American Soccer Association Cup
The American Soccer Association Cup was an open cup-tie competition that took place in 1929. The entries for this tournament were the ASL teams and amateur clubs from the Southern New York State Association. The amateur clubs played the early rounds to earn the right to play off against the ASL entrants in the final stages.[1] The tournament ran from February to May. The sixth round which constituted the tournament proper included the seven ASL teams and the only amateur side to qualify, the Brooklyn Celtics. The final was played over two legs with Providence gaining the title over the New York Nationals with a 4-2 win on May 20 after the teams drew 2-2 on May 18. A May 19 game was played but officials called the game on account of weather and continued as an exhibition match with the teams playing to a 4-4 draw. This tournament was not continued as the 'Soccer War' was later resolved.
First round
| Norwegian | 5-2 | Clan Campbell |
|---|---|---|
Referee:
| First Germans | 5-2 | Danish A.C. |
|---|---|---|
Referee:
Second round
| Swedish | 3-10 | Galicia |
|---|---|---|
| Trumpeldor | 6–0 | Klippen |
|---|---|---|
| Laszlo(4) Solomon(2) |
| Norwegian | 5-1 | Brooklyn Americans |
|---|---|---|
| Bakken(2 pk) Casper Alf Olsen Petterøe |
10' |
| German Hungarians | 0-3 | First German |
|---|---|---|
| Yonkers St.George | 0–1 | Otis Elevator |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Pete Joslip |
| Yonkers Thistle | 6–3 | New Rochelle |
|---|---|---|
| Walker Stewart(2) Lees(2) Heineman |
| Danersk | 0–4 | Port Chester |
|---|---|---|
| Nassau | 3–0 | Mineola |
|---|---|---|
| F.Kelly Glasgow Carr |
Referee: Hugh Evans
| Greenwich | 3–5 | Stamford |
|---|---|---|
| ?',55' Scott(2) Hendrie |
McMillan(3) Cunningham McLelland |
Referee: William Halliday
| Brooklyn Celtics | 7-0 | Gjoa |
|---|---|---|
| Davis Mills | 9-3 | Friars |
|---|---|---|
| Humphries (4) Golz (2) Beaulieu (2) Croteau |
Bouffard Braga |
Referee: Scholes
| Hose Ten | 3-2 | Butlers |
|---|---|---|
| White (2) La Rue |
Boule Waring |
Referee: Fonseca
| New Bedford Juniors | 1-5 | Picards |
|---|---|---|
| Connick | 15' L. Varnesse Jackson McGrady (3) |
Referee: Norse
Third round
| Yonkers Thistle | 3-2 | Otis Elevator |
|---|---|---|
| Adams Jock Stewart 80' Jock Stewart |
Leadbetter Nichol |
| Port Chester | 0-2 | Stamford |
|---|---|---|
| McMillan 88' McMillan |
Referee: W.Halliday
| Norwegian | 5–1 | Trumpeldors |
|---|---|---|
| Galicia | 1–1 | Nassau |
|---|---|---|
| Bruce(pk) | Carr |
Referee: O'Halloran
| First German | 1–1 | Brooklyn Celtic |
|---|---|---|
| Machle | Glenn |
| Nassau | 1–2 | Galicia |
|---|---|---|
| Fleming | Vega Doyle |
Attendance: 400
| Brooklyn Celtic | 3–0 | First German |
|---|---|---|
| Hughes Adams |
| Davis Mills | 3-2 | Picards |
|---|---|---|
| J.Eckersley (2) Beaulieu |
Remiliard (2) |
Referee: Lovett
Fourth round
| Brooklyn Wanderers | 5–2 | Norwegians |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Nehadoma(Pearce) 20' Curtis 67' Hogg(Mitchell) Brown(pk) Pearce(Hogg) |
[2] | 55' Fass Backen(pk) |
Referee: T.Dempsey
| Davis Mills | 1-0 | Hose Tens |
|---|---|---|
| George Bradbury | [3] |
Referee: Lovett
Fifth round
| Galicia | 2–2 | Philadelphia |
|---|---|---|
| Bruce Ozores |
[4] | 65' Wall 80' McKenna |
Referee: Dempsey
Attendance: 1000
| Philadelphia | 6–2 | Galicia |
|---|---|---|
| Wall(4) Purvis Moore |
[5] | Ozores Boyle |
Referee: Hayes
| Brooklyn Wanderers | 5–1 | Stamford |
|---|---|---|
| Mitchell 15' Nehadoma(Curtis) Nehadoma(McMillan) 55' Nehadoma(Hogg) 75' Curtis |
[6] | 8' Calder(pk) |
Attendance: 1500
Referee: C.Stott
| New York Nationals | 10–1 | Yonkers Thistle |
|---|---|---|
| 10' John Nelson(Carlson) 11' John Nelson(Leonard) 16' Gallagher John Nelson(Gallagher) Carlson Gallagher 50' McGhee(Leonard) Carlson Leonard McGhee |
[7] | Torrance(Knox) |
Attendance: 1500
Referee: H.Evans
| Davis Mills | 3–5 | Pawtucket |
