1922–23 American Cup
![]() | |
| Tournament details | |
|---|---|
| Country | United States |
| Dates | October 1922 – May 1923 |
| Teams | 37 |
| Final positions | |
| Champions | Fleisher Yarn (1st title) |
| Runners-up | J. & P. Coats |
The 1922–23 American Cup was the thirty–first edition of the annual challenge cup held by the American Football Association. The Secretary of the AFA, Andrew Beveridge received entries up to October 7, 1922. This season the American Cup was won by Fleisher Yarn, an amateur team from Philadelphia. En route to the championship they overcame American Soccer League heavyweights like Bethlehem Steel, J. & P. Coats and National Cup winners, Paterson F.C.
Preliminary round
The draw for the preliminary and first round took place on October 7, 1922 at the cup committee meeting in Newark, NJ. Games were due to be played by October 29.
Southern New England
| Prospect Hill | 2–3 | J. & P. Coats #1 |
|---|---|---|
| White 75' Slater |
[1] | 20', 85' Gallagher Shepherd |
Western Massachusetts and Northern Connecticut
| Holyoke | 6–2 | Manchester |
|---|---|---|
| James Brown (3) John Brown Horne Walter Dowdall |
[2] | Wilson (2) |
Connecticut and New Jersey
| Ryerson | – | Babcock & Wilcox |
|---|---|---|
| Paterson | 7–0 | Entre Nous |
|---|---|---|
| 7', 47' Hemingsley Fryer 35' Duggan 57', 2H' McKenna 72' Scott |
[3] |
Pennsylvania District
| Hibernian | 0–2 | Fairhill |
|---|---|---|
| [4] | 6' Fleming Smith (pk) |
First round
The first-round games were due to be played by November 12.
Southern New England
| Canadian | 1–5 | Fairlawn Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| Scott (2) Travis Smith (2) |
[5] | Barrett |
| J. & P. Coats #2 | 0–3 | Sayles Finishing |
|---|---|---|
| [6] | Dixon 55' Wilson 75' Pilkington |
| Greystone Blues | 1–6 | J. & P. Coats #1 |
|---|---|---|
| Gregson (pk) | [7] | 12' Gallagher Nelson Shephard Lappin (3) |
| West End Polish | 3–0 | Greystone Vets |
|---|---|---|
| 25' Campanelli Lukouic Barone |
[8] |
Northern Massachusetts
| Methuen | 6–0 | South Boston Rangers |
|---|---|---|
| [9] |
| Clan Sutherland | 1–0 | Charlestown |
|---|---|---|
| Allan Wilson | [10] |
| Fore River | 4–1 | American Woolen |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Lyons 30' Oakley 1H', 2H' Page |
[11] | Jones |
| General Electric United | 0–3 | Abbot Worsted |
|---|---|---|
| [12] | Lee (2) Brown |
Western Massachusetts and Northern Connecticut
| Ludlow Thistle | 2–4 | Falco |
|---|---|---|
| Milne Martin |
[13] | 30' Ford Downie Jenkins (pk) Logan (pk) |
| Chicopee Rovers | 0–4 | Holyoke |
|---|---|---|
| [14] | 28', 30', 65' John Brown Dowdall |
Connecticut and New Jersey
| Paterson | 5–1 | Bayonne Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| 15' Rudy Hunziker 40', 70' Murray 55' Tommy Duggan (pk) Scott |
[15] | Cosgrove |
| Babcock & Wilcox | 2–4 | American A.A. |
|---|---|---|
| Forrester Harding |
[16] | 5' Florie 2 Durkin 2 |
| St. George | 1–2 | Paterson Caledonian |
|---|---|---|
| Kilroy | [17] | Walter Freebairn (2) |
| Harrison | 3–0 | Antler |
|---|---|---|
| 15' Rhody McCartin (2) |
[18] |
Pennsylvania
| Fleisher Yarn | 3–2 | Bethlehem Steel |
|---|---|---|
| 25' McLaughlin (pk) 70' Purvis 95' McLaughlin |
[19] | 70' Goldie 75' Terris |
| Fairhill | 1–1 | Barney Ernst |
|---|---|---|
| Smith | [20] | D. Robinson |
replay
| Fairhill | 1–0 | Barney Ernst |
|---|---|---|
| 3' Hunt (pk) | [21] |
Second round
The second-round games were due to be played by December 3. The Harrison/Paterson match was delayed multiple times for weather/field conditions ultimately both teams had few open dates remaining with many ASL fixtures remaining.
