1923–24 American Cup
The 1923–24 American Cup was the thirty–second edition of the annual challenge cup held by the American Football Association. The Secretary of the AFA, Andrew Beveridge received entries up to September 29, 1923.
![]() | |
| Tournament details | |
|---|---|
| Country | United States |
| Dates | October 1923 – May 1924 |
| Teams | 43 |
| Final positions | |
| Champions | Bethlehem Steel (6th title) |
| Runners-up | Fall River |
Preliminary round
Matches were due to be completed by October 28, 1923. The following teams drew byes for this round: Abbot Worsted (Forge Village), Bethlehem Steel, Brooklyn, Crompton, Fairhill (Philadelphia), Fairlawn Rovers (Pawtucket), Falco (Holyoke), Fall River, Fleischer Yarn (Philadelphia), Fore River (Quincy), General Electric United (Lynn), J. & P. Coats (Pawtucket), Morell Mills (Philadelphia), National Giants (NY), New York, Newark, Philadelphia, Prospect Hill (Pawtucket), Sayles Finishing (Pawtucket), West End Polish (Crompton), and Weypoyset.
Northern Massachusetts
| Ludlow Thistle | 1–3 | Ludlow Wanderers |
|---|---|---|
| Munroe | [1] | F. Souza Maia Oliveira |
| Pacific Mills | 3–1 | Swedish American |
|---|---|---|
| Rodgers White Ormond |
[2] | Neelgram |
Southern New England
| Greystone Blues | – | Don Carlos |
|---|---|---|
| [3] |
| Greystone Vets | 1–1 | Providence Thistle |
|---|---|---|
| [4] |
replay
| Greystone Vets | – | Providence Thistle |
|---|---|---|
| [5] |
Connecticut and New York
| Ansonia | 2–1 | Campbell |
|---|---|---|
| Duncan (2) | [6] | 30' Berwick |
| Bedford | 4–0 | Danersk Athletics |
|---|---|---|
| Avery Rew (3) |
[7] |
New Jersey District
| General Electric | 0–2 | American A.A. |
|---|---|---|
| [8] | T. Strong (2) |
| Bayonne Rovers | 3–1 | Jersey A.C. |
|---|---|---|
| Elliott Carr 80' Callahan |
[9] | Perrini |
| Hudson | 4–0 | British War Veterans |
|---|---|---|
| C. Cavanaugh 60' R. Norris Koss McLoughlin |
[10] |
| Clan MacLeod | 3–3 | Clan McKay |
|---|---|---|
| McCrum O'Neil Hill |
[11] | 50' Boyle Speed Lees |
replay
| Clan MacLeod | 5–3 | Clan McKay |
|---|---|---|
| Bell (4) McPherson |
[12] | Boyle Brennan Cowie |
Pennsylvania District
| Viscose | 7–1 | 36th Ward |
|---|---|---|
| Chew (2) Murphy (2) Bennett (2) J. Nicol |
[13] | Smith |
First round
Matches were due to be completed by November 25, 1923. The Fore River–G.E. United match was called on account of rain after one half and was replayed on Thanksgiving Day.
Northern Section
| Ludlow Wanderers | 0–7 | Pacific Mills |
|---|---|---|
| [14] | Churchley (3) Kershaw (3) Lyons |
| Fore River | 2–1 | General Electric United |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Satterwaite Harrison |
[15] | Duthie |
| Greystone Vets | – | Crompton |
|---|---|---|
| [16] |
| Fall River | 7–1 | West End Polish |
|---|---|---|
| Harold Brittan (4) Harry McGowan (2) Campbell |
[17] | Frank Begos |
| Sayles Finishing | 2–0 | Waypoyset |
|---|---|---|
| 50', 2H' Bennie Wilson | [18] |
| J. & P. Coats | 2–1 | Fairlawn Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| 3' McLeavey Neilson |
[19] | Sandeman (pk) |
| Falco | 2–6 | Abbot Worsted |
|---|---|---|
| Veighey Brown |
