The Murder Game (TV series)
| The Murder Game | |
|---|---|
![]() | |
| Genre | Reality / Murder mystery |
| Created by | George Verschoor, Robert Fisher Jr., and Gordon Cassidy (for FOX) |
| Developed by | FOX/BBC |
| Directed by | Ewen Thomson |
| Presented by | Bob Taylor (The Chief) (author of Crimebuster) |
| Narrated by | Rupert Smith |
| Composers | Sophia Morizet, Helene Muddiman |
| Country of origin | United Kingdom |
| Original language | English |
| No. of seasons | 1 |
| No. of episodes | 9 |
| Production | |
| Executive producer | Conrad Green |
| Producers | Ewen Thomson, Nichola Hegarty, Aidan Hansell (reality producer), David Newcombe (drama producer) |
| Production locations | Maldon, Brentwood, Essex, England, UK |
| Cinematography | Janet Tovey |
| Editor | David Tibballs |
| Running time | 60 mins |
| Production companies | BBC Fox World UK |
| Original release | |
| Network | BBC One, BBC Three |
| Release | 29 March – 24 May 2003 |
| Related | |
| Murder in Small Town X | |
The Murder Game is a British reality television series that aired on BBC One from March to May 2003. The show was based on the American Fox series Murder in Small Town X. Though classified as a reality television series, it was more accurately a hybrid of reality TV, game show, and mystery drama. The series was narrated by Rupert Smith. Although there was no host in the traditional sense, Bob Taylor, as "the Chief", served a similar role on the show.
Premise
In the fictional town of Blackwater, a woman named Catherine Prior had been murdered. Ten contestants from the British public were set the challenge of becoming investigators and finding her killer. The investigators were led by Bob Taylor, known as the Chief Investigator or the Chief, who was in real life a retired Detective Chief Superintendent from the West Yorkshire Police.[1] The people of the town, played by actors, formed the pool of suspects, some of whom later became victims themselves.
At the beginning of each episode, one investigator was appointed Lead Investigator, a role carrying specific responsibilities and powers. The Lead Investigator split the others into teams, which were sent down different lines of inquiry determined by the Chief. Each line of inquiry involved a hidden test, which the team either passed or failed as judged by the Chief.
The Killer's Game
At some point during each episode's investigation days, the killer would leave a message revealing two locations, usually accompanied by the taunting phrase "coming out to play?". This signalled the start of the episode's elimination segment, the Killer's Game. The teams were then passed or failed on their lines of inquiry, and the investigators who had failed were put up for a group vote. Every investigator except the Lead Investigator could vote, and the investigator receiving the most votes became the first player of the Game. The Lead Investigator then chose any investigator to be the second player. The two chosen investigators each picked from two envelopes to determine who would go to which of the two locations — for example, the first two locations of the series were "The Old Oaks" and "The Power Museum". The Chief then gave the players one hour to pack their bags and prepare to play the Killer's Game. As the finale, episode 9 featured two Killer's Games; the first of these used a different selection process, with the Chief sending out the investigators who had failed the most lines of inquiry over the course of the series.
In the Killer's Game, the two selected investigators were sent completely alone to two different remote locations, their movements recorded only by a head-mounted camera. Equipped with a torch, each had to follow a map to the spot where a "clue" was located. One of the two would discover an important clue to help solve the mystery, while the other would be eliminated from the show by being "murdered" by the killer. The survivor's return through the entrance doors signalled that he or she had chosen correctly and would continue in the game.
The eliminated contestant chose the Lead Investigator for the next episode by means of a pre-recorded "last will and testament".
Story
Catherine Prior's father, Tony Wilmington, had given her £20,000 and the Wilmington Jewel, and she planned to leave the town of Blackwater forever, taking her daughter Anya with her. Trevor Dobie, however, heard of Catherine's plans and began threatening her. Catherine left home and broke into Jay Wilmington's barge, where she spent the night, taking a pair of navigational dividers with her as protection. The following day, Goldie was due to marry Jay Wilmington. Jennifer Wilmington picked Catherine up on the way to the church and saw that she was wearing the priceless necklace the family had believed missing. Jennifer called Jay to try to get it back, but failed; Jay then called Goldie and asked her to persuade Catherine to hand over the necklace, but Catherine refused. Meanwhile, Trevor continued to pester Catherine over Anya.
Later, Trevor arrived at the church, where Catherine was rehearsing for the wedding, intending to make her admit on camera that he was Anya's father. As he entered the church, his phone rang and he rejected the call. The call was from Jay, phoning from a telephone box to tell Trevor to stop hassling Catherine. Jay was the man in the brown checked shirt seen by the witness Edward Green; he was wearing the same shirt when Sam, Nick, and Christine saw him at the morgue the day after Catherine was attacked, at which point he said he had not changed his clothes in twenty-four hours. Jay therefore had an alibi without realising it. Trevor demanded that Catherine admit Anya was his daughter, which she did. However, she told him that he had never been a proper father to Anya and never would be, as the two of them planned to leave Blackwater. When Trevor asked how she could afford to do so, she told him that Tony Wilmington was her father and had given her the money to get away. Trevor had always hated the Wilmingtons because Felicity Wilmington had killed his mother's baby in an attempt to save the family name. He attacked Catherine, who tried to defend herself with the navigational dividers she had taken from Jay's barge; Trevor wrestled them from her and used them to stab her. He then took the necklace, hoping to use it to frame Jay or Jennifer, and kept it from the murder onwards. Why he chose to play the Killer's Game with the investigators is never explained.
