Tsao Hsing-cheng–Shen Chun-shan Go match donation controversy

The Shen Chun-shan one-game fundraising incident occurred in October 1995, when Shen Chun-shan, then president of National Tsing Hua University, requested a donation from Tsao Hsing-cheng, also known as Robert Tsao ,chairman of United Microelectronics Corporation, for the university. The two men agreed to settle the matter through a game of Go, after which Tsao decided to donate NT$15 million to National Tsing Hua University. Witnessed by journalist Chang Tso-chin and others, the donation agreement was formally signed in May 1996. The event was subsequently reported by United Daily News and became widely regarded as a celebrated anecdote during Shen's later years and after his death.

In 2025, during the 2025 Taiwanese mass electoral recall campaign, Tsao Hsing-cheng became the lead petitioner. Kuomintang legislator Weng Hsiao-ling then alleged in a Facebook post that Tsao had failed to fulfill his promised donation to National Tsing Hua University. The university stated to reporters that it had no record of receiving the donation, bringing the matter back into the news. Tsao, however, maintained that he had already delivered the donation to Shen Chun-shan.[1][2]

Background

Go match and donation

In October 1995, in order to raise funds for National Tsing Hua University, Shen Chun-shan, then president of the university, solicited a donation from Robert Tsao , chairman of United Microelectronics Corporation, during a banquet organized by the Friends of Tsing Hua Association. Tsao, believing that he had no reason to donate because he was an alumnus of National Chiao Tung University, proposed a Go challenge to Shen as a justification for making a donation. Tsao suggested that the amount of the donation be determined by the result of the game, with NT$10,000 donated for each point lost. Since Shen was the stronger player, the game began with a three-stone handicap. Tsao resigned midway through the game, and Shen won by resignation. The final margin was fifty points. Shen initially thought that the wager was NT$10,000 per point, but Tsao eventually decided to donate US$10,000 per point. Using an exchange rate of NT$30 to US$1, Tsao announced that he would donate NT$15 million to National Tsing Hua University.[3][4]

On 5 May 1996, Shen Chun-shan invited Academia Sinica president Lee Yuan-tseh, United Daily News editor-in-chief Chang Tso-chin, and others to attend the university anniversary banquet organized by the Friends of Tsing Hua Association as witnesses. According to Chang's recollections, Tsao Hsing-cheng and Shen Chun-shan, representing UMC and National Tsing Hua University respectively, signed an agreement under the pretext of a cooperative project, thereby completing the donation arrangement. The incident was reported by United Daily News on 6 May.[5] United Daily News published another report on 10 May, stating that after the 6 May article appeared, someone reported Shen Chun-shan to the Hsinchu District Prosecutors Office on suspicion of gambling. After questioning Shen, prosecutors decided not to indict him. The incident was later recounted in a memoir article published by Chang Tso-chin on Sin Chew Daily's website on 20 May 2011,[6] and was also included in his memoir Gu Nian Gai Sheng: Memoirs of Journalist Chang Tso-chin.[7] Volume I of Shen Chun-shan Talks About Stories of Go Masters records Shen's recollection of receiving Tsao's donation during an interview with children in 2003.[8]

During the "Infinite Wishes – Masters Dialogue Cultural Collection" event on 3 June 2011, then university president Chen Li-junstated in his speech that National Tsing Hua University had already received Tsao Hsing-cheng's NT$15 million donation.[9][10] Hsu Ming-te, a Tsing Hua alumnus and former director of the university's Office of Financial Planning, also mentioned Tsao's NT$15 million donation in an article published in the National Tsing Hua University Alumni Newsletter in 2014.[11][12]

Following Shen Chun-shan's death in 2018, the memorial collection produced by National Tsing Hua University,[13] as well as contemporary news reports, cited the incident.[3][4] The story was also included in Chronology of Shen Chun-shan, edited by Commonwealth Publishing Group.[14] In 2019, the National Tsing Hua University Library published a photograph of the two men playing Go in 1995, citing the memorial collection.[15]

