiders in Republican Council Primary on Staten Island". City Limits.
  6. 1 2 Liotta, Paul (22 February 2021). "Local political committees announce endorsements ahead of Staten Island's June primaries". Staten Island Advance.
  7. ↑ Bascome, Erik (14 May 2021). "Staten Island Republicans talk need to bolster NYPD". Staten Island Advance.
  8. ↑ Calder, Rich (12 June 2021). "Staten Island DA investigating alleged election fraud in City Council race". New York Post.
  9. ↑ Ostapiuk, Joseph (25 August 2021). "Judge slams 'deeply concerning, disturbing' patterns in Kepi ballots in court decision". Staten Island Advance.
  10. ↑ Liotta, Paul (15 October 2021). "Appellate judges reach decision bringing Carr-Kepi saga to an end". Staten Island Advance.
  11. ↑ Feldman, Ari Ephraim (2 November 2021). "David Carr holds Staten Island Council seat for GOP". NY1.
  12. ↑ Liotta, Paul (2021-11-30). "David Carr sworn in as new NYC Councilman representing Staten Island's Mid-Island". Staten Island Advance. Retrieved 2021-12-14.
  13. ↑ Dalton, Kristin F. (4 November 2021). "'I'm a friend, brother, son, and I happen to be gay,' said Ron Castorina, S.I.'s first openly gay Republican judge". Staten Island Advance.
  14. ↑ Liotta, Paul (7 November 2023). "Election 2023: Full results for Staten Island". Staten Island Advance.
  15. ↑ Bascome, Erik (4 November 2025). "Mid-Island City Council 2025: Republican David Carr claims victory". Staten Island Advance.
  16. ↑ Liotta, Paul (1 June 2022). "NYC Mayor Adams signs bill waving fees linked to massive 2020 Huguenot fire". Staten Island Advance.
  17. ↑ Liotta, Paul (2 March 2023). "Past due on your property taxes? A new NYC law may be able to help". Staten Island Advance.
  18. ↑ McDonough, Annie (7 October 2023). "Council's Italian Caucus will celebrate 'Columbus Day' this Monday". City & State.
  19. ↑ "Lesbian, Gay, Bi-sexual, Transgender, Queer, Intersex, Asexual Caucus". New York City Council. Retrieved 2023-11-02.
  20. 1 2 Fitzsimmons, Emma G. (5 December 2024). "New York City Is Set to Approve a Plan to Create 80,000 New Homes". The New York Times.
  21. ↑ Krichevsky, Sophie (February 3, 2025). "It's a leadership crisis in the NYC Council GOP!!!". City & State. Retrieved February 4, 2025.
  22. 1 2 3 Liotta, Paul (7 January 2026). "Staten Island regains City Council GOP leadership". Staten Island Advance.
  23. ↑ "Staten Island pol files for 2029 Borough President race: ‘I have always been very clear’," SILive, April 27, 2026.
  24. ↑ Liotta, Paul (January 7, 2026). "Staten Island regains City Council GOP leadership". Staten Island Advance. Retrieved May 23, 2026.
  25. ↑ Krichevsky, Sophie (January 28, 2025). "Ariola challenges Carr's victory as NYC Council minority leader". City & State. Retrieved May 23, 2026.
  26. ↑ Krichevsky, Sophie (February 3, 2025). "It's a leadership crisis in the NYC Council GOP!!!". City & State. Retrieved May 23, 2026.
  27. ↑ Krichevsky, Sophie (February 7, 2025). "Joann Ariola prevails as NYC Council minority leader". City & State. Retrieved May 23, 2026.
  28. ↑ "00501100050Richmond Member of the City Council 50th Council District Recap.pdf" (PDF). Vote NYC. New York City Board of Elections. December 2, 2025. Retrieved May 22, 2026.
  29. ↑ "00501600050Richmond Member of the City Council 50th Council District Recap.pdf" (PDF). Vote NYC. New York City Board of Elections. December 5, 2023. Retrieved May 22, 2026.
  30. ↑ "REP Council Member 50th Council District". Vote NYC. New York City Board of Elections. August 24, 2021. Retrieved May 22, 2026.
  31. ↑ "00500700050Richmond Member of the City Council 50th Council District Recap.pdf" (PDF). Vote NYC. New York City Board of Elections. November 30, 2021. Retrieved May 22, 2026.