Southern New England
| J. & P. Coats | 6–0 | West End Polish |
|---|---|---|
| Fleming (pk) Brooks Morley Gilmore Neilson |
[22] |
| Sayles Finishing | 4–3 | Fairlawn Rovers |
|---|---|---|
| Pilkington (3) OT' Dixon |
[23] | 1H', 78' E. Smith Tickle |
Northern Massachusetts
| Fore River | 2–1 | Methuen |
|---|---|---|
| 5' Dave Christie Oakley |
[24] | Morley |
| Abbot Worsted | 3–1 | Clan Sutherland |
|---|---|---|
| 10', 12', ?' Corrigan | [25] | Sammy Ritchie |
Western Massachusetts and Northern Connecticut
| Falco | 0–1 | Holyoke |
|---|---|---|
| [26] | 70' Horne |
Connecticut and New Jersey
| Harrison | – | Paterson |
|---|---|---|
| Paterson Caledonian | 0–5 | American A.A. |
|---|---|---|
| [27] | 20' Florie 21', 24' J. Strong 1H', 75' Coe |
Pennsylvania District
| Fairhill | 0–1 | Fleisher Yarn |
|---|---|---|
| [28] | Andy Stradan |
Third round
The third-round games were due to be played by April 8. The Sayles–Coats game was ordered replayed because of an ineligible player. Sayles refused to replay the game. The Pateson/Holyoke match was not played due to late season fixture congestion. Holyoke was withdrawn and offered a share in the gate of the cup final.
| Paterson | w/o | Holyoke |
|---|---|---|
| [29] |
| Sayles Finishing | 2–1 | J. & P. Coats |
|---|---|---|
| 37' Pilkington Red Britton |
[30] | 17' Tommy Fleming (pk) |
| Fore River | 3–2 | Abbot Worsted |
|---|---|---|
| Joe Black (pk) 2H', OT' Drummond |
[31] | 11' Corrigan Parker |
| Fleischer Yarn | 3–1 | American A.A. |
|---|---|---|
| [32] |
replay
| J. & P. Coats | w/o | Sayles Finishing |
|---|---|---|
| [33] |
Semifinals
| April 29, 1923 | Paterson | 1–3 | Fleisher Yarn | Paterson, NJ |
| 70' Joe Reynolds (pk) | [34] | 30' Purvis 77', 87' Stradan |
Stadium: Olympic Park Attendance: 1500 Referee: Robert McMahon (Newark) | |
| Note: Other source shows score 28', 85' Andy Stradden, 80' Olec McLaughlin[35] | ||||
| J. & P. Coats | 4–0 | Fore River |
|---|---|---|
| 29' Gallagher Fleming 47' McAvoy Bethune |
[36] |
Final

The final took place May 6, 1923 at Mark's Stadium in North Tiverton, RI. Fleisher Yarn of Philadelphia defeated J.& P. Coats of Pawtucket. The Coats aggregation along with making the AFA final were the American Soccer League champions and National Challenge Cup semifinalists. Fleisher Yarn had thirty–four victories on the season winning the Allied First Division of Philadelphia. They only suffered three exhibition losses with their only competitive loss to Bethlehem Steel in the second round of the National Cup. Along with the American Cup win, they went on undefeated runs in the Allied Amateur and National Amateur Cups, though neither tournament was completed, they reached the final and quarterfinals respectively.
| Fleisher Yarn | 2–0 | J&P Coats |
|---|---|---|
| 30' Stradden 70' Stradden |
[37][38] |
Champions

Front row: J. Malley, Purvis, Andy Staden, B. McLaughlin, J. Galloway.
Second row: Coleman, White (Captain), Duffy.
Standing: R. Rodgers, William Kucklick, William Fleming.