Use of the donation

Professor Yen Huang-che of the Department of Physics at National Tsing Hua University died of stomach cancer in 1995, and his family donated NT$5 million to the department. According to a report published by United Daily News on 6 May 1996, President Shen Chun-shan allocated part of Tsao Hsing-cheng's donation as matching funds to establish the Yen Huang-che Memorial Lecture, modeled after the Christmas Lectures of the Royal Society in the United Kingdom. The lectures were intended to invite distinguished professionals to give popular science lectures to secondary school students and the general public, with four lectures planned annually. On 5 May 1996, the inaugural Yen Huang-che Popular Science Lecture was held, with Academia Sinica president Lee Yuan-tseh delivering the first lecture, entitled "Lasers and Chemistry". Yang Chen-ning and Shiing-Shen Chern were later expected to give lectures as well.[5][16]

In the 1996 Memorial Collection for Professor Yen Huang-che, Shen Chun-shan mentioned the establishment of the Yen Huang-che Memorial Lecture in terms consistent with the report in United Daily News. He explained that the lecture expenses were initially paid out of discretionary funds already raised by the university president and that a separate endowment would later be established.[17] In response to the United Daily News report of 6 May 1996, National Tsing Hua University stated on 25 February 2025 that only the funds donated by Yen's family had been used to finance the lectures and denied that Tsao Hsing-cheng's donation had ever been used for the Yen Huang-che Memorial Lecture.[18]

Subsequent controversy

On 24 February 2025, Kuomintang legislator Weng Hsiao-ling accused Tsao Hsing-cheng of failing to fulfill his promised NT$15 million donation, alleging that the payment had been outstanding for thirty years.[19] National Tsing Hua University confirmed on the same day that it had not received the money. Tsao responded by stating that he had delivered the donation to Shen Chun-shan in the form of a check and had not concerned himself with how it was used.[2] Weng argued that Tsao's statement implied that Shen had embezzled the donation and demanded that the university condemn Tsao.[20]

According to the university's Digital History Museum website, then president Chen Li-junstated on 3 June 2011, during the "Infinite Wishes – Masters Dialogue Cultural Collection" event, that National Tsing Hua University had received Tsao Hsing-cheng's NT$15 million donation.[9][10] In response, the university reiterated on 25 February that it had in fact never received the donation.[21]University officials privately told reporters from the Central News Agency that the story had long been regarded within educational circles as a celebrated anecdote and that no detailed records of the donation had ever been found.[22] Chen Li-jun later told China Times that he had thanked Tsao in his speech because Tsao had privately told him that he had made the donation. He admitted that he had not verified the matter and that his remarks should not be regarded as proof. Chen further stated that the university had already determined several years earlier, when inviting Tsao to give a lecture, that no donation had been made, and that this was not a new discovery resulting from the controversy[23]

National Tsing Hua University stated that it had repeatedly, both directly and indirectly, requested donations from Tsao Hsing-cheng but had never received any payment. The university maintained that it had no record of receiving the donation and no record of any check. University officials agreed to speak to reporters only anonymously, and no one was willing to publicly verify the matter. The university further stated that it would make no additional comments.[24]

On 28 February 2025, National Tsing Hua University president Kao Wei-yuan issued an internal letter stating that, in order to protect donors' privacy, the university would not proactively disclose donation-related information unless requested by the donor concerned.[25]

Donation method

In response to National Tsing Hua University's allegation that Tsao Hsing-cheng had failed to fulfill his promised donation, Tsao initially stated that the donation had been delivered directly to President Shen Chun-shan by check in the year the pledge was made.[2]

According to technology journalist Lin Hung-wen, former United Microelectronics Corporation general manager Wu Hung-jen explained in 2025 that the donation had actually been made by UMC itself. The payment was made under the name of a cooperative project between the two parties and was not donated entirely under Tsao Hsing-cheng's personal name. He stated that National Tsing Hua University had only checked records of donations made in Tsao's personal capacity, which led the university to conclude that no payment had been received.[26][27]

