1989 judgments of the Supreme Court of Canada

Supreme Court of Canada
Cour suprême du Canada
EstablishedApril 8, 1875 (1875-04-08)
JurisdictionGeneral court of appeal for Canada
MottoJustitia et Veritas
Authorized bySupreme Court Act, RSC 1985, c. S-26
Appeals fromProvincial and federal courts of appeal
Judge term lengthRetirement at age 75
Number of positionsNine
LanguageEnglish and French
WebsiteSupreme Court of Canada

The tables below list the judgments delivered by the Supreme Court of Canada during 1989. The judgments are listed in the order of publication in the Supreme Court Reports, starting with the first judgments of the year, rendered on January 19, 1989, and ending with the last judgments, rendered on December 21, 1989. The tables give a general illustration of the positions taken by each justice in each case, and how justices concurred or dissented with the decisions of the majority.

The Supreme Court normally reserves its judgment after hearing argument on an appeal, and then gives its judgment at some later date. At the time of these judgments, the court would deliver its reserved decisions at a session in open court. In some cases, the court instead gives its judgment from the bench at the conclusion of the hearing, with a short outline of its reasons. Those judgments are included in the table. The court also could give its decision on an appeal from the bench at the conclusion of the hearing, reasons to follow at a later date.

This table includes cases which were argued in a previous year and reserved, with the judgment given in 1989. Cases which were heard in 1989 and reserved, with judgment in a later year, are included in the article for the later year.

The Court gave 133 judgments in 1989, reported in two volumes of the Supreme Court Reports.

There were several changes in the membership of the court in 1989:

The Supreme Court Act authorises a retired judge to participate in reserved appeals they have heard prior to their retirement, for up to six months.[7] Justices Le Dain and Estey (who also retired in 1988) did not participate in any decisions after their retirement; Justices Beetz and McIntyre did so.

