Brazilian Congressional Bill No. 122
Brazilian Congressional Bill No. 122 of 2006,[a] also known as the anti-homophobia law (Brazilian Portuguese: Lei anti-homofobia) or Alexandre Ivo Law, (Brazilian Portuguese: Lei Alexandre Ivo)[1][2] was a Brazilian bill introduced by then-Congresswoman Iara Bernardi (PT -SP). The bill aimed to criminalize homophobia in the country and was shelved after spending eight years in the Senate without approval.[3] It was considered constitutional by important jurists, including two ministers of the Supreme Federal Court (STF).[4] The immediate approval of specific legislation to criminalize homophobia is considered "urgently" necessary in the country by some legal experts.[4][5] However, according to some Christian entities (especially Catholic and Protestant), the bill violates religious freedom and freedom of expression by providing for imprisonment (up to 5 years) for public criticism of homosexuality, regardless of the reason.[6] However, this was not included in the text of the bill.[7]
The Bill 122 proposed the criminalization of prejudices motivated by sexual orientation and gender identity, equating them to other prejudices already covered by Law 7716/89. This bill was initiated in the Chamber of Deputies, authored by former deputy Iara Bernardi and processed there under number 5003/2001,[8] which in the wording approved by the Chamber proposed, in addition to criminal penalties, also additional civil penalties for homophobic prejudice, such as the loss of office for public servants, disqualification from contracts with the public administration, prohibition of access to credit from official banks and the prohibition of tax benefits.[9]
According to a telephone survey conducted by DataSenado in 2008 with 1120 people from all five regions of Brazil, 70% of respondents were in favor of criminalizing discrimination against homosexuals in the country. Approval is widespread across almost all segments, by region, sex, and age. Even the breakdown by religion shows approval of 54% among evangelicals, 70% among Catholics and adherents of other religions, and 79% among atheists. Among those aged 16-29, 76% supported the bill. Also according to the survey, people with higher levels of education tend to be more in favor of the bill – 78% of people with higher education and 55% of people with a 4th-grade education.[10] However, another DataSenado poll, this one conducted in 2009 with four hundred thousand people online, indicated that 51.5% of Brazilians are against Bill 122, while 48.5% are in favor.[11]
Background
To try to reach an agreement with religious entities that oppose the bill, Senator Marta Suplicy, rapporteur of Bill 122 in the Senate, modified the text to protect religious worship from criminalization. The modification states that the new legislation "does not apply to the peaceful expression of thought arising from faith and morality founded on freedom of conscience, belief and religion." However, the new text was rejected by LGBTQ rights advocates, who considered that the alteration distorts the original objective of the law,[12] and was still not enough to win the support of the evangelical caucus in parliament.[13] Bill 122 was to be voted on in the Senate Human Rights Committee on December 8, 2011, but its vote was eventually postponed.[13]
Public opinion
Support
Some legal experts argue that specific legislation criminalizing homophobia is "urgently" needed in Brazil given the lack of laws addressing discrimination based on sexual orientation and the spikes in violence.[5] Similarly, in November 2010, LGBTQ organizations and members of parliament held a demonstration on Paulista Avenue in São Paulo to advocate for the approval of Bill 122,[14] following emblematic episodes of aggression against homosexuals on that same avenue[15] and in Rio de Janeiro.[16]
Legal experts interviewed by the Folha de S.Paulo newspaper, including former Supreme Court Justice Marco Aurélio Mello, unanimously stated that the bill does not threaten the principle of freedom of expression, does not create a new crime, and is constitutional.[4] In 2011, former Supreme Court Justice Ayres Britto, also in an interview with Folha, stated that he is in favor of a bill that criminalizes homophobia.[17] According to Britto: "The homophobe exacerbates his prejudice to such an extent that he wallows in the mire of hatred. And the fact is that hate crimes are a hair's breadth away from violent crimes."[18]
For Senator Eduardo Suplicy (PT-SP), the project is "one of the most revolutionary in this House [ the Federal Senate], because it gives us very clearly the notion of the respect we must have for any human being, whoever they may be."[19] Congressman Jean Wyllys also declared his support for the bill. According to him: "What we need is a law that equates homophobia with racism and anti-Semitism, and that is what the original bill does."[12]
Oppose
Some groups, mostly Christian (Catholic and Protestant), oppose the text of Bill 122, claiming that it violates the principle of freedom of expression. These groups assert that, as the bill was written, any expression criticizing the conduct of homosexuals could be characterized as discrimination or prejudice.[20] They also claim that the bill infringes on religious freedom and creates a privileged caste.[6] A petition with over 1 million signatures against the bill was delivered to the president of the Senate.[6]