See also
References
- ↑ "Coats Team Has To Go To Beat Prospect Hill". (November 6, 1922). Pawtucket Times, p. 20 col. 1
- ↑ "Holyoke Wins Cup Tie Match". (October 30, 1922). Holyoke Daily Transcript, p. 7 col. 6
- ↑ "Patersons Win Easy Victory". (October 16, 1922). The Morning Call, p. 3 col. 3
- ↑ "Fairhill Too Strong For The Hibernians". (October 29, 1922). Philadelphia Record, p. 5 col. 6
- ↑ "Canadians Eliminated From American Cup Play". (November 13, 1922). Pawtucket Times, p. 20 col. 3
- ↑ "Sayles Enters Third Round Of American Cup". (November 13, 1922). Pawtucket Times, p. 20 col. 1–2
- ↑ "Threadmen Swamp Greystone". (November 12, 1922). Providence Sunday Journal, p. 4 col. 4–5
- ↑ "North Providence". (December 1, 1922). Pawtucket Times, p. 6 col. 6–7
- ↑ "Easy For Methuen". (November 12, 1922). Sunday Herald, p. 6 col. 6
- ↑ "Sutherland Ahead". (November 12, 1922). Sunday Herald, p. 6 col. 6
- ↑ "Fore River An Easy Winner". (November 13, 1922). Quincy Patriot, p. 6 col. 6
- ↑ "Abbots Wallop G.E. Kickers In Cup Contest". (November 20, 1922). Daily Evening Item, p. 4 col. 7
- ↑ "Ludlow Protests Cup Tie Victory Of Falco Eleven". (November 12, 1922). Springfield Union, p. 15 col. 3
- ↑ "Holyoke Soccer Club Wins Over Chicopee Rivals". (November 26, 1922). Springfield Union, p. 13 col. 6
- ↑ "Paterson F.C. Defeats The Bayonne Rovers". (November 8, 1922). The Morning Call, p. 16 col. 4–5
- ↑ "Americans Humble Babcock & Wilcox's In Close Game". (November 13, 1922). Bayonne Evening News, p. 7 col. 6
- ↑ "St. Georges Out Of A.F.A. Tourney". (November 20, 1922). Bridgeport Telegram, p. 6 col. 4
- ↑ "Harrison Club Squashes Antlers In Soccer Game". (November 27, 1922). Newark Evening News, p. 9* col. 2
- ↑ "Fleisher Yarners Jolt Bethlehem". (November 12, 1922). Philadelphia Inquirer, p. 23 col. 7
- ↑ "Fairhill And Ernst Play To An Even Break". (November, 1922). Philadelphia Record, p. 5 col. 6
- ↑ Wilcox, Levi (December 3, 1922). "Penalty Kick Wins Fairhill Cup Game". Philadelphia Inquirer, p. 19 col. 6
- ↑ "Ansonia And West Ends Teams Are Eliminated". (December 26, 1922). Pawtucket Times, p. 20 col. 1–2
- ↑ "Sayles Hangs 4–3 Defeat On Fairlawn". (April 2, 1923). Providence Journal, p. 6 col. 6–7
- ↑ "Fore River Wins Its Game With Methuen". (December 18, 1922). Quincy Patriot, p. 6 col. 4
- ↑ "Abbot Worsted Soccer Team Wins". (April 9, 1923). Lowell Sun, p. 10 col. 1
- ↑ "Holyoke Soccer Team Eliminate Falcos". (December 4, 1922). Holyoke Daily Transcript, p. 10 col. 2
- ↑ "American A.A. Downs Caleys". (April 16, 1923). The Morning Call, p. 16 col. 8
- ↑ "Fleisher vs. Fairhill". (December 10, 1922). Philadelphia Record, p. 12 col. 2
- ↑ "Holyoke Club Notes". (April 23, 1923). Holyoke Daily Transcript, p. 8 col. 4
- ↑ "Sayles Upsets Dope, Beats Threadmen". (April 16, 1923). Providence Journal, p. 6 col. 6–7
- ↑ "Abbott Give 3 To 2 Dfeat By Fore River". (April 20, 1923). Quincy Patriot, p. 5 col. 5
- ↑ "Fleisher Soccer Team Will Oppose Paterson". (April 22, 1923). Philadelphia Record, p. 4 col. 6
- ↑ "Sayles Refuses To Replay Cup–Tie Game With Coats". (April 23, 1923). Pawtucket Times, p. 20 col. 4–5
- ↑ "Paterson Loses, 3–1; Buslik Will Protest". (April 30, 1923). The Morning Call, p. 16 col. 4–5
- ↑ "Fleisher Dribbles Too Much For National Champs". (April 30, 1923). Philadelphia Inquirer, p. 12 col. 4–5
- ↑ "J. & P. Coats Whip Fore River". (April 30, 1923). Providence Journal, p. 7 col. 1
- ↑ "Fleisher Yarn Captures Trophy In 2–0 Game". (May 7, 1923). Pawtucket Times, p. 23 col. 1–2
- ↑ "Fleisher Soccermen Win American Cup". (May 7, 1923). Philadelphia Inquirer, p. 18 col. 7–8
