Honours
League champions
| Season |
Division One |
Division Two |
| 1949–50 |
Sheffield Training College |
Little Matlock |
| 1950–51 |
Sheffield Training College |
Ravens Amateur |
| Season |
Division One |
Division Two |
Division Three |
| 1951–52 |
Ravens Amateur |
|
|
| 1952–53 |
Sheffield Training College |
|
|
| 1953–54 |
Old Edwardians |
Old Centralians |
Croft House |
| 1954–55 |
Sheffield reserves |
De La Salle Old Boys |
Old Cestrefeldians 'B' |
| 1955–56 |
Sheffield Training College |
Sheffield Transport |
Greenhill |
| 1956–57 |
Sheffield Training College |
Sheffield University |
Nether Edge Old Boys |
| 1957–58 |
Sheffield Training College 'A' |
Electric Sports |
Holly Guild |
| 1958–59 |
Old Firparnians |
Hollinsend Amateurs |
English Steel Corporation |
| 1959–60 |
Old Firparnians |
|
|
| 1960–61 |
Sheffield Training College |
|
|
| 1961–62 |
Old Firparnians |
Sheffield Bankers |
Sheffield Bankers 'B' |
| Season |
Premier Division |
Division One |
Division Two |
Division Three |
| 1962–63 |
Electricity Sports |
Croft House |
Hollinsend Amateurs |
Oughtibridge War Memorial |
| 1963–64 |
Sheffield Training College |
De La Salle Old Boys |
Oughtibridge War Memorial |
Sheffield Teachers |
| 1964–65 |
Sheffield Training College |
Oughtibridge War Memorial |
Sheffield Teachers |
Sandersons Sports |
| 1965–66 |
Sheffield Training College |
Sheffield Teachers |
Sandersons Sports |
Colley YS |
| Season |
|
| 1966–67 |
Sheffield Training College |
| 1967–68 |
Hollinsend Amateurs |
| 1968–69 |
Not finished |
| Season |
Premier Division |
Division One |
Division Two |
Division Three |
| 1969–70 |
Old Firparnians |
Sheffield Education |
Woodthorpe |
Longley BC |
| 1970–71 |
Old Edwardians Old Boys |
Woodthorpe |
Crosspool |
Swan |
| 1971–72 |
Abbeydale Old Boys |
|
|
|
| 1972–73 |
Crosspool |
Dore |
Wadsley Church |
|
| 1973–74 |
Crosspool |
Wadsley Church |
Public Works Department |
|
| 1974–75 |
Trustee Savings Bankers |
Ash House |
Club Double |
Meynell Sports |
| 1975–76 |
Hollinsend Amateurs |
Park |
Meynell Sports |
Ecclesfield |
| 1976–77 |
Woodbourn |
Meynell Sports |
Middlewood Hospital |
|
| 1977–78 |
Meynell Sports |
Middlewood Hospital |
Wadsley Bridge |
Brown Bear |
| 1978–79 |
Earl Francis |
Old Firparnians |
Stannington College |
Dixcel |
| 1979–80 |
Earl Francis |
Stannington College 'A' |
Old Cestrefeldians |
Hurlfield Youth Club |
| 1980–81 |
Old Edwardians |
Jordanthorpe Old Boys |
Hurlfield Youth Club |
Gleadless |
| 1981–82 |
Hollinsend Albion |
Darnall |
Dixcel Sports |
Red Grouse |
| 1982–83 |
Stannington College 'A' |
Ecclesfield |
Escalop |
Handsworth Methodists |
| 1983–84 |
Stannington College 'A' |
Woodthorpe |
Handsworth Methodists |
Middlewood |
| 1984–85 |
Hurlfield Youth Club |
Red Grouse |
Granville Sports 85 |
Phoenix 'A' |
| 1985–86 |
Sheffield Foundry WMC |
Granville SP |
Phoenix 'A' |
DS Tooling |
| 1986–87 |
Dixcel Sports |
Phoenix 'A' |
DS Tooling |
Sheffield Academicals |
| 1987–88 |
De La Salle Old Boys |
Grade A Joinery |
Sheffield Academicals |
Midland Bank |
| 1988–89 |
De La Salle Old Boys |
Sheffield Gas |
Midland Bank |
Melchester Rovers |
| 1989–90 |
Sheffield Gas |
Hollinsend Albion |
Melchester Rovers |
Manpower Rangers |
| 1990–91 |
Freedom 90 |
Sheffield Medics 'A' |
Stocksbridge Park Steels 3rds |
Elm Tree |
| Season |
Premier Division |
