1920–21 American Cup
The 1920–21 American Cup was the annual challenge cup held by the American Football Association. The annual meeting to elect officials was held at the Hotel Berwick in Newark on September 18, 1920. The A.F.A. officials elected were president Donald MacMillan of East Newark, vice–president William Patrick of Bayonne, recording secretary James Galletley of Kearny, and secretary/treasurer Andrew N. Beveridge of Jersey City.[1] Entries for the tournament were due to close by September 20. Robins Dry Dock of Brooklyn recorded their second triumph of the American trophy in consecutive seasons. The shipbuilders defeated the steelworkers 1–0 in the final on May 2 at Harrison, New Jersey.
![]() | |
| Tournament details | |
|---|---|
| Country | United States |
| Dates | October 1920 – May 1921 |
| Teams | 44 |
| Final positions | |
| Champions | Robins Dry Dock (2nd title) |
| Runners-up | Bethlehem Steel Works |
First round
The first and second round draw took place October 2, 1920 at Hotel Berwick in Newark, NJ.[2] Matches were to be played by October 24. The following teams drew byes: Ansonia, Bethlehem Steel, Brooklyn, Chicopee Rovers, Clan Cameron (Providence), Clan MacDuff (New York), Columbia Graphaphone, Disston (Tacony), Erie, Farr & Alpaca, Greystone, General Electric (Lynn), Hibernian (Philadelphia), J. & J. Dobson, New Departure (Bristol), New York, Robins Dry Dock, Swedish Athletics, Tebo Yacht, and West Orange.
Pennsylvania District
No games
New Jersey District
| Paterson | 6–1 | Erie Juniors |
|---|---|---|
| Galloway (2) Petrie Burns Vanden Eyden Illingsworth |
[3] | McCarten |
| Crescent | 2–3 | Babcock & Wilcox |
|---|---|---|
| [4] | 89' Elliott (pk) |
| Sprague | 1–2 | Athenia Steel Company |
|---|---|---|
| [5] |
| Federal Ship | 8–1 | Bunker Hill |
|---|---|---|
| Richardson (4) S. Jamieson M. Jamieson (2) Field |
[6] | Gleason |
New York District
| Greenpoint | 3–2 | Viking |
|---|---|---|
| Gillespie Harrington |
[7] |
Connecticut District
| Stamford | 1–2 | Danersk Athletic |
|---|---|---|
| 2H' | [8] | 1H' 80' |
| Connecticut Lace Works | 0–5 | Waverly |
|---|---|---|
| [9] |
North Massachusetts District
| Hendee Indians | 1–3 | Fore River |
|---|---|---|
| 89' Earnest Logan (pk) | [10] | 5' Black (pk) 10' Dave Page Jack Kershaw |
New England District
| Fall River Rovers | 3–0 | St. Michael's |
|---|---|---|
| [11] | 65' Hodson Lynch 86' Parker |
| Potter Johnston | 1–8 | J. & P. Coats |
|---|---|---|
| 85' Cookson | [12] | Holgate (5) Bob Millar Al Lonie McIntosh |
| Sayles Finishing Plant | 2–2 | Ashton Berkeley |
|---|---|---|
| Cunliffe Downie |
[13] | Williams Slater |
| Crompton | 1–3 | Fairlawn Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| 2H' | [14] | Roger Smith (pk) 1H' Roger Smith Bobby Bowes |
replay
| Sayles Finishing Plant | 6–0 | Ashton Berkeley |
|---|---|---|
| [15] |
Second round
The second round matches were due to be played on or before November 14.[16] The Hibernian vs Disston game was forfeited by Disston for lack of players. The match was played as a friendly.