Judgments

Supreme Court Reports 1989: volume 1

  By the Court (C)
  Unanimous reasons for judgment (U)
  Concurred in the unanimous reasons (C–U)
  Majority reasons for judgment (M)
  Concurred in the majority (C–M)
  Concurring reasons (C–R)
  Concurred in the concurring reasons (C–C)
  Plurality reasons (P)
  Concurred in the plurality reasons (C–P)
  Dissenting reasons (D)
  Concurred in the dissent (C–D)
  Dissenting in part (D–P)
  Concurred in the partial dissent (C–DP)
  Seriatim reasons (S)
  Concurred in seriatim reasons (C–S)
  Motion (Mo)
  Did not sit on the appeal (NS)
  Did not participate in the judgment (NP)
  Not a Justice of the Court at the time of hearing or judgment (NJ)
  • "Decision by the Court" means that it is a unanimous judgment of the Court, not attributed to any particular justice.
  • "Unanimous reasons for judgment" indicated a unanimous decision, written by a particular justice.
  • Multiple concurrences and dissents within a case are numbered, with concurrences by other numbered accordingly. Justices occasionally concur in multiple reasons in a single case; each concurrence is subdivided accordingly.
  • Reasons are sometimes drafted jointly by two or more justices.
  • Decisions that are given orally from the bench are denoted by "Bench" on the justice who gave the oral decision.
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
R. v. Ross, [1989] 1 SCR 3[a][f] Jan 27, 1988 Jan 19, 1989 NS C–M C–D M C–M C–M D NS NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Amway Corp., [1989] 1 SCR 21 Oct 5, 1988 Jan 19, 1989 C–U NS C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U U NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Hayes, [1989] 1 SCR 44 Oct 6, 1988 Jan 19, 1989 C–M NS C–D C–D C–M C–M M D NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Genest, [1989] 1 SCR 59[a][f][g] Jan 29, 1988[g] Jan 26, 1989 U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Duguay, [1989] 1 SCR 93 Archived August 15, 2018, at the Wayback Machine Oct 14, 1988 Jan 26, 1989 M NS C–M C–M C–M C–M D C–M NJ NJ NJ
Granger v. Canada (C.E.I.C.), [1989] 1 SCR 141 Feb 1, 1989 Feb 1, 1989 NS NJ NS Bench
U
C–U C–U C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ
Andrews v. Law Society of British Columbia, [1989] 1 SCR 143[g] Oct 5, 6, 1987 Feb 2, 1989 C–P NS D C–D P C–R C–P NJ NJ NJ NJ
Ontario (Attorney General) v. Pembina Exploration Canada Ltd., [1989] 1 SCR 206[b][g] Jun 12, 1987 Feb 23, 1989 C–U NS C–U NS NS U C–U NJ NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Roman, [1989] 1 SCR 230[b] Jan 31, 1989 Feb 23, 1989 C NJ C C C C C C NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Hébert, [1989] 1 SCR 233 Feb 2, 1989 Feb 23, 1989 NS NJ NS C C C C C NJ NJ NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
American Airlines Inc. v. Canada (Competition Tribunal), [1989] 1 SCR 236 Mar 1, 1989 Mar 1, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ Bench
U
C–U C–U C–U C–U NS C–U NJ
Sobeys Stores Ltd. v. Yeomans and Labour Standards Tribunal (N.S.), [1989] 1 SCR 238[a][b][f][g] Feb 5, 1988 Mar 2, 1989 C–M C–C C–M C–M M C–R C–C NJ NJ NJ NJ
B. (B.) v. Child and Family Services, [1989] 1 SCR 291 Mar 2, 1989 Mar 2, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U Bench
U
NS C–U NJ
Arthur D. Little Inc. v. Coopers & Lybrand, [1989] 1 SCR 293 Mar 2, 1989 Mar 2, 1989 NS NJ NJ NS Bench
U
C–U C–U C–U NS C–U NJ
R. v. Gill, [1989] 1 SCR 295 Mar 3, 1989 Mar 3, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
NS C–U C–U C–U NS C–U NJ
R. v. Olson, [1989] 1 SCR 296[b] Jan 24, 1989 Apr 13, 1989 C NJ C NS NS C C C NJ NJ NJ
Brosseau v. Alberta Securities Commission, [1989] 1 SCR 301[f][g] Mar 28, 1988 Mar 9, 1989 C–U NS NS C–U C–U C–U U NJ NJ NJ NJ
Roberts v. Canada, [1989] 1 SCR 322[a][g] Jun 13, 1988 Mar 9, 1989 C–U C–U NS C–U U NS NS NS NJ NJ NJ
Borowski v. Canada (Attorney General), [1989] 1 SCR 342[b] Oct 3, 4, 1988 Mar 9, 1989 C–U NS C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U U NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Chaulk (Application), [1989] 1 SCR 369 Mar 13, 1989 Apr 27, 1989 C NJ NJ C C C C C NS C NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
Greater Montreal Protestant School Board v. Quebec (Attorney General), [1989] 1 SCR 377[a][b][g] Jun 7, 1988 Mar 16, 1988 C–C M C–M C–M C–R C–M NS NS NJ NJ NJ
Quebec (Attorney General) v. Belmoral Mines Ltée, [1989] 1 SCR 422 Mar 16, 1989 Mar 16, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
NS NS C–U Bench
U
C–U C–U NJ
R. v. Elias, [1989] 1 SCR 423 Mar 17, 1989 Mar 17, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
