Taipei Huannan Market COVID-19 cluster

The Taipei Huannan Market COVID-19 cluster was a cluster of COVID-19 infections associated with the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation (TAPMC), Binjiang Market, and Huannan Market in Taipei, Taiwan. The outbreak began on 14 May 2021 with the onset of illness in a vegetable auctioneer at the First Market of the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation(TAPMC).[1] According to subsequent reports, the company did not immediately disclose information or implement response measures,[2][3] the Taipei City Government did not establish screening stations at an early stage,[3] and the Council of Agriculture, the competent authority, did not promptly announce preventive measures.[2] It was not until 10 June that TAPMC issued a press release confirming infections at the Second Market.[4] As a result, consumers and vendors were exposed without full knowledge of the situation. The outbreak eventually resulted in a total of 247 confirmed cases linked to the First Market, Binjiang Market, and Huannan Market.

Timeline

According to Investigation Report No. 111-She-Diao-0001 issued by the Control Yuan,[3] the first vegetable auctioneer at TAPMC's First Market developed symptoms on 14 May, was reported on 18 May, and was confirmed positive on 20 May. The first Huannan Market case developed symptoms on 15 May, was reported on 2 June, and confirmed on 3 June. The earliest Binjiang Market case developed symptoms and was reported on 25 May, and was confirmed on 27 May. These represented the first recorded cases in the three markets.

On 5 June, central and local authorities held a meeting on establishing screening stations at fruit and vegetable wholesale markets in Taipei and New Taipei City. The meeting recommended that the Taipei City Government establish a rapid screening station at TAPMC's First Market, but the proposal was not adopted.[5]

On 13 June, the Taipei City Government launched the "TAPMC Rapid Screening Project", through which 45 cases were identified within one week.[6]

On 18 June, Taipei City Councillor Hsu Shu-hua criticized the city government's contact tracing and quarantine measures, arguing that confirmed cases were recorded only as Taipei cases without tracing or notifying other counties and cities.[7]

On 21 June, TAPMC established a screening station at Wanda Elementary School, followed by another at Binjiang Market on the next day,[8] more than two weeks after the 5 June meeting. Interviews with truck drivers and security personnel revealed that TAPMC lacked effective control over actual entries and exits and was unable to determine contacts after infections occurred. The Central Epidemic Command Center (CECC) requested lists of freight drivers and unloading workers, but TAPMC had never compiled such records.[2]

Between 22 and 23 June, infections at TAPMC's First Market reached their peak, with 19 new cases reported over two days.[5] Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je stated during a press conference that the available data suggested sporadic infections rather than a concentrated cluster.[9]

On 23 June, after a joint meeting between Ko Wen-je, the Council of Agriculture, and the CECC, a consensus was reached to establish an inter-county database based on national identification numbers, allowing epidemiological information to be shared across jurisdictions and reducing information gaps.[2]

On 24 June, access controls were strengthened, requiring proof of a negative rapid test before entry into the First Market, Binjiang Market, and related facilities.[10] Ko criticized deficiencies in the central contact tracing platform, arguing that the system made it difficult for Taipei authorities to track infected individuals arriving from other counties.[5] A subsequent statement by the Control Yuan clarified that both central and local governments had room for improvement, while noting that lists of cross-county contacts had been provided during the early stages of the outbreak.[11]

On 26 June, Ko Wen-je reversed his earlier position and announced that Wang Pi-sheng would be invited to conduct large-scale PCR testing and establish a forward command post at Binjiang Market and Wanda Market, integrating epidemiological investigations, testing, and vaccination services.[12]

On 27 June, Taipei city councillors criticized the city government for failing to publish contact-tracing information and cumulative case numbers, arguing that infection figures became known only through media investigations or disclosures by legislators.[13] Critics also pointed out that TAPMC had failed to release information promptly when the outbreak first emerged in May,[4] exposing consumers and vendors to unnecessary risks.

On 2 July, PCR testing at Huannan Market identified 41 confirmed cases. The CECC and Taipei City Government jointly held a press conference. Legislator Freddy Lim criticized Ko Wen-je for failing to conduct comprehensive testing earlier and argued that testing efforts remained insufficient, prompting a rebuttal from Huannan Market Self-Governance Association chairman Lin Sheng-tung, who accused Lim of neglecting local concerns.[14]

On 9 July, the Joint Forward Command Center for TAPMC and Huannan Market held its fifth meeting, attended by CECC executive director Wang Pi-sheng and Taipei Mayor Ko Wen-je. Wang stated that only three new cases had been identified during the second round of large-scale PCR testing.[15]

On 15 July, the Taipei City Government ordered that entry to TAPMC facilities required a TAPMC access permit, vaccination card, negative PCR result, or certificate of release from isolation. The Centers for Disease Control officially closed the investigation into the outbreak, reporting a total of 247 cases, including 105 linked to TAPMC's First Market, 24 linked to Binjiang Market, and 118 linked to Huannan Market.