New Jersey District
| Paterson | 0–4 | Erie |
|---|---|---|
| [17] | 25', 40' Heminsley Brown Archie Stark |
| Babcock & Wilcox | 5–0 | West Orange |
|---|---|---|
| [18] |
| Federal Ship | 9–0 | Athenia Steel |
|---|---|---|
| Richardson (3) Brierley (2) Mauncher M. Jamieson Field S. Jamieson |
[19] |
New York District
| New York | 2–0 | Clan MacDuff |
|---|---|---|
| 67', 82' Hardy | [20] |
| Robins Dry Dock | 2–1 | Tebo Yacht Basin |
|---|---|---|
| 28' Ratican 35' Clarke |
[21] | 25' Mitchell |
| Greenpoint | 1–1 | Brooklyn |
|---|---|---|
| [22] |
replay
| Greenpoint | 0–2 | Brooklyn |
|---|---|---|
| [23] | 7', 67' Bulcock |
Connecticut District
| Swedish | 1–3 | Ansonia |
|---|---|---|
| [24] | Speed |
| Waverley | 5–3 | Danersk Athletic |
|---|---|---|
| 47' Art Greenslade 69' Tommy Grey 87' Adams |
[25] |
| Columbia Graphophone | w/o | New Departure |
|---|---|---|
| [26] |
Northern Massachusetts district
| General Electric | 3–1 | Farr Alpaca |
|---|---|---|
| 20' McKay 43' Johnny Kane 85' Dundas |
[27] | 2H' Dowdall |
| Fore River | 7–0 | Chicopee Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| 2' Joe Kershaw Jack Kershaw (4) Law Shepard |
[28] |
Southern New England district
| Fairlawn Rovers | 4–0 | Greystone |
|---|---|---|
| Ward (2) McDonald (2) |
[29] |
| J. & P. Coats | 3–2 | Sayles |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Louie 47' Miller Holgate |
[30] | 1H', 89' Downie |
| Fall River Rovers | 14–0 | Clan Cameron |
|---|---|---|
| Connie Lynch (4) Tommy Adams (3) Pilkington (2) Parker (2) Morgan (2) Bouchard |
[31] |
Pennsylvania district
| Hibernian | w/o | Disston |
|---|---|---|
| [32] |
| J. & J. Dobson | 1–1 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| 85' Bergen | [33] | Brittan |
replay
| Bethlehem Steel | 6–0 | J. & J. Dobson |
|---|---|---|
| [34] |
Third round
The third round matches were due to be played on or before December 5.[35] Columbia Graphophone was awarded their game against Waverley by the referee due to player misconduct. The Robins vs. New York match was protested and ordered replayed.
New Jersey and New York District
| Federal Ship | 2–4 | Erie |
|---|---|---|
| 20' W. Jamieson 70' Fielder |
[36] | 30' Knowles 65' Heminsley 80' Ford Knowles |
| New York | 0–1 | Robins Dry Dock |
|---|---|---|
| [37] | 82' Irvine |
| Babcock & Wilcox | – | Brooklyn |
|---|---|---|
| [38] |
replay
| New York | 1–3 | Robins Dry Dock |
|---|---|---|
| 20' Sam McDonald | [39] | 10' Page 30' Ratican 40' Hosie |
Southern New England district
| Fairlawn Rovers | 0–1 | J. & P. Coats |
|---|---|---|
| [40] | 44' Lonie (pk) |
| Columbia Graphophone | w/o | Waverley |
|---|---|---|
| [41] |
| Fall River Rovers | 7–1 | Ansonia |
|---|---|---|
| Connie Lynch (2) Parker (3) Pilkington (2) |
[42] | 80' Beaton |
Northern Massachusetts district
| Fore River | 6–0 | General Electric |
|---|---|---|
| 8' David Page 13', 2H' Fred Churchley Law (2) Shepard |
[43] |
Pennsylvania district
| Hibernian | 0–3 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| [44] | 47' Wilson Forrest (2) |
Fourth round
The fourth round matches were due to be played on or before December 26.[45]
| Bethlehem Steel | 0–1 | Robins Dry Dock |
|---|---|---|
| [46] | 44' Sturch |
| J. & P. Coats | 0–1 | Fore River |
|---|---|---|
| [47] | 5' Shepherd |
| Erie | 4–0 | Babcock & Wilcox |
|---|---|---|
| Koelsch 25' Heminsley 75' Archie Stark 85' Davy Brown |
[48] |
| Fall River Rovers | 4–0 | Columbia Graphophone |
|---|---|---|
| Morgan Adams Parker (pk) Connie Lynch |
[49] |
Semifinals
| Fall River Rovers | 1–2 | Fore River |
|---|---|---|
| 71' Parker (pk) | [50] | 1H' Jimmy Farquhar 76' Shepard |
| Erie | 1–1 | Robins Dry Dock |
|---|---|---|
| 8' Koelsch | [51] | 10' Sweeney |

replays
| Erie | 1–1 | Robins Dry Dock |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Dave Brown (pk) | [52] | Hosie |

| Erie | 4–4 | Robins Dry Dock |
|---|---|---|
| 1' Heminsley Ford 51' Brown (pk) OT' Sturch |
[53] | 25' Harry Ratican Harry Ratican (pk) 87' McGuire OT' Spalding (pk) |
| Erie | 1–4 | Robins Dry Dock |
|---|---|---|
| Archie Stark | [54] | 24' Sweeney 48', 57', 67' McKelvey |
Final

The American Cup final took place at Harrison Field in Harrison, NJ on May 8. Fore River and Robins had met previously in the quarterfinals of the National Challenge Cup with Robins prevailing 3–0 and continuing on to win the Dewar trophy. On this occasion Robins Dry Dock would again win over Fore River 5–2 to earn a double. Robins were third in the National League while Fore River won first place honors in the Southern New England League.
