| Year |
D I / AAA |
D II / AA |
D III / A |
D IV |
D V |
D VI |
D VII |
| 1928 | | Columbus Aquinas | Centerville | |
| 1929 | | Columbus Central | Newcomerstown | |
| 1930 | | Martins Ferry | St Paris | |
| 1931 | | Cincinnati Woodward | Delphos Jefferson | |
| 1932 | | Columbus South | Tiltonsville | |
| 1933 | | Warren Warren G Harding | Congress West-Salem | |
| 1934 | | Cincinnati Withrow | Mayfield Village Mayfield | |
| 1935 | | St. Bernard Roger Bacon | Brookville | |
| 1936 | | Norwood | Etna | |
| 1937 | | Canton McKinley | Holgate | |
| 1938 | | Cincinnati Hughes | Sugar Grove Berne Union | |
| 1939 | | Canton McKinley | Pemberville | |
| 1940 | | Columbus North | Powhatan Point | |
| 1941 | | Cincinnati Withrow | Beavercreek | |
| 1942 | | Tiltonsville | Reading | |
| 1943 | | Cincinnati Elder | Leavittsburg | |
| 1944 | | East Cleveland Shaw | Reading | |
| 1945 | | Cincinnati Woodward | Plainville | |
| 1946 | | Cleveland Lincoln | Reading | |
| 1947 | | Cleveland Heights | Columbus Hamilton Township | |
| 1948 | | Cincinnati Western Hills | Cincinnati Sycamore | |
| 1949 | | Cincinnati Hughes | North Bend Taylor | |
| 1950 | | Cincinnati Withrow | Batavia Amelia | |
| 1951 | | Cincinnati Western Hills | Lima St Rose | |
| 1952 | | Cincinnati Elder | Beavercreek | |
| 1953 | | Cincinnati Purcell Marian | Beavercreek | |
| 1954 | | Mansfield Senior | Waverly | |
| 1955 | | Cincinnati Elder | Lockland | |
| 1956 | | Cincinnati Elder | Cincinnati Greenhills | |
| 1957 | | Reading | Middleport | |
| 1958 | | Cincinnati Elder | Goshen | |
| 1959 | | Cincinnati Elder | West Salem Northwestern | |
| 1960 | | Cincinnati Elder | Baltimore Liberty Union | |
| 1961 | | Cleveland South | Baltimore Liberty Union | |
| 1962 | | North Bend Taylor | Van Wert Lincolnview | |
| 1963 | | Euclid | Powhatan Point | |
| 1964 | | Lima Senior | Baltimore Liberty Union | |
| 1965 | | Shaker Heights | Versailles | |
| 1966 | | Kettering Fairmont West | West Salem Northwestern | |
| 1967 | | Cincinnati Western Hills | Nelsonville-York | |
| 1968 | | East Cleveland Shaw | Old Fort | |
| 1969 | | Columbus East | New Riegel | |
| 1970 | | Dayton Chaminade | Cincinnati Lincoln Heights | |
| 1971 | Findlay | Columbus Father Wehrle Memorial | Russia | |
| 1972 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Ironton | Anna | |
| 1973 | Cincinnati Elder | St Paris Graham | Portsmouth Sciotoville Community (East) | |
| 1974 | Wickliffe | Reading | Middletown Bishop Fenwick | |
| 1975 | Columbus West | Bryan | Lucasville Valley | |
| 1976 | Shaker Heights | Elida | Leipsic | |
| 1977 | Cincinnati Western Hills | Cincinnati Deer Park | Miller City | |
| 1978 | Cincinnati Elder | Coshocton | Hicksville | |
| 1979 | Oregon Clay | Columbus St Francis De Sales | Cardington-Lincoln | |
| 1980 | Cincinnati Oak Hills | Reading | Anna | |
| 1981 | Worthington | Parma Heights Holy Name | Middletown Bishop Fenwick | |
| 1982 | Euclid | Urbana | Gahanna Columbus Academy | |
| 1983 | Hamilton | Coldwater | Ashtabula Sts John And Paul | |
| 1984 | Cincinnati Elder | Coldwater | Miller City | |
| 1985 | Fairfield | Bellevue | Graysville Skyvue | |
| 1986 | Cincinnati Western Hills | Akron St Vincent-St Mary | Toledo Ottawa Hills | |
| 1987 | Upper Arlington | Coldwater | Rockford Parkway | |
| 1988 | Columbus Bishop Watterson | Youngstown Ursuline | Newark Catholic | |
| 1989 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Akron St Vincent-St Mary | Newark Catholic | |