Investigators
| Investigator | Age | Profession | Eliminated | Final Killer's Game Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Christine Rose | 38 | Housewife | Episode 2 | The Power Museum |
| Sarita Raval | 28 | Recruitment Consultant | Episode 3 | The Tyre Yard |
| Samantha Matthews | 31 | Communications Centre Officer | Episode 4 | The Grain Silos |
| Mervin Merchant | 30 | Visual Merchandiser | Episode 5 | The Fortress |
| Meryl Holt | 55 | Retired Legal Secretary | Episode 6 | The Old Docks |
| Ruairi McNally | 23 | Railway Maintenance Worker | Episode 7 | The Quarry |
| Richard Sharrocks | 32 | Commercial Pilot | Episode 8 | The Bottling Plant |
| Nick Sykes | 34 | Property Developer | Episode 9 | The Nuclear Bunker – Living Quarters* |
| Melanie "Mel" Sainz | 21 | Pub Landlady | Runner-up | The Grain Store |
| Andrew Weaver | 56 | Dairy Farmer | Winner | The Construction Warehouse |
Note: As episode 1 was a training and introduction episode featuring no investigations, no elimination took place.
- The Nuclear Bunker comprised two locations: Andrew went to the Operational Zone and Nick to the Living Quarters.
Suspects
| Suspect | Played By | Relation | Outcome | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Frank Prior | Colin Spaull | Father to Catherine and Goldie | 1st suspect cleared | At a petrol station doing a dodgy deal |
| Vanessa March | Leona Ekembe | The Babysitter | 2nd suspect cleared | Was buying a pregnancy test |
| Tina Wells | Joanne Adams | The Vicar's Wife | 3rd suspect cleared | Murdered while retrieving her husband's inhaler |
| Dean Garretty | Graham Bryan | The Best Man | 4th suspect cleared | At his showrooms sending an e-mail |
| George Hawick | Alan David | The Music Teacher | 5th suspect cleared | Was chopping wood at his home |
| Jennifer Wilmington | Jo Ross | Jay's Mother | 6th suspect cleared | Was visiting her solicitors about the Wilmington Jewel |
| Gillian "Goldie" Prior | Jo-Anne Stockham | The Bride and Catherine's sister | 7th suspect cleared | At a cash point withdrawing £50 to buy flowers for Jennifer |
| Jay Wilmington | Luke de Lacey | The Groom | 8th suspect cleared | In a telephone box trying to call Trevor |
| Trevor Dobie | Guy Scantlebury | The Builder | Not Cleared | The Murderer |
Teams
| Teams | Episode 2 | Episode 3 | Episode 4 | Episode 5 | Episode 6 | Episode 7 | Episode 8 | Finale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Team 1 | Christine, Nick, and Samantha † | Mervin and Richard | Meryl and Richard ✓ | Meryl and Nick ✓ | Melanie, Meryl, and Richard ✓ | Melanie and Ruairi † | Melanie and Nick † | Andrew, Melanie, and Nick ⁘ |
| Team 2 | Andrew, Melanie, and Mervin ✓ | Meryl, Samantha, and Sarita † | Andrew, Nick, Ruairi † | Richard and Ruairi ✓ | Andrew and Nick † | Andrew and Richard ✓ | Andrew and Richard † | No Team 2 |
| Team 3 | Meryl, Ruairi, and Sarita † | Andrew, Melanie, and Ruairi † | Melanie and Samantha † | Andrew and Mervin † | No Team 3 | |||
| Lead Investigator | Richard | Nick | Mervin | Melanie | Ruairi | Nick | Andrew | No Lead Investigator |
- † The team failed their line of inquiry
- ✓ The team passed their line of inquiry
- ⁘ There are no fails nor passes
Voting history
- An * indicates that the group vote ended in a tie, resulting in a revote between the tied investigators.
| Episode | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Finale | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Eliminated | Christine | Sarita | Samantha | Mervin | Meryl | Ruairi | Richard | Nick | Melanie | |||
| Group Vote | Sarita* | Sarita* | Andrew | Andrew | Andrew | Ruairi* | Andrew | N/A | ||||
| Lead Investigator's Pick | Christine | Andrew | Samantha | Mervin | Meryl | Richard | Richard | |||||
| Group Voting | ||||||||||||
| Andrew | Meryl | Meryl | Melanie | Mervin | Nick | Melanie | Richard | Six Failed | Winner | |||
| Melanie | Ruairi | Sarita | Andrew | L.I. | Andrew | Ruairi | Andrew | Four Failed | Runner-Up | |||
| Nick | Sarita | L.I. | Ruairi | Mervin | Andrew | Ruairi* | Andrew | Five Failed | ||||
| Richard | L.I. | Ruairi | Nick | Andrew | Nick | Ruairi | Melanie | |||||
| Ruairi | Meryl | Meryl | Melanie | Andrew | L.I. | Melanie | ||||||
| Meryl | Ruairi | Sarita | Andrew | Andrew | Andrew | |||||||
| Mervin | Nick | Richard | L.I. | Andrew | ||||||||
| Samantha | Sarita | Sarita | Andrew | |||||||||
| Sarita | Ruairi | Meryl | ||||||||||
| Christine | Sarita | |||||||||||
- The first episode consisted of training for the investigators. The Killer's Game was not introduced until episode 2.
