1998 Makati local elections

1998 Makati mayoral election

May 11, 1998 (1998-05-11)
 
Nominee Elenita Binay Arturo "Toro" S. Yabut III Nelson Irasga
Party PDP–Laban Lakas Liberal
Alliance
    • Performance Team
    • Team Batang Makati
    • Team Irasga-Manzano
Running mate Ernesto S. Mercado Gabriel "Bong" Daza III Edu Manzano
Popular vote 147,865 92,947 21,725
Percentage 56.08 35.25 8.24

 
Nominee Alexander Villalon Cesar C. Alzona
Party Independent Reporma
Alliance
    • Team Bambi-Bobby-Cesar
Popular vote 591 518
Percentage 0.22 0.20

Mayor before election

Jejomar Binay
PDP–Laban

Elected mayor

Elenita Binay
PDP–Laban

Vice mayoral election
 
Candidate Edu Manzano Ernesto S. Mercado Gabriel "Bong" Daza III
Party Liberal PDP–Laban Lakas
Alliance
    • Team Irasga-Manzano
    • Performance Team
    • Team Batang Makati
Popular vote 103,853 100,894 54,275
Percentage 40.09 38.95 20.95

Vice Mayor before election

Arturo S. Yabut
Lakas

Elected Vice Mayor

Edu Manzano
Liberal

Local elections was held in the City of Makati on May 11, 1998, within the Philippine general election. The voters elected for the elective local posts in the city: the mayor, vice mayor, the two congressmen, and the councilors, eight in each of the city's two legislative districts.

Background

Incumbent mayor and PDP–Laban stalwart Jejomar Binay was term-limited and appointed as MMDA chairman. His wife, Dra. Elenita Binay, ran in his place. She selected 2nd district councilor Ernesto Mercado as her running-mate.[1]

Binay's challengers were former city engineer Nelson Irasga of Liberal Party,[2] incumbent vice mayor Arturo "Toro" Yabut of Lakas–NUCD,[3] a member of the family who previously allied with the Binays,[4] former acting mayor Cesar Alzona and 1984 assembly candidate Alexander Villalon.

For the vice-mayoralty, Mercado faced actor Edu Manzano and Councilor Bong Daza.

Iglesia ni Cristo endorsed Binay and Mercado.[5]

Citizenship of Manzano

Even Edu Manzano won the vice mayoral race, closest rival Ernesto Mercado filed a disqualification case against Manzano's dual citizenship, as Manzano is a citizen of the Philippines by blood and of the United States by birth. To prove his loyalty to the Philippines, Manzano tore his American passport at a press conference. Later, the Supreme Court dismissed the case.[6] In 2019, while campaigning for congressman for San Juan, Metro Manila, Manzano faced another case the same as 1998.[7]

Candidates

Performance Team

Partido Demokratiko Pilipino-Lakas ng Bayan/Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino/Aksyon Demokratiko/Laban ng Demokratikong Pilipino/Performance Team
NameParty
For Mayor
Elenita "Dra. Ellen" G. Sombillo-Binay PDP–Laban
For Vice Mayor
Ernesto "Nestor" S. Mercado PDP–Laban
For House Of Representative (1st District)
Ceferino "Joker" P. Arroyo Jr. LAMMP
For Councilor (1st District)
Oscar M. Ibay PDP–Laban
Ricardo "Ric" S. Javier PDP–Laban
Ferdinand Jacinto "Ferdie Tangol" T. Eusebio PDP–Laban
Meynardo L. Gonzales Independent
Romeo "Romy" C. Medina Aksyon
Victor T. Gomez Jr. PDP–Laban
Josefina S. Vasquez PDP–Laban
Hermenegildo "Hermie" C. San Miguel PDP–Laban
For House Of Representative (2nd District)
Agapito "Butz" A. Aquino LDP
For Councilor (2nd District)
Johnny S. Wilson PDP–Laban
Pedro A. Ibay PDP–Laban
Salvador "Buddy" D. Pangilinan PDP–Laban
Nelson "Doc" S. Pasia LAMMP
Divina "Divine" A. Jacome PDP–Laban
Liberato "Levi" G. Siaron PDP–Laban
Astolfo C. Pimentel PDP–Laban
Jaime P. Padua PDP–Laban
Virginia F. Blanca PDP–Laban
Augusto B. Martinez Jr. PDP–Laban
Eugenio C. Macababayao Jr. PDP–Laban