| May 8, 1921 | Robins Dry Dock | 5–2 | Fore River | Harrisom, NJ |
| 3:00PM | 11', 50', Ratican 1H', 52' Sweeney 35' Hosie |
[55][56] | 10' Page Black (pk) |
Stadium: Harrison Field Attendance: 5100 Referee: George Young (Philadelphia) |
| Note: Other source shows Corrigan scored second Fore River goal[57] | ||||

See also
References
- ↑ "MacMillan Chosen Head Of Football Association". (September 19, 1920). The Sunday Call, p.16 col.1
- ↑ "Forty–Four Soccer Teams Enter American Cup Race". (October 3, 1920). The Sunday Call, p.17 col.2
- ↑ "Paterson Land Cup–Tie Game". (October 25, 1920). The Morning Call, p.3 col.1
- ↑ "Penalty Decides For Babs". (October 25, 1920). Paterson Evening News, p.16 col.1
- ↑ "Athenia Steel Wins Great Game From The Sprague Eleven". (October 25, 1920). Passaic Daily News, p.4 col.7
- ↑ "Shipyards Soccer Eleven Wins". (October 25, 1920). New York Times, p.20 col.5
- ↑ "Greenpoint Soccerites Defeat Vikings". (October 25, 1920). Evening Post, p.10 col.8
- ↑ "Danersks Defeat The Stamford Soccer Club". (October 25, 1920). Daily Advocate, p.8 col.2
- ↑ "Our Champs Badly Beaten". (October 25, 1920). Norwalk Hour, p.7 col.5
- ↑ "Fore River Has Best Of Hendee At League Park". (October 24, 1920). Springfield Union, p.14 col.3
- ↑ "Rovers Will Go In For American Cup". (October 25, 1920). Fall River Evening News, p.3 col.1–2
- ↑ "Three New Men Add Strength To Coats' Lineup". (October 25, 1920). Pawtucket Times, p.14 col.3
- ↑ "Saylesville 2, Ashton–Berkeley 2". (October 24, 1920). Providence Sunday Journal, sec.2 p.2 col.5
- ↑ "Fairlawn 3, Crompton 1". (November 1, 1920). Pawtucket Times, p.14 col.5
- ↑ "Football Game". (November 8, 1920). Pawtucket Times, p.9 col.1–2
- ↑ "Big Cup Tie Tomorrow". (November 1, 1920). Evening Post, p.15 col.4
- ↑ "Patersons Lose Cup–Tie To Eries". (November 15, 1920). The Morning Call, p.3 col.5–6
- ↑ "Soccer Results In Yesterday's Contests". (November 15, 1920). Bridgeport Times, p.4 col.1
- ↑ "Federal Shipyard Soccer Victory". (November 15, 1920). Jersey Journal, p.7 col.4
- ↑ "Wins From Clan MacDuff". (November 15, 1920). New York Times, p.19 col.2
- ↑ "Robins Soccers Eliminate Tebo From A.F.A. Cup Race". (November 15, 1920). Brooklyn Standard Union, p.10 col.4
- ↑ "B'klyn Ties Greenpoint". (November 15, 1920). New York American, p.15 col.6
- ↑ "Brooklyn Sockers Victors In Re–play". (November 22, 1920). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.2* col.5
- ↑ "Ansonia Soccer Team Wins". (November 15, 1920). Evening Sentinel, p.5 col.4
- ↑ "Danersks Lose At Soccer". (November 15, 1920). Daily Advocate, p.10 col.1
- ↑ "Soccer Notes". (November 7, 1920). Hartford Daily Courant, p.6Z col.3
- ↑ "Electrics Trim Farr Alpacas". (November 15, 1920). Daily Evening Item, p.9 col.3
- ↑ "Chicopee Was Soft For The Fore Rivers". (November 16, 1920). Quincy Patriot, p.6 col.5