- Beginning in episode 8, the Lead Investigator was no longer immune from playing the Killer's Game, and so participated in the lines of inquiry and the group vote.
- In the finale, the final three investigators were told how many times each of them had failed their lines of inquiry. The two with the most failures played the Killer's Game.
- In the finale, the second Killer's Game required the two remaining contestants to declare who they believed to be the killer and why. Melanie answered incorrectly and became the killer's final victim. Andrew answered correctly, solved the case, and won the £25,000 prize.
- The investigator's team passed their line of inquiry.
- The investigator's team failed their line of inquiry.
- The investigator was the lead investigator.
- The investigator was the lead investigator and failed their line of inquiry.
- The investigator was spared from playing the Killer's Game due to having the fewest failed lines of inquiry.
- The investigator played the Killer's Game because they did not have the fewest failed lines of inquiry.
- The investigator became the runner-up.
- The investigator won the game.
Sarita* = Both of the first two votes ended in ties, first between Sarita and Ruairi, then between Sarita and Meryl. In both cases a revote was held, and Sarita received the most votes both times.
Ruairi* = The group vote resulted in a tie between Ruairi and Melanie. As Lead Investigator, Nick broke the tie and sent Ruairi out to play the Killer's Game.
Episodes
| No. | Title | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Training the Investigators" | |
|
The investigators undertook five days of training to learn the techniques of police investigation work and self-defence. Short biographies of the individual investigators were shown between the training footage. The episode featured no lines of inquiry, and the Killer's Game had not yet been introduced. | ||
| 2 | "Episode 2" | |
|
Lead Investigator: Richard The first day began with the investigators arriving in Blackwater and stopping outside the church, the scene of a gruesome attack on Catherine Prior, who had been practising for the wedding of Jay Wilmington and Goldie Prior due to take place that afternoon. Catherine was taken to hospital but succumbed to her injuries in transit. The investigators began by choosing a leader, unanimously selecting Richard as Lead Investigator, before the Chief arrived to take charge of the investigation.
The investigators gathered evidence from the crime scene inside the church. As they searched for clues, a banging was heard at the door; when Nick opened it, they discovered a noose left outside the church along with a ringing mobile phone — the killer's introduction to the Killer's Game. The investigators consulted the Lead Investigator, Richard, on whether they should answer the phone. Richard advised them to do so, which they did through an evidence bag, but the call was silent. When the Chief asked whether the phone had been answered, Nick denied it; this initially went unnoticed, but the truth was discovered on the second day after a review of the team's work.
The investigators went to the morgue and encountered Jay and Goldie as they were leaving. The suspects asked numerous questions, including about the whereabouts of a necklace, but the investigators gave nothing away.
Melanie began questioning Goldie and Frank until a child entered the room, identified as Catherine's daughter, Anya. Mervin advised against continuing while Anya was present, and Melanie requested privacy before proceeding. The investigators then questioned both suspects on their movements throughout the day.
The investigators asked Frank to confirm his movements and noted that he omitted his previous statement about visiting a petrol station. As a result, CCTV footage from the petrol station in question was requested to establish whether he had been there.
When the video tape was requested, Dean realised the camera containing it had been stolen. In the confusion that followed, Sarita allowed Dean to leave the scene, and the investigators returned to HQ.
The investigators were to visit Dean at his home, but upon their arrival the previously missing wedding car pulled out of the driveway at high speed. The investigators pursued the car until the driver stopped at a disused railway and threw an object off a bridge into the overgrowth below. Further pursuit was blocked by a tractor. Sarita coordinated a systematic search of the area, which led to Ruairi finding Dean's missing video camera. The investigators discussed watching the tape inside it, but Meryl successfully argued against doing so. When the tape was later reviewed, it showed the attack on Catherine and revealed the next Killer's Game.