Division One |
Division Two |
| 1991–92 |
Stannington United |
Stocksbridge Park Steels 3rds |
Elm Tree |
| 1992–93 |
Dixcel Sports |
Elm Tree |
Record Tools |
| 1993–94 |
Elm Tree |
Burncross |
Gate 13 |
| 1994–95 |
Market Inn |
Midland Bank |
Davy reserves |
| 1995–96 |
Burncross |
Oughtibridge WMSC reserves |
Hillsborough |
| 1996–97 |
Burncross |
Hillsborough |
Crookes WMC |
| Season |
Premier Division |
Division One |
| 1997–98 |
Elm Tree |
Railway |
| 1998–99 |
Hillsborough |
Bradway |
| 1999–00 |
Forum |
Wombwell Main |
| 2000–01 |
Hollinsend Amateurs |
A Silkstone United B Junction |
| 2001–02 |
Fullflow Fairway |
Jubilee Sports |
| 2002–03 |
Silkstone United |
Phoenix All Stars |
| Season |
|
| 2003–04 |
Cross Scythes |
| Season |
Premier Division |
Division One |
| 2004–05 |
Jubilee Sports |
Yew Tree |
| 2005–06 |
Jubilee Sports |
Grimethorpe Athletic |
| 2006–07 |
Grimethorpe Athletic |
Kiveton Park reserves |
| 2007–08 |
Aston |
A New Bohemians B Sheffield West End |
| Season |
Premier Division |
Division One |
Division Two |
| 2008–09 |
Gleadless |
Boynton Sports |
Surud United |
| 2009–10 |
Jubilee Sports |
Sheffield Medics |
Manor Castle |
| Season |
Premier Division |
Division One |
| 2010–11 |
Gleadless |
Royston |
| 2011–12 |
Jubilee Sports |
North Gawber Colliery |
| 2012–13 |
North Gawber Colliery |
Dodworth Miners Welfare |
| Season |
|
| 2013–14 |
Byron House |
| 2014–15 |
Grimethorpe Sports |
| 2015–16 |
Sheffield Medics |
League Cup finals
| Season |
Winner |
Result |
Runner-up |
Venue |
| 1982–83 |
Darnall Wellington |
|
|
|
| 1983–84 |
Hurlfield Youth Club |
|
|
|
| 1984–85 |
Windsor reserves |
|
|
|
| 1985–86 |
Stannington College A |
|
|
|
| 1986–87 |
Jordanthorpe Old Boys A |
|
|
|
| 1987–88 |
Stannington College |
|
Stannington United |
|
| 1988–89 |
Stannington United |
|
Granville College |
|
| 1989–90 |
LDS |
|
Devonshire Arms |
|
| 1990–91 |
Elm Tree |
3–0 |
Phoenix 'A' |
|
| 1991–92 |
Elm Tree |
|
New Life |
|
| 1992–93 |
Castle College |
|
|
|
| 1993–94 |
De La Salle Old Boys |
|
|
|
| 1994–95 |
Gate 13 |
|
|
|
| 1995–96 |
Burncross |
2–1 |
Oughtibridge War Memorial SC reserves |
|
| 1996–97 |
Hillsborough |
|
|
|
| 1997–98 |
Hillsborough |
|
|
|
| 1998–99 |
Hillsborough |
|
|
|
| 1999–00 |
Forum |
|
|
|
| 2000–01 |
Burncross |
1–0 |
Silkstone United |
Woodbourn Road |
| 2001–02 |
Silkstone United |
|
|
|
| 2002–03 |
Everest |
6–1 |
Silkstone United |
Bracken Moor |
| 2003–04 |
Sheffield Bankers |
3–2 |
Oxspring United |
Bracken Moor |
| 2004–05 |
Cross Scythes |
2–1 |
Sheffield Bankers 'A' |
Bracken Moor |
| 2005–06 |
Grimethorpe Athletic |
3–1 |
Thorncliffe |
|
| 2006–07 |
Grimethorpe Athletic |
1–0 |
Athersley Recreation reserves |
Bracken Moor |
| 2007–08 |
Gleadless |
2 – 2 (3p2) |
Aston |
|
| 2008–09 |
Furnace |
4–2 |
New Bohemians |
Bracken Moor |
| 2009–10 |
New Bohemians |
3–1 |
Gleadless |
Bracken Moor |
| 2010–11 |
Jubilee Sports |
2–1 |
Gleadless |
Bracken Moor |
| 2011–12 |
North Gawber Colliery |
2–0 |
Aquaforce Barnsley reserves |
Bracken Moor |
| 2012–13 |
North Gawber Colliery |
2–1 |
Sheffield Medics |
Bracken Moor |
| 2013–14 |
Byron House |
3–2 |
Millmoor Juniors 'A' |
Bracken Moor |
| 2014–15 |
Sheffield Medics |
1–0 |
Brinsworth Whitehill |
Bracken Moor |
| 2015–16 |
Sheffield Medics |
2–1 |
Euroglaze |
Bracken Moor |