NS C–U C–U NS C–U C–U NJ
R. v. Bayard, [1989] 1 SCR 425 Mar 22, 1989 Mar 22, 1989 NS NJ NJ NS Bench
U
C–U NS C–U C–U C–U NJ
Hunter Engineering Co. v. Syncrude Canada Ltd., [1989] 1 SCR 426[b][f][g] Feb 25, 26, 1988 Mar 23, 1989 P NS C–R NS D–P C–P C–DP NJ NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Potvin, [1989] 1 SCR 525 Oct 6, 1988 Mar 23, 1989 C–C NS NS C–M M C–R NS C–M NJ NJ NJ
Prassad v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration), [1989] 1 SCR 560[b] Nov 28, 1988 Mar 23, 1989 C–M NJ C–M C–M C–D C–M D M NJ NJ NJ
Black v. Law Society of Alberta, [1989] 1 SCR 591[b][f][g] Mar 22, 23, 1988 Apr 20, 1989 C–M NS D–P NS C–M M C–DP NJ NJ NJ NJ
General Motors of Canada Ltd. v. City National Leasing, [1989] 1 SCR 641[a][b][g] May 17, 18, 1988 Apr 20, 1989 U C–U C–U C–U NS C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ NJ
Québec Ready Mix Inc. v. Rocois Construction Inc., [1989] 1 SCR 695[a][b][g] May 17, 18, 1988 Apr 20, 1989 U C–U C–U C–U NS C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
Laurentide Motels Ltd. v. Beauport (City), [1989] 1 SCR 705[a][b][g] May 24, 1988 Apr 20, 1989 NS M C–M C–M C–M C–M C–R NS NJ NJ NJ
Veilleux v. Quebec (Commission de protection du territoire agricole), [1989] 1 SCR 839[a][g] May 13, 1987 Apr 20, 1989 NS U NS C–U C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ NJ
Gauthier v. Quebec (Commission de protection du territoire agricole), [1989] 1 SCR 859[a][g] May 11, 1987 Apr 20, 1989 NS U NS C–U C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ NJ
Venne v. Quebec (Commission de la protection du territoire agricole), [1989] 1 SCR 880[a][g] May 11, 12, 1987 Apr 20, 1989 NS U NS C–U C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ NJ
Lebel v. Winzen Land Corp., [1989] 1 SCR 918[g] May 12, 1987 Apr 20, 1989 NS U NS C–U C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ NJ
Reference Re Workers' Compensation Act, 1983 (Nfld.), [1989] 1 SCR 922 Apr 24, 1989 Apr 24, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ C–U C–U Bench
U
C–U NS C–U C–U NS
Irwin Toy Ltd. v. Quebec (Attorney General), [1989] 1 SCR 927[a][b][f][g] Nov 19, 20, 1987 Apr 27, 1989 M D–P C–DP C–M C–M NS NS NJ NJ NJ NJ
Cohnstaedt v. University of Regina, [1989] 1 SCR 1011 Jan 30, 1989 Apr 27, 1989 C–U NJ NJ NS C–U C–U U C–U NJ NJ NJ
Maurice v. Priel, [1989] 1 SCR 1023 Feb 3, 1989 Apr 27, 1989 NS NJ NJ C–M C–M C–R C–M C–M C–M M NJ
R. v. Mcginn, [1989] 1 SCR 1035 Apr 26, 1989 Apr 26, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
C–U C–U NS C–U NS C–U NS
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
R. v. Lamb, [1989] 1 SCR 1036 Apr 28, 1989 Apr 28, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NS
Slaight Communications Inc. v. Davidson, [1989] 1 SCR 1038[g] Oct 8, 1987 May 4, 1989 M D NS D–P C–M C–M C–M NJ NJ NJ NJ
Vorvis v. Insurance Corporation of British Columbia, [1989] 1 SCR 1085[f][g] Oct 20, 1987 May 4, 1989 NS C–M M C–M D–P NS C–DP NJ NJ NJ NJ
Canadian Pacific Air Lines Ltd. v. British Columbia, [1989] 1 SCR 1133[a][b][g] Jun 8, 9, 10, 1988 May 4, 1989 NS C–R
1
C–C
1
C–P C–R
2
P C–P NS NJ NJ NJ
Air Canada v. British Columbia, [1989] 1 SCR 1161[a][b][g] Jun 8, 9, 10, 1988 May 4, 1989 NS C–R C–C C–P D–P P C–P NS NJ NJ NJ
Brooks v. Canada Safeway Ltd., [1989] 1 SCR 1219[a][b][g] Jun 15, 1988 May 4, 1989 U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ
Janzen v. Platy Enterprises Ltd., [1989] 1 SCR 1252[a][b][g] Jun 15, 1988 May 4, 1989 U C–U C–U NS C–U C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Turpin, [1989] 1 SCR 1296[a][g] Jun 16, 1988 May 4, 1989 C–U C–U NS C–U U C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Howard, [1989] 1 SCR 1337[b][g] May 19, 1988 May 18, 1989 NS NS C–M M NS C–M D NS NJ NJ NJ
Elsom v. Elsom, [1989] 1 SCR 1367 Feb 22, 1989 May 18, 1989 C–U NJ NJ NS C–U C–U C–U C–U U C–U NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
R. v. Zeolkowski, [1989] 1 SCR 1378 Mar 15, 1989 May 18, 1989 NS NJ NJ NS C–U NS C–U U C–U C–U NJ
R. v. Mohl, [1989] 1 SCR 1389 May 25, 1989 May 25, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ Bench
U
C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U
R. v. Lambretta; see also R. v. Adams, [1989] 1 SCR 1391 May 26, 1989 May 26, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U
R. v. Tutton, [1989] 1 SCR 1392[b][f][g][h] Nov 10, 1987 Jun 8, 1989 C–P NJ C–R
1
C–R
2
P C–P C–C
1
NJ NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Waite, [1989] 1 SCR 1436[b][f][g][h] Nov 10, 1987 Jun 8, 1989 C–P NJ C–R
1
C–R
2
P C–P C–C
1
NJ NJ NJ NJ