Team Batang Makati

Lakas-NUCD-UMDP/Nationalist People's Coalition/Team Batang Makati
NameParty
For Mayor
Nemesio Arturo "Toro" S. Yabut III Lakas
For Vice Mayor
Gabriel "Bong" V. Daza III Lakas
For House Of Representative (1st District)
Rose Marie Arenas NPC
For Councilor (1st District)
Enrico "Rico J." Puno Lakas
Robert Dean Barbers Lakas
Mark P. Joseph Lakas
Manuel A. Flores Lakas
Renato "Rene" L. Bondal Lakas
Joshua John C. Santiago Lakas
Jose Fidel B. Coronel Lakas
Nicolas "Nick" C. Enciso VI Lakas
For House Of Representative (2nd District)
Antonio "Tony" G. Manalili Lakas
For Councilor (2nd District)
AnaLuz "Atty. Luz" B. Cristal-Tenorio Independent
Cirilo A. Maccay Lakas
Israel "Boyet" S. Cruzado Lakas
Nilda M. Ariones Lakas
Alfredo N. Lapasaran Lakas
Edgardo "Bong" C. Manibog Lakas
Francisco U. Malabed Jr. Lakas
Mischa Nicanor "Nick" B. Elman Lakas

Team Irasga-Manzano

Liberal Party/Team Irasga-Manzano
NameParty
For Mayor
Nelson Q. Irasga Liberal
For Vice Mayor
Eduardo Luis "Edu" B. Manzano Liberal
For House Of Representative (1st District)
Alfonso Mike G. Policarpio Independent
For Councilor (1st District)
Aurora "Au" Pijuan Liberal
Fernando P. Angara Liberal
Mary Ann L. Susano Liberal
Celerino L. Umandap Liberal
Jay Fideli A. Francisco Liberal
Pedro P. Dadula Liberal
Amado G. de Vera III Liberal
John Rex T. Tiu Liberal
For House Of Representative (2nd District)
Billy Bibit Independent
For Councilor (2nd District)
Teresita E. Javier Liberal
Jason A. Maulit Liberal
Danilo M. Pangan Liberal
Eduardo E. Recometa Liberal
Rolando "Rolly" T. Torrente Liberal
Rodolfo "Rod" D. Biolena Liberal
Ricardo D. Dicon Liberal
Alfredo M. Ripoll Liberal

Team Bambi-Bobby-Cesar (Team BBC)

Partido para sa Demokratikong Reporma/Team Bambi-Bobby-Cesar (Team BBC)
NameParty
For Mayor
Cesar C. Alzona Reporma
For House Of Representative (1st District)
Perfecto "Bambi" M. Santos Reporma
For Councilor (1st District)
Felicisimo P. Bascon Jr. Reporma
Domingo C. Cobalida Jr. Reporma
Marco Luis V. Cabarloc Reporma
Geoffrey Q. dela Torre Independent
Jaime E. Aragon Independent
Ernesto A. Ramos Independent
Jose M. Caluag Independent
Feliciano L. Basilio Jr. Independent
For House Of Representative (2nd District)
Roberto "Bobby" G. Brillante Sr. Reporma
For Councilor (2nd District)
Virgilio Y. Baluyut Reporma
Eleuterio T. Tamayo Sr. Reporma
Melquiades B. Agustin Reporma
Eliseo C. Baldeviso Reporma

Independent Candidates

Independent
NameParty
For Mayor
Alexander J. Villalon Independent
For Councilor (1st District)
Amado D. Castrillo Independent
Jose Claro I. Swing Independent
Jose A. Brozoto Independent
For Councilor (2nd District)
Warren Anthony P. Sio I Independent

Other Non-Independent Candidates

PDP-Laban
For House Of Representative (1st District)
Adelia J. Insauriga PDP–Laban
Kilusang Bagong Lipunan
For House Of Representative (2nd District)
Ricardo O. Manila KBL
People's Reform Party
For Councilor (2nd District)
Eduardo V. Hubbard PRP

