Revolutionary Workers League (Canada)

Revolutionary Workers League/Ligue Ouvrière Révolutionnaire
LeaderJohn Riddell
Steve Penner
Founded8 August 1977 (1977-08-08)
Dissolved1990 (1990)
Merger ofLeague for Socialist Action/Ligue Socialiste Ouvrière
Revolutionary Marxist Group
Groupe Marxiste Révolutionnaire
Young Socialists/Ligue des Jeunes Socialistes
Succeeded byCommunist League
NewspaperSocialist Voice
La Lutte Ouvrière
Youth wingYoung Socialists/Ligue des Jeunes Socialistes
IdeologyTrotskyism
Political positionFar-left
International affiliationUnited Secretariat of the Fourth International

The Revolutionary Workers League (RWL; French: Ligue Ouvrière Révolutionnaire, LOR) was a Canadian Trotskyist political organization active from 1977 to 1990. It was formed on 8 August 1977 by the fusion of the League for Socialist Action/Ligue Socialiste Ouvrière (LSA/LSO), the Revolutionary Marxist Group (RMG), the Quebec-based Groupe Marxiste Révolutionnaire (GMR), and the LSA's youth wing, the Young Socialists/Ligue des Jeunes Socialistes.[1][2]

The RWL/LOR marked the reunification of the Canadian section of the Fourth International after the factional disputes that had divided Canadian Trotskyists in the early 1970s.[2] It published the English-language newspaper Socialist Voice and the French-language La Lutte Ouvrière.[3] In 1990, after years of close alignment with the Socialist Workers Party in the United States, the RWL/LOR left the Fourth International and changed its name to the Communist League.[2][4]

Formation

The RWL/LOR was created through a fusion of four organizations associated with the Fourth International. John Riddell, a former LSA and RWL leader, later described the fusion partners as the LSA/LSO, the historic Canadian section of the Fourth International; the RMG, a sympathizing group in English Canada; the GMR, a sympathizing group in Quebec; and the Young Socialists/Ligue des Jeunes Socialistes, an autonomous youth organization linked to the LSA/LSO.[2]

The groups had been divided by the 1972–73 factional dispute in the Fourth International, but moved closer together after the international conflict began to subside.[2] According to Riddell, the fused organization initially included close to 500 members and supporters, divided roughly equally between the LSA/LSO and Young Socialists on one side and the RMG/GMR on the other.[2] The fusion also brought together several newspapers, headquarters, bookstores, distribution networks and full-time staff.[2] Robert J. Alexander similarly describes the RWL as the organization created by the 1977 fusion of the Canadian Trotskyist groups associated with the Fourth International.[5]

The RWL/LOR adopted a statement of principles at its founding conference on 8 August 1977.[1] A reprint of the statement was published by Vanguard Publications in 1978.[6]

Publications and organization

The RWL/LOR published Socialist Voice in English and La Lutte Ouvrière in French.[7] The Trotskyist serials bibliography by Wolfgang and Petra Lubitz lists Socialist Voice as a Toronto-based publication of the Revolutionary Workers League beginning in September 1977, continuing the numbering of Labor Challenge, The Militant and Young Socialist, and identifies La Lutte Ouvrière as its French edition.[8]

The organization sought to create a unified bilingual leadership centre in Montreal after the fusion. Riddell wrote that this goal was soon achieved and that a united central leadership emerged with components from the RMG, GMR, LSA and LSO.[2] He also wrote that the new organization maintained the work areas of its predecessor groups at first, but lacked a unified action plan immediately after the fusion.[2]

Quebec national question

The Quebec national question was one of the major political issues facing the new organization. Riddell wrote that RWL/LOR members viewed policy toward the Quebec workers' movement and Quebec nationalism as decisive questions for socialists in the Canadian state.[2] The fused organization reached agreement on support for an independent socialist Quebec and for building a mass workers' party in Quebec based on the trade unions.[2]

In early 1978, however, an internal debate opened when some leaders from the former LSA/LSO criticized former GMR leaders for what they regarded as excessive concessions to Quebec nationalism.[2] Riddell later argued that, although some criticisms had merit, the debate reproduced geographic tensions between English Canada and Quebec and was made more difficult by the involvement of representatives of the United States SWP in Canadian leadership discussions.[2]

Turn to industry

In 1978 and 1979, the RWL/LOR adopted what became known as the "turn to industry", an orientation influenced by the Socialist Workers Party in the United States and later endorsed by the Fourth International.[2] The policy called for members to take jobs in major industrial workplaces and unions. Riddell wrote that more than 100 RWL/LOR members attended the SWP's 1978 conference in Oberlin, Ohio, where the American party was already engaged in shifting members into unionized industry.[2]

Supporters of the turn argued that the student and youth radicalization of the 1960s and 1970s was ebbing, while industrial unions would become increasingly central to class struggle in Canada.[2] The RWL/LOR Central Committee voted to "qualitatively increase" the number of members in key industrial unions, and Riddell later wrote that most members were soon placed in industrial unions.[2]

The policy was controversial. Riddell later argued that the industrial turn was based on a prediction of future worker radicalization rather than on existing conditions, and that the organization reacted to labour retreat in the early 1980s by radicalizing the turn instead of reconsidering it.[4] He wrote that the RWL/LOR reduced or eliminated work in several public-sector union and social-movement areas and that many earlier orientations inherited from its predecessor organizations were abandoned.[4] Socialist Project's obituary of Ernie Tate, a former LSA and RWL member, states that Tate initially helped the RWL carry out industrial training but later concluded that the turn had become sectarian and destructive.[9]