Scott v. Wawanesa Mutual Insurance Co., [1989] 1 SCR 1445[b] Dec 15, 1988 Jun 8, 1989 C–D NJ C–M C–M C–M D M C–D NJ NJ NJ
United States of America v. Cotroni; United States of America v. El Zein, [1989] 1 SCR 1469 May 5, 1988; Feb 22, 23, 1989[i] Jun 8, 1989 C–M NJ NJ NS D
1
M C–M D
2
C–M C–M NJ
R. v. Streu, [1989] 1 SCR 1521 Feb 23, 1989 Jun 8, 1989 NS NJ NJ NS C–U C–U C–U U C–U NS NJ
YMHA Jewish Community Centre of Winnipeg Inc. v. Brown, [1989] 1 SCR 1532 Mar 14, 1989 Jun 8, 1989 C–U NJ NJ C–U C–U C–U U C–U C–U NS NJ
Air Canada v. Mcdonnell Douglas Corp., [1989] 1 SCR 1554 Mar 17, 1989 Jun 8, 1989 NS NJ NJ C–U NS C–U C–U NS U C–U NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
Moysa v. Alberta (Labour Relations Board), [1989] 1 SCR 1572 Mar 20, 1989 Jun 8, 1989 C–U NJ NJ C–U C–U NS C–U U C–U C–U NJ
R. v. Leblanc, [1989] 1 SCR 1583 Jun 13, 1989 Jun 13, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ C–U C–U C–U NS C–U C–U C–U NS
R. v. Gagné, [1989] 1 SCR 1584 Jun 15, 1989 Jun 15, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
NS C–U NS C–U C–U C–U NS
Service d'optique Élite Ltée v. Ordre des optométristes du Québec, [1989] 1 SCR 1585 Jun 16, 1989 Jun 16, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
NS NS C–U C–U C–U C–U NS
R. v. Leduc, [1989] 1 SCR 1586 Jun 16, 1989 Jun 16, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
NS NS C–U C–U C–U C–U NS
Dupont v. Watier, [1989] 1 SCR 1588 Jun 19, 1989 Jun 19, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ Bench
U
NS C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NS
R. v. Lavigne, [1989] 1 SCR 1591 Jun 19, 1989 Jun 19, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NJ Bench
U
NS C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NS
Belcourt Construction Co. v. Roger Marchand Ltée, [1989] 1 SCR 1593 Jun 21, 1989 Jun 21, 1989 NS NJ NJ Bench
U
NS NS C–U C–U C–U C–U NS
R. v. Kalanj, [1989] 1 SCR 1594[b][f][g] Mar 28, 1988 Jun 22, 1989 NS NS M D
1
D
2
C–M C–M NJ NJ NJ NJ
Pioneer Hi‑Bred Ltd. v. Canada (Commissioner of Patents), [1989] 1 SCR 1623[g][h] May 26, 1988 Jun 22, 1989 C–U NP NS U NS C–U C–U NS NJ NJ NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
R. v. Pringle, [1989] 1 SCR 1645[b][g] Oct 13, 1988 Jun 22, 1989 NS NS C–U U C–U NS C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Conway, [1989] 1 SCR 1659 Dec 16, 1988 Jun 22, 1989 C–M NJ NJ C–R NS C–M M D NJ NJ NJ
Bell Canada v. Canada (Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission), [1989] 1 SCR 1722 Feb 21, 1989 Jun 22, 1989 NS NJ NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U U C–U NJ
R. v. Meltzer, [1989] 1 SCR 1764[g][h] Apr 28, 29, 1988 Jun 29, 1989 NS NP U C–U C–U C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Heikel, [1989] 1 SCR 1776[g][h] Apr 28, 29, 1988 Jun 29, 1989 NS NP U C–U C–U C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Ouellette, [1989] 1 SCR 1781[g][h] April 28, 29, 1988 Jun 29, 1989 NS NP U C–U C–U C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson Beetz[a] McIntyre[b] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier[c] Cory[d] McLachlin[e]
  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 Justice Beetz resigned on November 9, 1988. As permitted by the Supreme Court Act, he continued to participate in judgments on appeals he heard before his resignation.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 Justice McIntyre resigned on February 15, 1989. As permitted by the Supreme Court Act, he continued to participate in judgments on appeals he heard before his resignation.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Justice Gonthier was appointed on February 1, 1989, succeeding Justice Beetz.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Justice Cory was appointed on February 1, 1989, succeeding Justice Le Dain.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Justice McLachlin was appointed on March 30, 1989, succeeding Justice McIntyre.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Justice Estey sat on the hearing, but resigned on April 22, 1988, and did not participate in the decision of any case after that date.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 Justice Le Dain sat on the hearing, but resigned on November 29, 1988, and did not participate in the decision of any case after that date.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Justice Beetz sat on the hearing, but resigned on November 9, 1988, and did not participate in the decision of any case rendered more than six months after that date.
  9. ↑ Re-hearing; original panel was Beetz, Wilson, Le Dain, La Forest and L'Heureux‑Dubé JJ.