- ↑ "Federals Eliminate West New York Blues". (November 10, 1920). Newark Evening News, p.7 col.2
- ↑ "Threadmen Win Over Bleachers In American". (November 15, 1920). Pawtucket Times, p.18 col.4
- ↑ "Clan Cameron No Match For Rovers". (November 22, 1920). Evening Herald, p.9 col.5–6
- ↑ "Disston Forfeits Cup Match To Hibernians". (November 28, 1920). Philadelphia Record, p.4 col.3
- ↑ "Bethlehem Held To Tie Score". (November 5, 1920). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.20 col.7
- ↑ "Dobsons No Match For Bethlehem Stars". (December 12, 1920). Philadelphia Record, p.4 col.1
- ↑ "Kearny Soccer Rivals Paired In Cup Battles". (November 20, 1920). Newark Evening News, p.17 col.4
- ↑ "Eries Again Eliminate Feds in Cup Tie Game". (December 6, 1920). Newark Evening News, p.16 col.2
- ↑ "Robins Sockers Qualify By Defeat Of New York". (December 6, 1920). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.*3 col.5
- ↑ "A.F.A. Cup Ties". (December 5, 1920). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.S3 col.5
- ↑ "Robins Soccers Win". (December 13, 1920). New York Times, p.21 col.4
- ↑ "Threadmen Lucky To Beat Fairlawn". (December 6, 1920). Pawtucket Times, p.18 col.3
- ↑ "Soccer Notes". (December 12, 1920). Hartford Daily Courant, p.9 col.1–2
- ↑ "Rovers Trounce Ansonia Team". (December 13, 1920). Evening Herald, p.8 col.7–8
- ↑ "Go To Fourth Round For The American Cup". (December 13, 1920). Quincy Patriot, p.6 col.6
- ↑ "Bethlehem Trips Hibernians". (December 19, 1920). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.21 col.2
- ↑ "Eries Will Boot Bayonne Eleven". (December 12, 1920). The Sunday Call, p.18 col.6
- ↑ Nonnemacher, Fred (January 3, 1921). "Robins Prove A Better Eleven". The Globe–Times
- ↑ "Threadmen Beaten By Fore River Eleven". (January 3, 1921). Pawtucket Times, p.14 col.3–4
- ↑ "Eries To Meet Robins In American Cup Game". (January 3, 1920). Newark Evening News, p.19 col.1
- ↑ "Rovers Best Bridgeport". (January 10, 1921). Fall River Globe, p.9 col.1–2
- ↑ Walsh, Ed (March 21, 1921). "Rovers Beaten By Fore River". Evening Herald, p.8 col.1–2
- ↑ "Eries And Robins Stage 1–1 Draw In Semi–Final". (March 14, 1921). Newark Evening News, p.14 col.6–7
- ↑ "Erie–Robins Tie In Cup Semi–Final". (March 21, 1921). Newark Evening News, p.14 col.1
- ↑ "Robins And Erie Soccermen Play Another Tie Game". (April 3, 1921). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.21 col.2
- ↑ "Robins Dry Dock Easily Beats Erie". (April 10, 1921). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.21 col.3
- ↑ "Robins Defeat Rovers In American Cup Final". (May 9, 1921). Newark Evening News, p.20 col.4
- ↑ "Fore River Loses American Cup Game". (May 9, 1921). Quincy Patriot, p.4 col.1–2
- ↑ "Second Socker Cup For Robins Team". (May 9, 1921). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p. *3 col. 1
