Mach Recruitment Ltd v Oliveira

Mach Recruitment Ltd v Oliveira
CourtEmployment Appeal Tribunal
Citation[2025] EAT 107[1]
Case opinions
Bowers J
Keywords
Transfer of undertakings

Mach Recruitment Ltd v Oliveira is a 2025 Employment Appeal Tribunal case which clarified the application of the Transfer of Undertakings (Protection of Employment) Regulations 2006 (TUPE) to temporary agency workers.[1][2][3] The case addressed the meaning of an organised grouping of employees in the context of a service provision change between two temporary work agencies.[4][5] The tribunal upheld the initial ruling, finding that a TUPE transfer had occurred.[3]

Background

The claimant, Mrs. Oliveira, was an agency worker supplied by G-Staff Ltd to Butcher's Pet Care Ltd, where she consistently worked alongside the same group of colleagues.[5] Oliveira was under an employment contract due to G-Staff's use of the "Swedish derogation" exemption to rules on treating workers as direct employees of the end user.[3]

In July 2018, Mach Recruitment Ltd took over the contract, and Oliveira continued to work at the site in the same role.[5] Oliveira subsequently brought a claim arguing her employment should have automatically transferred from G-Staff to Mach Recruitment.[4]

Judgment

In order to determine whether a TUPE transfer had taken place, the Employment Tribunal examined the core issue of the existence of a deliberately organised grouping of employees formed for the purposes of carrying out work for the client.[4][5] The tribunal ruled that this was the case and found in favour of Oliveira.[4]

Mach Recruitment appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT), arguing that there was no deliberately organised grouping, but that the employees had been assembled organically.[5] The EAT ruled that a formal decision to structure the group of employees was not a necessary precondition for it to be considered an "organised grouping" and upheld the original ruling.[4][5]

See also

UK labour law

References

  1. 1 2 "Mach Recruitment Ltd v Mrs Maria Oliveira: [2025] EAT 107". GOV.UK. Retrieved 10 September 2025.
  2. ↑ "Employment Cases Update: Mach Recruitment Ltd v Oliveira: [2025] EAT 107". Employment Cases Update. Retrieved 9 September 2025.
  3. 1 2 3 B, Michael (26 August 2025). "Mach Recruitment Ltd v Oliveira [2025] EAT 107 – Service Provision Changes Under TUPE: Organised Groupings of Employees in Temporary Work Agency Transfers • FCSA". FCSA. Retrieved 9 September 2025.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 Solicitors, Thompsons. "TUPE and Agency Workers: Oliveira v Mach Recruitment Ltd". Thompsons Solicitors. Retrieved 9 September 2025.
  5. 1 2 3 4 5 6 "Mach Recruitment Ltd v Oliveira [2025] EAT 107 – Service Provision Changes Under TUPE: Organised in Agency Transfers". www.theteamnetwork.co.uk. 4 September 2025. Retrieved 9 September 2025.