| Member |
Party |
Years |
Cong ress |
Electoral history |
| District created March 4, 1875 |
 John Baker (Goshen) |
Republican |
March 4, 1875 – March 3, 1881 |
44th 45th 46th |
Elected in 1874. Re-elected in 1876. Re-elected in 1878. Retired. |
 William H. Calkins (Laporte) |
Republican |
March 4, 1881 – October 20, 1884 |
47th 48th |
Redistricted from the 10th district and re-elected in 1880. Re-elected in 1882. Retired to run for governor and resigned. |
| Vacant |
October 20, 1884 – December 1, 1884 |
48th |
|
 Benjamin F. Shively (South Bend) |
Anti-Monopolist |
December 1, 1884 – March 3, 1885 |
Elected to finish Calkins's term. Was not candidate for full term. |
.jpg) George Ford (South Bend) |
Democratic |
March 4, 1885 – March 3, 1887 |
49th |
Elected in 1884. Retired. |
 Benjamin F. Shively (South Bend) |
Democratic |
March 4, 1887 – March 3, 1893 |
50th 51st 52nd |
Elected in 1886. Re-elected in 1888. Re-elected in 1890. Retired. |
 Charles G. Conn (Elkhart) |
Democratic |
March 4, 1893 – March 3, 1895 |
53rd |
Elected in 1892. Retired. |
 Lemuel W. Royse (Warsaw) |
Republican |
March 4, 1895 – March 3, 1899 |
54th 55th |
Elected in 1894. Re-elected in 1896. Lost renomination. |
 Abraham L. Brick (South Bend) |
Republican |
March 4, 1899 – April 7, 1908 |
56th 57th 58th 59th 60th |
Elected in 1898. Re-elected in 1900. Re-elected in 1902. Re-elected in 1904. Re-elected in 1906. Died. |
| Vacant |
April 7, 1908 – November 3, 1908 |
60th |
|
.jpg) Henry A. Barnhart (Rochester) |
Democratic |
November 3, 1908 – March 3, 1919 |
60th 61st 62nd 63rd 64th 65th |
Elected to finish Brick's term. Re-elected in 1908. Re-elected in 1910. Re-elected in 1912. Re-elected in 1914. Re-elected in 1916. Lost re-election. |
 Andrew J. Hickey (La Porte) |
Republican |
March 4, 1919 – March 3, 1931 |
66th 67th 68th 69th 70th 71st |
Elected in 1918. Re-elected in 1920. Re-elected in 1922. Re-elected in 1924. Re-elected in 1926. Re-elected in 1928. Lost re-election. |
 Samuel B. Pettengill (South Bend) |
Democratic |
March 4, 1931 – March 3, 1933 |
72nd |
Elected in 1930. Redistricted to the 3rd district. |
| District eliminated March 4, 1933 |