Reporters from Business Today interviewed staff members who had handled the matter at National Tsing Hua University at the time. According to them, the donation had been made through the UMC Education and Culture Foundation over a five-year period, with NT$15 million each being donated to National Tsing Hua University and National Chiao Tung University.[26]

In a personal statement, Tsao Hsing-cheng stated that the donation had been made in UMC's name and that he had never promised to make it in his own name. Following this donation, UMC hired two former presidents of National Tsing Hua University as independent directors. When the university built the College of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science Building (now the Liu Chung-laung Hall), UMC donated NT$150 million. UMC also donated NT$100 million toward the construction of Chun-Shan Hall. Tsao questioned whether National Tsing Hua University, by cooperating with Weng Hsiao-ling in making accusations against him, had been infiltrated by the Chinese Communist Party.[28]

References

  1. ↑ "曹興誠未捐清大1500萬假捐款慣犯 翁曉玲再轟他:企圖顛覆政局" [Tsao Hsing-cheng failed to donate the NT$15 million to National Tsing Hua University—a habitual offender of making empty donation pledges; Weng Hsiao-ling slams him again, accusing him of attempting to subvert the political landscape.]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-24. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  2. 1 2 3 三立新聞網 (2025-02-24). "清大證實未收到1500萬 曹興誠最新回應了:支票是直接交給沈君山" [Tsinghua University confirms it did not receive the NT$15 million; Robert Tsao issues latest response: The check was handed directly to Shen Chun-shan.]. www.setn.com (in Chinese). Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  3. 1 2 "「四大公子」沈君山與曹興誠對弈 一盤棋為清大募1500萬" ["Four Great Young Masters" member Shen Junshan plays a match against Cao Xingcheng; a single game raises 15 million for Tsinghua University.]. 遠見雜誌 - 前進的動力 (in Chinese). 2018-09-12. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  4. 1 2 "沈君山科學文人 高超棋藝曾為清大募款千萬" [Shen Chun-shan: Scientist and Scholar—His Superb Go Skills Once Raised Millions for Tsinghua University]. 中央社 CNA (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2025-05-27. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  5. 1 2 "曹興誠1500萬捐了沒?「聯合報」1996年舊聞解答:前校長沈君山提用部分辦理「通俗科學講座」" [Did Robert Tsao donate the 15 million? A 1996 *United Daily News* report provides the answer: Former President Shen Chun-shan utilized a portion of the funds to organize a "popular science lecture series."]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-25. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  6. ↑ 自由時報電子報 (2025-02-25). "矢板明夫觀點》30年前曹興誠輸棋捐款1500萬給清大 有文為證" [Yaita Akio’s Perspective: Documentary Evidence Confirms Robert Tsao Donated 15 Million to Tsinghua University 30 Years Ago After Losing a Go Match]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2025-05-27. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  7. ↑ 自由時報電子報 (2025-02-25). "轟翁曉玲胡說八道 楊斯棓:4名人+1媒體可證明曹興誠捐清大1500萬" [Slamming Weng Hsiao-ling's remarks as nonsense, Yang Ssu-pang stated that four prominent figures and one media outlet can verify Robert Tsao's NT$15 million donation to National Tsing Hua University.]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2025-12-07. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  8. ↑ "沈君山曾親口承認「收到曹興誠捐款」!他曝重要證據:這鬧劇該結束了" [Shen Jun-shan personally admitted to receiving a donation from Robert Tsao! He revealed key evidence, stating, "This farce needs to end."]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-03-02. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  9. 