1964 South Carolina Senate election

1964 South Carolina Senate election

November 3, 1964

23 of 46 seats in the South Carolina Senate
24 seats needed for a majority
  Majority party Minority party
 
Leader Edgar Allan Brown —
Party Democratic Republican
Leader since 1942 —
Leader's seat Barnwell Co. —
Last election 24 seats, 65.04% 0 seats, 34.92%
Seats before 46 0
Seats won 23 0
Seats after 46 0
Popular vote 52,506[a] 24,914
Percentage 66.18% 31.40%

     New Democratic senator elected
     Democratic incumbent senator re-elected

Democratic:      50–60%      70–80%      80–90%      Unopposed


President before election

Edgar Allan Brown
Democratic

Elected President

Edgar Allan Brown
Democratic

An election in the U.S. state of South Carolina was held on November 3, 1964 to elect 23 of the South Carolina Senate's 46 members to four-year terms. Five of the 23 seats were at stake in the general election, four contested by Republicans and one by a draft write-in campaign. Every seat up for election was won by the nominee of the Democratic Party. For most seats, the real contests were the Democratic primary elections, with a first round on June 9 and a runoff election on June 23.

Of the 23 senators up for re-election, all sought another term.[1] In the first round of the Democratic primary, seventeen incumbent senators won renomination outright, ten of whom were unopposed. Four senators lost renomination outright, including a reversed result, and two advanced to a runoff. One senator won renomination and the other lost renomination in the runoff.

1963–64 special elections

Chester County

A special election was held on September 8, 1964, to fill the unexpired term of Chester County state senator Wilbur G. Grant to serve until the 1966 general election. Grant died of a heart attack in June 1964. Political newcomer Paul Hemphill Jr., cousin of U.S. representative and federal judge Robert W. Hemphill, defeated J. D. Leitner 2,994 votes to 2,186 votes in the Democratic primary on July 28.[2] Hemphill did not draw any Republican or independent opposition and won the subsequent special general election with 1,026 votes, with only five write-in votes cast against him.[3] He took office on September 16.

Overview

County Incumbents Candidates[4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11] Result
SenatorParty
Aiken Edward Cushman Democratic
  • General election:
  • ▌Green tickY Edward Cushman (Democratic) 12,788 votes, 51.55%
  • ▌Marion Hartzog Smoak (Republican) 12,019 votes, 48.45%
  • Democratic primary:
  • ▌Green tickY Edward Cushman
Incumbent re-elected.
Bamberg P. Eugene Brabham Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY Frank R. Hartzog
  • ▌P. Eugene Brabham
Incumbent lost renomination.
New member elected.
Democratic hold.
Barnwell Edgar Allan Brown Democratic Incumbent re-elected.
Beaufort James M. Waddell Jr. Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY James M. Waddell Jr.
  • ▌Lou M. Neale
Incumbent re-elected.
Calhoun Marion Gressette Democratic Incumbent re-elected.
Dorchester H. H. Jessen Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY H. H. Jessen
  • ▌W. S. Horne
Incumbent re-elected.
Edgefield Frank E. Timmerman Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY William A. Reels
  • ▌Frank E. Timmerman
Incumbent lost renomination.
New member elected.
Democratic hold.
Fairfield Ben F. Hornsby Democratic
  • General election:
  • ▌Green tickY John A. Martin (Democratic) 2,603 votes, 57.51%
  • ▌Ben F. Hornsby (Write-in) 1,923 votes, 42.49%
  • Democratic primary:
  • ▌Green tickY John A. Martin 2,088 votes, 50.05%
  • ▌Ben F. Hornsby: 2,084 votes, 49.95%
Incumbent lost renomination.
New member elected.
Democratic hold.
Georgetown C. C. Grimes Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY C. C. Grimes
Incumbent re-elected.
Greenville P. Bradley Morrah Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY P. Bradley Morrah
Incumbent re-elected.
Greenwood Francis Nicholson Democratic
  • General election:
  • ▌Green tickY Francis Nicholson (Democratic) 8,903 votes, 79.17%
  • ▌Olyn L. Gee (Republican) 2,342 votes, 20.83%
  • Democratic primary:
  • ▌Green tickY Francis Nicholson
  • ▌Marion P. Carnell
Incumbent re-elected.
Horry James P. Stevens Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY James P. Stevens
  • ▌E. Windell McCrackin
  • ▌G. Stanley Bryant
Incumbent re-elected.
Jasper Henry C. Walker Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY Henry C. Walker
Incumbent re-elected.
Laurens King Dixon Democratic
  • Democratic runoff:
  • ▌Green tickY W. C. Dobbins: 3,228 votes, 51.92%
  • ▌King Dixon: 2,989 votes, 48.08%
  • Democratic primary:
  • ▌checkY King Dixon
  • ▌checkY W. C. Dobbins
  • ▌David S. Taylor
Incumbent lost renomination.
New member elected.
Democratic hold.
Lexington Francis C. Jones Democratic
  • General election:
  • ▌Green tickY F. Beasley Smith (Democratic) 8,789 votes, 55.24%
  • ▌G. Wilson Hunter (Republican) 7,123 votes, 44.76%
  • Democratic primary:
  • ▌Green tickY F. Beasley Smith
  • ▌Francis C. Jones
Incumbent lost renomination.
New member elected.
Democratic hold.
Marion J. Ralph Gasque Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY J. Ralph Gasque
Incumbent re-elected.
McCormick L. L. Hester Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY L. L. Hester
  • ▌Hugh C. Brown
Incumbent re-elected.
Newberry J. F. Hawkins Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY J. F. Hawkins
Incumbent re-elected.
Oconee Marshall J. Parker Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY Marshall J. Parker
  • ▌S. P. Wells
Incumbent re-elected.
Orangeburg Marshall B. Williams Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY Marshall B. Williams
Incumbent re-elected.
Saluda Fred G. Scurry Democratic
  • ▌Green tickY Fred G. Scurry
  • ▌W. F. Sample
Incumbent re-elected.
Spartanburg Charles C. Moore Democratic
  • Democratic runoff:
  • ▌Green tickY Charles C. Moore: 8,503 votes, 56.21%
  • ▌Paul Moore: 6,625 votes, 43.79%
  • Democratic primary:
  • ▌checkY Charles C. Moore
  • ▌checkY Paul Moore
  • ▌John A. Munn
Incumbent re-elected.
York Robert W. Hayes Democratic
  • General election:
  • ▌Green tickY Robert W. Hayes (Democratic) 19,423 votes, 84.99%
  • ▌Clark Adicks (Republican) 3,430 votes, 15.01%
  • Democratic primary:
  • ▌Green tickY Robert W. Hayes
Incumbent re-elected.