Killer's Calling Card: On Day 1, the killer left a noose at the church door with Polaroids reading "Come out to play" and "I am one of the nine". Later that night, while the investigators were having dinner together, the killer hurled a brick through the conservatory window with a wreath tied to it by a rope, along with a set of nine Polaroids each marked "Killer?", referring to the nine suspects in the investigation. On Day 2, the investigators reviewed the recovered video tape, which turned out to show Catherine's attack and murder. The footage showed the killer entering the church — the sound of a phone ringing is heard before being abruptly cut off — and heading up to the organ where Catherine was practising before attacking her. Speaking in a distorted voice, the killer told the investigators, "You think this is a game", as Catherine lay bleeding on the floor, adding "I know who you are" over footage of the investigators eating dinner at HQ the previous night. The killer then revealed the locations via Polaroids captioned "Meet me at The Old Oaks", "Meet me at The Power Museum", "Alone, tonight" and "One of you will not come back!". The video ended with a reversed recording of "coming out to play" as Catherine lay near-lifeless and the sound of a heartbeat faded away.
| ||
| 3 | "Episode 3" | |
|
Lead Investigator: Nick
The clue was a scribbled note on an envelope, apparently referring to a meeting arranged to take place the following day.
The investigators were spotted by Dean, who fled the scene, but they managed to hide in time to witness Vanessa arrive for the meeting. They overheard her contact Dean by mobile phone and question him about missing their long-scheduled meeting.
The investigators searched the now burnt-out car for evidence, and Samantha identified the tracker. However, none of the investigators knew the purpose of a tracker, so they left it in the car and returned to HQ. The Chief sent out his special unit to recover the tracker, which provided evidence that the car had been driven to the Sluice Pond in the early hours of the morning before returning.
The investigators expected the Sluice Pond to be the dumping ground of the murder weapon. Unbeknownst to them, it contained four metal items: three dummies and the actual weapon. One of the four — a bent iron pipe — was found before Sarita broke both metal detectors, forcing the investigators to perform a fingertip search of the pond. Upon finding the second of the four items, a trowel, the investigators believed they had found the murder weapon and returned to HQ.
While Andrew interviewed Jay, the other two investigators dusted only the exterior handle for prints. Melanie collected the sole print they found on the door handle, leading them to believe they had completed their task, and they returned to HQ.
The investigators placed the hidden bugs around the living room as requested and chose to place the personal bug in a cardigan belonging to Jennifer. Although they were not caught placing the bugs or spotted later while under cover in the old shed, they left behind several items indicating that someone had recently been there: a camera battery in a zip-lock bag, an earpiece, and a bottle half full of urine.
Killer's Calling Card: On the morning of Day 2, the investigators were woken by banging noises. When Meryl, Mel, and Sarita went to look, they found that the killer had left blood-covered Polaroids on the windows of Investigator HQ bearing the locations "The Tyre Yard" and "Dead End Farm".
| ||
| 4 | "Episode 4" | |
|
Lead Investigator: Mervin
The investigators questioned the suspects separately, first asking Trevor about his knowledge of being Anya's father, which he denied while appearing surprised but pleased. They then asked Jennifer about the pill box; she confirmed it was hers and had been missing for some time. She requested it back, but the investigators assured her it was best kept with them.
The investigators spotted the vital evidence: a red coat hanging in a tree, containing a wedding invitation addressed to Tina Wells. They also realised that the area was quite large and suspected Catherine may have needed assistance to reach the church in time to rehearse.
The investigators did not separate Jay and Goldie when asking Jay about the discovery that Catherine had broken into his boat. Because the investigators questioned Jay about his relationship with Catherine in front of Goldie, she decided to leave, and Andrew attempted to catch up with her so that she could be interviewed.
Vanessa told the investigators that she had sent Dean out to purchase a pregnancy test, which was negative, although she had told Dean it was positive. The investigators obtained the credit card receipt from the chemist where the test was purchased, noting that it had been signed and that the time of purchase would provide the signer with an alibi. They requested copies of both Dean's and Vanessa's signatures, and during the nightly meeting Ruairi spotted that Vanessa's matched the receipt. The investigators were able to clear Vanessa, as she had an alibi for the time of the murder, though it was noted that she had also attempted to provide a cover story for Dean.
The investigators deduced that even though George claimed he had been cut off by the tide over the causeway, he could have used a boat to reach the mainland before the time Catherine was murdered. They therefore established that the tide did not provide George with an alibi.
The press asked a series of questions, all but one of which could have been answered. The investigators had previously asked Mervin, the Lead Investigator, how they should approach the conference; he advised them to refuse any general questions and to use the conference solely to appeal for information on Catherine's last known movements. As a result, the press posed their questions to Frank and Goldie only, who left the conference when the questioning became intrusive.
Killer's Calling Card: During the night of Day 1, after the investigators had gone to sleep, the killer hacked into HQ's computer, waking everyone as the killer's voice played and images flashed up showing the locations "The Deserted Railway" and "The Grain Silos", each accompanied by the words "Alone" and "Tonight".
| ||
| 5 | "Episode 5" | |
|
Lead Investigator: Melanie
Tina told the investigators about a secret Catherine had divulged to her two weeks before her murder, involving the Wilmington house, "Alice's Room", and something within it that would "change everything". While speaking to them, Tina received what appeared to be a silent nuisance call. Meryl asked about it, and Tina admitted she had been receiving such calls at home and on her mobile, before insisting she be allowed to leave to carry on with her errands. Meryl asked whether she owned a red coat; Tina confirmed she did, but said she kept it at the church as a spare and that it should still be there if they wanted it, before cycling off. Later that night, Tina called the incident office to report a disturbance in the graveyard. Meryl and Nick went to investigate and found that a grave had been tampered with. Deciding it was in the best interests of the investigation, they began digging into the grave for clues, hearing noises nearby as they worked and keeping watch on their surroundings. They eventually unearthed a photo album containing a photograph from the 1930s and Polaroids of the two Killer's Game locations.