Results

Mayor

Dra. Elenita Binay won against incumbent vice mayor Arturo "Toro" Yabut, former mayor Cesar Alzona, City Engineer Nelson Irasga, and independent candidate Alexander Villalon.[8]

1998 Makati mayoral election
CandidatePartyVotes%
Elenita "Dra. Ellen" G. Sombillo-BinayPDP–Laban/Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino147,86556.08
Nemesio Arturo "Toro" S. Yabut IIILakas–NUCD–UMDP92,94735.25
Nelson Q. IrasgaLiberal Party21,7258.24
Alexander J. VillalonIndependent5910.22
Cesar C. AlzonaPartido para sa Demokratikong Reporma5180.20
Total263,646100.00
PDP–Laban hold

Vice Mayor

Actor Edu Manzano won against 2nd district councilors Ernesto Mercado and Gabriel "Bong" Daza III.[9]

1998 Makati vice mayoral election
CandidatePartyVotes%
Eduardo Luis "Edu" B. ManzanoLiberal Party103,85340.09
Ernesto "Nestor" S. MercadoPDP–Laban/Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino100,89438.95
Gabriel "Bong" V. Daza IIILakas–NUCD–UMDP54,27520.95
Total259,022100.00
Liberal Party gain from Lakas–NUCD–UMDP

Makati's 1st district congressman

Incumbent Joker Arroyo of Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino was re-elected to a third term.

CandidatePartyVotes%
Ceferino "Joker" P. Arroyo Jr. (incumbent)Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino91,26970.94
Rose Marie ArenasNationalist People's Coalition34,80727.05
Alfonso Mike G. PolicarpioIndependent1,2460.97
Perfecto "Bambi" M. SantosPartido para sa Demokratikong Reporma1,1560.90
Adelia J. InsaurigaPDP–Laban1840.14
Total128,662100.00
Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino hold
Source: Commission on Elections[10]

Makati's 2nd district congressman

The seat was left vacant after Butz Aquino of Laban ng Demokratikong Pilipino, who received the most number of votes in the district in the 1995 election, was disqualified by the Commission on Elections on June 2, 1995, for lack of residency. Aquino ran in the 1998 election as the candidate of Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino and won.

CandidatePartyVotes%
Agapito "Butz" A. AquinoLaban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino/Laban ng Demokratikong Pilipino76,80765.85
Antonio "Tony" G. ManaliliLakas–NUCD–UMDP19,97117.12
Roberto "Bobby" G. Brillante Sr.Partido para sa Demokratikong Reporma10,3348.86
Billy BibitIndependent9,2327.92
Ricardo O. ManilaKilusang Bagong Lipunan2940.25
Total116,638100.00
Laban ng Makabayang Masang Pilipino gain
Source: Commission on Elections[10]

City Council

1st District

Five of eight candidates of Binay-Mercado slate won the city council seats for this district.

City Council election at Makati's 1st district
Party Candidate Votes %
PDP–Laban Oscar M. Ibay 73,470
PDP–Laban Ricardo "Ric" S. Javier 61,876
PDP–Laban Ferdinand Jacinto "Ferdie Tangol" T. Eusebio 58,867
Independent Meynardo L. Gonzales 57,036
Lakas Enrico "Rico J." Puno 56,302
Aksyon Romeo "Romy" C. Medina 54,433
Lakas Robert Dean Barbers 54,185
Lakas Mark P. Joseph 51,366
PDP–Laban Victor T. Gomez Jr. 47,554
PDP–Laban Josefina S. Vasquez 46,854
PDP–Laban Hermenegildo "Hermie" C. San Miguel 46,500
Lakas Manuel "Maning" A. Flores 41,267
Lakas Renato "Rene" L. Bondal 38,208
Lakas Joshua John C. Santiago 34,426
Lakas Jose Fidel B. Coronel 32,665
Lakas Nicolas "Nick" C. Enciso VI 26,325
Liberal Aurora "Au" Pijuan 23,780
Liberal Fernando P. Angara 23,104
Liberal Mary Ann L. Susano 19,993
Liberal Celerino L. Umandap 8,752
Liberal Jay Fideli A. Francisco 7,934
Independent Geoffrey Q. dela Torre 7,850
Liberal Pedro P. Dadula 6,899
Liberal Amado G. de Vera III 6,617
Reporma Felicisimo P. Bascon Jr. 4,055
Liberal John Rex T. Tiu 3,731
Independent Jaime E. Aragon 3,726
Independent Ernesto A. Ramos 2,231
Independent Jose M. Caluag 2,098
Independent Feliciano L. Basilio Jr. 1,523
Reporma Domingo C. Cobalida Jr. 1,294
Independent Amado D. Castrillo 1,243
Reporma Marco Luis V. Cabarloc 1,236
Independent Jose Carlo I. Swing 775
Independent Jose A. Brozoto 670
Total votes

2nd District

Seven of eight candidates of Binay-Mercado slate won the city council seats for this district.