On June 1, 2011, more than 25,000 Protestants and Catholics protested in front of the Brazilian National Congress against Bill 122.[21] On the same day, on the Manhã no Parlamento program on Rádio Câmara, Pastor Silas Malafaia, of the Assembly of God, accused Bill 122 of creating unconstitutional privileges for homosexuals, saying, "There is a glaring difference between criticizing a certain conduct and discriminating against people" and also, "What they can't stand is criticism."[22] At the 2011 March for Jesus, Silas Malafaia criticized the approval of same-sex civil unions, instructing his followers not to vote for politicians who support Bill 122.[23][24]
References
- ↑ raoscandiuzzi (August 5, 2011). "Mãe de Alexandre Ivo conta história do filho assassinado por homofobia" [Alexandre Ivo's mother tells the story of her son, who was murdered because of homophobia]. Rede Brasil Atual (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on October 29, 2013. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Setti, Ricardo (December 1, 2011). "Alexandre Ivo: Projeto contra a homofobia vai a votação e promete gerar batalha no Senado" [Alexandre Ivo: Bill against homophobia goes to vote and promises to generate battle in the Senate]. Veja (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on November 9, 2013. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ "Projeto de criminalização da homofobia é arquivado no Congresso" [Bill to criminalize homophobia is shelved in Congress]. Empresa Brasil de Comunicação (in Brazilian Portuguese). January 13, 2015. Archived from the original on January 18, 2015. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- 1 2 3 Machado, Uirá (December 22, 2010). "Ato em São Paulo defende lei contra homofobia" [Rally in São Paulo defends law against homophobia]. Folha de S.Paulo (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved May 4, 2026.
A Folha ouviu seis especialistas em direito constitucional: o ministro Marco Aurélio Mello, do Supremo Tribunal Federal, um segundo ministro do STF, que falou em caráter reservado, Ives Gandra da Silva Martins, Virgílio Afonso da Silva, Conrado Hübner Mendes e Octavio Luiz Motta Ferraz. São unânimes: o projeto é constitucional e não ameaça a liberdade de expressão. O principal argumento é o fato de a Constituição dizer em dois artigos (3º e 5º) que a discriminação e o preconceito deverão ser combatidos pela lei. É o que já ocorre, por exemplo, com a prática do racismo, cuja condenação legal é aceita desde 1988. O que o projeto anti-homofobia faz é considerar a atitude homofóbica tão criminosa quanto a racista. Não há a "criação" de um crime novo.
[Folha interviewed six experts in constitutional law: Minister Marco Aurélio Mello of the Supreme Federal Court, a second minister of the STF who spoke on condition of anonymity, Ives Gandra da Silva Martins, Virgílio Afonso da Silva, Conrado Hübner Mendes, and Octavio Luiz Motta Ferraz. They are unanimous: the bill is constitutional and does not threaten freedom of expression. The main argument is the fact that the Constitution states in two articles (3 and 5) that discrimination and prejudice must be combated by law. This is already the case, for example, with the practice of racism, whose legal condemnation has been accepted since 1988. What the anti-homophobia bill does is consider homophobic attitudes as criminal as racist ones. There is no "creation" of a new crime.] - 1 2 Garcia, Janaina (July 21, 2011). "Agressões e mortes exigem criminalização "urgente" da homofobia, defendem especialistas" [Attacks and deaths demand "urgent" criminalization of homophobia, experts argue]. Universo Online (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on January 19, 2012. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- 1 2 3 Castro, Gabriel (June 1, 2011). "Religiosos entregam 1 milhão de assinaturas contra projeto que criminaliza homofobia" [Religious leaders submit 1 million signatures against bill that criminalizes homophobia]. Veja (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on June 3, 2011. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- ↑ "Projeto de Lei da Câmara N° 122, de 2006" [Chamber Bill No. 122 of 2006]. www.senado.gov.br (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on September 24, 2015. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- ↑ "PL 5003/2001" [Bill 5003/2001]. www.camara.leg.br (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- ↑ "REDAÇÃO FINAL PROJETO DE LEI Nº 5.003-B, DE 2001" [FINAL DRAFT OF BILL NO. 5.003-B, OF 2001] (PDF). www.camara.gov.br (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original (PDF) on January 4, 2009. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- ↑ "Pesquisa Nacional: Criminalização do preconceito ou discriminação contra homossexuais" [National Survey: Criminalization of prejudice or discrimination against homosexuals] (PDF). www.senado.gov.br (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original (PDF) on November 13, 2011. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- ↑ "Magno Malta critica enquete sobre PLC 122/06 no site do Senado" [Magno Malta criticizes poll on Senate website regarding Bill 122/06]. Senado Federal (in Brazilian Portuguese). December 2, 2009. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- 1 2 Vermelho, Portal (December 7, 2011). "Queda de braço na votação do projeto que criminaliza homofobia" [Tug-of-war in the vote on the bill that criminalizes homophobia]. Portal Vermelho (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on March 3, 2016. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- 1 2 Huberman, Bruno. "Projeto de lei anti-homofobia desagrada gays e evangélicos" [Anti-homophobia bill displeases gays and evangelicals]. Veja (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on February 6, 2012. Retrieved May 4, 2026.
