Hong Kong historiography

Hong Kong historiography refers to an approach that views the history of Hong Kong from a Hong Kong-centered standpoint. It stands alongside the colonial historiography and nationalist historiography as one of the three main perspectives for writing the history of Hong Kong.”[1][2] It places greater emphasis on Hong Kong’s unique culture, similar to the island historiography approach seen in Taiwan.[2]

History

Hong Kong-centered narratives of Hong Kong history had already appeared in the 1980s. Kwong Chi-man points out that at that time Steve Tsang, in A Modern History of Hong Kong, viewed Hong Kong history from the perspective of Hong Kong Chinese; Ko Tim-keung similarly described Hong Kong during the Japanese occupation from a Hong Kong-centered approach.[3] By the late 1990s, due to the need of the People’s Republic of China to establish the legitimacy of the sovereignty handover, scholars in the region began to construct a narrative of Hong Kong history with this purpose in mind. Out of this effort emerged works such as The Vicissitudes of Hong Kong, broadcast on CCTV, and Hong Kong in the Nineteenth Century, edited by Liu Cunkuan[4] They place particular emphasis on the oppression of Hong Kong people under British rule, the local resistance against British colonialism, and the relationship between Hong Kong and China[5] In response, Wang Hongzhi and Cai Rongfang published The Burden of History: A View of Mainland China’s Hong Kong Historiography from Hong Kong (2000) and A Hong Kong People’s History of Hong Kong (2001), respectively. Both works place stronger emphasis on a Hong Kong-centered perspective, with the former further highlighting the problems present in the official narratives put forward by the People’s Republic of China[1][6][7]

Later, in 2007, Marco Cabada released A Short History of Hong Kong, which examines Hong Kong’s history from a localist perspective. Its Chinese translation, titled 香港简史─从殖民地至特别行政区 (A Short History of Hong Kong: From Colony to Special Administrative Region), was published by Zhonghua Book Company in 2013.n 2013 and 2014, Kwong Chi-man published Lonely Outpost and Old Soldiers Never Die, respectively, applying the Hong Kong historical perspective to write about Chinese soldiers serving in the British Army and the Battle of Hong Kong during the Pacific War[8] In 2014, Tsui Sing-on released City-State Chronicles: Twelve Books on Hong Kong’s Local History, where he employed the Hong Kong historical perspective to present twelve important works on the history of Hong Kong.[9] In 2015, Kwong Kin-ming released The Hong Kong-British Era: British Colonial Governance Techniques, offering a Hong Kong-centered analysis of why the ‘hearts and minds’ failed to return after the handover and highlighting the advantages of the British colonial administration over the Hong Kong SAR government.[8] In 2017, Tsui Sing-on extended the ideas from City-State Chronicles and released Hong Kong, a Restless Homeland: A Localist Perspective on Hong Kong’s Origins.[9][10] A revised edition of this book was published in 2019[9] In this work, Hongkongers are depicted as a distinct national group. The author made it clear during the writing process that the aim was to challenge Chinese imperialism and Orientalism, and therefore there was no intention to maintain ‘neutrality or impartiality.[10]

Features

The Hong Kong historiographical approach emphasizes analyzing Hong Kong’s history with Hong Kong itself as the primary focus[1] It advocates interpreting Hong Kong’s history from the viewpoint of Hong Kong residents[2] It does not avoid engaging with historical events deemed sensitive by the People’s Republic of China, including the refugee wave from the People’s Republic of China to British Hong Kong, the territory’s economic development after World War II, the 1967 Hong Kong riots, and opinion polling on Hong Kong identity[2][11] In contrast to the colonial and nationalist historiographies, it gives more weight to the voices and experiences of Hong Kong’s Chinese population and ethnic minorities, placing their rights and concerns at the forefront.[1]