The investigators were approached by Vanessa and Tina. Vanessa told them that Anya had said her father used to be violent towards Catherine. Both Tina and Vanessa stated that they did not know who the father was, as Catherine had never told them, although Tina added that she found it a coincidence that Catherine had been threatened by the father and was now dead. Tina also stated that Catherine had been seeing Dean before she died, and that Dean was also seeing Vanessa — for which reason Tina considered him untrustworthy.
The investigators interviewed three witnesses, using the killer's tape and the pathologist's report to confirm or refute their statements. They concluded that the first witness, Zoe, was mistaken, as the killer's tape showed that Catherine was left-handed rather than right-handed. They also established that the second witness, Mary, was mistaken, as the pathologist reported that Catherine wore contact lenses and so could not have put on glasses as Mary described. This left Edward's statement as the correct one, providing the investigators with clues as to who else might have seen Catherine before she died.
The investigators confronted Jennifer with the eyewitness statement, and she began telling them what had happened and what the witnessed argument was about when Trevor Dobie, another suspect, approached. After failing to move Jennifer far enough away from Trevor, Richard left Ruairi to continue taking Jennifer's statement while he led Trevor away.
The investigators established that the dividers belonged to Jay, but that they had been missing for a few days and he had assumed he misplaced them.
The investigators gained access to the room and discovered its secret: the mummified remains of a baby. They decided to photograph the scene, but also to close the door to the adjacent box room where the remains were found and return to HQ, taking the secret with them before the rest of the Wilmington family returned home.
Killer's Calling Card: While digging into the grave at the church graveyard, Meryl and Nick found a photo album containing a picture of the Wilmingtons in the 1930s and Polaroids bearing the locations "The Hospital" and "The Fortress".
| ||
| 6 | "Episode 6" | |
|
Lead Investigator: Ruairi
Felicity informed the investigators that the baby was hers and had been born premature. Although the preliminary forensic report given to them before the visit stated that the baby appeared full term, they believed her until the full post-mortem confirmed that the baby was not premature. They were then able to use the box of family tree information collected from Tina, along with their knowledge of Trevor's mother, to establish that the dead baby was likely Dorothy's, not Felicity's. During the night of Day 1, the Chief was informed of a disturbance at a local farm, and a search team was sent out with sniffer dogs and a piece of Tina's clothing. The investigators accompanied them to investigate the find. Following the dogs, they located the body of Tina Wells in a grain store. However, they failed to spot a message from the killer — a knife through an animal heart, along with the locations of the next Killer's Game.
The investigators established which nursing home Dorothy had lived in before her death and spoke to a resident who might remember Catherine's visit. The date on the Dictaphone tape enabled the resident to check his diary and confirm that Catherine had been there speaking to Dorothy.
The break-in was phoned in before they could confront Trevor. The investigators attended the property, where Tina stated that she was still receiving silent calls, including some before the break-in. The investigators gathered evidence before moving on to their main line of inquiry. The Lead Investigator, Ruairi, informed them that Catherine's phone records had arrived and that Trevor had called her minutes before she was murdered. Trevor admitted making the call but claimed he could not remember much of the conversation. Andrew spotted the visual clue: the same picture previously discovered in the photo album that the killer had buried for the investigators to find. Trevor informed them that his mother, Dorothy, was the maid in the photo. This new information distracted the investigators, who failed to confront Trevor about the threats he had been making towards Catherine. During the night of Day 1, the investigators were sent to protect Tina Wells, who felt she was being watched and was frightened. She received another silent phone call while Andrew was in attendance, but he failed to notice that there were eight new messages on the voicemail. Tina's husband suffered an asthma attack upstairs, and Tina and Andrew went to assist him. When Tina ran downstairs to fetch an inhaler, her husband clung to Andrew, preventing him from following her. During this time, Tina was murdered and dragged out through a back door.
When confronting Trevor, the investigators told him there had been accusations of him threatening and being violent towards Catherine. Because they did not mention that the accusations were levelled specifically at Anya's father, they failed to gain a valuable piece of information until Trevor himself asked whether he was being questioned because he was Anya's father. He told them he had not known he was her father and had always believed Jay to be — thus pointing the finger of suspicion at Jay for threatening Catherine. When questioned, Dean claimed to have been at the car showroom working on his laptop at the time of the abduction, as he had "a lot of work to catch up on". While the investigators were there, he received an e-mail from Jay, announced by an audible standard e-mail alert. As Dean appeared uncooperative, the investigators left for HQ, with Dean forcefully shutting his laptop as they exited the office.