- ↑ Balza, Guilherme (November 19, 2010). "Após agressões a gays, avenida Paulista tem ato por lei anti-homofobia" [Following attacks on gay people, Paulista Avenue hosts protest for anti-homophobia law]. Universo Online (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on February 22, 2025. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Apolinário, Marcio (November 14, 2010). "Grupo usou lâmpada fluorescente para agredir jovens em São Paulo" [Group used fluorescent light bulb to attack young people in São Paulo]. Último Segundo. Archived from the original on November 19, 2010. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Lauriano, Carolina Lauriano (July 28, 2011). "Baleado por militar após Parada Gay no Rio não sai à noite há 8 meses" [Shot by a soldier after Gay Pride Parade in Rio, he hasn't gone out at night for 8 months]. G1 (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Sobral, Sidclei. "Ministro do STF defende criminalização da homofobia" [Supreme Court Justice defends criminalizing homophobia]. Ne10 (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on July 13, 2011. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
- ↑ Vermelho, Portal. "STF: Carlos Ayres Britto defende criminalização da homofobia" [Supreme Court Justice Carlos Ayres Britto defends the criminalization of homophobia]. Portal Vermelho (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on March 4, 2016. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
- ↑ "Eduardo Suplicy defende aprovação do projeto que criminaliza a homofobia" [Eduardo Suplicy defends the approval of the bill that criminalizes homophobia]. Diário do Nordeste (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on July 1, 2013. Retrieved May 7, 2026.
- ↑ "Projeto sobre criminalização divide opiniões" [Draft bill on criminalization divides opinions]. Jornal do Comércio (in Brazilian Portuguese). June 27, 2011. Archived from the original on July 27, 2014. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Castro, Gabriel (January 1, 2011). "Marcha de evangélicos e católicos protesta contra aborto, casamento gay e legalização da maconha" [Evangelical and Catholic march protests against abortion, gay marriage, and marijuana legalization]. Veja (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on June 3, 2011. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ "Evangélico e presidente da ABGLT debatem homofobia" [Evangelical leader and president of ABGLT discuss homophobia]. Portal da Câmara dos Deputados (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ Domingos, Roney (June 23, 2011). "Organização afirma que Marcha para Jesus alcançou 5 milhões de pessoas" [Organization claims March for Jesus reached 5 million people]. G1 (in Brazilian Portuguese). Retrieved May 5, 2026.
- ↑ "Marcha para Jesus vira ato contra união homoafetiva" [March for Jesus turns into protest against same-sex civil unions]. Último Segundo (in Brazilian Portuguese). Archived from the original on July 1, 2011. Retrieved May 5, 2026.
O discurso mais radical foi do pastor Silas Malafaia. Com palavreado vulgar, usando termos como "otário" e "lixo moral", Malafaia atacou duramente a decisão do STF de legalizar a união estável entre pessoas do mesmo sexo. "O STF rasgou a Constituição que, no artigo 226, parágrafo 3º, diz claramente que união estável é entre um homem do gênero masculino e uma mulher do gênero feminino. União homossexual uma vírgula", disse o pastor. O pastor defendeu a desobediência por parte de pastores caso o PL 122 seja aprovado. "Eles querem aprovar uma lei para dizer que a Bíblia é um livro homofóbico e botar uma mordaça em nossa boca. Se aprovarem o PL 122 no mesmo dia, na mesma hora, tudo quando é pastor vai pregar contra a prática homossexual. Quero ver onde vai ter cadeia para botar tanto pastor."
[The most radical speech came from Pastor Silas Malafaia. Using vulgar language, including terms like "fool" and "moral trash," Malafaia harshly attacked the Supreme Court's decision to legalize same-sex civil unions. "The Supreme Court tore up the Constitution, which, in article 226, paragraph 3, clearly states that a civil union is between a man of the male gender and a woman of the female gender. Homosexual union my foot," said the pastor. The pastor advocated for disobedience on the part of pastors should Bill 122 be approved. "They want to pass a law to say that the Bible is a homophobic book and put a gag in our mouths. If they approve Bill 122, on the same day, at the same hour, every pastor will preach against homosexual practice. I want to see where there will be enough jail space for so many pastors."]
- ↑ Abbreviated as PLC 122/2006 or PL 122