|---|---|---|
| 60' Golz Beaulieu 68' Bradbury |
[8] | Sam Kennedy(4) Jim McAuley |
Referee: Lovett
Quarterfinals
| Pawtucket | 1–1 | Providence |
|---|---|---|
| Kennedy | [9] | Paterson |
| Providence | 6–0 | Pawtucket |
|---|---|---|
| Paterson (3) Hogg (2) Watson |
[10] |
| Boston | 4–2 | Fall River F.C. |
|---|---|---|
| Nilsen G.Burness H.Burness McEachran |
[11] | Patenaude Patenaude |
| Fall River F.C. | 3–3 | Boston |
|---|---|---|
| Patenaude Granger |
[12] | Gonsalves Gonsalves McIntyre(og) Nilsen |
| New York Nationals | 2–1 | Philadelphia |
|---|---|---|
| 11' Nelson 89' Worden(pk) |
[13] | 35' Nicol |
| Brooklyn Wanderers | 3–1 | Brooklyn Celtics |
|---|---|---|
| 22' Curtis 55' Curtis 67' Pearce |
[14] | 10' Hughes |
Semifinals
| Boston | 2–1 | Providence F.C. |
|---|---|---|
| Nilsen 69' McEachran |
[15] | 63' Paterson |
| Providence F.C. | 1–0 | Boston |
|---|---|---|
| 89' Paterson | [16] |
| Providence F.C. | 2–0 | Boston |
|---|---|---|
| 130' Paterson 139' Turner |
[17] |
| New York Nationals | 2–1 | Brooklyn Wanderers |
|---|---|---|
| 62' Nelson 80' Nelson |
[18] | 88' Pearce |
| New York Nationals | 2–2 | Brooklyn Wanderers |
|---|---|---|
| 10' Nelson 87' McGhee |
[19] | 30' Nehadoma 62' Lyell |
Final

| Providence F.C. | 2–2 | New York Nationals |
|---|---|---|
| 16', 41' Nelson | [20] | 15' Paterson 35' Auld |
Exhibition
| New York Nationals | 4–4 | Providence F.C. |
|---|---|---|
| 25' Leonard 1H' Nelson Gallagher (2) |
[21] | 15' Watson 1H' Oswald 2H' Fitzpatrick 75' Auld |

Replay
| New York Nationals | 2–4 | Providence F.C. |
|---|---|---|
| 31', 75' McGhee | [22] | 35', 55' Paterson (3) 88' Fitzpatrick |
See also
References
- ↑ "Cup Pairings Are Announced". (February 19, 1929). Chester Times, p.13 col.2
- ↑ "Norsemen Lose To Wanderers In Cup Match". (April 14, 1929). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.2C col.8
- ↑ "Wind Aids 2 To 0 Win By Walsh–Chevs". (April 20, 1929). Evening Standard, p.7 col.5
- ↑ "Gjoa Eleven Beats Clan Campbell". (April 8, 1929). New York Times, p.28 col.4
- ↑ "Phillies Booters Win Cup Match, 6–2". (April 14, 1929). Philadelphia Inquirer, p.6S col.6
- ↑ "Wanderers Go Into 6th Round By Soccer Win". (April 21, 1929). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.2C col.4
- ↑ "Nationals Victor At Soccer By 10-1". (April 21, 1929). New York Times, p.S3 col.8
- ↑ "Davis Mills Team Bows To Pawtucket, Score 5–3". (April 22, 1929). Fall River Herald, p.17 col.7–8
- ↑ "Providence 1, Pawtucket 1". (April 29, 1929). Pawtucket Times, p.15 col.4–5
- ↑ Murray, Herbert F. (April 29, 1929). "Gold Bugs Rout Pawtucket 6 To 0; Paterson Nets Three". Providence Journal, p.7 col.7–8
- ↑ Collins, George M. (April 28, 1929). "Wonder Workers Defeat Fall River By 4 To 2". Boston Sunday Globe, p.A25 col.1–2
- ↑ "Fall River Eliminated From Cup Competition". (April 29, 1929). Fall River Herald, p.16 col.1–2
- ↑ "Soccer Cup Match Won By Nationals". (April 29, 1929). New York Times, p.20 col.3
- ↑ "Wanderers Trim Quaker Eleven In Cup Game". (April 29, 1929). Brooklyn Daily Eagle, p.A5 col.3
- ↑ Collins, George M. (May 5, 1929). "Wonder Workers Have Association Cup Edge". Boston Sunday Globe, p.A21 col.7–8
- ↑ Murray, Herbert F. (May 6, 1929). "Paterson's Late Goal Downs Hub Team 1–0 In Cup Play". Providence Journal, p.7 col.7–8
- ↑ Murray, Herbert F. (May 13, 1929). "Providence Soccer Eleven Qualifies For Final Match". Providence Journal, p.7 col.1–2
- ↑ "Nelson's Two Goals Win For Nationals". (May 6, 1929). New York Times, p.21 col.2
- ↑ "Nationals Tie 2-2, But Gain Cup Final". (May 13, 1929). New York Times, p.20 col.1
- ↑ Murray, Herbert F. (May 19, 1929). "Fletchermen Battle Nats To 2–2 Draw In Cup Contest". Providence Sunday Journal, p.B1 col.2–3
- ↑ "Nationals Tie 4-4, In Soccer Cup Test". (May 20, 1929). New York Times, p.33 col.5
- ↑ "Providence Eleven Defeats Nationals". (May 21, 1929). New York Times, p.37 col.6