Supreme Court Reports 1989: volume 2

  By the Court (C)
  Unanimous reasons for judgment (U)
  Concurred in the unanimous reasons (C–U)
  Majority reasons for judgment (M)
  Concurred in the majority (C–M)
  Concurring reasons (C–R)
  Concurred in the concurring reasons (C–C)
  Plurality reasons (P)
  Concurred in the plurality reasons (C–P)
  Dissenting reasons (D)
  Concurred in the dissent (C–D)
  Dissenting in part (D–P)
  Concurred in the partial dissent (C–DP)
  Seriatim reasons (S)
  Concurred in seriatim reasons (C–S)
  Motion (Mo)
  Did not sit on the appeal (NS)
  Did not participate in the judgment (NP)
  Not a Justice of the Court at the time of hearing or judgment (NJ)
  • "Decision by the Court" means that it is a unanimous judgment of the Court, not attributed to any particular justice.
  • "Unanimous reasons for judgment" indicated a unanimous decision, written by a particular justice.
  • Multiple concurrences and dissents within a case are numbered, with concurrences by other numbered accordingly. Justices occasionally concur in multiple reasons in a single case; each concurrence is subdivided accordingly.
  • Reasons are sometimes drafted jointly by two or more justices.
  • Decisions that are given orally from the bench are denoted by "Bench" on the justice who gave the oral decision.
Case name Argued Decided Dickson McIntyre[a] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier Cory McLachlin[b]
R. v. Provo, [1989] 2 SCR 3 Dec 15, 1988 Jul 13, 1989 C–U NS NS U C–U C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ
British Columbia v. Henfrey Samson Belair Ltd., [1989] 2 SCR 24 Apr 21, 1989 Jul 13, 1989 NS NJ C–M C–M C–M C–M NS C–M D M
Canada (Auditor General) v. Canada (Minister of Energy, Mines and Resources), [1989] 2 SCR 49[a] Oct 7, 1988 Aug 10, 1989 U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NJ NJ NJ
R. v. D. (L.E.), [1989] 2 SCR 111 Dec 14, 1988 Aug 10, 1989 NS NS C–M C–M C–M D M NJ NJ NJ
R. v. Black, [1989] 2 SCR 138 Feb 1, 1989 Aug 10, 1989 NS NS C–U U C–U C–U C–U NS NS NJ
Greater Montreal Protestant School Board v. Quebec (Attorney General), [1989] 2 SCR 167 Jun 27, 1989 Aug 10, 1989 C NJ C C C NS NS C NS NS
Nelles v. Ontario, [1989] 2 SCR 170[a][c][d][e] Feb 29, 1988 Aug 14, 1989 C–P C–R
1
P C–P C–R
2
D–P NJ NJ NJ NJ
Alberta Government Telephones v. Canada (Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission), [1989] 2 SCR 225[a][c][d][e] Nov 12, 13, 1987 Aug 14, 1989 M C–M C–M D C–M C–M NJ NJ NJ NJ
IBEW v. Alberta Government Telephones, [1989] 2 SCR 318[a][c][d][e] Nov 12, 13, 1987 Aug 14, 1989 M C–M C–M C–R C–M C–M NJ NJ NJ NJ
Reference re Workers' Compensation Act, 1983 (Nfld.) (Application to intervene), [1989] 2 SCR 335 Dec 7, 1988 Feb 13, 1989 NS NS NS NS NS NS Mo NJ NJ NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson McIntyre[a] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier Cory McLachlin[b]
Neveu v. Côté Estate (Motion), [1989] 2 SCR 342 Apr 11, 1989 Apr 11, 1989 NS NJ NS NS NS NS NS Mo NS NS
R. v. Cassidy, [1989] 2 SCR 345 Feb 23, 1989 Sep 14, 1989 C–U NJ U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NS NJ
MacKay v. Manitoba, [1989] 2 SCR 357 Mar 14, 1989 Sep 14, 1989 C–U NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NS U NJ
R. v. Smith (Joey Leonard), [1989] 2 SCR 368 Mar 21, 1989 Sep 14, 1989 C–D NJ P C–D D C–R
1
C–R
2
C–P NS NJ
R. v. Leaney, [1989] 2 SCR 393 May 23, 1989 Sep 14, 1989 NS NJ D–P D NS C–M C–M NS NS M