City Council election at Makati's 2nd district
Party Candidate Votes %
PDP–Laban Johnny S. Wilson 73,484
PDP–Laban Pedro A. Ibay 67,955
PDP–Laban Salvador "Buddy" D. Pangilinan 65,229
LAMMP Nelson "Doc" S. Pasia 63,348
Independent AnaLuz "Atty. Luz" B. Cristal-Tenorio 56,211
PDP–Laban Divina 'Divine" A. Jacome 55,553
PDP–Laban Liberato "Levi" G. Siaron 54,808
PDP–Laban Astolfo C. Pimentel 50,327
Lakas Cirilo A. Maccay 44,082
Lakas Israel "Boyet" S. Cruzado 31,673
Lakas Nilda M. Ariones 28,677
Lakas Alfredo N. Lapasaran 25,651
Lakas Edgardo "Bong" C. Manibog 23,985
Lakas Francisco U. Malabed Jr. 21,738
Lakas Mischa Nicanor "Nick' B. Elman 20,472
Reporma Virgilio Y. Baluyut 19,460
Liberal Teresita E. Javier 13,959
Liberal Jason A. Maulit 12,244
Liberal Danilo M. Pangan 12,080
Liberal Eduardo E. Recometa 12,029
Liberal Rolando "Rolly" T. Torrente 10,751
Reporma Eleuterio T. Tamayo Sr. 9,118
Liberal Rodolfo "Rod" D. Biolena 7,136
Liberal Ricardo D. Dicon 7,086
Reporma Melquiades B. Agustin 6,733
PDP–Laban Jaime P. Padua 4,461
Liberal Alfredo M. Ripoll 3,772
Reporma Eliseo C. Baldeviso 3,655
PDP–Laban Virginia F. Blanca 3,638
PDP–Laban Augusto B. Martinez Jr. 2,488
PDP–Laban Eugenio C. Macababayao Jr. 1,402
PRP Eduardo V. Hubbard 815
Independent Warren Anthony P. Sio I 549

References

  1. ↑ "Binay-Mercado tandem confident of win". Manila Standard. Kamahalan Publishing Corporation. March 30, 1998. p. 2. Retrieved November 9, 2024.
  2. ↑ "Irasga fears violent elections in Makati". Manila Standard. Kamahalan Publishing Corporation. March 7, 1998. p. 4. Retrieved November 8, 2024.
  3. ↑ "Yabut backs Jojo Binay's bid in Makati mayoral race". Philstar.com. March 7, 2001. Retrieved 2024-10-30.
  4. ↑ "Former Vice Mayor Yabut dies at MMC". Philstar.com. May 16, 2002. Retrieved 2024-10-30.
  5. ↑ Sy, Marvin (2001-05-15). "Elections in Makati generally peaceful". www.philstar.com. Retrieved 2024-10-30.
  6. ↑ Panganiban Perez, Tina; Magsino, Donna (2019-05-06). "Comelec disqualifies Edu Manzano from running for congressman in San Juan". GMA News Online. Retrieved 2024-10-30.
  7. ↑ Viray, Patricia Lourdes (May 8, 2019). "Edu Manzano insists Filipino citizenship despite serving in US Air Force". Philstar.com. Retrieved 2024-10-30.
  8. ↑ "MAKATI CITY Mayor (1998 Election)". cids.up.edu.ph. Philippine Local Government Interactive Dataset. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
  9. ↑ "G.R. No. 135083". The Lawphil Project. May 26, 1999. Retrieved November 28, 2024.
  10. 1 2 Commission on Elections. Certified List of Provincial Candidates, May 11, 1998 National and Local Elections, NCR. Manila. 2006.