Relationship with the Socialist Workers Party

The RWL/LOR was strongly influenced by the Socialist Workers Party in the United States. The LSA/LSO had long had close ties with the SWP, but Riddell wrote that the SWP's role changed during the fusion period and after 1977, when SWP representatives became more directly involved in Canadian leadership discussions.[2] He argued that this marked a shift from earlier relations, in which the SWP generally acted with more restraint toward the Canadian section.[2]

In 1979, the SWP began developing its own international current critical of the majority leadership of the Fourth International.[2] In 1982–83, the SWP dropped the designation "Trotskyist" and expelled dissidents who opposed the change. Riddell wrote that this had a strong effect in Canada, where a majority of RWL/LOR members accepted the SWP's new orientation.[2]

Critics of the SWP-aligned current argued that it had abandoned key elements of Trotskyist theory, including permanent revolution, and had adopted an uncritical view of the Cuban Revolution. Barry Weisleder, later a founder of Socialist Action Canada, wrote that the SWP "broke with Permanent Revolution" and that its Canadian affiliate was the Communist League.[10] Because Weisleder wrote from the standpoint of a later dissident current, his account is best treated as an attributed criticism rather than a neutral description.

Dissidents and splits

The RWL/LOR experienced several departures and splits during the early 1980s. In Quebec, a dissident group left the RWL/LOR in 1980 and later formed Gauche Socialiste in 1983.[2] In English Canada, another group launched the Alliance for Socialist Action, later renamed Socialist Challenge.[2]

Riddell wrote that by 1983 about half of the original RWL/LOR membership had left and that only a small minority remained from the former RMG and GMR.[2] Socialist Action Canada later traced its own origins to these disputes, stating that former RWL members and dissidents passed through the Socialist Workers' Collective, the Alliance for Socialist Action and Socialist Challenge before a further split led to the formation of Socialist Action Canada in 1994.[11]

The organization's internal tensions also affected members active in feminist and lesbian/gay liberation politics. In an interview with Left History, Gary Kinsman recalled that in 1979 some members who were increasingly disaffected from the RWL formed "Tendency Z" to fight for the integration of lesbian and gay liberation into the organization.[12] Kinsman later commented on Riddell's history that a number of Tendency Z members left the RWL on 8 March 1980 when they concluded that the organization was refusing to discuss their position.[2]

Name change and successor organization

By the late 1980s, the RWL/LOR had declined significantly. Riddell wrote that it had ceased independent publishing activity and increasingly circulated publications of the SWP.[4] In 1990, the organization dropped the RWL/LOR name and became the Communist League, matching the name used by other organizations associated with the SWP-led international tendency.[4] Riddell described this as a structural integration of the Canadian organization into the stronger United States movement.[4]

Riddell also wrote that the SWP and its supporters, including the Communist League in Canada, left the Fourth International in 1990.[2] The Communist League continued as a smaller organization associated with the SWP and its publishing house, Pathfinder Press.

Legacy

Riddell later described the RWL/LOR as a promising but ultimately unsuccessful attempt to unite the main Canadian Trotskyist organizations of the 1970s.[2] He argued that the organization initially brought together substantial resources and experienced activists, but that it failed to develop a common action plan and later became increasingly shaped by the SWP's orientation.[2][4]

Several later Canadian socialist organizations emerged from or were influenced by the RWL/LOR's breakup. Gauche Socialiste continued in Quebec and later participated in the political process that led to Québec solidaire.[2] Socialist Challenge later merged into the New Socialist Group in English Canada.[2] Socialist Action Canada, founded in 1994, also traced part of its origins to dissidents from the RWL/LOR and Socialist Challenge.[13]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 "Revolutionary Workers League Statement of Principles (1977)". Socialist History Project. 8 August 1977. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 Riddell, John (19 November 2018). "RWL: Inquest into a failed socialist fusion". John Riddell: Marxist Essays and Commentary. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  3. ↑ Simms, Robert (10 December 2007). "38 years in communist movement". The Militant. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Riddell, John (26 November 2018). "RWL/LOR: Explaining a failed fusion". John Riddell: Marxist Essays and Commentary. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  5. ↑ Alexander, Robert J. (1991). International Trotskyism, 1929–1985: A Documented Analysis of the Movement. Duke University Press. pp. 155–156. ISBN 978-0-8223-1066-2.
  6. ↑ Revolutionary Workers League (1978). Statement of Principles (Reprint ed.). Vanguard Publications. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  7. ↑ Simms, Robert (10 December 2007). "38 years in communist movement". The Militant. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  8. ↑ Lubitz, Wolfgang; Lubitz, Petra (2004). "Trotskyist Serials Bibliography: Main Part" (PDF). TrotskyanaNet. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  9. ↑ "In Memory of Ernie Tate (1934–2021)". Socialist Project. 12 February 2021. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  10. ↑ Weisleder, Barry (27 March 2023). "The History and Practice of Socialist Action – Canada (2020)". Socialist Action Canada. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  11. ↑ Weisleder, Barry (27 March 2023). "The History and Practice of Socialist Action – Canada (2020)". Socialist Action Canada. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  12. ↑ "Interview with Gary Kinsman". Left History. York University. Retrieved 6 July 2026.
  13. ↑ Weisleder, Barry (27 March 2023). "The History and Practice of Socialist Action – Canada (2020)". Socialist Action Canada. Retrieved 6 July 2026.