1 2 聯合新聞網 (2025-02-25). "曹興誠捐清大1500萬疑雲 前校長14年前稱:確實收訖無誤" [Questions Surround Cao Hsing-cheng’s NT$15 Million Donation to NTHU; Former President Confirmed Receipt 14 Years Ago]. 聯合新聞網 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2025-05-27. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  10. 1 2 陈力俊〈我愿无穷-大师对谈文化搜藏致欢迎词〉:“曹董在清华最脍炙人口的一件事,应是 1996 年与沈君山前校长围棋大赛。是役曹军大败,为清华大学赢得一千五百万捐款。关于这盘棋另有一说:‘曹董知道清华需要这笔经费,所以多输了几子。’不论如何,清华都很感谢。刚才曹董告诉我说竟然有人曾声称他未兑现诺言,我在此也顺便正式代为澄清,清华大学确实收讫捐款无误,以了此公案。”Chen Li-chun (Delivering the welcome address at the "Boundless Aspirations: A Dialogue with Masters on Cultural Collecting" event): "Perhaps the most talked-about anecdote regarding Chairman Tsao at Tsinghua is his 1996 Go match against former President Shen Chun-shan. Although Chairman Tsao suffered a crushing defeat in that game, the match secured a donation of NT$15 million for the university. There is, however, another version of the story: that Chairman Tsao knew Tsinghua needed the funds and intentionally lost by a wider margin. Regardless of the details, Tsinghua remains deeply grateful. Chairman Tsao just mentioned to me that some have actually claimed he failed to honor his pledge; I would like to take this opportunity to officially clarify that Tsinghua University did indeed receive the donation in full, thereby putting this matter to rest."
  11. ↑ "翁曉玲控曹興誠食言捐清大1500萬 楊斯棓秀證據打臉:早有4名人1媒體證明已收到" [Weng Hsiao-ling accused Robert Tsao of reneging on a pledge to donate NT$15 million to National Tsing Hua University; Yang Ssu-pu refuted the claim with evidence, showing that four individuals and one media outlet had already confirmed receipt of the funds.]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2025-03-30. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  12. ↑ 自由時報電子報 (2025-02-26). "自由廣場》翁曉玲沒資格站上清大講壇" [Liberty Square | Weng Hsiao-ling Is Unfit to Stand at the Podium of National Tsing Hua University]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2025-03-30. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  13. ↑ "清大數位校史館:沈君山校長相關報導" [NTHU Digital History Museum: Reports Related to President Shen Chun-shan]. archives.lib.nthu.edu.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2008-08-17. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  14. ↑ 沈君山. "【懷念沈君山】" [[In Memory of Shen Chun-shan]]. 天下文化 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  15. ↑ "曹興誠「下棋捐1500萬」照片曝光 清大圖書館貼文被灌爆:明目張膽說謊" [Photo of Robert Tsao "donating NT$15 million while playing chess" surfaces; Tsinghua University Library post flooded with comments: "Blatant lying."]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-25. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  16. ↑ "曹興誠有捐1500萬! 聯合報舊聞揭"沈君山提用部分辦講座"" [Robert Tsao did donate NT$15 million! A past *United Daily News* report reveals that Shen Chun-shan utilized a portion of the funds to organize lectures.]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-25. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  17. ↑ 沈君山〈清不绝俗,贞不忤物—怀念颜晃彻教授〉:“因此我们筹设了颜晃彻纪念讲座(以后还准备设一晃彻杯足球比赛),每年举办四次高水准的通俗演讲......。取法乎上,以过去英国皇家学会的圣诞演讲为效法的对象。讲座经费现在暂由已捐得的校长自由支配款支付,以后将单独募集资金。”Shen Chun-shan, "Pure Yet Not Aloof from the World, Upright Yet Not at Odds with Others—In Memory of Professor Yen Huang-che": "We have therefore established the Yen Huang-che Memorial Lecture Series (with plans to also launch a 'Huang-che Cup' soccer tournament in the future), featuring four high-caliber public lectures each year. We are setting our sights high, modeling the series after the Royal Institution's Christmas Lectures in the UK. Funding for the lectures is currently covered by the President's discretionary fund from existing donations, though we intend to raise separate funds for the initiative moving forward."