[20] | 3' Neil Bob Perry (4) Farquhar |
| Prospect Hill | 9–1 | Don Carlos |
|---|---|---|
| Cookson (3) White McCaughey T. Littleford (3) Withers |
[21] | Hayes |
replay
| Fore River | 2–1 | General Electric United |
|---|---|---|
| Joe Black (2) | [22] | Duthie |
Southern Section
| Philadelphia | 1–2 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| 40' Braidford | [23] | Alec Jackson Walter Jackson |
| Viscose | 0–2 | Fairhill |
|---|---|---|
| [24] | Farrell Hamilton |
| Morrell Mills | 1–3 | Fleisher Yarn |
|---|---|---|
| W. Flynn | [25] | Straddon (2) Galloway |
| Clan MacLeod | 2–1 | Hudson |
|---|---|---|
| G. Carnegie 80' Hartie |
[26] | Reich (pk) |
| Ansonia | 1–4 | Bedford |
|---|---|---|
| 40' McKenzie (pk) | [27] | Gallagher Adamson 75', 85' Kerr |
| National Giants | 2–3 | New York |
|---|---|---|
| Reynolds (og) 60', 80' Peter Sweeney |
[28] | 75' Duggan Bart McGhee |
| Bayonne Rovers | 0–3 | American A.A. |
|---|---|---|
| [29] | 75' Tommie Strong Andie Hutchinson Dick Porter |
| Brooklyn Wanderers | 4–2 | Newark |
|---|---|---|
| 8' Docherty 11' Curtis 13' Hogg 50' Cosgrove |
[30] | 1H' Bleich 65' Heminsley |
Second round
Matches were due to be completed by January 20, 1924. Prospect Hill forfeited their match with Fore River.[31]
Northern section
| Fall River | 2–0 | Sayles Finishing |
|---|---|---|
| 35' Johnny Reid McPherson |
[32] |
| J. & P. Coats | 1–2 | Crompton |
|---|---|---|
| Fleming | [33] | 8' Baronne 82' Read |
| Fore River | w/o | Prospect Hill |
|---|---|---|
| [34] |
| Abbot Worsted | 4–0 | Pacific Mills |
|---|---|---|
| Cummings Farquhar Perry Dundas |
[35] |
Southern section
| Bedford | 1–6 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| 75' Donelly | [36] | Alec Jackson (3) Walter Jackson McGregor Maxwell |
| Clan MacLeod | 1–5 | American A.A. |
|---|---|---|
| P. Hartie | [37] | J. Durkin Tommy Strong (2) T. Florie A. Hutchison |
| Fleisher Yarn | 1–0 | Fairhill |
|---|---|---|
| 80' Galloway | [38] |
| New York | 2–0 | Brooklyn Wanderers |
|---|---|---|
| 53' Archie Stark 81' Duggan |
[39] |
Third round
Northern section
| Fall River | 6–2 | Crompton |
|---|---|---|
| Fred Morley (2) Tom Raeside (2) Johnny Reid (2) |
[40] | 35' Cullerton Simone (pk) |
| Abbot Worsted | 2–0 | Fore River |
|---|---|---|
| 41' Perry 42' Neil |
[41] |
Southern section
| Fleisher Yarn | 1–3 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| 86' Straddan | [42] | Walter Jackson (2) Granger |
| New York | 2–1 | American A.A. |
|---|---|---|
| 2H', 115' Archie Stark | [43] | 30' Tommie Strong |
Semifinals
| Fall River | 4–1 | Abbot Worsted |
|---|---|---|
| 27' McPherson (pk) 109', 113' Harold Brittan 114' Morley |
[44] | 75' Dundas |
| New York | 0–1 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| [45] | 75' Walter Jackson |
Final

The final took place on May 11, 1924 at the Jersey City baseball grounds. Bethlehem Steel, by their victory, broke up a near treble by Fall River who had previously won the National Challenge Cup in March and finished first in the American Soccer League which wrapped up in June. For their part, Bethlehem Steel was a semifinalist in the National Cup and finished second in the ASL.