Fairfield Democratic primary controversy

In the first round of the Democratic primary for Fairfield County's state senate seat, incumbent senator Ben F. Hornsby appeared to defeat former senator John Martin by six votes in unofficial tallies. After a mandatory recount, Hornsby's lead grew to eleven votes for a final vote count of 2,082–2,071, and the county Democratic executive committee certified Hornsby's nomination. Martin did not concede, and chose to appeal the decision to the state Democratic executive committee.[12] The SDEC met in Columbia in June 30 to settle the dispute.

Twenty-five ballots were in question. In the original recount, the county had thrown out twenty-three for being improperly marked. Upon further examination of the ballots, the SDEC determined that seventeen belonged to Martin, four to Hornsby, with the remaining four being unintelligible. This was enough to reverse the election in Martin's favor, and the SDEC ruled Martin the victor, 2,088 votes to 2,084, a four-vote margin. Upon learning of his defeat, Senator Hornsby left the meeting and checked out of his hotel.[13]

Hornsby declined to fight the ruling in the courts. Under South Carolina law, candidates who lost a primary could not contest or campaign in the general election. A write-in campaign led by Columbia attorney Malcolm E. Rentz was organized without consulting Hornsby in an attempt to re-elect him.[14] A large number of local voters backed the effort, but it was ultimately unsuccessful, as Democratic nominee Martin was elected over Hornsby at the general election by 680 votes, 2,603 to 1,923.[5]

Notes

  1. ↑ Excludes vote totals from uncontested seats

References

  1. ↑ "35 Of 273 Demo Candidates Get Primary Run With No Opposition". The Greenville News. June 7, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  2. ↑ Morrison, Bruce (July 30, 1964). "Deadline set for nominee". The Herald. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  3. ↑ "Hemphill Will Fill Senate Senate". The State. September 9, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  4. ↑ Williams, William B. (June 7, 1964). "S.C. Democratic Primary Climaxes Tuesday". The State. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  5. 1 2 "Returns Still Incomplete; Amendment Still In Doubt". The State. November 21, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  6. ↑ Law, Ernestine (June 24, 1964). "How South Carolina Voted: A County-by-County Roundup of the Runoff". The State. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  7. ↑ "Most county delegation Nominations Settled on Tuesday". Florence Morning News. June 11, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  8. ↑ "Here's the precinct-by-precinct vote in York". The Herald. November 4, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  9. ↑ Chigges, Gus J. (November 5, 1964). "Lexington Republicans See 'Definite Future' (Gus J. Chigges)". The State. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  10. ↑ Watson, Margaret (November 10, 1964). "More Help Urged At Voting Places". The Index-Journal. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  11. ↑ "County-By-County Vote on Local Issues". The State. November 5, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  12. ↑ "Carolina Datelines". The Index-Journal. Associated Press. June 16, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  13. ↑ Williams, William B. (July 1, 1964). "Fairfield: 4-Vote Decision". The State. Retrieved February 27, 2026.
  14. ↑ "Write-In Campaign Begins For State Senator Hornsby". The Index-Journal. Associated Press. September 25, 1964. Retrieved February 27, 2026.