  18. ↑ "30年前報導曝!「提1500萬部分辦講座」清大:使用教授遺產,無其他來源" [Report from 30 Years Ago Surfaces! "$15 Million Withdrawn to Fund Seminars"—Tsinghua University: Professor's Bequest Used; No Other Funding Sources Involved.]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-25. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  19. ↑ "曹興誠未捐清大1500萬假捐款慣犯 翁曉玲再轟他:企圖顛覆政局" [Tsao Hsing-cheng failed to donate the NT$15 million pledged to National Tsing Hua University; serial "fake donor" slammed again by Weng Hsiao-ling for attempting to destabilize the political landscape.]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-24. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  20. ↑ "清大沒收到1500萬捐款 曹興誠稱有給沈君山支票 翁曉玲一看氣炸" [Tsinghua University did not receive the 15-million-yuan donation; Robert Tsao claimed he had given a check to Shen Chun-shan—a revelation that infuriated Weng Hsiao-ling.]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-24. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  21. ↑ 聯合新聞網 (2025-02-25). "曹興誠捐款疑雲前校長曾稱收訖無誤 清大:確實沒收到" [Regarding the controversy over the donation from Robert Tsao—which a former president had claimed was received correctly—Tsinghua University states that the funds were indeed never received.]. 聯合新聞網 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2025-05-28. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  22. ↑ 中央通訊社 (2025-02-25). "遭指控捐款清大未兌現 曹興誠:支票交給沈君山" [Accused of failing to honor a donation pledge to Tsinghua University, Robert Tsao states: "The check was handed to Shen Chun-shan."]. 中央社 CNA (in Chinese). Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  23. ↑ 中時新聞網 (2025-02-25). "曹興誠有捐1500萬?清大前校長認沒查證 校方堅稱沒收到" [Did Robert Tsao donate NT$15 million? Former NTHU president admits failing to verify; university insists nothing was received.]. 中時新聞網 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  24. ↑ 自由時報電子報 (2025-02-25). "清大無人出面證實 僅採不具名確認未收到曹興誠捐款明細" [Tsinghua University has not come forward to confirm the matter publicly; it only confirmed—on condition of anonymity—that it has not received the details of Robert Tsao's donation.]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2025-05-27. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  25. ↑ 中央通訊社 (2025-02-28). "曹興誠捐1500萬元爭議 清大:保護捐款者隱私不主動揭露" [Controversy over Robert Tsao's NT$15 million donation: NTHU states it will not proactively disclose details in order to protect the donor's privacy.]. 中央社 CNA (in Chinese). Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  26. 1 2 數位內容部整理 (2025-02-26). "曹興誠欠捐清大1500萬?「捐錢是情份,不捐是本分」!一張圖說真相,聯電前總經理親揭是「它」捐的" [Did Robert Tsao fail to fulfill a NT$15 million donation pledge to National Tsing Hua University? "Donating is a gesture of goodwill; not donating is simply a matter of discretion." An infographic reveals the truth: the former UMC president clarifies that the donation actually came from "that" entity.]. www.businesstoday.com.tw (in Chinese). Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  27. ↑ "1500萬捐了沒? 聯電前總經理:是「聯電」捐給清大 查曹興誠當然查不到" [Was the 15 million donation actually made? Former UMC President: It was UMC that donated to Tsinghua University; investigating Robert Tsao would naturally yield no results.]. Yahoo News (in Chinese). 2025-02-26. Retrieved 2026-06-22.
  28. ↑ 記者楊祖宇, Newtalk新頭殼 (2025-03-02). "還原與沈君山下棋捐款始末!曹興誠曝聯電捐清大「這麼多錢」:怎好意思對我反咬一口?" [The full story behind the donation made while playing Go with Shen Chun-shan revealed! Robert Tsao discloses the "massive sum" UMC donated to National Tsing Hua University: "How could they have the nerve to turn around and bite the hand that fed them?"]. www.businesstoday.com.tw (in Chinese). Retrieved 2026-06-22.