| Bethlehem Steel | 1–0 | Fall River F.C. |
|---|---|---|
| 37' Jack Rattray | [46][47] |
See also
References
- ↑ "Wanderers Surprise Thistles In Cup Tie". (October 28, 1923). Springfield Union, p.14 col.1
- ↑ "Pacific Advances In The American Cup Competition". (October 29, 1923). Evening Tribune, p.14 col.2
- ↑ "Drawings For American Cup Games Made". (October 9, 1923). Evening Bulletin, p.7 col.5
- ↑ "Thistle Takes On Greystone Vets". (October 20, 1923). Providence News, p.10 col.7
- ↑ "With The Rhode Island Amateurs". (October 27, 1923). Evening Bulletin, p.11 col.5
- ↑ "Locals Eliminate Campbell A.C.". (November 5, 1923). Evening Sentinel, p.3 col.6–7
- ↑ "Bedford Club Blanks Danersk Of Stamford". (November 5, 1923). Brooklyn Standard Union, p.18 col.6
- ↑ "Center Stars In Victory Of American Soccerites". (October 22, 1923). Newark Evening News, p.18 col.4
- ↑ "Bayonne Rovers Win Over Jerseys". (October 29, 1923). Bayonne Times, p.8 col.7
- ↑ "Hudsons Defeat Trenton Eleven". (October 29, 1923). Hudson Observer, p.14 col.8
- ↑ "M'Leod & M'Kay Football Draw". (October 29, 1922). Jersey Journal, p.15 col.6
- ↑ "Clan M'Leod Defeats Clan M'Kay At Soccer". (November 6, 1923). Hudson Observer, p.12 col.3
- ↑ "Viscose Victors in Game For Cup". (October 29, 1923). Chester Times, p.10 col.1
- ↑ "Wanderers Lose To Pacific Millers". (November 25, 1923). Springfield Sunday Republican, p.1B col.8
- ↑ "Rain Stops Soccer Game". (November 26, 1923). Quincy Patriot, p.8 col.1
- ↑ "Soccer Notes". (November 22, 1923). Fall River Globe, p.12 col.8
- ↑ "Trounce West End Polish A.C.". (November 30, 1923). Fall River Globe, p.19 col.1–2
- ↑ "Sayles Puts Waypoysets Out Of Cup Competition". (November 30, 1923). Providence Journal, p.8 col.2
- ↑ "Threadmen Beat Rovers". (November 30, 1923). Pawtucket Times, p.40 col.1–2
- ↑ "Falcos Defeated By Crack Abbot Worsteds". (November 30, 1923). Holyoke Daily Transcript, p.15 col.3
- ↑ "Prospect Hill Runs Wild Against Don Carlos". (December 10, 1923). Pawtucket Times, p.21 col.2
- ↑ "Fore River Wins Soccer". (November 30, 1923). Quincy Patriot, p.4 col.6
- ↑ Wilcox, Levi (November 25, 1923). "Phil Kickers Bow To Bethlehem Steel". Philadelphia Inquirer, p.21 col.1–2
- ↑ "Fairhill Downs Viscose Eleven". (November 26, 1923). Chester Times, p.8 col.6
- ↑ "Fleisher Yarners Win From Morrell Mills". (November 25, 1923). Philadelphia Record, p.5 col.5
- ↑ "McLeods Defeat Hudsons". (November 26, 1923). Jersey Journal, p.20 col.1
- ↑ "Ansonia Soccer Team Defeated By Bedford". (November 26, 1923). Evening Sentinel, p.4 col.3–4
- ↑ "N.Y.F.C. Defeats National Giants". (December 10, 1923). New York Times, p.22 col.5
- ↑ "Rovers Lose To American A.A.". (December 17, 1923). Bayonne Evening News, p.5 col.1
- ↑ Meany, Thomas W. (January 21, 1924). "Docherty Scintillates In Last Contest Here". Brooklyn Daily Times, p.12 col.1–2
- ↑ "Another Round For American Cup". (January 25, 1924). Boston Globe, p.9 col.4
- ↑ "Marksmen Blank Saylesville 2 To 0". (January 2, 1924). Evening Herald, p.12 col.1–2
- ↑ "Crompton Upsets Dope; Defeats Coats". (January 14, 1924). Pawtucket Times, p.22 col.5–6
- ↑ "Quincy Point". (January 25, 1924). Quincy Patriot, p.4 col.2
- ↑ "Splashing Victory For The Abbots". (February 4, 1924). Lowell Sun, p.12 col.3
- ↑ "Bethlehem Beats Bedford At Soccer". (January 14, 1924). New York Times, p.23 col.4
- ↑ "M'Leod's Soccer Team Defeated". (January 21, 1924). Jersey Journal, p.14 col.8
- ↑ "Fleisher Beats Fairhill In American Cup League". (January 13, 1924). Philadelphia Record, p.4 col.2
- ↑ "Wanderers Beaten By N.Y.F.C. Eleven". (February 4, 1924). New York Times, p.24 col.8
- ↑ "Cromptons No Foe For Local Leaders". (February 4, 1924). Evening Herald, p.13 col.1–3
- ↑ "Abbot Worsteds' Win Two Games". (February 25, 1924). Lowell Sun, p.8 col.3
- ↑ "Bethlehem Steel Downs Fleisher". (March 23, 1924). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.21 col.6
- ↑ "Extra–Period Game Won By N.Y. Eleven". (March 24, 1924). New York Times, p.11 col.2
- ↑ "Spot Kick Lucky For Fall River". (April 21, 1924). Fall River Globe, p.13 col.2
- ↑ "N.Y.F.C. Forced Out Of Soccer Classic". (April 21, 1924). New York Times, p.24 col.2
- ↑ Nonnemacher, Fred S. (May 12, 1924). "SPEAKING OF CHAMPS STEEL SOCCER TEAM JOINS THAT CLASS". The Globe. Archived from the original on October 21, 2009.
- ↑ "Bethlehem Takes The American Cup". (May 12, 1924). Fall River Herald, p.1 col.4–5