Killer's Calling Card: After murdering Tina Wells and leaving her body in a grain store on the farm, the killer left a knife through an animal heart along with Polaroids bearing the locations "The Dark Woods" and "The Old Docks", which the investigators failed to collect.
| ||
| 7 | "Episode 7" | |
|
Lead Investigator: Nick
Jay denied both being Anya's father and threatening Catherine, and asked the investigators who had told them he was involved. The investigators did not reveal that the information had come from Tina Wells and Trevor Dobie.
Felicity informed the investigators that she had killed Dorothy's baby, thereby confessing to murder. The investigators questioned her further, asking whether the death was accidental and how she could be sure she was responsible. Felicity stated plainly that she knew she had killed the baby because she had allowed it to die, and then asked whether the investigators were going to arrest her. Melanie told her they were not, explaining that they were simply gathering information on Dorothy, Felicity, and the baby, and that Felicity was not in any trouble, before returning to HQ.
While George was being questioned, a friend of his, Rodney "Rod" Lewis, stopped by to show off the back page of the daily paper, which featured a photo of Rod holding a large fish. When George asked when it was taken, Rod stated that it was exactly two weeks earlier. Richard realised this would have been the day of the murder and asked Rod how long he had borrowed George's boat for. Rod replied that he took the boat at approximately 6:00 am and returned with the fish at about midday. The investigators were then left stranded on the island by their driver and unable to walk back to the mainland, having been cut off by the tide. After waiting for the tide to go out, they made their way on foot over the causeway, at which point the killer fired a flare to draw attention to a taunting message left on a gate, containing the next Killer's Game locations.
The investigators discovered that the photo in the paper had been cropped from a larger image, which showed George Hawick in the background chopping wood. The time stamp revealed that the photo was taken at 12:04 pm, giving George an alibi for the murder of Catherine.
Goldie's Kidnapping: On the afternoon of Day 1, Nick, the Lead Investigator, was sent a video of a kidnapped Goldie Prior reading a ransom note demanding the necklace in exchange for her release. Both teams worked together to make the exchange, with Melanie chosen by Nick as the negotiator. The bag containing the necklace was bugged by Team 2 so that it could be tracked; however, the investigators lost sight of the car and recovered only the empty bag from the area indicated by the tracker. Killer's Calling Card: As noted above, while stranded by the high tide at the end of their Day 1 inquiry, Andrew and Richard found Polaroids on a fence bearing a sign reading "Coming out to play", revealed when a flare was fired. The Polaroids showed the locations "The Quarry" and "The Derelict Barn".
| ||
| 8 | "Episode 8" | |
|
Lead Investigator: Andrew Note: With only four investigators remaining, the Lead Investigator had to join the others in the field and could be nominated by the group to face the Killer's Game.
The investigators asked Jennifer who had access to the shop and whether she had seen or heard anything of Jay and Goldie in recent days. Jennifer told them that Jay and Trevor had access to the shop and that she had not seen or heard from Jay or Goldie recently. She gave the investigators permission to access the store room, which they believed was the setting of the ransom video, but they failed to spot that day's newspaper on the table, which would have cast doubt on Jennifer's claim not to have entered the store room for several days. Melanie asked Nick whether it was a crime scene, and Nick incorrectly stated that it was not. The investigators did not confront Jennifer with the evidence that Goldie had been held in the store room.
The investigators used surveillance to establish why Jennifer was scared of Trevor, but observed no behaviour from Trevor to justify her concern. They did hear Jennifer telling Trevor that she had told the investigators he had been in the store room recently, to which he questioned why she would say so when it was untrue. Jennifer retorted that she had thought he was in there, and added that she could have told them he was at the church on the day Catherine was murdered. Trevor confronted her, demanding to know why she was telling the investigators things about him and what her reasoning was. Jennifer told him she thought he should leave. Upon Trevor's exit, the investigators' surveillance van was shaken and banged from the outside. When they attempted to leave, they realised they were locked in. The killer had left a message on the van, along with Polaroids of the locations for the next Killer's Game. While trapped in the van, the investigators also saw Jay enter the shop, flustered and trying to reach the store room. Jennifer tried to hush him and usher him out before he could say or do anything, as she was aware the shop was under surveillance while Jay was not. She instructed him to meet her at the local pub, and Jay left. Jennifer then found the investigators in the van, and upon releasing them she confessed to the kidnapping and explained that it had all been about the necklace. She offered a potential alibi, saying she had been at her solicitor's at the time of the murder. When the investigators followed this up, the solicitor believed Jennifer had been there earlier than the time she had stated. However, on checking the visitor log, they found that the solicitor had misremembered: Jennifer had indeed been at the solicitor's at the time of the murder, providing her with an alibi.
At the grain store where Tina's body had been found, the investigators were told it had been flooded with dirty water. They needed to search it systematically until they found the item the killer had supposedly hidden there. The clue was a shredded letter in a bag weighed down with a brick. Once reassembled, the letter was found to have been written by Charles Wilmington to his son Tony, and revealed the existence of the necklace. Charles gave Tony instructions on passing down the heirloom, telling him to pass it on to a child he trusted, and adding that he had never approved of Tony's choice of wife — implying that Jennifer was not to have it.
