| Year | Champion | Site | Most Outstanding Player |
|---|
| 1989 | Providence | Chestnut Hill, MA | Chris Wajda, Connecticut |
| 1990 | Villanova | J.S. Coyne Field • Syracuse, NY | Jennifer Peacock, Villanova |
| 1991 | Providence | Chestnut Hill, MA | Debbie Hagie, Providence |
| 1992 | Connecticut | Chestnut Hill, MA | Yolanda Muntz, Connecticut |
| 1993 | Syracuse | Chestnut Hill, MA | Julie Williamson, Syracuse |
| 1994 | Boston College | Chestnut Hill, MA | Sarah Egnaczyk, Boston College |
| 1995 | Syracuse | Chestnut Hill, MA | Cheri Herr, Syracuse |
| 1996 | Connecticut | George J. Sherman Family-Sports Complex • Storrs, CT | Wendy Brady, Connecticut |
| 1997 | Boston College | Chestnut Hill, MA | Andrea Durko, Boston College |
| 1998 | Connecticut | Villanova Stadium • Villanova, PA | Alison Sharpe, Connecticut |
| 1999 | Connecticut | J.S. Coyne Field • Syracuse, NY | Nicole Castonguay, Connecticut |
| 2000 | Connecticut | George J. Sherman Sports Complex • Storrs, CT | Katie Stephens, Connecticut |
| 2001 | Syracuse | Chestnut Hill, MA | Michelle Aronowicz, Syracuse |
| 2002 | Connecticut | J.S. Coyne Field • Syracuse, NY | Lauren Henderson, Connecticut |
| 2003 | Boston College | Chestnut Hill, MA | Bronwen Kelly, Boston College |
| 2004 | Connecticut | J.S. Coyne Field • Syracuse, NY | Lauren Henderson, Connecticut |
| 2005 | Connecticut | Bauer Field • Piscataway, NJ | Meagan Hoffman, Connecticut |
| 2006 | Connecticut | Trager Stadium • Louisville, KY | Lauren Aird, Connecticut |
| 2007 | Connecticut | J.S. Coyne Field • Syracuse, NY | Katie Semanoff, Connecticut |
| 2008 | Syracuse | George J. Sherman Sports Complex • Storrs, CT | Shannon Taylor, Syracuse |
| 2009 | Connecticut | Lennon Family Field • Providence, RI | Loren Sherer, Connecticut |
| 2010 | Syracuse | George J. Sherman Sports Complex • Storrs, CT | Lindsey Conrad, Syracuse |
| 2011 | Syracuse | J.S. Coyne Field • Syracuse, NY | Lauren Brooks, Syracuse |
| 2012 | Connecticut | Trager Stadium • Louisville, KY | Louisa Boddy, Connecticut |
| 2013 | Connecticut | George J. Sherman Sports Complex • Storrs, CT | Chloe Hunnable, Connecticut |
| 2014 | Connecticut | Lennon Family Field • Providence, RI | Roisin Upton, Connecticut |
| 2015 | Connecticut | L.R. Hill Sports Complex • Norfolk, VA | Charlotte Veitner, Connecticut |
| 2016 | Connecticut | Howarth Field • Philadelphia, PA | Amanda Collins, Connecticut |
| 2017 | Connecticut | Lennon Family Field • Providence, RI | Amanda Collins, Connecticut |
| 2018 | Connecticut | Liberty Field Hockey Field • Lynchburg, VA | Cécile Pieper, Connecticut |
| 2019 | Connecticut | Quinnipiac Field Hockey Stadium • Hamden, CT | Svea Boker, Connecticut |
| 2020 | Connecticut | The Proving Grounds • Conshohocken, PA | Sophie Hamilton, Connecticut |
| 2021 | Liberty | George J. Sherman Sports Complex • Storrs, CT | Jill Bolton, Liberty |
| 2022 | Liberty | L.R. Hill Sports Complex • Norfolk, VA | Azul Iritxity Irigoyen, Liberty |
| 2023 | Old Dominion | Howarth Field • Philadelphia, PA | Nicole Fredricks, Old Dominion |
| 2024 | Connecticut | Lennon Family Field • Providence, RI | Natalie McKenna, Connecticut |
| 2025 | Liberty | Liberty Field Hockey Field • Lynchburg, VA | Lou Combrinck, Liberty |