Aftermath and Review

On 19 January 2022, the Control Yuan released an investigative report identifying several shortcomings in the Taipei City Government's response, including:

  • Failure to promptly strengthen testing and control mechanisms for nearly one month after the first case was detected.[16]
  • Conducting epidemiological investigations only for infected individuals residing in Taipei City, while failing to trace infected persons from other counties and cities.[3][11]

On 14 February 2022, Deputy Mayor Huang Shan-shan stated during a COVID-19 press conference that, during the outbreak at the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation (TAPMC), the city government was unable to access patients' workplace information. As a result, it could not obtain information on cases from other counties and cities when the outbreak occurred. She argued that shortcomings in the central government's epidemiological investigation system, rather than the Taipei City Government, were responsible for the problem.[17]When Mayor Ko Wen-je was asked whether he should apologize for the outbreak that infected 247 people, he replied that the issue had become a matter of political attacks. He argued that epidemic prevention involved medical expertise and suggested that investigations should be conducted by medical professionals rather than by individuals without medical backgrounds.[18]

On 17 February 2022, the Control Yuan issued a statement clarifying that:[11]

  • Its investigation focused on possible administrative negligence and did not accuse the city government of medical malpractice.
  • It noted that, during a press conference on 22 June 2021, Ko Wen-je had explicitly stated that "the data suggested sporadic infections rather than a cluster outbreak."
  • The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) had provided information on infections involving other counties and cities from the beginning of the TAPMC outbreak and had reminded the Taipei City Government that it should not limit its analysis to Taipei residents, as the city government possessed the capacity to conduct epidemiological investigations.
  • Regarding problems with the contact-tracing platform, the Control Yuan concluded that both central and local governments had room for improvement and requested that the CDC review and improve the system.

Controversy

On 22 July 2021, Ko Wen-je remarked that "I was the one doing all the work" and questioned what contributions Wang Pi-sheng had made.[19] The comments were criticized by observers as ungrateful and dismissive of Wang's role. Ko later apologized during a subsequent press conference.[12]