Tony Wilmington had taped a conversation with Catherine four or five days before her death, in which he told her about the necklace and its history. He bequeathed it to her, but she felt it would be inappropriate, as it was a family heirloom better suited to Jay or Jennifer. When he began telling her about his relationship with her mother, Catherine revealed that she already knew he was her father, adding that no one else knew. Tony tried to give her the necklace again, but Catherine refused once more, telling him it would not be good for herself and Anya, because Trevor wanted Anya, being her father. Tony stated that Trevor would never have any claim on the necklace and that he would make a provision in his will to confirm it. He also told the investigators that he had given Catherine £20,000 to fund a fresh start away from Blackwater. Before the final briefing, Team 2 was sent back to Creeksea Place, where a fire had broken out. The fire ultimately killed Tony Wilmington, who died in the ambulance on the way to hospital. The investigators reached Tony as he was first rescued from his room and spotted a letter in his hand, which they recovered as potential evidence. The letter revealed that Jay had heard the contents of the tape before his wedding was due to take place — and that the person who had let him hear it was Catherine herself.
Note: Anya was also interviewed by a family liaison officer and, when questioned, said that Goldie (her aunt) had left the house on the day of the murder. The investigators realised that Goldie had lied to them about her whereabouts when they first spoke to her and revealed that Catherine had died. Killer's Calling Card: As described above, the killer shook and banged on the surveillance van the investigators were using. Once they were able to get out, they found Polaroids for the next two locations: "The Boathouse" and "The Bottling Plant".
| ||
| 9 | "Episode 9" | |
|
Lead Investigator: There was no Lead Investigator for the finale, and no hidden tests, passes or fails. Instead, the final three investigators (Andrew, Melanie, and Nick) worked together to interview the final three suspects (Goldie, Jay, and Trevor). Final Three
During the morning briefing, the Chief and the final investigators discussed the clue Andrew had found at the last Killer's Game: two numbers, which Nick identified as a bank account number and sort code. The numbers were revealed to relate to a bank account shared by Goldie and Jay, showing a withdrawal of £50.00 on the morning of Catherine's murder. The investigators realised this might clear Goldie or Jay — or potentially implicate Trevor, if he had access to the account — but they would need CCTV to identify who made the withdrawal, as the PIN and card could have been used by anyone the account holders trusted. The Chief told the investigators that their first line of inquiry was to attend the reading of Tony Wilmington's last will and testament, and their second was to interview Jay and Goldie to establish who had withdrawn the money. The investigators attended the reading of Tony Wilmington's will at the solicitor's office, along with Goldie, Jay, Felicity, and Jennifer. Tony left Jennifer and Jay the entire estate, but via a video testament bequeathed the Wilmington necklace to Catherine. He stated that, in accordance with Catherine's wishes, Anya would inherit the necklace afterwards, but also that one person should under no circumstances lay claim to it: Trevor Dobie, Anya's biological father. Jay called Trevor a "bastard" and left hastily before the investigators had a chance to speak to him. As the rest of the family was leaving, Goldie asked to talk to the investigators at the café. At the café, she confessed what had happened on the morning of the murder. Jay had phoned her at approximately 11 am to ask for her help in getting the necklace back. He said he did not know why Catherine had the family heirloom, but he needed it back or the wedding could not go ahead; he had asked Catherine for it, and she had refused. At Jay's request, Goldie asked Catherine for the necklace under the guise that it could be her "something borrowed" for the wedding, but Catherine again refused, and when asked where she had got it, would say only that it would all come out later. While leaving the church after arguing with Catherine, Goldie overheard a telephone conversation between Catherine and Trevor; she could tell the two were arguing but not what about. She then said she saw Jay outside the church, but stopped only to tell him she had been unsuccessful and was not getting involved any further before driving off. Andrew then asked her about the joint bank account and the £50.00 withdrawal. Goldie stated that she had forgotten to buy a gift for Jennifer and had withdrawn £50 for flowers before going home. Nick asked who had instigated the kidnapping, and she stated it was Jay's idea; her reasoning for acting as an accomplice was that if Jay wanted the necklace, it meant he could not have killed Catherine, giving her hope that he was innocent. Goldie also explained that she had not revealed what actually happened on the morning of the murder when first questioned because she had not wanted to implicate Jay as the killer. The investigators were then alerted by Jennifer that she had seen Trevor moving out of the annexe at Creeksea Place. When they arrived, Trevor had already left, and Jennifer let them into the property. Investigating Trevor's living area, they found that one of the rooms had been boarded up. After pulling down the plasterboard covering, they discovered that the attic room had been prepared for Anya. Jennifer stated that she had never seen Anya visit the annexe, and Nick spotted letters addressed to Anya that had been marked "return to sender". The investigators went to Jay's barge to attempt an interview, having been unable to speak to him earlier when he rushed off from the solicitor's. Jay was not there, but they entered the boat to investigate the scene. Melanie noticed a new answerphone message; on playing it, they heard Goldie telling Jay that she had told the investigators everything, and Melanie took the tape as evidence. Andrew and Nick found a bulletin board covered in familiar Polaroids. The front bore pictures of Goldie, but on turning it around they found pictures of Catherine on the back, along with a card from her relating to Jay being Anya's godparent, dated April 1991. The investigators decided to bring the entire bulletin board back with them and returned to HQ. Back at HQ, the investigators found the power cut and evidence that the killer had broken in. There were messages stencilled on the windows, a hanged Barbie doll, and two pictures showing the locations for the next Killer's Game. The power was restored and, after a phone call from Nick, the Chief arrived early for the evening briefing. The killer still demanded two investigators to play the Killer's Game; instead of a group vote, the Chief sent out the two investigators who had failed the most lines of inquiry over the entire investigation. Killer's Calling Card: After ransacking HQ and leaving "coming out to play" messages throughout, the killer left the mess as the penultimate message, along with the locations "Operational Zone" and "Living Quarters", both within the same nuclear bunker.