| 1990 | Upper Arlington | Urbana | Coldwater | |
| 1991 | Fairfield | Columbus Bishop Watterson | Hamilton Badin | Rockford Parkway |
| 1992 | Defiance | Elyria West | Coldwater | Morral Ridgedale |
| 1993 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Hebron Lakewood | Campbell Memorial | Cincinnati Country Day |
| 1994 | Toledo Start | Hebron Lakewood | Ontario | Steubenville Catholic Central |
| 1995 | Canton GlenOak | Wauseon | Bainbridge Paint Valley | Cincinnati Summit Country Day |
| 1996 | Canton GlenOak | Hamilton Badin | Wheelersburg | Columbus Bishop Hartley |
| 1997 | Hamilton | Columbus Bishop Watterson | Dayton Oakwood | Defiance Ayersville |
| 1998 | Lakewood St Edward | Cincinnati Archbishop McNicholas | Plain City Jonathan Alder | Toronto |
| 1999 | Cincinnati Elder | Cuyahoga Falls Walsh Jesuit | Cincinnati Madeira | St Henry |
| 2000 | Toledo Start | Washington Court House Washington | Youngstown Ursuline | St Henry |
| 2001 | Dublin Coffman | Chardon Notre Dame-Cathedral Latin | Marion Pleasant | Cincinnati Country Day |
| 2002 | Cleveland St Ignatius | Tallmadge | Heath | Newark Catholic |
| 2003 | Cincinnati St Xavier | Cincinnati Purcell Marian | St Henry | Newark Catholic |
| 2004 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Cuyahoga Falls Walsh Jesuit | New Albany | Newark Catholic |
| 2005 | Cincinnati Elder | Hebron Lakewood | Archbold | Gibsonburg |
| 2006 | Strongsville | Cuyahoga Falls Walsh Jesuit | Marion Pleasant | Newark Catholic |
| 2007 | West Chester Lakota West | Canfield | Heath | Fort Loramie |
| 2008 | Lakewood St Edward | Cuyahoga Falls Walsh Jesuit | Perry Township Central Catholic | Hamler Patrick Henry |
| 2009 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Chardon Notre Dame-Cathedral Latin | Gnadenhutten Indian Valley | Hamler Patrick Henry |
| 2010 | Lakewood St Edward | Plain City Jonathan Alder | Bellville Clear Fork | Fort Loramie |
| 2011 | Liberty Twp. Lakota East | Columbus St Francis De Sales | Central Catholic | Minster |
| 2012 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Columbus St Francis De Sales | Wheelersburg | Minster |
| 2013 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Defiance | Wheelersburg | Newark Catholic |
| 2014 | Massillon Jackson | Bloom-Carroll | Coldwater | Defiance Tinora |
| 2015 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Defiance | Perry Township Central Catholic | Newark Catholic |
| 2016 | Pickerington North | Defiance | Berlin Hiland | Newark Catholic |
| 2017 | Massillon Jackson | Tallmadge | Champion | Minster |
| 2018 | Olentangy Liberty | Dayton Chaminade-Julienne | Canfield South Range | Fort Loramie |
| 2019 | Cleveland St. Ignatius | Dayton Chaminade-Julienne | Coldwater | Toronto |
| 2020 | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled | Tournament canceled |
| 2021 | New Albany | Akron Archbishop Hoban | Cincinnati Hills Christian Academy | Warren John F. Kennedy |
| 2022 | Sylvania Northview | Chardon | Apple Creek Waynedale | Russia |
| 2023 | Cincinnati Archbishop Moeller | Chargin Falls Kenston | Apple Creek Waynedale | Berlin Hiland |
| 2024 | William Mason | Beloit West Branch | Heath | Berlin Hiland |
| 2025 | Lewis Center Olentangy | Whitehouse Anthony Wayne | Newark Licking Valley | Mentor Lake Catholic | Apple Creek Waynedale | Berlin Hiland | Minster |
| 2026 |
Cincinnati St. Xavier |
New Albany |
Hamilton Badin |
Sandusky Perkins |
Apple Creek Waynedale |
Hartville Lake Center Christian |
Delphos St. John |