One-size-fits-all hypothesis (insect genitalia)

The one-size-fits-all hypothesis of spider and insect male genitalia was proposed by William G. Eberhard et al. in 1998. It asserts that male genitalia will not vary significantly in size, even if the body size of the animal itself or another body part does vary significantly in size. This means that a large individual of a certain species will have roughly the same size genitalia as that of a small individual of the same species, according to the hypothesis. This is beneficial because if the structure of the female genital opening requires a specific size and shape for a successful mating, then males with medium-sized genitalia will successfully mate more on average, causing selection pressure. This specific type of selection pressure is called cryptic sexual selection. To measure its effects, one needs to study the allometry of the animal. If the allometry is negative, it indicates that the hypothesis is correct.[1][2]

The hypothesis was challenged by Andy J. Green one year after Eberhard et al. published their article. He wrote in the same journal that their conclusions were incorrect and caused by a biased statistical methodology.[3] Eberhard and his co-authors replied to this and refuted Green's claims.[4] The one-size-fits-all hypothesis has been continualy revisited by multiple authors since its proposal in 1998, and as of 2025, there is seemingly good support for the hypothesis.[5]

References

  1. ↑ Eberhard, William G.; Huber, Bernhard A.; S., Rafael Lucas Rodriguez; Briceno, R. Daniel; Salas, Isabel; Rodriguez, Viterbo (April 1998). "One Size Fits All? Relationships Between the Size and Degree of Variation in Genitalia and Other Body Parts in Twenty Species of Insects and Spiders". Evolution. 52 (2): 415–431. doi:10.2307/2411078. ISSN 0014-3820. JSTOR 2411078. PMID 28568329.
  2. ↑ Cao, Chengquan; Yu, Pei; Hayashi, Fumio (2019-06-10). "Allometry and morphological trait relationship in the sexually dimorphic Chinese dobsonfly, Acanthacorydalis asiatica (Wood-Mason, 1884) (Megaloptera, Corydalidae)". ZooKeys (854): 119–129. Bibcode:2019ZooK..854..119C. doi:10.3897/zookeys.854.32897. ISSN 1313-2970. PMC 6579787. PMID 31231160.
  3. ↑ Green, Andy J. (October 1999). "Allometry of Genitalia in Insects and Spiders: One Size Does Not Fit All". Evolution. 53 (5): 1621–1624. doi:10.2307/2640909. JSTOR 2640909. PMID 28565573.
  4. ↑ Eberhard, W. G.; Huber, B. A.; Rodriguez, R. L. (October 1999). "Don't Forget the Biology: A Reply to Green". Evolution. 53 (5): 1624–1627. doi:10.2307/2640910. JSTOR 2640910. PMID 28565565.
  5. ↑ Matsuo, Takashi (September 2025). "Scaling of ovipositor size in two species of Drosophila : altered genital coupling mechanisms and evolution of allometric slopes". Biology Letters. 21 (9) 20250295. doi:10.1098/rsbl.2025.0295. ISSN 1744-957X. PMC 12441749. PMID 40958649.