Dallaire v. Paul-Émile Martel Inc., [1989] 2 SCR 419 Jun 21, 1989 Sep 14, 1989 NS NJ C–U NS NS C–U C–U U C–U NS
Bank of Montreal v. Kuet Leong Ng, [1989] 2 SCR 429 Mar 16, 1989 Sep 28, 1989 NS NJ C–U C–U C–U NS NS U C–U NJ
R. v. M. (S.H.), [1989] 2 SCR 446 Apr 27, 1989 Sep 28, 1989 C–M NJ C–M C–M C–D D C–M C–M C–M M
R. v. L. (J.E.), [1989] 2 SCR 510 Apr 27, 1989 Sep 28, 1989 C–M NJ C–M C–M C–D D C–M C–M C–M M
Tremblay v. Daigle, [1989] 2 SCR 530 Aug 8, 1989 Aug 8, 1989; Nov 16, 1989[f] C NJ C C C C C C C C
Case name Argued Decided Dickson McIntyre[a] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier Cory McLachlin[b]
Lac Minerals Ltd. v. International Corona Resources Ltd., [1989] 2 SCR 574[a] Oct 11, 12, 1988 Aug 11, 1989 NS C–DP C–R
1
C–R
2
M NS D–P NJ NJ NJ
Q.N.S. Paper Co. v. Chartwell Shipping Ltd., [1989] 2 SCR 683 Mar 24, 1988; Apr 28, 1989[g] Sep 28, 1989 NS NJ C–C
1
C–M M C–R
2
C–M NS C–M C–R
1
Watkins v. Olafson, [1989] 2 SCR 750 May 24, 1989 Sep 28, 1989 C–U NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U U
Scarff v. Wilson, [1989] 2 SCR 776 May 24, 1989 Sep 28, 1989 C–U NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U U
Falk Bros. Industries Ltd. v. Elance Steel Fabricating Co., [1989] 2 SCR 778 May 25, 1989 Sep 28, 1989 C–U NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U U
Nova Scotia (Attorney-General) v. Nova Scotia (Royal Commission Into Marshall Prosecution), [1989] 2 SCR 788 Apr 19, 20, 1989 Oct 5, 1989 NS NJ C–U C–U U C–U NS C–U C–U C–U
MacKeigan v. Hickman, [1989] 2 SCR 796 April 19, 20, 1989 Oct 5, 1989 NS NJ C–R
1
D–P
1
C–R
2
C–P NS C–P D–P
2
P
Chandler v. Alberta Association of Architects, [1989] 2 SCR 848 Jan 30, 1989 Oct 12, 1989 C–M NS NS C–M C–D D M NJ NJ NJ
R. v. D. (G.C.), [1989] 2 SCR 878 Oct 5, 1989 Oct 5, 1989 NS NJ NS Bench
U
NS NS C–U C–U C–U C–U
Syndicat des employés de production du Québec et de l'Acadie v. Canada (Canadian Human Rights Commission), [1989] 2 SCR 879[h] Feb 2, 1989 Oct 12, 1989 C–R NP C–P C–D C–P D P NS NS NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson McIntyre[a] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier Cory McLachlin[b]
R. v. Docherty, [1989] 2 SCR 941 Mar 15, 1989 Oct 12, 1989 NS NJ C–U U C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NJ
Hémond v. Coopérative fédérée du Québec, [1989] 2 SCR 962 Jun 20, 1989 Oct 12, 1989 NS NJ C–U NS NS C–U C–U U C–U NS
R. v. Pinske, [1989] 2 SCR 979 Oct 12, 1989 Oct 12, 1989 Bench
U
NJ Bench
U
C–U C–U NS C–U NS C–U C–U
Arthur D. Little Inc. v. Coopers & Lybrand (Application), [1989] 2 SCR 981 Oct 13, 1989 Oct 13, 1989 NS NJ NS Mo NS NS NS NS NS NS
Caimaw v. Paccar of Canada Ltd., [1989] 2 SCR 983[h] Dec 13, 1988 Oct 26, 1989 C–S NP C–C D
1
S D
2
C–R NJ NJ NJ
Lejeune v. Cumis Insurance Society Inc., [1989] 2 SCR 1048 Jun 15, 1989 Oct 26, 1989 NS NJ C–U NS NS C–U C–U U C–U NS
R. v. Hare, [1989] 2 SCR 1065 Nov 2, 1989 Nov 2, 1989 NS NJ Bench
U
C–U C–U NS C–U C–U C–U C–U
Canadian Pacific Air Lines Ltd. v. British Columbia (Re‑hearing), [1989] 2 SCR 1067 Nov 6, 1989 Nov 6, 1989 Bench
U
NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U NS NS NS NS
Oregon Jack Creek Indian Band v. Canadian National Railway Co., [1989] 2 SCR 1069 Nov 7, 1989 Nov 7, 1989 Bench
U
NJ NS C–U C–U C–U C–U NS C–U Bench
U
R. v. Ionson, [1989] 2 SCR 1073 Nov 8, 1989 Nov 8, 1989 Bench
U
NJ C–U NS C–U C–U C–U C–U C–U NS
Case name Argued Decided Dickson McIntyre[a] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier Cory McLachlin[b]