Note: Melanie failed only four lines of inquiry, allowing her to progress to the final stage automatically. Final Two
At the morning briefing, the Chief revealed that the bank had sent CCTV footage from the cash point showing Goldie making the withdrawal. This confirmed her story about withdrawing £50.00, and she was cleared. The Chief informed the two remaining investigators that he had reviewed all the evidence put before them and deduced the killer's identity. The investigators were given one hour to do the same before naming to the Chief who they believed the killer to be and why. They were reminded that they were now in direct competition for the prize money — although if both guessed correctly they would share the £25,000, while if both were wrong, neither would receive anything. They separately informed the Chief of their chosen suspect and their reasoning.
The Chief then sent the investigators out to trail their chosen suspects. Andrew chased Trevor down a river as he tried to escape by boat from the yacht club, while Melanie pursued Jay across fields as he attempted to flee on a dirt bike through the disused airfield. Both lost their suspects at closed gates and had to wait for news of new sightings. Melanie learned that Jay's dirt bike had been spotted outside a remote grain store, while Andrew received word that Trevor's pickup truck had been located at a construction warehouse 30 km from Blackwater. As both headed to their locations, the killer left each of them a message — "Coming out to play one last time?" — inviting them to one final Killer's Game.
Jay Wilmington was cleared. He had an alibi from the eyewitness Edward, who had been forced to use a different phone box because the one he intended to use was occupied by a man in a brown checked shirt — the same shirt Jay was wearing when he went to the morgue with Goldie and told the investigators he had not changed his clothes in over twenty-four hours. Jay had gone to the phone box to call Trevor and tell him to stop hassling Catherine; the killer's own video captured the sound of a phone ringing once before being rejected. This was the call Jay made from the phone box moments before Catherine was killed by Trevor. | ||
Production
The town of Maldon, Essex was used as the setting for the fictional town of Blackwater, named after the river on which Maldon sits.[2] The Kelvedon Hatch Secret Nuclear Bunker was also used in the series: Andrew Weaver and Nick Sykes went to its Operational Zone and Living Quarters respectively during the penultimate Killer's Game. Before the game began, the investigators were sent on a training course at the Police Training Centre in Wakefield.
Andrew Weaver won the game despite being sent to play the Killer's Game six times, excluding the final Killer's Game against runner-up Melanie "Mel" Sainz. He holds the record for the most times a contestant has been sent to play the Killer's Game, breaking Kristen Kirchner's record of five in the American version, Murder in Small Town X. Andrew was also the only investigator to fail a line of inquiry while serving as Lead Investigator, and he received the most votes against him of any contestant over the season, with ten. He correctly identified builder Trevor Dobie as the killer, whereas Melanie chose groom Jay Wilmington. Andrew was sent to the yacht club, where Trevor was last seen, and was "invited" to the final Killer's Game at the construction warehouse, where he found Bob Taylor waiting to proclaim him the winner of the £25,000 grand prize.
Viewer interaction
Using Sky, cable or Freeview, viewers could access additional content through BBCi's digital interactive features. One feature, Blackwater TV, reviewed the case and presented mock television news reports. The React feature allowed viewers to vote for who they believed the killer to be, with the results shown the following week. The Investigators section featured exclusive footage of the Chief commenting on the contestants' handling of the case. The fourth feature, the Case File, held all the details of the case uncovered so far, including timelines, locations, suspects' relationships, and evidence.
References
- ↑ "The Murder Game Press Kit" (PDF). BBC. 11 March 2003. Retrieved 30 August 2008.
- ↑ "The Murder Game". UKGameShows. Retrieved 30 August 2008.
External links
- The Murder Game at IMDb
- The Murder Game at BBC Online (No longer active)
- "The Murder Game at bbc.co.uk". 9 April 2003. Archived from the original on 9 April 2003. Retrieved 10 December 2008.
- BBC One original programming
- British television series based on American television series
- 2003 British television series debuts
- 2003 English-language television series debuts
- 2003 British television series endings
- 2003 English-language television series endings
- 2000s British reality television series
- English-language British television shows
- 2000s British mystery television series