References

  1. ↑ 自由時報電子報 (2021-05-19). "傳台北第一果菜市場有人確診 北農:非公司承銷人" [Reports of a confirmed case at Taipei's First Fruit and Vegetable Wholesale Market; Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation: The individual is not a company-registered wholesaler.]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-09. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  2. 1 2 3 4 "被冷藏的疫情熱區──揭開北農群聚風暴,大到追不了的隱形傳播鏈" [The Sidelined COVID-19 Hotspot: Unveiling the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation Cluster—An Invisible Chain of Transmission Too Vast to Trace] (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2022-03-01. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  3. 1 2 3 4 "調查 報告" [Investigation Report]. Archived from the original on July 27, 2022. Retrieved June 20, 2026. 據報導,臺北農產運銷股份有限公司自110年5月14日起,即傳出有1名承銷商員工確診新冠肺炎,5月下旬再爆發疫情,染疫病例達13例,直至6月疫情持續擴大,已累積確診案例達45例。究相關主管機關有無依據傳染病防治法相關規定,進行疫調及辦理防疫措施?有無錯失先機,防堵疫情蔓延?相關人員有無消極任事,並涉及怠惰失職情事?實有深入瞭解之必要案。 [Reports indicate that starting May 14, 2021, a wholesaler employee at the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation was confirmed to have COVID-19. An outbreak subsequently occurred in late May, resulting in 13 confirmed cases, and the situation escalated further in June, bringing the cumulative total to 45 cases. It is essential to thoroughly investigate whether the relevant competent authorities conducted epidemiological investigations and implemented disease prevention measures in accordance with the Communicable Disease Control Act; whether they missed the opportunity to contain the spread of the virus; and whether the personnel involved were passive in their duties or guilty of negligence and dereliction of duty.]
  4. 1 2 林靜梅 王德心 / 台北報導 (2021-06-11). "北農二市場6人確診兩週後才公布 攤商、消費者都不知情" [Confirmed cases among six people at the Beinong No. 2 Market were not announced until two weeks later; neither vendors nor consumers were aware of the situation.]. 公視新聞網 PNN. Archived from the original on 2021-07-25. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  5. 1 2 3 自由時報電子報 (2022-02-14). "北農群聚案 監院:北市府輕忽疫情" [Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation Cluster: Control Yuan Says Taipei City Government Underestimated the Outbreak]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-09. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  6. ↑ 聯合新聞網. "北農群聚案再擴大!員工、承銷商、派遣工皆中鏢 累計45人確診" [Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation cluster expands further! Employees, wholesalers, and dispatched workers all infected; cumulative total reaches 45 confirmed cases.]. 聯合新聞網 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2021-06-21. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  7. ↑ "北農18+1確診!北市議員憂疫調不全成防疫破口" [19 Confirmed Cases at Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation; City Councilors Fear Incomplete Contact Tracing Could Create a Gap in Disease Prevention] (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-09. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  8. ↑ "萬大國小快篩站 民眾前往篩檢 (圖)" [Residents visit the rapid testing station at Wanda Elementary School (Photo)] (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-11. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  9. ↑ "柯文哲:北農組成分子來自全台 別說是群聚感染" [Ko Wen-je: Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation personnel come from all over Taiwan; don't call it a cluster infection.] (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-11. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  10. ↑ "因應臺北農產運銷公司群聚感染事件,指揮中心啟動「市場專案」強化相關防疫作為" [In response to the cluster infection at the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation, the Central Epidemic Command Center has launched a "Market Project" to strengthen relevant epidemic prevention measures.]. www.cdc.gov.tw (in Traditional Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-18. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  11. 1 2 3 "監察院對於外界提出北農群聚感染案調查報告之相關指教,予以澄清" [The Control Yuan issues a clarification regarding external comments concerning the investigation report on the cluster infection at the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation (TAPMC).]. 監察院全球資訊網 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). 2022-02-17. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  12. 1 2 "批王必勝沒貢獻反挨轟 柯文哲改口道歉:我反省過,我錯了" [Ko Wen-je faces backlash after criticizing Wang Pi-sheng for lack of contribution; he backtracks and apologizes: "I’ve reflected on this—I was wrong."]. 鏡週刊 Mirror Media (in Chinese (Taiwan)). 2021-07-23. Archived from the original on 2022-04-09. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  13. ↑ "北市府115人確診 未公布足跡" [115 Taipei City Government employees test positive; movement history not released.]. www.cdns.com.tw (in Chinese (Taiwan)). Archived from the original on 2022-05-05. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  14. ↑ "林昶佐吐槽柯文哲「講廢話」 當場遭自治會長怒嗆從未關心" [Freddy Lim criticized Ko Wen-je for "talking nonsense," only to be angrily confronted on the spot by an association president who accused him of never having cared about the issue.]. ETtoday新聞雲 (in Chinese (Taiwan)). 2021-07-02. Archived from the original on 2021-07-02. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  15. ↑ "環南市場篩檢新增3例確診 王必勝:往好的方向發展 目標清零" [Three additional confirmed cases detected at Huannan Market; Wang Pi-sheng: Situation moving in a positive direction, goal is zero cases.]. Rti 中央廣播電臺 (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-09. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  16. ↑ 自由時報電子報 (2021-07-05). "5月批發市場爆首例確診市府內部規劃高強度管制 卻被柯文哲打槍" [After the first confirmed case was detected at a wholesale market in May, the city government internally planned high-intensity control measures, but the proposal was rejected by Ko Wen-je.]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-04-09. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  17. ↑ 自由時報電子報 (2022-02-14). "監院揭市府輕忽釀北農疫情 黃珊珊批:針對台北市而來" [Control Yuan reveals city government negligence led to Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation outbreak; Huang Shan-shan criticizes move as targeting Taipei City.]. 自由時報電子報 (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-05-16. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  18. ↑ "監委檢討北農群聚疫調 黃珊珊:嚴重誤導視聽" [Control Yuan reviews contact tracing for the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation cluster; Huang Shan-shan: It seriously misleads the public.] (in Chinese). Archived from the original on 2022-05-10. Retrieved 2026-06-20.
  19. ↑ 「事都我在做」 柯P:王必勝對北農有何貢獻?|華視新聞 20210722. Archived from the original on 2022-04-09. Retrieved 2026-06-21."I'm the one doing all the work"—Mayor Ko asks: What contribution has Wang Pi-sheng made to the Taipei Agricultural Products Marketing Corporation?