R. v. Nygaard, [1989] 2 SCR 1074 May 26, 1989 Nov 9, 1989 C–M NJ C–M C–M C–C D C–M C–C M C–R
Tétreault‑Gadoury v. Canada (Employment and Immigration Commission) (Motion), [1989] 2 SCR 1110 Oct 24, 1989 Nov 17, 1989 NS NJ Mo NS NS NS NS NS NS NS
R. v. Szlovak, [1989] 2 SCR 1114 Nov 28, 1989 Nov 28, 1989 Bench
U
NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U NS NS C–U C–U
R. v. Stensrud, [1989] 2 SCR 1115 Nov 30, 1989 Nov 30, 1989 Bench
U
NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U Bench
U
C–U C–U C–U
R. v. Hall, [1989] 2 SCR 1117 Nov 30, 1989 Nov 30, 1989 NS NJ Bench
U
C–U NS C–U NS C–U C–U NS
R. v. Sarvaria, [1989] 2 SCR 1118 Dec 1, 1989 Dec 1, 1989 NS NJ Bench
U
C–U NS NS C–U C–U Bench
U
NS
R. v. Smith (Michael Harold), [1989] 2 SCR 1120 May 24, 25, 1989 Dec 7, 1989 C–U NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U U C–U C–U C–U
R. v. Debot, [1989] 2 SCR 1140 Jun 22, 1989 Dec 7, 1989 C–M NJ M C–R
1
NS NS C–R
2
NS C–M NS
R. v. Hearn, [1989] 2 SCR 1180 Dec 8, 1989 Dec 8, 1989 NS NS NS Bench
U
NS C–U NS C–U C–U C–U
Tock v. St. John's Metropolitan Area Board, [1989] 2 SCR 1181[h] Jan 31, 1989 Dec 7, 1989 C–C
1
NP C–P P C–R
1
C–P C–R
2
NJ NJ NJ
Case name Argued Decided Dickson McIntyre[a] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier Cory McLachlin[b]
Just v. British Columbia, [1989] 2 SCR 1228 Feb 24, 1989 Dec 7, 1989 C–M NJ NS C–M C–M C–M D C–M M NJ
Rothfield v. Manolakos, [1989] 2 SCR 1259 March 21, 1989 Dec 7, 1989 C–P NS C–DP
2
D–P
1
P C–DP
1
NS C–P D–P
2
NJ
Saskatchewan (Human Rights Commission) v. Saskatoon (City), [1989] 2 SCR 1297 Feb 27, 1989 Dec 21, 1989 C–U NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U U NS C–U NJ
Saskatchewan (Human Rights Commission) v. Moose Jaw (City), [1989] 2 SCR 1317 Feb 27, 1989 Dec 21, 1989 C–U NJ C–U C–U C–U C–U U NS C–U NJ
Edmonton Journal v. Alberta (Attorney General), [1989] 2 SCR 1326 Mar 3, 1989 Dec 21, 1989 C–P NJ C–P C–R D–P C–DP C–DP NS P NJ
R. v. Lee, [1989] 2 SCR 1384 Mar 22, 1989 Dec 21, 1989 C–M NJ M D C–M NS C–D C–R C–M NJ
R. v. Buttar, [1989] 2 SCR 1429 Nov 10, 1989 Dec 21, 1989 NS NJ C–M C–M C–M C–C NS C–M M C–R
Case name Argued Decided Dickson McIntyre[a] Lamer Wilson La Forest L'Heureux-Dubé Sopinka Gonthier Cory McLachlin[b]
  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Justice McIntyre resigned on February 15, 1989. As permitted by the Supreme Court Act, he continued to participate in judgments on appeals he heard before his resignation, for up to six months.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Justice McLachlin was appointed on March 30, 1989, succeeding Justice McIntyre.
  3. 1 2 3 Justice Estey sat on the hearing, but resigned on April 22, 1988, and did not participate in the decision of any case after that date.
  4. 1 2 3 Justice Beetz sat on the hearing, but resigned on November 9, 1988, and did not participate in the decision of any case rendered more than six months after that date.
  5. 1 2 3 Justice Le Dain sat on the hearing, but resigned on November 29, 1988, and did not participate in the decision of any case after that date.
  6. ↑ Judgment from the bench on August 8, 1989; reasons delivered Nov 16, 1989.
  7. ↑ Re-hearing; panel on first hearing was Beetz, Lamer, Le Dain, La Forest and L'Heureux-Dubé.
  8. 1 2 3 Justice McIntyre sat on the hearing, but resigned on February 15, 1989, and did not participate in the decision of any case rendered more than six months after that date.