Evaluation

Lau Chi-pang, director of the Hong Kong Institute for the Humanities and Social Sciences, is cautious about the localist historiographical approach, believing that it neglects the China–Hong Kong relationship embodied in historical artifacts and the clan traditions of the New Territories.However, Tsui Sing-on counters by arguing that the New Territories clan genealogies mentioned by Lau are fabricated constructs devised by indigenous residents to exploit the household registration system.[12]

In A Hong Kong People’s History of Hong Kong, Choi Wing-hong proposes that the history from the Opium War to the Second World War should be rewritten from a Hong Kong-centered perspective[3]

See also

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 陳, 學然 (2014-03-31). 五四在香港──殖民情境、民族主義及本土意識 [The May Fourth in Hong Kong — Colonial Context, Nationalism, and Local Consciousness] (in Chinese). 中華書局(香港)出版有限公司. ISBN 978-988-8290-08-6.
  2. 1 2 3 4 徐, 承恩 (2016). 城邦舊事: 十二本書看香港本土史 (修訂版) [City-State Chronicles: Twelve Books on Hong Kong’s Local History (Revised Edition)]. Red Publish. p. 15. ISBN 978-9888380381.
  3. 1 2 "致谢" [Acknowledgements]. www.hkmemory.hk. Retrieved 2026-02-13.
  4. ↑ 王, 宏志 (2000). 歷史的沉重︰從香港看中國大陸的香港史論述 [The Weight of History: Viewing Hong Kong’s Historiography from Mainland China’s Perspective]. 牛津大學出版社. ISBN 0-19-590070-7.
  5. ↑ 蔡, 玉萍 (2010). 誰是香港人 身份與認同 [Who Are Hongkongers? Identity and Recognition]. 進一步多媒體有限公司、研習所. pp. 41–42. ISBN 978-988-8011-05-6.
  6. ↑ 蔡, 榮芳 (2001). 香港人之香港史 1844-1945 [A Hongkonger’s History of Hong Kong, 1844–1945]. 牛津大學出版社. ISBN 0-19-592778-8.
  7. ↑ 香港中文大學, 歷史系 (2016). 貫古通今 融東會西:扎根史學五十年 [Connecting Past and Present, Merging East and West: Fifty Years Rooted in Historical Studies]. 三聯書店. p. 185. ISBN 9789620440267.
  8. 1 2 "鄺智文、蔡耀倫,《孤獨前哨:太平洋戰爭中的香港戰役》 | Article Database" [Kwong Chi Man and Tsai Yiu Lun, The Lonely Outpost: The Battle of Hong Kong in the Pacific War]. schina-publication.hkust.edu.hk. Retrieved 2025-05-26.
  9. 1 2 3 吳叡人 (2020-04-05). "處在帝國夾縫中,香港認同從何而來?──《香港,躁鬱的家邦》" [Caught Between Empires, Where Does Hong Kong Identity Come From? — Hong Kong, a Manic-Depressive Homeland]. 說書. Archived from the original on 2021-05-12. Retrieved 2020-06-17.
  10. 1 2 "香港人千年史(三):中國國族主義風潮下的本土意識" [A Millennium of Hongkongers’ History (Part 3): Local Consciousness Amid the Tide of Chinese Nationalism]. 故事 StoryStudio. 2015-08-30. Retrieved 2025-05-26.
  11. ↑ 讀者投書 (2014-11-18). "拒絕被「撥亂反正」的歷史觀,香港的故事要由香港人來說" [Rejecting a “Rectified” Historical Narrative — Hong Kong’s Story Should Be Told by Hongkongers Themselves]. TNL The News Lens 關鍵評論網 (in Chinese). Retrieved 2025-05-26.
  12. ↑ "回應《鏗鏘集:歷史的補白》受訪者對本土史觀的質疑" [A Response to the Interviewees in “Hong Kong Connection: Historical Addendum” Who Questioned the Localist Historical Perspective]. 徐承恩 Eric S.Y. Tsui (in Chinese (Taiwan)). 2016-04-05. Retrieved 2025-05-26.