Summaries

Summary of judgments 1989
TypeNumber
By the Court6
Unanimous76
Majority with concurrences9
Majority with dissents16
Majority with dissents and concurrences3
Majority with dissents and dissenting in part3
Majority with dissents in part3
Plurality with concurrences4
Plurality with dissents3
Plurality with concurrences and dissents5
Seriatim2
Motions3
Total133
Summary of Each Justice's Positions 1989
Decision TypeDicksonBeetz[a]McIntyreLamerWilsonLa ForestL'Heureux-DubéSopinkaGonthierCoryMcLachlin
Court50255655221
Unanimous18432193311724
Unanimous (concurring)227104349575939324510
Majority52242433044
Majority (concurring)132918181898760
Concurring reasons12456734103
Concurred in concurrence31220140100
Plurality10024301011
Plurality (concurrence)60021450300
Seriatim00000100000
Seriatim (concurrence)10000000000
Dissent011162114010
Dissent (concurrence)20223302000
Dissenting in part01125111020
Dissenting in part (concurrence)00240051000
Motion00011001100
Not Sitting5613182124232528211222
Not Participating04300000000
Not a Justice03974000025585888
  1. ↑ The court gave 133 judgments in 1989, with 76 reported in volume 1 of the SCR, and 57 reported in volume 2. Justice Beetz did not participate in any cases that were reported in volume 2, so his total number of entries is only 76.
Judgments Issued, 1980 to 1989
YearJudgmentsChief Justice
1989133Dickson
1988106Dickson
198794Dickson
198676Dickson
198584Dickson
198463Dickson
198390Laskin
1982118Laskin
1981112Laskin
1980112Laskin
Ten-Year Average99
Source: Supreme Court Judgments, 1979 to 1988

References

  1. ↑ Supreme Court of Canada: Biographies of Former Justices: The Honourable Charles Doherty Gonthier.
  2. ↑ Supreme Court of Canada: Biographies of Former Justices: The Honourable Jean Beetz.
  3. ↑ Supreme Court of Canada: Biographies of Former Justices: The Honourable Peter deCarteret Cory.
  4. ↑ Supreme Court of Canada: Biographies of Former Justices: The Honourable Gerald Eric Le Dain.
  5. ↑ Supreme Court of Canada: Biographies of Former Justices: The Honourable William Rogers McIntyre.
  6. ↑ Supreme Court of Canada: Biographies of Former Justices: Right Honourable Beverley McLachlin, P.C., C.C.
  7. ↑ Supreme Court Act, RSC 1985, c. S-26, s. 27(2).